Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 07, 2009 Tishrei 19, 5770 | | Israel Time: 13:54 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Real Estate Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 17:29 22/09/2009
The Gaza War 'victory' - Has Israel grown dependent on terror?
By Bradley Burston
Tags: Israel News, terror 

Click here for more articles by Bradley Burston



It is a sickening thought. It is one that many in Israel have had to live with for months. One they have kept inside, silenced, some for reasons of guilt, others out of sympathy, superstition, or denial:

Despite everything, despite international denunciation unprecedented even by the standards of past Israeli operations, despite mind-reeling devastation of residential areas and unconscionable loss of life among Palestinian civilians, could the winter invasion of Gaza have actually been a success?

The suggestion was put forward this week in a Washington Post opinion piece headlined "Israel's Gaza Vindication." The Monday column was written by Jackson Diehl, who covered the first intifada as the paper's Jerusalem bureau chief, and who early in the Gaza war had called Cast Lead "Olmert's final failure."

Diehl noted that while a number of Israel's stated - and patently unrealizable - aims for the war went unaddressed, two crucial elements of the postwar reality were cause for distinct Israeli satisfaction: a precipitous drop in Palestinian rocket launchings against the Negev, and a considerable rise in the strength of Hamas blood rival, Mahmoud Abbas' Fatah-led Palestinian Authority in the West Bank.

Israel's defeat in Gaza has widely been portrayed as a foregone conclusion. During the war, Time magazine's cover was headlined "Why Israel can't win." An accompanying article asked darkly "Can Israel survive its assault on Gaza?"

Diehl's article argues that Israel has done far more. "The point," he writes, "is that Israel has bought itself a stretch of relative peace with Hamas, just as its costly 2006 invasion of Lebanon has produced three years of quiet on that front. From the Israeli perspective, a respite from conflict is the most that can be expected from either group - or from their mutual sponsor, Iran."

The idea that the very brutality of these wars is what caused them to succeed, raises a number of extremely uncomfortable questions for Israelis. There is little question that a intentionally ferocious military offensive was the object of Israeli strategic planners, even if real efforts were made to reduce civilian casualties.

On the first day of the war, IDF Southern Front Commander Yoav Galant said that in attacking Hamas in the Gaza Strip, the Israel Defense Forces would try to "send Gaza decades into the past" in terms of weapons capabilities, while achieving "the maximum number of enemy casualties and keeping Israel Defense Forces casualties at a minimum."

Is this the meaning of victory here? Is resort to extreme force the only way to defend Israeli civilians against rocket attacks north and south? If this is how you win, what does this say about us, and our future? What does this say about the enemies we face, and the viability, durability and credibility of any peace agreements forged between the sides?

Was it, in fact, the bludgeon of overwhelming military force that has kept the borders quiet north and south? If not, one must ask, why else have the rockets stopped? What else has changed? Not occupation, not settlement activity, certainly not Palestinian affection for Israel as a neighbor.

The issue, at a time of relative quiet vis a vis armed Palestinian groups, raises other questions as well. To what extent has terrorism itself proven a failure, has it begun dying out, and if it is, will Israel be capable of an appropriate response?

Earlier this month, a number of analysts marked the eight anniversary of the 9/11 attacks with assessments that Al-Qaida was in decided retreat. Time ran headlined a story by Tony Karon headlined "Why Osama Bin Laden failed." The Guardian, meanwhile, reported that Al-Qaida faced a recruitment crisis.

Perhaps most significantly, a recent Pew Global Attitudes poll found "Support for suicide bombing in freefall among Muslim publics."

Of the nine Muslim publics polled, support for suicide bombings was far the strongest among Palestinians, with 68 percent calling it often or sometimes justified [a decline of only two percentage points in the last two years], and only 17 percent ruling out bombings altogether.

Yet the fact remains that Palestinian terrorism, whether borne by Qassam or suicide bomber, has decreased dramatically.

At the same time, terrorism, whether real or not, remains central to Israel's explanations of many of the most morally problematic of its policies, including the siege of Gaza and restrictions on the movements and commerce of Palestinians in the West Bank.

For the right, the specter of terrorism has become the primary, at times, the only argument against territorial compromise in the West Bank.

So reliant has Israel become on terrorism as the underpinning of its policies, it remains to be seen if its reflex dependency on Palestinian violence can be replaced by a world view appropriate to a Holy Land uncontaminated by terrorism.

May this be a year in which we have a chance to find out. May this be a year in which Palestinians have the steadfastness and the strength and the shrewdness to resist the temptation to launch attacks, and may Israel have the might and the wisdom and the ability to change course, to keep from launching military adventures when the other side is, for whatever reason, holding its fire.

____________________


Follow Bradley Burston on Twitter

Previous Blogs:

Can there be such a thing as an Israeli hero?
For Israel, a New Year, and a new left
This Jewish New Year, let's put an end to hope
A straight's prayer for young Israelis shot for being gay
Mr. Obama, have a talk with these Israelis, and soon
The painful cost to Israel of its settler adventure
Will Israel grant asylum to fascism?
This is what is wrong with a Jewish state
Slapping Obama, or Please God, keep Israel from making peace
Outpost Watch: Obama's future minefield - and Netanyahu's
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Israeli breakthrough
Israeli firm develops a way to make electrity from street traffic.
Family Goy
Animated TV family discovers Jewish roots, hilarity ensues.
  1.   terror not a "requirement" but a reality 17:13  |  Paul Freedman 22/09/09
  2.   Bradley 17:21  |  Your problem is 22/09/09
  3.   Bunk! (but not Burston`s) 17:41  |  Victor 22/09/09
  4.   Um Victor, that provacation would be HAMAS tearing up the 18:08  |  Jacob Blues 22/09/09
  5.   To Jacob Blues... 18:22  |  Silvienne 22/09/09
  6.   The chicken or the egg 18:28  |  B. Roberts 22/09/09
  7.   DELETED BY MODERATOR 18:34  |  Sidney 22/09/09
  8.   really victor? 18:38  |  citizen zero 22/09/09
  9.   Obama stopped the Qassams, not Cast Lead 18:38  |  PZ 22/09/09
  10.   Achievable peace? 18:41  |  D.L.Martin 22/09/09
  11.   Is terror against an "oppressor" really terror....??? 18:42  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/09/09
  12.   Terrorism is dying out? 19:21  |  Jonas Menchik 22/09/09
  13.   Hamas and other groups are merely changing weapponry 19:33  |  Kris Lazar 22/09/09
  14.   Obstruction &Check points and people 19:45  |  Dan 22/09/09
  15.   A very strange question 20:23  |  James K. 22/09/09
  16.   The right has grown dependent on terror to achieve its goals 21:18  |  sh 22/09/09
  17.   Isreal has nothing to prove 21:23  |  Jack 22/09/09
  18.   B. Roberts # 5 21:33  |  American in NY 22/09/09
  19.   Israel smacked around terrorist 21:38  |  Chaim Ben Kahan 22/09/09
  20.   Bradley`s tiresome introspection 22:14  |  Greg Graze 22/09/09
  21.   Burstons should stop feeling guilty for being Israeli 22:19  |  Scott 22/09/09
  22.   Israel`s responses worked in both the Lebanon and Gaza war. 22:27  |  4:20 22/09/09
  23.   Scott 07:08  |  sh 23/09/09
  24.   PZ is SUPER NAIVE 13:04  |  tal 23/09/09
  25.   Swiss (Dingo) #11 Maybe if the Europeans 13:15  |  Gil 23/09/09
  26.   #18 American in NY 13:37  |  Tim R 23/09/09
  27.   Wrong Title 14:27  |  Raj 23/09/09
  28.   Military state 15:10  |  Jim 23/09/09
  29.   #28 Jim from Ramallah, West Bank 16:42  |  Smadar 23/09/09
  30.   Bradley 17:00  |  Yaron 23/09/09
  31.   #9 PZ, Don`t be a Potz. Obama didn`t stop Qassams neither N.Korea 17:09  |  Canadian Historian 23/09/09
  32.   Wrong take on Lebanon 17:17  |  James 23/09/09
  33.   dino 17:18  |  oz 23/09/09
  34.   We are not allowed to agree with you Mr. Burston 17:45  |  Mark Lincoln 23/09/09
  35.   How a fool may appear to be wise? 19:17  |  Boris 23/09/09
  36.   Smadar in wonderland #29 19:26  |  FOX 23/09/09
  37.   Bradley, Israel wallows in terrorism... 19:41  |  Dutch 23/09/09
  38.   Cast Lead not needed to end Rocket attacks 22:16  |  Ramsey Kamar 23/09/09
  39.   Title should`ve been: "OMG! There is a military option!!!" 22:33  |  Robert 23/09/09
  40.   Bradley The Truth... 07:07  |  Yosemite 25/09/09
  41.   Jim from Ramalla 08:19  |  Daniela 26/09/09
  42.   THE wholw world knows not depends on terror cominng 2009" score". 08:23  |  PETER SM 27/09/09
  43.   Israel`s created terror. 06:18  |  Steve 28/09/09
  44.   #43 We Get It Steve ... 11:09  |  Tim R 29/09/09
  45.   #43 As For The Rest of Your Post Steve ... 00:20  |  Tim R 30/09/09
  46.   War, misuse of the word. 03:07  |  John Fisher 30/09/09
  47.   Propaganda victory 05:22  |  Nick Ferriman 01/10/09
  48.   Israel invented terror 21:56  |  patriot 02/10/09
  49.   AMEN to # 5 and his response! 21:57  |  patriot 02/10/09
  50.   Re to # 5 Mrs. Silvienne 12:40  |  Michael Dar 03/10/09
  51.   Re to #11 Dino 13:25  |  Michael Dar 03/10/09
  52.   Until next time..... 19:50  |  David 03/10/09
  53.   Re to # 48 self proclaimed patriot! 21:45  |  Michael Dar 03/10/09
  54.   Winning ? Who`s winning ? 10:50  |  Nora Tel Aviv 04/10/09
  55.   Israelis forget that they were the first terrorists 23:57  |  John 05/10/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Holiday Greetings from the Heart
LIBI-Caring for Israeli Soldiers
JGooders Special Rosh Hashanah Gift Cards
Send Gift Cards to you Friends and Family and Taste the Sweetness of Giving
Date Local Jewish Singles
Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Amazing Jewelry
Visit SoKoBe.com for the best priced fine jewelry in the world
More Headlines
13:51 Israeli scientist wins Nobel Prize in chemistry
12:10 Abbas aide: Deferring action on Goldstone report was a mistake
09:44 U.S. to Israel and PA: Calm Jerusalem tensions
08:11 Israel fears violence following arrest of Islamic Movement head
11:23 Where did two Iran nuclear scientists disappear to?
08:36 U.S. slams Honduras radioman's remark 'let Hitler finish his vision'
10:23 Netanyahu's UN speech was that of a Jew, not an Israeli
22:48 TV ROUND-UP: Islamic Movement leader arrested, Israeli drug ring busted
13:10 Hamas bans Gaza motorcyclists from giving women rides
13:13 Mel Gibson cleared of DUI that led to anti-Semitic outburst
08:13 UN Security Council to meet Wednesday on Goldstone report
10:14 Rehovot man suspected of hammering wife to death
08:41 Orthodox Jewish boxer 'Star of David' to vie for crown
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved