Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., November 25, 2009 Kislev 8, 5770 | | Israel Time: 18:57 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Jews prominent among lawyers defending Guantanamo inmates
By Nathan Guttman, The Forward
Tags: terrorism, human rights 

GUANTANAMO BAY, CUBA - David Remes, a Washington attorney who left a major corporate law firm to take on full-time representation of terrorism suspects held in the American detention center here, recalled vividly one of his early visits to meet with his clients:

"We were a group of lawyers, and the young guard was leading us through the camp," Remes said. "Then he looked at us and at the huts surrounding the camp's yard, and said, 'This looks like a guided tour of a concentration camp.'"

Remes, who established the not-for-profit legal practice, Appeal for Justice, and now represents 19 detainees, tried to avoid such comparisons and stressed that he sees no equation between Guantanamo and the Nazi camps. Still, he added, "When you consider the way Jews were dehumanized as vermin, there's an unfortunate echo."
Advertisement
It is a sentiment born of Remes's own sense of Jewish identity. And even if Remes' way of putting it is his own, the source of personal commitment is one shared by many other lawyers representing the remaining 225 Guantanamo detainees in American courts. For the defense: Jonathan Hafetz, of the American Civil Liberties Union, and Karen Abravanel say their religious background has not interfered with their ability to defend Muslim terrorism suspects. Many of these lawyers are Jewish. In fact, Jewish attorneys are considered to be the backbone of the campaign to provide legal rights for the Guantanamo detainees, all imprisoned without charge or trial.

"Among the lawyers who were involved in this from the beginning, and even now, there is a substantive over-representation of Jews," said Joe Margulies, law professor at Northwestern University and veteran fighter for the legal rights of Guantanamo detainees. Margulies and other Jewish colleagues were the first to take on the cause, and they are still leading the pack in pro bono representation of the detainees once tagged by then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld as the "worst of the worst" of America's enemies.

Since then, it has become clear that many of Guantanamo's detainees had little to do with terror. At its peak, the camp held more than 600 detainees, but most have since been released without charge. Of the 225 remaining detainees, dozens, such as the Chinese Ouigers held in minimum security Camp Iguana, are waiting for a third country to accept them, since they cannot return to their homelands. Others - there are no exact figures - will be tried either by American courts or by military commissions. President Barack Obama has also suggested his administration may seek to indefinitely incarcerate, without charge or trial, a small number of the remaining detainees whom prosecutors doubt they can convict, but whom they nevertheless consider too dangerous to release.

The struggle over these detainees took many turns until the Supreme Court ruled in 2008 that Guantanamo terrorism suspects have the right to habeas corpus - that is, to have their case independently reviewed by a court of the United States. Altogether, some 600 attorneys have represented detainees in their habeas corpus cases since the United States set up the Guantanamo center in 2002, and Jews still play a major role. Speaking with their clients means traveling to Guantanamo regularly for meetings that take place in Camp Echo, a facility built to accommodate these discussions.

Initial attempts to challenge the legal status of Guantanamo detainees in court were led by five attorneys, all of them Jewish.

"There was some debate about it in our office," recalled Michael Ratner, president of the Center for Constitutional Rights, as he described the early decision within his organization to take on the defense of terror suspects at a time when America was still in shock after the September 11 attacks. "My answer was that what's going on is so distinct in taking away fundamental rights that we have to protect the right of habeas corpus."

Not all Jewish attorneys share that view. When Nathan Lewin, a prominent Washington lawyer, was asked in 2008 to help prepare a brief to the Supreme Court on behalf of a Guantanamo detainee, he refused. "A lawyer is not a cab driver," Lewin said. "A lawyer has the right, if not the duty, to look at the ideology of a defendant." Lewin argued that, independent of their guilt or innocence, the presumed ideology of Guantanamo detainees runs contrary to his views as a Jew. "If someone tries to undermine my beliefs and convictions by attacking the Western world and Israel, I don't want any part in representing these people in the legal system," he added.

Collective memory

But Remes said that the collective Jewish memory of suffering and persecution was key to his motivation to protect Guantanamo detainees. "It made me identify to a certain extent with their suffering and persecution," he said.

Margulies agreed. He spoke of Jewish understanding of other people's suffering as "ingrained in our DNA," and said that Jews understand "what it means to be singled out."

Others point to the broader set of Jewish values of justice and tikkun olam (righting the world) as the driving force behind their decision to take on these cases. Jonathan Hafetz of the ACLU sees it as "an extension of the participation of many Jewish lawyers in human rights and civil rights causes" dating to the 1960s. "This is the new front," he said.

Hafetz, who is a staff attorney with the ACLU's National Security Project, represented one of Guantanamo's most widely known detainees. Mohammed Jawad was 15 when he was arrested in Afghanistan. He spent six years in American custody. Last August, he was released, and upon returning to Afghanistan he alleged that he suffered abuse and torture in Guantanamo.

Hafetz and other Jewish lawyers representing terror suspects said their religion was never an obstacle when engaging with their Muslim clients. Karen Abravanel, a New York attorney representing a Saudi detainee, said the issue of her religion was first raised only after several meetings with her client in Camp Echo. "He said, 'Abravanel sounds like a Jewish name,'" she recalled. When she confirmed that she was Jewish, her client replied, "This is the first time I am in a room with a Jewish person." From there, the two went on to discuss traditions, holidays and dietary laws. "It was pretty meaningful for me," Abravanel said.

According to several Jewish lawyers, the only instance in which faith was raised as an issue with the detainees was before the first round of visits to Guantanamo. One of the attorneys, Tom Wilner, said he was told by two of his clients that their interrogators warned them that he, Wilner, was Jewish. "How can you trust a Jew?" one detainee said he was told. "They only want to take advantage of Muslims."

The defense attorneys saw this as an attempt to drive a wedge between the Jewish lawyers and their Muslim clients. Wilner filed an affidavit to the court on the issue, which the court sealed. The military filed no response, he said. The attorneys agreed that the attempt failed.

Several Jewish attorneys also invoke the story of a detainee who asked his lawyer whether he was Jewish. When the answer was negative, the detainee was crestfallen. "I heard they were the best," he said, according to the tale.

Another possible wedge issue was the attorneys' views on Israel. "There is no distinction in the Middle East between Jews and Israel," Remes said, "so sometimes it requires an effort to explain these are not identical." Others also encountered situations in which they felt it necessary to tell their clients that they do not necessarily support all Israeli policies.

While attorneys visiting Guantanamo speak of the good rapport they've built with the detainees, guards and commanders on the ground report a different experience. Bruce Vargo, commander of the Joint Detention Group, said that since January there have been 750 assaults on guards, most of them involving the throwing of bodily fluids by detainees. "We call this a mental battlefield," Vargo said. He stressed that guards are under strict orders not to respond to detainee provocations.

Most observers doubt the Obama administration will meet its self-declared January 22, 2010, deadline for closing Guantanamo - one of Obama's most publicized campaign vows. But clearly its days are numbered, and commanders on the ground are fighting a rear-guard action for the detention center's legacy. Despite accounts by detainees and attorneys of abuse, the military believes that the center's image is in large part a problem of bad publicity and misperceptions.

"This place has become a symbol of everything that has gone wrong around the world," said Thomas Copeman, commander of the Guantanamo Joint Task Force - an apparent reference to the abuse of Muslim prisoners by American soldiers at Abu Ghraib in Iraq, and by employees and contract agents for the CIA at so-called black sites around the world. "When all is said and done, the truth will come out."

The defense attorneys, ironically, fear the center's closing almost as much as they have been alarmed by its existence. Guantanamo's shutdown, they say, will create a perception that all problems have been solved, while they believe there is still more to do.

"We don't like a lot of the things that are happening," Ratner said. He referred to the plans for continuation of a preventive detention program even after Guantanamo is closed, the continued incarceration of uncharged detainees in Afghanistan, and the use of military commissions instead of courts. "The problem," he said,"is that the pendulum did not swing back the whole way."

By arrangement with The Forward

Related articles:
  • Suspected 9/11 mastermind, 4 co-defendants offer to confess
  • VIDEO: Lawyers release first-ever footage of Guantanamo interrogation
  • Freed BBC reporter writes to Guantanamo detainee
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    New Mideast plan
    Ray Hanania, American-Palestinian, married to a Jew, running for PA presidency.
    Shalit on the table
    PA negotiation officials for Gilad Shalit deal arrive in Syria to discuss finalizing deal.
      1.   Ha-ha - Welcome to America 06:15  |  Mike 29/09/09
      2.   It`s sad that so-called `Christians` are often the last 06:17  |  AB 29/09/09
      3.   Will this never stop 07:00  |  Alex 29/09/09
      4.   progressive jews rock 07:16  |  jj 29/09/09
      5.   Who pays these attorneys? 07:27  |  shtarka 29/09/09
      6.   Jewish Lawyers? 08:40  |  Chaim Ben Kahan 29/09/09
      7.   Well, it is fair to assume that there is an over-representation.. 09:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/09/09
      8.   Why not?? 11:50  |  MiddleStanian 29/09/09
      9.   Jewish lawyers 12:10  |  Elise 29/09/09
      10.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 13:14  |  james burke 29/09/09
      11.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 13:33  |  Gene 29/09/09
      12.   They were right to 13:47  |  Chris Linthwaite 29/09/09
      13.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 13:48  |  Mark Bernadiner 29/09/09
      14.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 13:52  |  disgusted 29/09/09
      15.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 14:19  |  Brod 29/09/09
      16.   Easy solution let Muslims and Arabs stop murdering the innocent!! 14:29  |  arthur 29/09/09
      17.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 14:53  |  Joe Kelsall 29/09/09
      18.   Just a note...there is one thing not mentioned 16:44  |  Lynn 29/09/09
      19.   This is Judaism at its best, not the Baraks a& Bibis of the worl 17:45  |  Secular 29/09/09
      20.   THEY WERE RIGHT TO 00:12  |  Harriet 30/09/09
      21.   #7 Swiss displays his ignorance 09:28  |  shtarka 30/09/09
      22.   nice one 18:07  |  rikki 04/10/09
      23.   Jewish lawyers defending muslim murderers 18:46  |  Tony Petros 25/11/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Award-Winning 'Obsession'
    Watch 'Obsession: Radical Islam's War Against the West' Online FOR FREE!
    Protea Hills
    A Retirement Village in Nature Nestled in the Foothills of Jerusalem
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    18:43 Hamas leader accuses Israel of holding up Shalit deal
    18:44 Netanyahu: Settlement freeze will prove Israel really wants peace
    18:29 Enraged rightists on settlement freeze: Netanyahu spitting in our faces
    17:01 Barghouti: Shalit abduction achieved what no dialogue could
    16:00 'Kick a Jew day' ends in suspensions for 10 Florida students
    12:58 Facebook suicide threat sparks massive manhunt in Eilat
    10:13 Israeli scientists: Solve erectile dysfunction with electric shock
    10:10 TV ROUND-UP: Sides edge toward Shalit swap, Barghouti release debated
    14:14 Lieberman demands cabinet take polygraph tests over leak to Haaretz
    15:51 Iran cleric: Religious authorities have begun taking control of schools
    09:46 Yedidia Stern drops out of race for attorney general
    09:32 Rights group: 69 cases of Palestinian olive trees destroyed, but no prosecutions
    08:25 With all eyes on Iran, who's watching Pakistan's nuclear arsenal?
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved