Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 14, 2009 Tishrei 26, 5770 | | Israel Time: 11:52 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 10:32 01/09/2009
When did American Jews start thinking about the Holocaust?
By Jerome A. Chanes
Tags: American Jews, Israel news 

Hasia Diner is a historian who believes that things actually happened in history. She is also comprehensive, indeed dogged in her research, which her oeuvre amply demonstrates.

Diner, who teaches history at New York University, made a major contribution with her superb "A Time for Gathering: The Second Migration" (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992), which articulated for many of us a vocabulary for understanding mid-19th century American Jewish history.

In her latest work, "We Remember With Reverence and Love: American Jews and the Myth of Silence After the Holocaust, 1945-1962" - also an assiduously researched book - Diner tackles the question of consciousness of the Holocaust in America.
Advertisement
Diner's mission is to explode the eponymous "myth" that there was only a gradual evolution of Holocaust consciousness. Diner asserts that much of postwar American Jewish history and public affairs needs to be understood in the context of the Holocaust.

There was no "silence" about the Holocaust - far from it. Diner avers that discussion, programming, and indeed activism of and about the Holocaust were the reality from early on, right after World War II.

The author bombards us with data in support of her thesis. Holocaust observances, memorials, programs, school curricula, survivors' gatherings, literature both serious and popular - all and more are catalogued by Diner in her effort to demonstrate not only that people knew about the Holocaust, but that the Holocaust had come immediately to centrality in American Jewish life.

Diner's view is, on its face, plausible. The activities she documents did take place. There is much of interest, and of value, in Diner's catalogue. But the reality is that whatever memorials and other programs took place, overall these were marginal to the core agendas of American Jews, both individually and as a community.

Why this notion is so, is a matter of debate. On the one hand, there was the powerful psychological dynamic of many survivors who were reluctant to talk about the past. At the same time, there was an American Jewish community that - in some of the most shameful and shabby episodes of our history - in many cases treated the survivors with contempt.

When survivor groups in the early 1960s went around to synagogues in New York, hat in hand, for a place to hold their first commemorations, they were turned away at the door. (It was Temple Emanuel that in 1967, after the survivors had held two commemorations at Carnegie Hall, hosted the first communal synagogue-based Holocaust commemoration in New York.)

More important was the nature of the American Jewish communal agenda during the 1940s, 50s, and 60s. The priorities on the national agenda moved from antisemitism - absolutely regnant until the mid-1950s - to civil rights, which was the central issue to American Jewish groups until the mid-1960s.

In the mid-1960s two things happened that irrevocably changed the nature of the Jewish communal agenda in America: the beginnings of the Soviet Jewry movement in the United States in 1963, and the Six-Day War in 1967. The most important result of the 1967 war was that for the first time, Israel was absolutely front-and-center as a priority for American Jews and Jewish organizations.

From policymakers to professional historians to community members, many had thought that the 1960 Eichmann trial in Israel would generate American Jewish consciousness of the Holocaust. But this trial happened in Israel, not in the United States.

It was the Six-Day War, with the specter of another Holocaust in the days and weeks prior to the conflict, which in the view of many triggered for the first time consciousness of the Holocaust.

Many analysts maintain that it was not the Six-Day War but the screening in 1978 of Gerald Greene's landmark television series Holocaust that was the key. Whichever is the case, the Holocaust was not in the forefront of the Jewish personal or organizational mind until relatively late.

Part of the problem is that Diner falls into the trap that has ensnared many a scholar of the American Jewish experience who addresses issues of public policy as processed by Jewish communal organizations.

Historians are rarely sure-footed when it comes to the organizational dynamics of the American Jewish community. Examples abound: The "American Jewish Year Book" is pretty much the document of record for Diner when it comes to American Jewish affairs, fair enough.

The Year Book is a most important resource; but more telling in terms of what was on the Jewish communal agenda was the annual "Joint Program Plan" of the National Community Relations Advisory Council. This latter was the contemporary document of record when it came to what Jewish groups were thinking about and doing in public affairs, but is overlooked by Diner.

Likewise, Diner overstates the "swastika epidemic" of the late 1950s in terms of its impact on survivors' activism. "The survivors shook up the American Jewish communal framework" over American Nazi George Lincoln Rockwell and swastika daubing? That statement is hardly the case. And Diner would have it that the Holocaust was the raison d'etre for the respected Orthodox journal Tradition getting off the ground in 1958.

Not true: Tradition was an important part of the warp and weft of an American Orthodoxy that was shaping its own intellectual and religious contours at that time; the Holocaust was, at most, a minor factor in the genesis of the journal.

There are other missteps in "We Remember with Reverence and Love." It is deeply troubling that Diner lumps together Norman Finkelstein and Peter Novick, historians who assert the thesis of American Jewish Holocaust avoidance. Both are fierce critics of the American Jewish establishment, especially with respect to processing the Holocaust; but it does her scholarship a disservice to talk about these two in the same breath.

Whatever one thinks of Novick's conclusions, agree or not - and I have serious questions about his views on Jewish organizations cynically manipulating the Holocaust - Novick is a serious historian who, in his "The Holocaust in American Life," did truly amazing archival research. Finkelstein, by contrast, is simply out to "get" the Jewish organizational establishment by attacking the use of the Holocaust as a means of rationalizing the abuses of the State of Israel, which Finkelstein detests.

Having said these things, Diner is right on the mark in her discussion of the landmark "Studies in Prejudice," commissioned in the late 1940s as a series of studies, published as books by the American Jewish Committee. These included a number of watershed volumes, which are duly noted by Diner, although she inexplicably fails to note the most important work in the series, the classic "The Authoritarian Personality."

The AJCommittee was responding to the potential of an authoritarian threat in the United States, and concluded that people who are anti-Jews will be anti-other groups. But the AJCommittee research program was not, as Diner would have it, a vehicle "to advance its liberal agenda" - unhelpfully imputing ulterior motives - but for establishing strategic and tactical guidelines for combating prejudice in this country.

"We Remember with Reverence and Love" is a treasure trove of reproductions of posters, flyers and handbills, advertisements, cartoons, sheet music and other early postwar popular-culture artifacts. These memorabilia (with their helpful descriptive captions) are invaluable resources. And Diner's long chapter on Germany and Germans in the post-war era is splendid. Both the data in this chapter, and the analysis about Germany in the postwar era that flows from those data, will serve scholars well, even though Diner's discussion of the Christian rescuers of Jews is off the mark.

"We Remember with Reverence and Love" is a valuable volume; the prodigious research in the book will be of immeasurable assistance to scholars. But Diner's history of the American Jewish communal response to the Holocaust, in terms of political and public-affairs dynamics - and those are the ones that count - is flawed.

What happened, in the end, proved to be far less significant than the myriad of events recorded by Diner. However we regret it, American Jews did not in the postwar years acknowledge the Holocaust in a way it should have been acknowledged, recalled, commemorated; and no amount of 21st century review can change that.

Jerome A. Chanes is the author of the award-winning "A Dark Side of History: Antisemitism through the Ages" and the forthcoming "The Future of American Judaism" (Columbia University Press).
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Explosion in Lebanon
IDF video reportedly proves Hezbollah stored weapons in a South Lebanon home
Hitler and Republicans
Republicans post link to video in which even Hitler appears to be disappointed in Obama
  1.   This Review Is As Interesting And Argumentative As The Book 11:31  |  dyinglikeflies 01/09/09
  2.   100% American 12:51  |  Akiva 01/09/09
  3.   book review: Americans Jews 16:38  |  Dee 01/09/09
  4.   Silly to generalize 17:44  |  sue 01/09/09
  5.   Holocaust Now 17:53  |  Barry S Larkman 01/09/09
  6.   The liberal environment and the wish to be american fostered the 18:29  |  ksss 01/09/09
  7.   half right half wrong? 19:29  |  Richard Sherwin 01/09/09
  8.   Should they have? 19:54  |  Colin Wright 01/09/09
  9.   Excellent review, except for cheap shot 20:17  |  W 01/09/09
  10.   What were we supposed to think 20:20  |  Fred Shapiro 01/09/09
  11.   Reform 00:47  |  A History Buff 02/09/09
  12.   Israeli Attitudes To the Holocaust 02:09  |  PCH 02/09/09
  13.   history shaped by the few that shout loud 02:59  |  gaga 02/09/09
  14.   great neck, new york holocaust avoidance 07:53  |  george levine 02/09/09
  15.   Utter nonsense... 10:33  |  Hanna 02/09/09
  16.   To #14, Hanna, your comment is disgusting !!! 09:33  |  Inna 03/09/09
  17.   Inna #16: So compassion for Palestinians is disgusting to you? 19:02  |  Hanna 03/09/09
  18.   Novick and Finkelstein. Are you, J.A.Chanes for real or just HI? 11:09  |  zmogus, PhD 04/09/09
  19.   American Jews and the Holocoust 11:18  |  Max Zaslawsky 14/10/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Holiday Greetings from the Heart
LIBI-Caring for Israeli Soldiers
JGooders Special Rosh Hashanah Gift Cards
Send Gift Cards to you Friends and Family and Taste the Sweetness of Giving
Date Local Jewish Singles
Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Amazing Jewelry
Visit SoKoBe.com for the best priced fine jewelry in the world
More Headlines
10:09 PA seeks UN censure of Israel over Temple Mount, Gaza
11:47 Haaretz exclusive: Palestinian draft resolution on Goldstone, Gaza and Jerusalem
11:18 Report: Turkey banned Israel from NATO drill over late aircraft shipment
05:45 After snubbing Israel, Turkey to hold defense drills with Syria
11:27 One person killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza tunnels
07:23 COMMENT / Nobel for Obama rules out U.S. strike on Iran
07:03 WATCH: Even Hitler is disappointed in Obama
07:16 TV ROUND-UP: Hezbollah denies stockpiling arms; Israelis likely to survive cancer
11:46 Woman dies after leaving party on rope made of sheets tied to window
05:44 'Iran pays, Syria smuggles, and Hezbollah receives weapons'
07:48 Israel: Lebanon turning blind eye to Hezbollah arms
05:44 Israel to Turkey: We won't wage war of words through the press
04:46 Groups decry police undercover unit targeting Arabs
04:07 Yishai: Deporting foreign children preserves Israel's Jewish identity
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved