Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., November 17, 2009 Cheshvan 30, 5770 | | Israel Time: 16:06 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Poet Josh Healey.
(Natasha Mozgovaya)
Share |
Poet booted from J Street meet for comparing Guantanamo to Auschwitz
By Natasha Mozgovaya, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Israel news, J Street 
Poet Josh Healey to J Street: If you're trying to be an alternative to AIPAC - don't behave like AIPAC.

Five days ahead of the leftist pro-Israeli lobby J Street's first National Conference in Washington, D.C., the controversies continue to mount. The Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren refuses to attend the conference, despite the open letter issued by the organization's Executive Director Jeremy Ben-Ami; but over the weekend the lobby took one more step to appease critics.

The poetry session, featuring three artists - Kevin Coval, Tracy Soren and Josh Healey, scheduled as part of the "Culture as a Tool for Change" track, was canceled. Apparently, the event was nixed following a reminder by a conservative blogger that Healey, a Jewish activist and poet, compared Guantanamo prison to Auschwitz.

J-Street's Ben-Ami issued the following explanation: "As a matter of principle, J Street respects the dissenting voice that poetry can represent in society and politics. We acknowledge that expression and language are used differently in the arts and artistic expression when compared to their use in political argumentation. Nevertheless, as J Street is critical of the use and abuse of Holocaust imagery and metaphors by politicians and pundits on the right, it would be inappropriate for us to feature poets at our Conference whose poetry has used such imagery in the past and might also be offensive to some conference participants."
Advertisement

In an interview with Haaretz, Josh Healey didn't conceal his disappointment. "I had a conversation with 'J Street' staff, and they explained that they are playing the game - Washington politics, and seeking legitimacy. And they are not willing to fight this battle. I was born in Washington, so I'm not surprised to become Van Jones of J Street," (U.S. President Barack Obama's "green jobs czar" who resigned over the controversy about his past political associations).

"So Van Jones resigned, but did the right wing stop attacking Obama? On one level, I understand them - it's easier to get rid of the poet, who cares? But as an artist and a Jewish activist, it's a matter of principle. If you're trying to be an alternative to AIPAC - don't behave like AIPAC."

"I told them I don't think it's the legitimacy they want, because it's not the legitimacy that makes change. When you're trying to make change, you must expect that some people will push back. But they kick out their allies - and I still consider myself an ally. I'm not personally offended - I'm politically disappointed. It's ironic that we were invited to perform and be a part of the dialogue at the track 'The culture as a tool for change.' But we can't even have this dialogue. The Jewish community acts like children, with smear campaigns and name-calling. I am not surprised by the right wing attacks - but that J-Street went along with it and accommodated it."

Referring to the specific line which stirred the negative emotions, Healey said: "It was taken of context. Judged by themselves, these lines don't even make sense. Just before this line, I wrote: 'I remember when the German soldiers put yellow stars on my family coats and they put pink ones on my friends.' I was talking about de-humanization. And yes, I have family that was killed in the Holocaust. There were Jewish people killed and gay people and Gypsies, and many others, and as a Jew, my solidarity is with my people - and with all people. And my solidarity is with the people of Israel - but also with the people of Palestine. And I believe in two state solution and peace and justice for all people. And if J-Street are not willing to have debate with people who believe in solidarity and humanity, I don't know what legitimacy they want, because it's not a moral legitimacy."

"I love my people, the Jewish people, and that's why I'm critical - because it's my people, my family that are silencing people the same way we were silenced and suppressed for centuries," Healey concluded.

Related articles:
  • Michael Oren ducks the question of J Street
  • J Street embraced by Obama administration, but not in Israel
  • Sure, J Street is pro-peace - but is it pro-Israel?
  • J Street, ADL launch war of words over Obama Israel policy
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Bibi, be a statesman
    Netanyahu knows exactly what he must do for peace with Syria, Palestinians.
    Unilateral Palestine
    Netanyahu says there is no substitute for talks, appeals to PA to negotiate at once.
      1.   first they throw out the poets 07:23  |  peter rouget 20/10/09
      2.   Healey makes sense 07:32  |  hf 20/10/09
      3.   The new Nazi party 08:56  |  Gilad 20/10/09
      4.   another useless liberal arts major 08:57  |  Tom 20/10/09
      5.   Pro-Israel??? 09:18  |  Emir 20/10/09
      6.   Wake up Healy 09:46  |  Gilad 20/10/09
      7.   A boy`chik in quest of fame/notoriety could stay 11:18  |  17 20/10/09
      8.   Modern "anti-semitism" is not different 12:14  |  Fritz T. 20/10/09
      9.   Poetic insanity 13:08  |  Lola 20/10/09
      10.   the poet 14:09  |  Shmuelshachor 20/10/09
      11.   J Street is NOT an alternative `American/Israel` Lobby 14:09  |  David P. 20/10/09
      12.   #5 Tom ,right on the mark-another useless liberal arts major 14:14  |  JE 20/10/09
      13.   Josh Healy, the epitome of a self hating Jew 14:29  |  Mark from Georgia 20/10/09
      14.   just when everybody thought Goldstone was a nutter 15:03  |  Israeliguy 20/10/09
      15.   Comparing Guantanamo to Auschwitz is an obcenity 15:42  |  Nechama 20/10/09
      16.   Hey Peter, his poem is not offensive? 15:47  |  Nechama 20/10/09
      17.   Poem, or 15 minutes of fame 15:51  |  Frank 20/10/09
      18.   Like attracts like. Where`s Goldstone? 16:16  |  IW 20/10/09
      19.   it`s just bad poetry 16:21  |  ross 20/10/09
      20.   to Nechama #15 16:54  |  zeev 20/10/09
      21.   Healey absolutely right--Oren Is Likud Apparratchik 18:37  |  Dolphin 20/10/09
      22.   See, I liked Healey`s poem, and his message 19:57  |  Jon 20/10/09
      23.   i guess being a poet means knowing nothing but feelings 02:16  |  ralph 21/10/09
      24.   RE: Poetric Insanity 03:21  |  Matt 21/10/09
      25.   re: Poet of 15 Minutes of Fame 04:47  |  Spirit 21/10/09
      26.   Josh Healy is no Van Jones 05:33  |  eldar 21/10/09
      27.   to Gilad #3 - 3rd try 11:32  |  zeev 21/10/09
      28.   to hf #2 - 3rd try 11:34  |  zeev 21/10/09
      29.   #25 spirit 15:56  |  Frank 21/10/09
      30.   J Street right to bar Healy 19:52  |  bronxite10 21/10/09
      31.   Why throw him out? He`s a perfect J Street representative 06:33  |  B 22/10/09
      32.   Jstreet is not a friend of Israel 17:48  |  Mark Jeffery Koch 22/10/09
      33.   Is he a Poet-Czar, like V-Jones? 18:48  |  Mike 22/10/09
      34.   The veneer is crumbling 21:53  |  Mary 22/10/09
      35.   Practical politics 13:05  |  Yitzhak 27/10/09
      36.   Poetic License Revoked? 16:46  |  new_york_loner 27/10/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    15:08 Netanyahu: IDF refusal will bring about Israel's collapse
    13:50 EU rejects Palestinian bid for unilateral declaration of state
    14:40 Iran boosts fuel output to prove it can handle nuclear sanctions
    14:44 Israel ranks No. 32 least corrupt country in the world
    15:07 U.S. politician wants American Jews to buy West Bank homes
    15:01 Who is funding the rabbi who endorses killing gentile babies?
    16:02 'They're kosher vampires,' says Twilight and New Moon screenwriter
    11:39 TV ROUND-UP: Pro-settler IDF troops demoted; Lieberman slams press
    15:49 Israeli actor director Assi Dayan suffers severe heart attack
    09:21 Argentina protesters to Peres: You deserve Nobel for murder
    10:52 Court orders cop to pay NIS 50,000 to right-wing protester he attacked
    11:05 Police expose illegal arms trade in Israeli Arab town
    08:56 Palestinians to Arab states: You can stop Jerusalem light rail
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved