Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., August 31, 2009 Elul 11, 5769 | | Israel Time: 20:11 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Focus U.S.A. Travel Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 13:21 26/06/2009
The potency of a right
By Nadav Shragai
Tags: West Bank, Barack Obama 

One can continue waging the argument with the United States over settlements by citing mathematical figures, numbers and formulas on natural growth or natural development, and perhaps doing so is the correct thing, but whoever believes that settling the territories of Judea and Samaria is the actualization of a natural right and historical justice cannot be content with simply stating these figures.

Perhaps one can continue to bombard George Mitchell with numbers; to inform him that the settlers constitute 17 percent of the residents of Judea and Samaria (300,000 out of a total population of 1.8 million people); that the built-up areas in the settlements occupy just 1.7 percent of the land area of Judea and Samaria; and that if the settlers continue to build solely at the rate of their natural growth (9,000 births per year), they will only need a small fraction of the area to do so (0.054 percent of the territory).

Perhaps it's possible to persuade Mitchell and his boss, President Barack Obama, that over the next decade the settlers will consume just one-half of one percent for construction purposes in an area already delineated as "their municipal boundaries." But this math is just a minor argument between merchants. One might expect more national pride and a clearer, more lucid statement from a government that believes Judea and Samaria are inseparable parts of the historic homeland, and at the very least sees the "settlement blocs" as an inseparable part of the State of Israel in any final status accord. Perhaps a statement in the spirit of Simon Maccabaeus, who said: "We have neither taken other men's land, neither do we hold that which is other men's: but the inheritance of our fathers, which was for some time unjustly possessed by our enemies."
Advertisement
Our friends in the United States, both real and imagined, need to hear from us that the historic, religious, legal and sentimental links that bind the people of Israel with Hebron and Beit El are no less legitimate than those of the Palestinians; that we are not occupiers in our own country and that there are Jews for whom this land is holy, just as it is holy to Palestinians - Jews whose connection to these pieces of land are bound by love, the Bible, tradition, nature and beauty.

Many years ago, a member of the British House of Lords asked Chaim Weizmann why the Jews insist on settling in the Land of Israel when there are so many undeveloped countries that could serve as a national home. Weizmann responded with a question: Why do you drive 200 kilometers every Sunday to visit your mother when there are so many old ladies living on your street?

This elementary truth in relation to all parts of the Land of Israel has not changed. From a moral standpoint, there is no difference between settling the Land of Israel at the beginning of the last century in areas where Arabs lived and settling the Land of Israel at the beginning of this century in areas where Arabs reside; no difference between settling the Galilee, the Negev and Petah Tikva - which Moshe Smilansky described generations ago as "a small Hebrew community among large Arab villages to the east, north and south" - and settling Judea and Samaria.

The real argument is about possible borders; it is certainly not about rights. This right must once again be raised with our friends in Washington, even if there are those, particularly in Israel, who will chafe at this claim because it is not within the realm of realpolitik.

This right, it should also be remembered, is not based on security concerns. Theoretically, a Jewish state could have arisen anywhere in the world, and perhaps we would have attained security elsewhere. In practice, the Jewish state was established specifically in the Land of Israel as a national home and a country of refuge on the strength of this right and the historic, national collective memory - a state that succeeded in gathering Jews from exile.

Whoever makes do with number-crunching and the petty settling of scores will sooner or later find himself in a battle over Jerusalem and a more truncated Israel, with which the Arabs of Israel and the entire region have yet to reconcile, to this day, as the state of the Jewish people.

Thus far, the preoccupation with numbers has not yielded benefits, and perhaps this is a positive development. Obama's U.S., which is not prepared to accept the minimum - construction to accommodate natural growth in settlements - is forcing the government of Israel to look in the mirror and to remember the strength of the right.
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Olmert indicted
Multiple charges filed against the former PM in three corruption affairs
Her Madgesty is here
Madonna arrives in Israel ahead of her back-to-back concerts in Tel Aviv
  1.   If Israel moved to the right, who would notice? 13:31  |  Natallie Durson 26/06/09
  2.   Utter drivel 14:15  |  Sylvie 26/06/09
  3.   Not A New Mirror 15:47  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/06/09
  4.   Israel is all about Jews returning to their historical homeland 16:52  |  Boris 26/06/09
  5.   True 17:17  |  Shalom Freedman 26/06/09
  6.   Natallie # 1 & if Israel moved to the left would anyone notice? 17:19  |  American in NY 26/06/09
  7.   The Settlements 17:19  |  Jim 26/06/09
  8.   90% of Israelis 17:45  |  rob 26/06/09
  9.   Borris - their homeland was owned by others 18:24  |  Don Boston 26/06/09
  10.   Natalie`s wishfull thinking 18:47  |  arik 26/06/09
  11.   Palestinians lost another historic opportunity 20:26  |  Voice of Reason 26/06/09
  12.   numbers lie 20:31  |  Spokanite 26/06/09
  13.   Valley Forge/Coventry/Helicopters in Desert/Gettysburg Address 20:48  |  Shaul Ben-Yimini 26/06/09
  14.   Some Jewish enclaves stayed in the "WB" for millennia... 21:09  |  yona 26/06/09
  15.   Bottom Line: Obama destroyed peace chances while he`s President. 21:12  |  Dr. L. Brnd 26/06/09
  16.   land of Cannan 21:21  |  ben 26/06/09
  17.   boris 4 22:29  |  potobac 26/06/09
  18.   Boris # 4 Amnesia re the other "facts on th ground" ? 23:35  |  David 26/06/09
  19.   THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!! 01:24  |  Yos 27/06/09
  20.   Boris, I understand 01:25  |  DavidSanders 27/06/09
  21.   Well Boris (4), what about the Arabs then? 01:39  |  Spider 27/06/09
  22.   a bunch of hypocrites.-why not stand up for... 01:43  |  Steve 27/06/09
  23.   G-D`S WORD GIVES TITLE TO THE WHOLE LAND OF CANAAN ?? 02:00  |  BILL 27/06/09
  24.   The potency of a right justifies all wrongs? 02:24  |  Roger 27/06/09
  25.   Pushing to the right? LIberman and BIBI in power 02:43  |  Adam Rahman 27/06/09
  26.   The MISLED/OVER-Indoctrinated TRAGICALLY Deny PEACE/Keep KILLING. 04:31  |  U.S. Pal Defender 27/06/09
  27.   Moving to the right? 08:04  |  john Spear 27/06/09
  28.   #17 Bill -You Should Consider Decafeinated Coffe! 09:58  |  Roger 27/06/09
  29.   Natallie Durson - You Rock! 10:02  |  Roger 27/06/09
  30.   Nadav Shragai - A counter argument 11:01  |  Bandar Michaels 27/06/09
  31.   "...remember the strength of the right...." 11:06  |  Esther 27/06/09
  32.   #18 comedy from roger in the usa and real hypocrisy 11:21  |  v hardman 27/06/09
  33.   Suggestion 12:45  |  Phil 27/06/09
  34.   #8 yona 14:36  |  Axel 27/06/09
  35.   on links being "no less legitimate" than other links 16:10  |  newageblues 27/06/09
  36.   The Potency of a Right 17:09  |  Tommytoons 27/06/09
  37.   who but Israel? 23:56  |  Lea de Lange 27/06/09
  38.   The real cause 09:39  |  Mac 28/06/09
  39.   Nadav Shragai ... 12:18  |  zeev 28/06/09
  40.   Where have all the Zionists Gone? 13:20  |  Robert 28/06/09
  41.   to Lea de Lange #34 17:19  |  zeev 28/06/09
  42.   to Tommytoons #36 - 2nd try 18:23  |  zeev 28/06/09
  43.   The potency of a right 00:09  |  Sue Bee 29/06/09
  44.   Potency of the right? Not so 23:59  |  Albert 26/08/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
Dead Sea Salt
From the Dead Sea Coupon cofe Haaretz for 10% off!
hotel Jerusalem
David Citadel Hotel, come stay at the finest of Jerusalem hotels.
Master's Program in Desert Studies
An innovative, multidisciplinary, international program specialized in Desert Research
Dead Sea Cosmetics .Summer Specials
Velvet Hand Cream just $14.90
Handmade In Tel Aviv
Itay Noy, Timepiece Maker
ISRAEL ARMY SURPLUS STORE
IDF insignia,Uniforms, Paladium Boots Watches, Israel Army T-shirts & Collectibles
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Marina Royale
Your Luxurious Suite While staying in Israel
Table to Table
Help to Israel food bank
4XP
Trading Platform Online Currency Trading
More Headlines
19:40 Court gives Education Min. 48 hours to answer call to enroll Ethiopians
15:19 Lieberman: Israel won`t let Palestinians declare state unilaterally
14:57 Israeli Arab charged in Hezbollah plot to kill IDF chief
15:34 Abbas: No peace talks without full settlement freeze
15:50 Report: Hamas wants Jordanian prisoners freed in Shalit deal
17:19 This Jewish New Year, let's put an end to hope
14:19 Olmert lawyers: Corruption charges lack evidence
21:56 TV ROUND-UP: Ehud Olmert indicted, Madonna arrives in Israel
18:47 Germany to host six-power talks on Iran nuclear program this week
16:43 Following inflammatory article, Sweden to demand EU condemn anti-Semitism
02:47 Olmert indictment / Why are the charges so serious?
13:54 IDF soldier suspected of killing Palestinian still hasn't been charged
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Israel 2009 election results | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved