Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., October 23, 2009 Cheshvan 5, 5770 | | Israel Time: 06:16 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 09:41 13/10/2009
Israel sees court rulings on Palestinian land as mere 'recommendations'
By Akiva Eldar, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: dorit beinisch, israel news 

So what if the Supreme Court rules? In Israel those decisions are just recommendations, especially if they deal with Palestinian land. In most enlightened democratic countries, saying that decisions of the courts obligate the state authorities is like stating that the sun rises in the east. But that may not be so for Israel.

Last week, Supreme Court President Dorit Beinisch had to state that "rulings of this court are not mere recommendations, and the state is obliged to abide by them and to execute them with the necessary speed and efficiency, according to the circumstances of the matter."

The head of the judicial system added: "In the case before us, the state took the law into its own hands."
Advertisement
The case dates back to June 2006. The High Court of Justice at that time responded to a petition from Hamoked - the Center for the Defense of the Individual, and instructed the Defense Ministry to move the route of the separation fence near the villages of Azzun and Nabi Ilyas in the northern West Bank.

Aharon Barak, who was then president of the Supreme Court, stated in the ruling that "the petition points to an event that cannot be tolerated according to which the information that was supplied to the court did not reflect all of the considerations that were taken into account by the decision makers."

He was referring to the fact that the Defense Ministry did not reveal to the court that the route of the fence was congruent with the map of the plan to expand the settlement of Tzufim at the expense of Palestinian lands. The prosecution promised that the fence would be dismantled within six months from the completion of the fence along the new route.

It can be assumed that the officials of the Defense Ministry understood that when the court ordered that the injustice toward the residents of the Palestinian villages be corrected "in the shortest time possible" it was not referring to three and a half years.

In any case, from Beinisch's remarks about a ruling she handed down during a process of contempt of court, it was evident that this was not her interpretation of Barak's ruling.

"It is not possible to put up with conduct of this kind," she scolded the representatives of the prosecution and she ordered the state to pay the petitioners' court costs of NIS 20,000. This sum was added to another NIS 50,000 which the taxpayers paid when the original ruling was handed down as well as the salaries of the lawyers from the prosecution who were sent to defend against the contempt of court ruling.

Before closing the case, Beinisch stated that in countries where there is a rule of law, a political and public storm would have arisen over this.

"In this case before us, the state took the law into its own hands," she said.

And this is not the only case where the Defense Ministry has made a mockery of court decisions relating to the route of the fence. More than two years ago, the court ordered the state to consider an alternative to the fence's route that was robbing the village of Bil'in of lands in favor of the settlement of Modi'in Ilit, and to do so "within a reasonable period of time."

In the ruling that was handed down after 15 months, Beinisch wrote that the alternative that was chosen was not in accordance with the court decision and she ordered the state to abide by it "without further delay."

Since then 10 months have elapsed, the residents of the village and their supporters have demonstrated, the police have used tear gas, and the fence is still in place.

Maskit Handel of the Association of Civil Rights In Israel recently documented no fewer than eight cases where the state was, or still is, in contempt of rulings handed down by the High Court of Justice since 2006. Among other things, she found two decisions relating to the fortification of schools in communities along the border with the Gaza Strip, three decisions instructing the state to build 245 classrooms in East Jerusalem, and a decision to stop making the granting of work permits for migrant workers dependent on their working for a single employer.

Enlightened rule

An affidavit submitted to the High Court of Justice a few weeks ago (in response to a petition) by the Defense Minister's adviser on settlement affairs, Eitan Broshi, indicates that from Ehud Barak's point of view, anything relating to Palestinian rights, and not only the high court's rulings, are nothing more than a recommendation.

The affidavit states that the defense minister has decided, for the time being, to refrain from carrying out demolition orders against nine homes in Ofra that were built on private Palestinian land. The explanation no doubt convinced the Palestinians who lost their lands that they are living under an enlightened rule of occupation.

"There is no point in separating this individual case or any other without seeing the general picture and the system of circumstances under which the respondents are acting," the affidavit stated.

And what is the general picture? Two dozen outposts and numerous illegal homes? And what does the phrase "the system of circumstances" mean? Fear of the settlers?

Daniel Ben Simon, the faction chairman of Barak's party, Labor, declared during a tour of the outposts organized by Peace Now at the end of August, that if they are not vacated by the start of the winter session of the Knesset, "the Labor party will reconsider its continued membership of the government."

No special excitement could be seen among the factions on the right when the winter session opened Monday. However informed sources promise that this time they are serious. The sources reveal that in return for the pass the prime minister received with regard to freezing settlement construction, the defense minister has promised the Americans that there will be a speedy evacuation of the outposts, and he has even shown them the schedule.

Related articles:
  • Ari Shavit / A new Palestine
  • While Ramallah prospers
  • Ramadan in Ramallah / Partying in the West Bank's Tel Aviv
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Barring Refaeli
    Ultra-Orthodox rabbis are irate over a highway billboard featuring model Bar Refaeli.
    Goldstone vs. Obama
    Goldstone challenges U.S. president: Show me flaws in the report on Gaza war crimes.
      1.   Jail Time for Contempt is NOT Uncommon 05:06  |  Mark of Lewiston 13/10/09
      2.   observation 05:11  |  potobac 13/10/09
      3.   Not to worry - in time Palestinian will reverse the gains 05:23  |  Gazi Muileh 13/10/09
      4.   `RECOMMENDATIONS," 05:28  |  EL 13/10/09
      5.   Honestly, is this new or surprising...?! 07:23  |  Esther 13/10/09
      6.   Whose land is it? 08:22  |  Cham Ben Kahan 13/10/09
      7.   to No. 6 - Does it really matter? 13:59  |  M 13/10/09
      8.   EL (#4) May, May, you are asking a question and 14:12  |  Gil 13/10/09
      9.   Cham Ban Kahan (#6) 14:25  |  Gil 13/10/09
      10.   #8 gil and the law you cannot appeal beyond the supreme court 14:45  |  vhardman 13/10/09
      11.   This Time They Are Serious!!??!!?? 14:55  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/10/09
      12.   Truly a light unto all banana republics 15:05  |  American in NY 13/10/09
      13.   EL (#4) 15:21  |  Gil 13/10/09
      14.   Chaim! Like G-d you try to create reality with words 15:23  |  meir gush etzion 13/10/09
      15.   Israel: No Truth and No Justice 15:35  |  Vladek 13/10/09
      16.   EL (#4) 15:50  |  Gil 13/10/09
      17.   בימים ההם אין מלך בישראל איש הישר בעיניו יעשה 15:53  |  Esther 13/10/09
      18.   Gil sorry, it is not Governemnt Land--it is occupied territory 16:05  |  Labhras 13/10/09
      19.   #9 v hardhead aka Paul Harris---san remo is dead3rd try 16:21  |  Labhras 13/10/09
      20.   Labhras, the clueless oracle of Irelnad, has spoken 16:28  |  Darth Zaider (Ed) 13/10/09
      21.   At least Israel doesn`t have the court 16:39  |  Mark Lincoln 13/10/09
      22.   VHarmand (#10) This is not so 17:36  |  Gil 13/10/09
      23.   Darth Zaider on Jacques Gauthier 18:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/10/09
      24.   Settlements Ended Israeli Democracy--In Case You Didn`t Already 18:52  |  Dolphin 13/10/09
      25.   Laughable Claims To Democracy 18:52  |  chet 13/10/09
      26.   #20 Thus Speaks Darthie 00:27  |  Johnboy 14/10/09
      27.   vladek 03:25  |  sweis Melbourne 14/10/09
      28.   To Cham ben Kahan #6 `Whose Land is it?` 08:20  |  Colin Wright 14/10/09
      29.   Colin Wright (#26) Dear Colin ever heard of `Safiyya bint Huyayy` 12:52  |  Gil 14/10/09
      30.   darth zaider (ed) 17:54  |  potobac 14/10/09
      31.   gil 29 16:40  |  potobac 15/10/09
      32.   The Supreme Court is not answerable to democratic institutions 04:30  |  Ben Tzur 23/10/09
      33.   The Supreme Court is authoritarian, Part 2 04:37  |  Ben Tzur 23/10/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    05:43 Mitchell: Effort to revive Mideast talks hasn't failed
    04:21 EU official: Israel out of loop on Iran talks
    04:20 Analysis / Will Iran nuke deal bury chances of Israeli attack?
    06:06 Solana to Haaretz: New rules of war needed for age of terror
    04:50 West Bank settlers ramping up construction
    03:07 Comment / BBC is correct to give platform to far-rightist
    03:48 Israelis working to save endangered species through cloning
    23:58 TV ROUND-UP: Coalition crisis for Netanyahu, demonstrators break into BBC studios
    03:52 Clinton to Obama: We've made scant progress on Mideast peace
    05:06 German museum refuses to return Kafka manuscript to Israel
    04:37 Will arrest of key rightist further inflame settler extremism?
    05:02 UNICEF to expand activities, open active office in Israel
    09:17 Bar Refaeli highway billboard roils rabbis
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved