Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 25, 2009 Cheshvan 7, 5770 | | Israel Time: 16:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 13:21 24/10/2009
Solana to Haaretz: New rules of war needed for age of terror
By Adar Primor, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: France Israeli ties 

For exactly 10 years Javier Solana has represented the "international face" of Europe; 10 years in which he has closely followed the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, with all its turns and crises; a decade in which, to a great extent he was the answer to the famous question of Henry Kissinger: "Who should I call when I want to talk to Europe?"

To a certain extent Solana, the head of Europe's Common Foreign and Security Policy, has served simultaneously as the counterpart of U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates.

Soon, the most complicated role in the world may come to an end: with the final ratification of the Lisbon Treaty- the constitutional document of the European Union, the EU will appoint, for the first time, a foreign minister, who will head a European diplomatic service. Solana will step down. A proverbial moment before he does, he has agreed to grant Haaretz an exclusive interview.
Advertisement
The 67-year old Solana, who was in Israel this week as a guest at the President's Conference, is uncertain what the future holds for him. He is also not willing to reveal whom, among the candidates for the new position, he prefers. He prefers to talk about the day to day issues that were his bread and butter during the past decade.

For example, he would like to understand what troubled Israel that led to its decision to prevent French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner to travel to the Gaza Strip this week. After all, he says, the visit was humanitarian in nature. He was told that Israel would like to prevent a "Hamas festival" that will grant legitimacy to the terrorist group ruling the Gaza strip.

He was also told that, according to one assessment, the Israeli attitude stemmed from the French handling of the Goldstone report. France opted to abstain from the vote at the Human Rights Council instead of rejecting the report, and angered the Israeli leadership.

Solana responds with a smile and a gesture of dismissal. He says that, "this is a very short sighted approach. After all, it is the Foreign Minister of France, a state which is one of the most important allies of Israel."

For years Solana has sought to bring about a "victory of a coherent and effective European foreign and security policy," in order to prove that Europe has joint values and political direction, which it advances on the international arena. In order to emphasize this, Solana, a Physics professor, offers a parallel from the world that is close to his heart.

"The Union is not a mixture of states," he says. "It is a type of molecule with joint electrons that enable us to act together and make binding political decisions."

However, it appears that during the vote at the Human Rights Council of the United Nations in Geneva, the electrons opted to make up new rules of physics: Italy, Hungary and Slovakia voted against the Goldstone Report, Belgium abstained, while Britain and France chose not to participate in the vote.

He is much more concerned with the near consensus that has taken root in Israel against Judge Richard Goldstone.

"I know Goldstone very well," Solana says. "He has helped us a great deal in his legal work in former Yugoslavia and I have no doubts regarding his rectitude and honesty. It is entirely obvious that Goldstone did not seek to harm the sides, certainly without intention to harm Israel. His report may not have been read properly. In any case, it is now important to look forward and to hold an independent investigation in Israel and the other side [the Palestinians]. This would be the best outcome."

When Solana is asked whether Israel is in part responsible for the report, for its refusal to cooperate with its author, he says, "Sure, I would have recommended that Israel would have cooperated. In the Union we respect the UN and multilateral bodies a great deal. Unfortunately, this view of ours which is linked to the era of globalization and the need to create different mechanisms for global governance, is different from the view that is prevalent here."

Solana is presenting a European philosophy, which in Israel they are hard pressed to understand. Multilateralism and internationalism ¬ the "new religion" of Solana and his colleagues in the EU, constitute an essential lesson of the world wars, and of the destructive nationalism that caused them.

They are also the result of the increased migration and the demographic changes that Europe underwent in the past decades, and which blurred the notion of nation-tribe throughout the continent. Europe has relinquished the supremacy of national values in favor of the international society of law.

However, Solana's "religion" is not of the radical sort. For example, he tends to emphasize that the struggle against terrorism is deeply ingrained in him.

In an interview he gave Haaretz in 2004, he said that "nearly every week I had to participate in the funeral of a person who was killed by terrorism. This situation did not change even when I served as Secretary General of NATO, and reached its peak with the large attacks that occurred in Madrid on March 11 2004."

Perhaps this is why he understands ¬ and even supports ¬ the call of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the need to alter the laws governing international warfare, which are not aligned with the reality in which countries need to combat terrorist entities. Solana chooses not to address the question of war crimes attributed to Israel in the report, but stresses that "in yesterday's world there were wars of armies against armies and there were laws and conventions that dealt with the conduct of such wars.

It is necessary to invest thought to the changing situation in which there is asymmetry between fighting parties, a situation in which it is difficult to implement the classic/old rules of war." But he says that "until new rules are in place we must obey the old ones."

Solana opts not to comment on the declaration of Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, which described the Goldstone report as "an obstacle to the peace process." However, his view on the matter is clear: In a visit Solana made to Ramallah this week he stressed that the aim of the EU is "to establish a Palestinian state at the earliest possible moment within the 1967 borders."

In July it seemed that he had lost his patience when he declared that "the UN should set a target date for establishing a Palestinian state and recognizing it, even if the Israelis and the Palestinians do not reach an agreement. Then the Security Council will be asked to call for the adoption of a two state solution that will deal with all the parameters of borders, refugees, the issue of Jerusalem, and the security arrangements. There is a need to also accept the Palestinian state as a full fledged member of the UN and set a time table for implementing the solution until the declaration of an end to the conflict."

At the panel on "Tomorrow," which was part of the President's Conference, Solana said that peace much be achieved today. "Globalization and the demographic data in the region demand it," he says during the interview.

His efforts in our region have taught him that without the mediation of a third party the two sides are unable to reach agreement. Solana is convinced that following the final ratification of the Lisbon Treaty, the European Union, which he describes as "one of the most beautiful constitutional projects" will have a greater and more evident presence on the international arena. He therefore insists that "Israel must place some of its eggs in the European basket," and not leave everything in the American one.

For example, he says that if the sides ask the EU to deploy a military force in the territories that the IDF will evacuate as part of an agreement, Europe will rally to the cause. However, he recognizes the fact that the United States, "with whom Europe is in complete agreement on most issues," is the "best" mediator for the region. Solana does not agree with the disappointment and the ridicule that has followed the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to U.S. President Barack Obama.

He is convinced that the U.S. president is determined to act in order to resolve the problem and applauds the appointment of George Mitchell to the role of special envoy to the Middle East, "a wise man with many talents," he says. The two were party to the preparation of the Mitchell Report in 2001, which investigated the events of the second intifada, and led to the formulation of the road map.

Solana is also the representative of the international community in the talks with Iran on its nuclear program. He visited Tehran many times and held dozens of meetings with the Iranian leadership. In response to a question on a military option in case talks fail, Solana was firm.

"We are looking for political solutions, but I want to be very clear," he says. "We will not accept in any case a situation in which Iran has nuclear weapons.

Related articles:
  • EU Foreign Policy Chief Solana arrives in Syria for peace talks
  • Israel urges EU: Show 'caution' in contacts with Damascus
  • Livni urges EU: Don't halt EU-Israel relations upgrade
  • Centrifugal force / The threat has just been postponed
  • Iran denies holding secret nuclear talks with Israel
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Hummus battle
    Lebanon breaks world record, sends message to Israel: Hands off our hummus!
    West Bank unrest
    Dozens of leftists, settlers arrested in fresh West Bank unrest
      1.   War and police dont replace policy 01:25  |  Fritz T. 23/10/09
      2.   GOLDSTONE refused to accept the reality of how terrorists fight 02:42  |  PETER SM 23/10/09
      3.   Kept from Gaza? 04:00  |  A TRUE American 23/10/09
      4.   But no objection to Hamas & Hezbollah targeting Jewish civilians 04:53  |  Javier Solana 23/10/09
      5.   Rules of War don`t need to be changed 05:50  |  Javier Lobo 23/10/09
      6.   RE: Javier 06:35  |  judith 23/10/09
      7.   which war? 07:06  |  Miron 23/10/09
      8.   The New War. 07:21  |  B. Gold 23/10/09
      9.   Lost in the discussion- `67 borders 08:02  |  shtarka 23/10/09
      10.   Will someone ask Solana something? 08:19  |  Jerrold Cohen 23/10/09
      11.   solana uncertain about his future? 08:31  |  ron 23/10/09
      12.   rules, thanks Javier 08:33  |  kibishi 23/10/09
      13.   `New rules of war needed for age of terror ` 09:06  |  Colin Wright 23/10/09
      14.   Javier 09:29  |  Marc 23/10/09
      15.   Javier Lobo totally nonesense 10:16  |  arik 23/10/09
      16.   changing the rules of war 10:17  |  Carol Scheller 23/10/09
      17.   The rules of war don`t need to change 10:46  |  Apa 23/10/09
      18.   Hiding behind the classic old Rules of War 12:00  |  allang 23/10/09
      19.   arik, alang 13:00  |  kibishi 23/10/09
      20.   Solana 16:00  |  JimUSA 23/10/09
      21.   Wrong Allong 17:00  |  r cummings 23/10/09
      22.   Only one rule needed 17:08  |  American 23/10/09
      23.   one new rule 17:26  |  jochai Rubinstein 23/10/09
      24.   If this is the case then why not change intl law... 17:28  |  Eli 23/10/09
      25.   New Rules 18:16  |  White Russian 23/10/09
      26.   easy to respect UN & multinational bodies when not singled out - 18:19  |  ivo 23/10/09
      27.   To PeterSM - But Don`t You Know That.,.. 18:24  |  Eli 23/10/09
      28.   No new rules needed 19:49  |  betz55 23/10/09
      29.   Respect "...old laws?" 9/11 was years ago!! Still waiting 21:38  |  Jason 23/10/09
      30.   Solana 21:47  |  Gastone Ciucci Neri 23/10/09
      31.   Rules of War 22:08  |  sfg 23/10/09
      32.   right on Judith 6 22:21  |  right on Judith 23/10/09
      33.   nec sine te nec tecum 22:28  |  skipster 23/10/09
      34.   Kibishi 23:01  |  Philippe 23/10/09
      35.   kibishi 23:02  |  Philippe 23/10/09
      36.   the age of terror has arrived,it`s official- It`s #2 23:40  |  ZORRO 23/10/09
      37.   Now, if the rules are changed 04:36  |  Richard Pearce 24/10/09
      38.   No. 14 - Marc your wish is reality.... 04:53  |  Anti-settler 24/10/09
      39.   #19 Kibishi... returning to the Neanderthal days 06:25  |  allang 24/10/09
      40.   Shooting civilians with white flags is not "self-defense..." 06:48  |  BBSNews 24/10/09
      41.   New Rules Of War! 07:01  |  Yosemite 24/10/09
      42.   Laws of Armed Conflict 07:37  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/10/09
      43.   What? 07:49  |  Daniel Carroll 24/10/09
      44.   About False Flag Attacks and "Irrefutable Evidence" 07:59  |  Alan 24/10/09
      45.   Solana, the "dreamer", still believes that a majority..... 08:26  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/10/09
      46.   Yosemite - Ann Coulter? 08:28  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/10/09
      47.   What a yes man Solana has been .... 08:59  |  Dutch 24/10/09
      48.   #20 r cummings.... you have a point 10:17  |  allang 24/10/09
      49.   The age of terror has arrived,it`s official -part 1 10:55  |  ZORRO 24/10/09
      50.   BSNews and how to be inane 10:56  |  SDHD 24/10/09
      51.   the age of terror has arrived,it`s official- It`s #3 11:10  |  ZORRO 24/10/09
      52.   The Un should IMPLEMENT Solana`s view. 17:05  |  Kofi Bann 24/10/09
      53.   Goldstone on Bill Moyer 17:43  |  Spokanite 24/10/09
      54.   Eastern wisdom on war 18:19  |  Carol Scheller 24/10/09
      55.   whar r the rules n e way??!! 21:34  |  flame 24/10/09
      56.   HUH??? 21:35  |  flame 24/10/09
      57.   Fighting terrorism have no rules ! 23:30  |  Akram Zekatia 24/10/09
      58.   Rules of war indeed 00:10  |  John 25/10/09
      59.   WHITE RUSSIAN worried about rules?Speak to your govt about Grozny 04:16  |  PETER SM 25/10/09
      60.   COHEN ask why Pakistan can have an Islamic bomb?The same Pakistan 04:22  |  PETER SM 25/10/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    15:21 IAEA inspectors visit second Iran nuclear site
    08:01 Analysis / Expect more trickery from Iran in nuclear talks
    14:55 Deputy PM: Reveal minutes of Gaza war cabinet meetings
    13:34 Israel Police battle Arab rioters on Temple Mount; PA official arrested
    13:10 Arab MK: Israel provoking a billion Muslims over Temple Mount
    16:03 U.K. teen who took on far-rightist: Jews, Israel don't want BNP support
    16:02 J Street convenes in Washington, but to what effect?
    13:44 Is Taliban helping Gaza militants make deadlier roadside bombs?
    21:51 TV ROUND-UP: Abbas defends poll; Netanyahu clarifies Gaza remarks
    13:38 Iran arrests 12 accused of promoting satanism
    10:18 Cops get one year for seeking to bomb reputed Nahariya mob boss
    02:13 Palestinian elections / Abbas on the offensive
    14:29 IDF soldier hospitalized after beating by officer
    09:00 Hostility to Israel clouds Egypt's view of its Jewish past
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved