Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., September 29, 2009 Tishrei 11, 5770 | | Israel Time: 11:47 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Culture Strenger than Fiction Business Real Estate Focus U.S.A. Magazine Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 17:42 24/09/2009
Netanyahu: No peace until Palestinians accept Israel as Jewish state
By Natasha Mozgovaya, Haaretz Correspondent and Haaretz Service
Tags: Iran, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad 

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told Haaretz on Wednesday that he would not agree to a Palestinian demand that Israel accept the 1967 borders as a condition for renewing peace negotiations.

Netanyahu also gave a condition of his own, saying Thursday that he would never drop his demand that the Palestinians recognize Israel as a Jewish state.

"I told Abu Mazen [Abbas] I believe peace hinges first on his readiness to stand before his people and say, 'We...are committed to recognizing Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people'," Netanyahu said.
Advertisement
"I will not drop this subject and other important issues under any final peace agreement," Netanyahu said.

Netanyahu said that U.S. President Barack Obama's speech to the United Nations General Assembly on Wednesday was "positive" because "he also said something we had been seeking for six months, that we have to meet and begin the diplomatic process without preconditions."

Obama had spoken "clearly about Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people," said Netanyahu. "I believe that disagreement about this is the root of the conflict."

Netanyahu also pointed out that Obama had made reference to Israeli efforts to improve the Palestinian economy by lifting roadblocks.

Obama speech on Wednesday was one of many from world leaders, and the American president focused a portion of his talk on efforts toward Middle East Peace.

"The goal is clear," Obama told the General Assembly, "two states living side by side in peace and security - a Jewish State of Israel, with true security for all Israelis; and a viable, independent Palestinian state with contiguous territory that ends the occupation that began in 1967, and realizes the potential of the Palestinian people."

Referring to Obama's statement Netanyahu said, "The things he said about the occupation are not new. He also said them in Cairo, and in fact that is the formula adopted by the road map and it does not say we have to go back to the 1967 borders.

"This is the formula adopted by governments before the one I head, which did not agree to go back to the 1967 borders. We certainly would [also] not agree to that. In the matter of the settlements he also said nothing new. These disagreements should not prevent the beginning of the process which, among other things if it is successful, will also decide this issue."

Netanyahu said Obama, like other American presidents, reflected the deep basic friendship between the American and the Israeli people, and that "he stood in Cairo before the whole Muslim world and said this relationship would never be severed." Netanyahu added he believed the obligation of the United States to Israel's security was total.

When asked about claims that Tuesday's three-way summit with Palestinian Authority chairman Mahmoud Abbas and Obama would become an excuse for foot-dragging, Netanyahu responded, "not on our part."

Netanyahu told Channel 2 that Obama's speech to the the UN regarding negotiations without preconditions and the two state solution was "an important blessing."

"The president said let's come and resume the peace process without preconditions. As you know I have been saying that for nearly six months. I was happy," Netanyahu said.

However, Israelis and Palestinians said Wednesday that their envoys would meet with U.S. officials but not with each other, cementing the impression that the summit had produced little results.

Chief Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat said there would be no follow-up session with the Israelis because the two sides hadn't bridged the divides that have prevented them from resuming talks.

"It's not happening because we agreed to continue dealing with the Americans until we reach the agreement that will enable us to relaunch the negotiations," Erekat said.

Israeli government spokesman Mark Regev said Israel would dispatch envoys to meet with U.S. officials in Washington, but there were no plans now to meet again with the Palestinians.

He said, however, that it was Israel's "sincere hope that we will see the restart of direct Israeli-Palestinian talks."

The Palestinians refuse to restart talks until Israel freezes settlement construction. They also want talks to restart where they left off before breaking down earlier this year, something Netanyahu has refused.

'Obama assured commitment to stopping Iran nukes

Netanyahu told several U.S. network television stations late Wednesday that Obama had also assured him he was committed to stopping Iran's nuclear program.

In those interviews, Netanyahu also reiterated that Israel was unwilling to freeze "life" in West Bank settlements.

Answering to whether he knew how long it was before Iran could produce a nuclear weapon, Netanyahu told ABC interviewer Charlie Gibson that he didn't "want to discuss whether we need another week or another month."

"The crucial question is, what's the goal? And the president assured me time and again that the goal is to prevent Iran from developing a nuclear weapon. And I think that's the right goal," the premier said.

The prime minister added that he saw Iran as "the major sponsor of world terrorism. Now, imagine what terrorism could be if the terrorists had a patron that gave them a nuclear umbrella, or worse, if that patron actually gave them nuclear weapons. "

"That's a nightmare scenario, and we all have to ensure that it doesn't happen," Netanyahu told ABC.

Netanyahu also reiterated comments he made recently about what he considered as the instability of the current regime in Tehran, saying he thought "this regime is a lot weaker than people think, and I think the civilized countries are a lot stronger than they tend to think about themselves."

"This regime tyrannizes its own people, guns them down when they peacefully protest for freedom," the prime minister added.

"There are so many reasons, endless reasons why this should not be allowed to happen. And it's time the international community acted in unison to make sure that it doesn't happen," Netanyahu said.

In an interview to Fox News, Netanyahu commented on the possibility of unilateral action against Iran, saying "any country has and reserves the right for self defense and Israel is no exception but I think the specter of Iran arming itself with nuclear weapons and possibly giving it to terrorists or giving them [is] sufficiently troublesome for the international community to get its act together and act to stop this from happening."

Answering to the question whether he was convinced Iran wanted a nuclear weapon, the premier asserted: "Yes I am."

Netanyahu: Won't freeze 'life' in settlements

On the subject of renewing peace negotiations with the Palestinian Authority, Netanyahu asserted to NBC interview Matt Lauer that he was "willing to make gestures to help the peace process."

When asked how big a gesture Israel intends to make, the premier said: "We'll get there very soon, I suppose."

"But I'll tell you one thing I'm not willing to do. I can't freeze life," Netanyahu added, referring to a possible West Bank settlement freeze, insisted on by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas.

"There are a quarter of a million people there, in these communities which are called 'settlements', although really most of them are bedroom suburbs of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem".

Echoing the same sentiment, the prime minister said he was looking "to reconcile two things. One is to start the peace process again, something that I'm glad - I hope that we started today."

"And, second, to enable normal life to continue. There are a quarter of a million people living in these communities. You know, they need kindergartens. They need schools. They need health clinics." Netanyahu said

"They're living. I'm committed not to build new settlements. I am committed not to expropriate additional land for existing settlements. But people have to live. You can't freeze life."

Stressing what he felt as the shared Palestinian responsibility for stalled peace talks, Netanyahu told ABC that "Anytime Israel met an Arab leader who has genuinely committed to peace, such as Anwar Sadat, we made peace," adding that the government who achieved peace with Egypt "was a Likud government under Menachem Begin.

"When Yitzhak Rabin, the Labor prime minister, met the late King Hussein, who wanted peace, we made peace," the premier said, adding that peace could be made "if the Palestinian leadership says we want peace, we recognize Israel as the Jewish state, the nation state of the Jewish people, just as we're asked to recognize the Palestinian state as the nation state of the Palestinian people."

The prime minister concluded by saying that Israel wanted "a real peace. You know, we don't want a peace where we hand over territory which becomes a base for Iran's proxy so they can fire thousands of rockets on us," adding that Israel was "one of the tiniest countries in the world."

"Now, if you're the size of Monaco or the size of Luxembourg, that by itself doesn't pose a security problem. But if your neighbors also say, 'We're going to destroy you or throw you into the sea and fire thousands of rockets at you,' that does pose a security problem. So, Israel wants both recognition and security from its neighbors, and this will be the task of the negotiations in the coming months," Netanyahu added.

PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
No Israelis allowed
Egypt media group agrees on massive boycott against Israel and Israelis of all positions
Picturesque Yom Kippur
In Pictures/ The empty and earily quiet streets of Israel on Yom Kippur
  1.   US Policy is unchanged, colonies illegitimate... 05:00  |  BBSNews 24/09/09
  2.   Obama more interested in his popularity 05:08  |  Lorin 24/09/09
  3.   goood old mark regev 05:54  |  edgar 24/09/09
  4.   Deluded Netanyahu 06:16  |  Cynic 24/09/09
  5.   Seems to me Obama Sold Israel out at the UN 06:31  |  Shepherd 24/09/09
  6.   So Amend Your Constitution, er, Basic Law 07:33  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/09/09
  7.   What a hypocrit Bibi is about "preconditions"... 07:34  |  Esther 24/09/09
  8.   Netanyahu`s position is weak and that`s obvious to all except ... 07:40  |  S 24/09/09
  9.   State sponsored terrorism 08:25  |  Steve Beikirch 24/09/09
  10.   "No Weapon" Doesn`t Mean WAR 08:33  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/09/09
  11.   Too true 08:41  |  Mark Lincoln 24/09/09
  12.   #2 Lorin, I realize you live in CA, but c`mon... 08:48  |  golda 24/09/09
  13.   borders, settlements 08:53  |  barkochma 24/09/09
  14.   Should it be up to Israel? 09:19  |  isratinian 24/09/09
  15.   Mark of Lewiston #4 09:28  |  S 24/09/09
  16.   Israel won`t agree 09:47  |  rm 24/09/09
  17.   Judea and Samaria 09:56  |  Gavriela 24/09/09
  18.   The Palestinians shouldn`t care anymore...... 10:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/09/09
  19.   Arabs still not interested in Palestinian State 10:36  |  Baruch Gold 24/09/09
  20.   Time to Reclaim Gaza? 10:44  |  Harold S Kramer 24/09/09
  21.   So Obama wants "an end to the occupation 11:07  |  Larry W 24/09/09
  22.   mark of lewiston "time for obama to force both sides to the table 12:06  |  harzion 24/09/09
  23.   mark of lewiston "use one of the gaza cards as a hammer" 12:07  |  yirmiyahu 24/09/09
  24.   1967 12:19  |  Hermann 24/09/09
  25.   Russia has agreed to support sanctions against Iran! 12:23  |  Realist 24/09/09
  26.   1967 12:39  |  Hisham 24/09/09
  27.   global civil society`s response 13:05  |  Nick Ferriman 24/09/09
  28.   You are dead on point Lorin 13:09  |  STU 24/09/09
  29.   A line of truth drawn in History by Bibi ! 13:11  |  Akram Zekaria 24/09/09
  30.   Hypocrisy never fails to amaze 13:11  |  Ishai 24/09/09
  31.   another Victory to Hamas 14:11  |  Antwan Saca 24/09/09
  32.   Netanyahu says status quo preferable to peace 14:13  |  American in NY 24/09/09
  33.   Palestinians want the result of negotiations before hand 14:19  |  Avi 24/09/09
  34.   cat is out of the bag...lanf theft 14:22  |  sam i am 24/09/09
  35.   ...and the war... 15:29  |  Cesare 24/09/09
  36.   # 18 Swiss (Dino) 15:44  |  christa 24/09/09
  37.   The more critical concern is the U.S. stance.... 15:46  |  Smadar 24/09/09
  38.   pre-conditions 15:51  |  Sameer S Reehani 24/09/09
  39.   A Jewish state ? 15:53  |  christa 24/09/09
  40.   All that is asked of Israel is to obey the law 15:53  |  CJ 24/09/09
  41.   #34 sam u were 16:00  |  *BEN JABO 24/09/09
  42.   "get their land back" 16:01  |  ol` Case 24/09/09
  43.   it does sound so noble doesn`t it? 16:04  |  rm 24/09/09
  44.   Netanyahu no32 16:20  |  Hisham 24/09/09
  45.   what is all this stupid talk 16:27  |  michael 24/09/09
  46.   # 6 Mark of Lewiston 16:39  |  The Teacher/Instruct 24/09/09
  47.   Silliness 16:47  |  Vladek 24/09/09
  48.   Jewish State --What happens to the other 25% 16:51  |  Stephen 24/09/09
  49.   Mark of Lewiston # 6 16:58  |  American in NY 24/09/09
  50.   christa 17:01  |  dave 24/09/09
  51.   Netanyahu: No Peace ......Jewish State 17:03  |  Marilyn K. Melville 24/09/09
  52.   Define Mark of Lewiston? 17:22  |  utagawa 24/09/09
  53.   Israel a Jewish state? 17:25  |  JW 24/09/09
  54.   Would a people "longing for peace" act like this....??? 17:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/09/09
  55.   Someone please tell the Pals 1967 was 42 years ago 17:39  |  Kipperraes 24/09/09
  56.   Stephen and Jewish State - AGAIN WRONG 17:40  |  A TRUE American 24/09/09
  57.   #37 the complete jerk and illegal ? how ? 17:44  |  v hardman 24/09/09
  58.   Saying no to 1967 borders=no to peace 17:53  |  jens 24/09/09
  59.   # 45 17:53  |  Alan 24/09/09
  60.   S - Borders can be Negotiated, Not Nature of State 18:08  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/09/09
  61.   Christa 18:08  |  Jack Steiner 24/09/09
  62.   It is difficult, nearly impossible to see a resolution of the... 18:12  |  Eitan 24/09/09
  63.   Freeze Settlements 18:17  |  Leeguy 24/09/09
  64.   There will be no peace until there is a Palestinian State... 18:28  |  Silvienne 24/09/09
  65.   In the absence of anything else reasonable and just... 18:30  |  Esther 24/09/09
  66.   #43, American in NY... 18:31  |  Silvienne 24/09/09
  67.   So much for "no preconditions" 18:34  |  sh 24/09/09
  68.   Christa, Tell Armenians there should not be an Armenian State 19:05  |  eve 24/09/09
  69.   Netanyahu: no peace until... 19:20  |  Colin Wright 24/09/09
  70.   What would be the next hurdle? 19:21  |  janice 24/09/09
  71.   insanity 19:33  |  Rog 24/09/09
  72.   `Global civil society`s response`, Nick? (#27) 19:39  |  Morris Valentine 24/09/09
  73.   To barkochma 19:40  |  Marc Amelot 24/09/09
  74.   Simple Solution to the Palestinian problem 19:42  |  Canadian 24/09/09
  75.   Swiss (Dino) What is wrong with Obama`s stand? 19:48  |  David Israel 24/09/09
  76.   dave 44 19:52  |  potobac 24/09/09
  77.   Netanyahu-style crap 19:57  |  a true Zionist 24/09/09
  78.   The "occupation" 20:04  |  Martyman39 24/09/09
  79.   #52 Very good idea but with BiBi?? 20:17  |  Ardi 24/09/09
  80.   student teacher # 40 re Mark of Lewiston- query resolved 20:24  |  American in NY 24/09/09
  81.   No brainer for no brainer 20:27  |  John 24/09/09
  82.   to protobac 21:06  |  Dave 24/09/09
  83.   #25 Russia has agreed.... 21:14  |  Observer 24/09/09
  84.   A Laughably Predictable Conflict 21:48  |  Antonius 24/09/09
  85.   Great 22:00  |  John Lieb 24/09/09
  86.   A TRUE American - although I agree with you 22:01  |  David Israel 24/09/09
  87.   It`s time 22:34  |  Yakov 24/09/09
  88.   West Bank 23:12  |  J B 24/09/09
  89.   Kipperraes#50 00:15  |  Mike 25/09/09
  90.   FACT is the Palestinians have NEVER recognized Israel 00:55  |  www.not-haaretz.com 25/09/09
  91.   More impossible preconditions designed to avoid talking 00:59  |  peacelover 25/09/09
  92.   What`s in a name? 01:14  |  Nezam el Jenini 25/09/09
  93.   #87 THE PALESTINIAN NATIONAL CHARTER 02:00  |  Gil 25/09/09
  94.   #87 THE PALESTINIAN NATIONAL CHARTER 02:01  |  Gil 25/09/09
  95.   #33 Avi asks.... 02:08  |  Johnboy 25/09/09
  96.   netanyahu`s speach, at the united nations 02:26  |  cathryn siegelman 25/09/09
  97.   wake up 05:14  |  its not 1967 25/09/09
  98.   #58 Jens - The Arabs said NO to `67 borders 06:25  |  *BEN JABO 25/09/09
  99.   #40 CJ = Stop being a lawyer 06:28  |  *BEN JABO 25/09/09
  100.   #96 Cathryn Siegelman 06:37  |  *BEN JABO 25/09/09
  101.   #88 JB - DALLAS 06:42  |  * BEN JABO 25/09/09
  102.   #77 True Zionist - You should be in ZION not NY 06:44  |  *BEN JABO 25/09/09
  103.   1.5 million Palestinians 07:18  |  Spokanite 25/09/09
  104.   What does "Jewish State" mean? removing Israeli Arabs or RoR 23:02  |  Bloodyscot 26/09/09
  105.   Annapolis is 1967 00:13  |  Daniel Garcia. 27/09/09
  106.   Ben Jarbo 00:24  |  Stephen 27/09/09
  107.   one democratic Palestine is the inevitable solution 15:36  |  sami abu ismail 28/09/09
  108.   Islamist-Jihadist trick 18:43  |  Brod 28/09/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
Holiday Greetings from the Heart
LIBI-Caring for Israeli Soldiers
WORLD'S LARGEST YOM KIPPUR SERVICE
150 Locations. 40,000 Participants Great Investment. Guaranteed Results
Date Local Jewish Singles
Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Amazing Jewelry
Visit SoKoBe.com for the best priced fine jewelry in the world
More Headlines
11:47 Israel marks 36th anniversary of Yom Kippur War
10:51 Iran: We'll soon set time for inspection of second nuke plant
10:34 Crucial nuclear talks give Iran 'last chance' to dodge harsh sanctions
10:54 ANALYSIS / Why is Israel suddenly praising Iran sanctions?
09:32 Jews prominent among lawyers defending Guantanamo inmates
04:47 Israel ramps up efforts to block Hamas fund-raising network
09:08 Why Israelis shouldn't read travel guides to their country
08:15 TV ROUND-UP: Obama warns Iran, IAF kills 3 Gaza militants
11:44 Study: Four years after pullout, 16% of Gaza evacuees unemployed
22:51 Hamas agrees in principle to reconcile with Fatah
05:18 Israel's claims of Sweden-Hamas contacts likely unfounded
11:09 Foreign diplomats to rally with Israeli Arabs marking October 2000 riots
08:02 Israel envoys head to U.S. for talks on relaunching peace talks
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved