Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., November 27, 2009 Kislev 10, 5770 | | Israel Time: 12:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 05:52 05/09/2009
Suddenly, Netanyahu is popular and Obama is not
By Aluf Benn
Tags: Barack Obama, Israel news 

Later this month, between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, U.S. President Barack Obama will take the podium at the United Nations General Assembly and, flanked by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, declare the resumption of the Middle East peace process.

He will set an ambitious goal: to achieve, within two years, a "comprehensive regional peace" that will end the Israeli-Arab conflict and replace it with new and friendly relations between the states and peoples of the region. In contrast to his immediate predecessor, George W. Bush, who instructed the parties to talk and asked only that they report to him on the results, Obama intends to be involved: His emissaries will sit in the conference room and put forward compromise proposals and solutions.

Obama will have to work hard to persuade people that with him it will be different, that peace is possible, that a Palestinian state will be established, that the Syrians will return to the Golan Heights and Israel will dwell in the region in safety - and all of this by September 2011.
Advertisement
After another decade of wars and disappointments, it's tough to sell the "New Middle East" in a new wrapping to cynical populations that have long since lost all belief in impassioned speeches promising peace and change. But Obama's declaration will have immediate strategic importance. By presenting a two-year timetable for the peace agreements, the president will make it clear that dealing with Iran is more urgent than establishing an independent Palestine alongside Israel.

That will be a major diplomatic achievement for Netanyahu. In his visit to the White House in May, the prime minister's main aim was to persuade Obama of "Iran first and the Palestinians afterward." It was convenient at the time for Obama to present a disagreement with Netanyahu in order to strengthen U.S. credibility in the Arab world. One hundred days later, it turns out that on the crucial issue - setting the foreign affairs agenda - Netanyahu's view prevailed.

Next year, 2010, will be the "year of Iran." The Palestinians will have to wait their turn and pass the time in empty talks until Iran is restrained. Under the quid pro quo principle, in return for advancing action on Iran, Netanyahu agreed to freeze construction in the West Bank settlements for a period of nine months, according to leaks from his talks with U.S. envoy George Mitchell.

Netanyahu will have to play a delicate political game with Israel's right wing. It's a safe bet that the dismantling of outposts will be removed from the agenda, on the grounds that preserving internal cohesion against Iran is far more important than violent, media-intense spats with the settlers on the West Bank hilltops.

Back in May, Obama seemed like the messiah heralding historic change in America and in its relations with the world in general and Muslims in particular. Obama projected hope and change, while Netanyahu looked like a throwback, a musty, right-wing nuisance who was wasting the president's time talking about "natural growth in the settlements."

This week the Washington columnists competed with each other to write the gloomiest forecasts of the political hell awaiting the president when he returns from his vacation in Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts. As the summer progressed, Obama had a serious marketing slip: He lost his focus. His astonishing ascension to power rested on a clear and focused message: I represent change, I don't look like Bush or talk like him. Now, though, despite the signs of economic recovery, Obama is plunging in the polls even faster than previous presidents this early into their terms.

In regard to the two main issues on his agenda - national health care and the war in Afghanistan - Obama is struggling to explain his goals to the American people. His rivals are conducting an effective campaign against health care reform. The president will address Congress next week in an effort to save his initiative and not reprise Bill Clinton's failure in trying to expand health insurance. The situation in Afghanistan is no less desperate. The polls show that most Americans don't understand the purpose of the war and don't believe victory is possible. The mounting casualty rate is rapidly eroding public support for continuation of the war.

Responsible adult

While Obama was sinking, Netanyahu behaved like a responsible adult. He refrained from flamboyant military actions that could kindle the region and compel Obama to deal with body-strewn crises. He effectively froze authorizations for new construction in the settlements, and he announced his acceptance of the principle of a two-state solution. He dismantled West Bank checkpoints and toned down his anti-Iran rhetoric (until his Berlin visit last week, when he returned to the analogy between a nuclear Iran and Auschwitz). He even apologized to Israel's "elites" for his inflammatory remarks against them in his previous term as prime minister.

At the same time, to preserve his right-wing base, Netanyahu announced new construction for Jews in East Jerusalem and also quarreled with Sweden. Obama will have to swallow Netanyahu's declarations that Jerusalem is "the eternal capital of the Jewish people." There are few supporters of the settlements in Congress, but the unity of Jerusalem has been an accepted mantra for many years. Netanyahu has entrenched himself in a position that will enable him to recruit supporters in Washington, while avoiding both blatant lobbying on Capitol Hill and publicly embracing the president's rivals, as he did with Clinton.

Under these circumstances, Netanyahu has a chance for a good second round with Obama. The president is hungry for a policy achievement, which Netanyahu can provide to him in the form of a construction freeze in the settlements and the renewal of negotiations with the Palestinians. If Netanyahu sticks to his policy of restraint, focuses on Iran and avoids provocations in the territories and on Israel's borders, he will be received in the White House as a welcome and worthy guest.

But his true test will come when Obama's timetable reaches the critical point. If Israel is perceived as the party that torpedoed the peace process and spoiled Obama's 2012 campaign, Netanyahu will be punished - provided, of course, he manages to survive politically until then.

Related articles:
  • Obama envoy Mitchell says had 'good meeting' with Israeli officials
  • Obama blesses Muslim month of Ramadan as Israel envoy looks on
  • Obama seeks trilateral summit with Israel, Palestinians
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Likud MK slams U.S.
    Culture and Sports Minister says the decision to freeze settlements is a mistake.
    Settlements freeze
    Barak instructed IDF to issue injunction to temporarily freeze settlement construction.
      1.   Neither of them is going to accomplish anything 10:30  |  Rafi 04/09/09
      2.   Sustaining hope requires some audacity 10:43  |  Shimon Cleopas 04/09/09
      3.   obama was never popular in israel, so he need not worry 11:09  |  Abraham 04/09/09
      4.   Obama, the cautious conservative 11:13  |  Roo 04/09/09
      5.   Experience shows 11:23  |  Chappaqua neighbor 04/09/09
      6.   what does Netanyahu actually want? 11:29  |  tom s 04/09/09
      7.   like s second term rabin netanyahu has learnt well 11:49  |  ombudsman 04/09/09
      8.   arab friendly gestures 11:53  |  ombudsman 04/09/09
      9.   ISRAEL WILL BE BLAMED FOR AN APPEASEMENT WORSE THAN CHAMBERLAIN ? 11:58  |  BILL 04/09/09
      10.   Good post Roo 12:05  |  Peter Williams 04/09/09
      11.   help me please,for i am like most americans,unlike most israelis 12:14  |  cpl. chiel 04/09/09
      12.   #10 12:54  |  flora 04/09/09
      13.   A fair analysis 13:01  |  Shalom Freedman 04/09/09
      14.   to #6;bibi end game is..... 13:07  |  Yom Tov 04/09/09
      15.   #6 13:11  |  Harold 04/09/09
      16.   Where? 13:12  |  Singer 04/09/09
      17.   Unfortunately Aluf Benn`s analysis is leaving out "the world".... 13:39  |  Swiss (Dino) 04/09/09
      18.   Time in Office 14:07  |  Arieh Zimmerman 04/09/09
      19.   flora 14:17  |  udi 04/09/09
      20.   SURPRISED? 14:47  |  udi 04/09/09
      21.   6. Israel`s right wing gave up on peace. It just plays for time. 15:07  |  Michael 04/09/09
      22.   cpl chiel perhaps 15:13  |  petra 04/09/09
      23.   WE`LL Work WITH Obama: NO More Years Like The LAST 8 Years!!! 15:31  |  Americans REMEMBER! 04/09/09
      24.   Netanyahu`s endgame? 15:35  |  un2here 04/09/09
      25.   Roo - chapeau 15:46  |  17 04/09/09
      26.   Swiss (Dino) 18:24  |  Linichka 04/09/09
      27.   #23 Obama tore down his own credibility 18:27  |  Scott 04/09/09
      28.   roo 18:34  |  JimUSA 04/09/09
      29.   Netanyahu and Obama images are actually easy to understand... 18:41  |  Dr. L. Brnd 04/09/09
      30.   #13 What did your PM (and) FM on the 18:55  |  Ardi 04/09/09
      31.   Iran - Existential threat to Jews 19:01  |  Scott 04/09/09
      32.   suddenly ..obama is not popular 19:03  |  cdk 04/09/09
      33.   #17 Swiss...this from a little country 19:20  |  Lynn 04/09/09
      34.   No 23 - quite right 19:40  |  Ussishkin 04/09/09
      35.   There goes Bibi`s last excuse for a settlement freeze. 19:43  |  Chaim 04/09/09
      36.   #4 Roo...I told you so 20:53  |  Lynn 04/09/09
      37.   Honest broker 20:53  |  Froy 04/09/09
      38.   Giving land back.... 23:27  |  Al 04/09/09
      39.   # 6 Harold - wrong numbers 00:14  |  David 05/09/09
      40.   Obama is irrelevant 00:32  |  Andy 05/09/09
      41.   An Unusually Gross Misread 00:36  |  Donnelley 05/09/09
      42.   simply because 00:50  |  joe 05/09/09
      43.   To Swiss (#17) 01:13  |  Amir 05/09/09
      44.   SUPPORT FOR THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL 01:31  |  Herman and Gerda 05/09/09
      45.   Wait!!? 02:16  |  Texan 05/09/09
      46.   hmmm 02:17  |  Sizy 05/09/09
      47.   TAKE YOUR POLL AND SHOVE IT 04:03  |  Mike 05/09/09
      48.   #4, Roo 05:55  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/09/09
      49.   Of Course 07:56  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/09/09
      50.   popularity is a bad measure of wisdom 16:00  |  peter rouget 05/09/09
      51.   ECONOMY economy economy.Pals come # 13 after that 17:53  |  PETER SM 05/09/09
      52.   #36 Lynn.."I told you so" Even a stopped-clock... 19:32  |  Roo 05/09/09
      53.   CJK `genius` 19:33  |  Roo 05/09/09
      54.   US Presidential Job Approval 19:39  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/09/09
      55.   Netanyahu and Obama 19:19  |  richard Phillips 06/09/09
      56.   Why not Love but Blood 08:17  |  Hasan 27/11/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Award-Winning 'Obsession'
    Watch 'Obsession: Radical Islam's War Against the West' Online FOR FREE!
    Protea Hills
    A Retirement Village in Nature Nestled in the Foothills of Jerusalem
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    11:59 Palestinian killed as IAF strikes Gaza
    06:24 Israel okays 28 new settlement buildings, despite freeze
    06:31 ANALYSIS / Settlers have been working for months to undermine construction freeze
    10:50 God's promise of land to Jews has deep pull on secular Israelis
    10:51 Iran confiscates rights lawyer's Nobel Peace medal
    04:14 The Golan is moving closer to Israel, geologists say
    11:07 IBM to buy Israeli start-up company for $225 million
    00:35 TV ROUND-UP: Palestinian stabs two Israelis near Hebron
    11:03 Iran warns IAEA not to use 'language of force'
    05:02 Left-wing radio caller ordered to compensate rightist for on-air insult
    08:18 Hamas Deputy Chief: Significant progress achieved in Shalit deal
    06:36 ANALYSIS / Is Netanyahu positioning himself to be the next Ariel Sharon?
    06:20 Agam painting sells for record-setting $326,500 in New York
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved