Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., August 17, 2009 Av 27, 5769 | | Israel Time: 10:21 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Focus U.S.A. Travel Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 12:22 07/07/2009
ANALYSIS / Why Israel won't evacuate West Bank outposts
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Israel news, West Bank 

If George Mitchell, America's special envoy to the Middle East, wants an advance estimate on the reliability of Israeli promises to evacuate outposts, he may find the High Court of Justice discussion on the outpost of Migron helpful.

The state's request to be granted another year-long extension before having to evacuate the outpost by law offers a sad glimpse into the situation, and reveals the gaps between the official declarations of the Netanyahu administration and the actual law enforcement in the territories.

On Monday, the justices held yet another discussion on the petition filed by human rights group Peace Now and Arab land owners, seeking to have settlers removed from the area. While the court session was underway, Defense Minister Ehud Barak was meeting with Mitchell in another time zone. Alongside declarations on regional peace, Barak promised that 23 West Bank outposts would be evacuated within "weeks and months, not years."
Advertisement

But the High Court heard prosecution representative Anar Hellman sing a completely different tune. According to Hellman, the state will require at least a year to prepare for the implementation of a compromise plan jointly devised by the Defense Ministry and the settler council Yesha. The plan calls for 50 new homes to be built in the adjacent settlement Adam for those who will be evacuated from Migron. The prosecution attorney promised that in a year's time, the state will evacuate by force anyone who will refuse to leave peacefully.

In order to truly understand the state's foot-dragging on the Migron issue, one must go back and look at the chronology of the case. Migron was established in early 2002, amid the height of a terror wave in the West Bank, on land that has always been under undisputed private Palestinian ownership. In October 2006 a petition was filed with the High Court seeking to compel the state to evacuate Migron. The state agreed that the outpost was in fact illegal, and that it would be evacuated, but did not specify a date for the evacuation.

Six months ago, Barak came to an understanding with the settlement council over the alternative housing in Adam. However, even if the state abides by the new timetable (and that would certainly be a precedent when it comes to outpost evacuation), Migron won't be evacuated until the summer of 2010 at the earliest, 8 and a half years after the land was taken from its rightful owners.

Even this eventuality depends on two things: One, it is unlikely that all the residents of the outpost will agree to evacuate their homes willingly, and it is even more unlikely that the Yesha Council heads will agree to enforce a peaceful evacuation. Two, it is not certain that the Obama administration will agree to the compromise plan under which the Migron residents will be transferred to a settlement located east of the fence, in an area beyond the lines of the existing settlement border, in violation of old Israeli commitments to the U.S.

Maybe that is what Chief Justice Dorit Beinisch meant when she asked the attorney Hellman whether he thought the plan was feasible. The state's representative answered optimistically, but it is not clear if he has good reason to be optimistic.

"The High Court is starting to bear its teeth ? as well it should," said a senior legal official in regard to a separate security-related case that was recently discussed by the High Court of Justice. It may be that the justices are finally beginning to lose their patience in the face of the foot-dragging.

About a week ago the state was faced with the High Court's skepticism, this time in regard to the route of the West Bank separation fence. A third petition is also currently on the agenda, also filed by Peace Now, seeking to compel the state to demolish permanent housing in various outposts. The case, filed in the summer 2005, is still under discussion.

Not just in the courts, but also on the ground, it is hard to see any real indication that the settlement enterprise is headed toward a freeze. Dror Etkes, the man behind the petitions, photographed construction in the outpost of Ali this week. In March, the court outlawed the continued paving of a road connecting Ali and the adjacent outpost Yuval, because it runs through private Palestinian land. The Civil Administration blocked the access to the unfinished road with mounds of rocks. But Etkes discovered that the settlers were one step ahead of the Civil Administration, and simply continued paving the road about a half a kilometer from there, at the other end.

Inside Ali, where construction is illegal right now, a new lot has been discovered being prepared for the erection of caravan homes. The Civil Administration has recently cracked down on the transport of caravan homes, but the settlers found a solution: now they transport the caravans in pieces, and then assemble them at the designated outpost under the noses of the authorities.
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Theft in the IDF
Chief of Staff Ashkenazi revealed as mystery figure at center of credit card scam.
Is Disney bad for kids?
One Israeli educator says Disney promotes negative stereotypes of the 'other.'
  1.   Israel has no trouble disciplining Pal civilians, just settlers. 12:00  |  Michael 07/07/09
  2.   For Arabs, Migron = Haifa = Jaffa 12:19  |  Kenny 07/07/09
  3.   The state of Israel simply needs motivation 12:24  |  Natallie Durson 07/07/09
  4.   All Pals should move anywhere but Israel. 12:35  |  petra 07/07/09
  5.   Migron--Land Ownership NOT Undipsuted 12:42  |  Yehudit 07/07/09
  6.   Petra #14: publicly holding such views could get you jailed 14:02  |  Paul 07/07/09
  7.   Israeli justice 14:26  |  WHG 07/07/09
  8.   yehudit from beit shemesh 15:33  |  g. lee 07/07/09
  9.   Israel Is Implacable 15:54  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/07/09
  10.   Yehudit on Migron and Haaretz Doing Better 16:25  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/07/09
  11.   evacuation 17:07  |  rm 07/07/09
  12.   g lee &yaakov 17:51  |  dave 07/07/09
  13.   The true scale of the problem 18:01  |  r cummings 07/07/09
  14.   dave in Istanbul on Compromise 18:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/07/09
  15.   Israel by robbery 20:22  |  Ian 07/07/09
  16.   Apartheid Law 20:26  |  Adam 07/07/09
  17.   petra - The majority of `Pals` are innocent civilians 21:41  |  CJ 07/07/09
  18.   dave 21:48  |  CJ 07/07/09
  19.   Because America is responsible for pressuring Israel to do it 22:12  |  Ivar 07/07/09
  20.   # 17 CJ - "The acquisition of territory by force/war is illegal." 23:18  |  17 07/07/09
  21.   Never give up! 04:53  |  yeiel 08/07/09
  22.   #4 petra you have chosen a good name for yourself 06:12  |  C2 08/07/09
  23.   Petra-you are not a minority 10:03  |  Moshe49 08/07/09
  24.   Aren`t we glad that G-ds laws trump the UN? 14:46  |  petra 10/08/09
  25.   Ivar in your dreams. 14:56  |  petra 10/08/09
  26.   petra 03:34  |  pd 14/08/09
  27.   Petra, the Arizona settler 10:14  |  Arieh Zimmerman 17/08/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
Dead Sea Salt
From the Dead Sea Coupon cofe Haaretz for 10% off!
hotel Jerusalem
David Citadel Hotel, come stay at the finest of Jerusalem hotels.
Master's Program in Desert Studies
An innovative, multidisciplinary, international program specialized in Desert Research
Dead Sea Cosmetics .Summer Specials
Velvet Hand Cream just $14.90
Handmade In Tel Aviv
Itay Noy, Timepiece Maker
ISRAEL ARMY SURPLUS STORE
IDF insignia,Uniforms, Paladium Boots Watches, Israel Army T-shirts & Collectibles
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
More Headlines
09:15 IDF troops wound Egypt soldier in border mix-up
08:12 Ex-nuclear reactor staffer says forced to drink uranium
08:16 Settlers building more caravans to stave off U.S. talks of freeze
09:45 U.S. group invests tax-free millions in East Jerusalem land
08:16 Palestinian state is not synonym for terrorist entity
10:19 Elderly man becomes ninth to die of swine flu in Israel
10:11 Huckabee to attend dinner at disputed East Jerusalem hotel
22:50 TV ROUND-UP: Lynch victim laid to rest, Israel won't attack Iran, is the recession over?
09:16 Who can protect the IDF chief from personal theft?
08:07 Israel seeks to overcome brain drain with NIS 1.6b plan
08:34 Secret crawl space in Jerusalem home served as Haganah cache
08:18 Do Disney movies promote anti-Semitism and racism?
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Israel 2009 election results | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved