Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., July 13, 2009 Tamuz 21, 5769 | | Israel Time: 22:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Maccabiah Travel Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 14:41 29/06/2009
Outpost Watch: Obama's future minefield - and Netanyahu's
By Bradley Burston
Tags: Israel News, Palestinians 

Click here for more articles by Bradley Burston

The following is the first phase of a project aimed at helping monitor outposts and clarify the potential difficulty in countering them for the sake of peace. The data is based in large part on extensive research conducted over years by the Peace Now organization, augmented with and cross-referenced by information from settlers and Haaretz correspondents.

The accompanying map of outposts is under construction. It is, as is the lists of outposts below - and the outposts themselves - a work in progress.

The public will be invited to assist this project. Information on new outposts, or changes in existing outposts, is welcome via the Talkback feature.

___________________________



Of the long list of hackneyed pro-Israel arguments which persuade no one except previously and permanently persuaded fellow-Israelis, none tops the tired clunker trotted out by Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman in his U.S. visit to Washington this month.

Settlements in the West Bank, he told reporters after talks with U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, are "not an obstacle to achieve peace."

Permit me at this point to save some time, and to speak candidly. Everyone - and I do mean everyone, whether they are willing to publicly acknowledge this or not - knows that obstacles are precisely what West Bank settlements were put there to be.

Settlements, whether considered legal or illegal, whether granted overt or blind-eye Israeli government sanction, or placed there by unruly-eyed fanatics who hate the Israeli government almost as much as they hate Arabs, have a common goal.

They were built to be explicit, intentional, physical, literal obstacles to any peace process that would include ceding West Bank land to Palestinians. And that, everyone knows, describes any conceivable future peace process.

Yes, they are also a place to live. And yes, the land they occupy may well be mentioned in the bible, even scores of times. And yes, generations of Jews have now been born and raised there. But this last only underscores the reason they are there.

It should be noted that at this point, there are in fact three distinct classes of West Bank settlements. The first are the government-approved enclaves on the "Israel side" of the West Bank barrier. Under a future peace deal, these are expected to be annexed to Israel, with an acreage-equivalent swath of the western Negev appended to an independent Palestine.

The second class, in every sense, are government-authorized settlements scattered across the West Bank, on the "Palestinian-side" of the fence/wall.

Finally, there are the outpost settlements, which Israel and even elements of the settler movement concede are illegal.

If the settlements are obstacles, the outposts are designed to be landmines. They are volatile, potentially explosive, often vaguely marked and defined.

They defend established settlements by creating a protective outer ring of obstructions to be cleared prior to any move to raze the older, larger, more solidly built enclaves.

And if Barack Obama and, for that matter, Benjamin Netanyahu, make any substantive moves toward Mideast peace, the number of these minefields is certain to mushroom.


View Outpost watch in a larger map

With thanks to Adam Abrams

The current list:

1. ADEI AD
2. AHAVAT HAIM
3. AHIYA
4. ALONEI SHILO, OR NOF KANEH FARM
5. ALTITUDE 468, or, NOFEI PRAT WEST.
6. AMONA
7. ANCIENT SYNAGOGUE OF SUSYA
8. ASA'EL
9. AVIGAIL
10. BAT AYIN EAST
11. BAT AYIN WEST
12. BEIT EL EAST
13. BNEI ADAM, OR ADAM EAST
14. BRACHA A
15. BRUCHIN
16. DERECH HA'AVOT
17. EIN PRAT
18. ELISHA, OR TZOFIT [PRE-IDF SERVICE ACADEMY]
19. ELMATAN
20. ESH KODESH
21. GILAD FARM
22. GIVAT ASSAF
23. GIVAT HADAGAN
24. GIVAT HADEGEL
25. GIVAT HAHISH
26. GIVAT HAREL
27. GIVAT HATAMAR
28. GIVAT SALIT
29. GVA'OT OLAM
30. HABAYIT HA'ADOM, OR HADA'AT FARM
31. HAHAR
32. HAKARON
33. HANEKUDA
34. HAR HEMED
35. HARESHA
36. HARO'EH, OR ELI 762
37. HAYOVEL
38. HERUTI
39. HILL 26, OR KARMEI NETANEL
40. HILL 725
41. HILL 777
42. HILL 782
43. HILL 836
44. HILL 851
45. HORESH YARON
46. IBEI HANAHAL
47. JABEL ARITIS, OR ALT. 909
48. KARMEI DORON, OR EINAV NORTHEAST
49. KFAR TAPUAH WEST
50. KIDA, OR ADEI AD NORTH
51. KOCHAV YAAKOV EAST
52. KOCHAV YAAKOV WEST
53. LEHAVAT YITZHAR
54. MAALEH EFRAIM [PRE-IDF SERVICE ACADEMY]
55. MAALEH HAGIT
56. MAALEH ISRAEL
57. MAALEH REHAVAM
58. MAALEH SHLOMO
59. MAAVAR MICHMASH, OR MIGRON SOUTH
60. MAGEN DAN
61. MAON FARM, OR HILL 833
62. MAOZ ZVI
63. MAROM AYALON, OR MEVO HORON NORTH
64. MEVO'OT JERICHO
65. MIGRON
66. MISHPATEI ARETZ, OR BEIT HAGDUD [YESHIVA]
67. MITZPEH DANNY
68. MITZPEH ESHTAMOA, OR SHIM'A NORTH
69. MITZPEH HA'AI
70. MITZPEH JERICHO NORTHEAST
71. MITZPEH KRAMIM
72. MITZPEH LACHISH
73. MITZPEH YAIR, OR MAGEN DAVID
74. MITZPEH YITZHAR
75. MOR FARM
76. MUL NEVO
77. NEVE DANIEL NORTH, OR SDE BO'AZ
78. NEVE EREZ
79. NOF HARIM
80. NOF NESHER, OR LUCIFER FARM
81. NOFEI NEHEMIA
82. OFRA NORTHEAST
83. OLD MASSUOT YITZHAK
84. OMER FARM, OR EINOT KEDEM
85. PALGEI HAMAYIM, OR HIRBET A-SHUNA
86. PNEI KEDEM
87. RAMAT GILAD
88. RACHELIM SOUTH
89. SDE BAR FARM, OR KFAR ELDAD
90. SDE KALEV, OR KIRYAT ARBA SOUTH
91. SHALHEVET FARM, OR YITZHAR WEST
92. SKALI'S FARM, OR POINT 792
93. SNEH YAAKOV
94. SUSYA NORTHWEST, OR RUJUM El CHAMRI
95. TEKOA B AND C
96. TEKOA D
97. TZUR SHALEM
98. YAIR FARM
99. YATIR SOUTHWEST
100. ZAIT RAANAN

I never thought I'd be rooting for Iran
In Iran, upheaval in the streets, but nuclear business as usual
Loving Israel by hating Obama
GM as parable, and Israel's sudden choice: Obama or Kahane
In Israel, Adam Lambert would have won
Obama, Netanyahu, and two states for spoiled brats
How would Israel look if its left finally died?
Michael Oren, Ambassador, or, this is how the occupation ends
Could the Taliban get the bomb before Iran does?
Obama, Netanyahu, and Zionists Against Occupation
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
'Racist' Israeli ad
Facebook group blasts ad showing IDF troops playing soccer by separation fence
No regrets
IDF chief during Second Lebanon War says he'd do it again the same
  1.   Exactly right 16:05  |  Natallie Durson 22/06/09
  2.   Outpost Watch 16:43  |  Yosef Leibowitz 22/06/09
  3.   Givat HaDegal 17:02  |  Ibnezra 22/06/09
  4.   Bradley Be Careful Some Jews Are Dangerous... 17:26  |  Yosemite 22/06/09
  5.   Incomplete list 17:29  |  Uetliberg 22/06/09
  6.   He`s 101% Right 17:38  |  Ed 22/06/09
  7.   West Bank Settlements 18:10  |  Chance 22/06/09
  8.   A map?? 19:46  |  Fred blogs 22/06/09
  9.   Give us a map 20:21  |  Student 22/06/09
  10.   The map 20:51  |  Haaretz.com 22/06/09
  11.   Outposts - Let them stay 21:45  |  Scott 22/06/09
  12.   Good project on the perils of settlements 21:51  |  Secular 22/06/09
  13.   Islamic arrogance is the obsticle to peace 22:00  |  Dean Blake 22/06/09
  14.   The Settlements will stay.. 22:04  |  petra 22/06/09
  15.   Sorry Bradley - even Jimmy Carter supports settlements 22:10  |  Yakir 22/06/09
  16.   Errors in the Ha`aretz list 22:15  |  JPS 22/06/09
  17.   Obama as Don Quixote 22:17  |  Mark Lincoln 22/06/09
  18.   You Missed Some 22:45  |  Yishai Kohen 22/06/09
  19.   Yakir 1 down how many to go 23:13  |  Jane@amazon.com 22/06/09
  20.   JPS Is not efrat in the occupied territories. 23:19  |  Raven 22/06/09
  21.   Bradley does not mention how many people will be displaced 23:25  |  Avi 22/06/09
  22.   Tough to dislodge? 23:35  |  Colin Wright 22/06/09
  23.   Finally 23:43  |  Dave Duncan 22/06/09
  24.   Map of Illigal Arab housing in and outside Israel? 23:52  |  Hidden Truths 22/06/09
  25.   Not hard at all. Cut off electricity and roads. 00:06  |  Ivar 23/06/09
  26.   the little black hole in Bradley`s argument about the intent - 00:18  |  ivo 23/06/09
  27.   Mark Lincoln # 16 00:48  |  American in NY 23/06/09
  28.   Why isn*t Grossingers on the list? 00:52  |  American in NY 23/06/09
  29.   Palestine Mandate- IS JEWISH RIGHT TO YESHA 02:51  |  Get a hint 23/06/09
  30.   Coalition Tops the Dismantling List 03:12  |  Shaul Ben-Yimini 23/06/09
  31.   Ready Solution 03:16  |  Iain 23/06/09
  32.   Israel has successfully created an hell for Palestinians 03:28  |  UK 23/06/09
  33.   #14 Yakir How often do you agree with Jimmy Carter? 03:54  |  jim the mechanic 23/06/09
  34.   #15 Well, JPS..... 04:00  |  Johnboy 23/06/09
  35.   The settlers to bibi are the same as Taliban to Pakistan 04:53  |  justis 23/06/09
  36.   I didn`t expect it to pass censors 06:49  |  Mark Lincoln 23/06/09
  37.   #16 Mark Lincoln, you are one misantropic disbeliever in US power 09:32  |  Mark B. 23/06/09
  38.   NO EXCUSES! ISRAEL Did This And ISRAEL Should FIX It! 10:28  |  U.S. Pal Defender 23/06/09
  39.   Obviously no Justis in occupied Boston 11:03  |  Yakir 23/06/09
  40.   Practical problem 11:37  |  question_asker 23/06/09
  41.   it would be very easy to remove the outposts / settlements 12:06  |  SD 23/06/09
  42.   Re: Practical problem 12:17  |  Ilan 23/06/09
  43.   Remove all the illegal squatters 12:40  |  Matty Groves 23/06/09
  44.   #36 I find your attitude rather odd, Mark Lincoln 13:09  |  Johnboy 23/06/09
  45.   #31, 38, 41, 43 and all that think they can be 13:49  |  question_asker 23/06/09
  46.   to single out the settlements as the only /main problem is false 14:09  |  ivo 23/06/09
  47.   Peace Later 15:46  |  Nura 23/06/09
  48.   Question_Asker - an answer 16:06  |  Matty Groves 23/06/09
  49.   The closeness of last election implies only the differences... 16:37  |  Smadar 23/06/09
  50.   To Raven - The answer is no. 16:38  |  JPS 23/06/09
  51.   I agree with number 48 16:39  |  SD 23/06/09
  52.   Wake up Jane and Jim - reality is here 16:55  |  Yakir 23/06/09
  53.   #40 That`s nonsense, question_asker 17:12  |  Johnboy 23/06/09
  54.   Johnboy ignores political reality 18:24  |  question_asker 23/06/09
  55.   #54 question_asker I wouldn`t make assumptions... 18:57  |  Smadar 23/06/09
  56.   #54 question_asker 19:08  |  S 23/06/09
  57.   Re # 8 and 9 Yes, a map ! Now ! 21:40  |  David 23/06/09
  58.   question_asker: you`ve probably forgotten what happened in gaza - 00:41  |  ivo 24/06/09
  59.   Mark B. You clearly don`t know dick about democrats 01:17  |  Mark Lincoln 24/06/09
  60.   Oh, Johnny Boy, the pipes the pipes are calling 01:22  |  Mark Lincoln 24/06/09
  61.   Dear Liberals - a reality check 01:26  |  Mark Lincoln 24/06/09
  62.   Whether 100 or 1000, die is cast 02:04  |  Witness 24/06/09
  63.   Remove the IDF protection -- the settlers will leave 02:06  |  Dolores 24/06/09
  64.   #54 Oh, it`s called "political reality", is it? 02:09  |  Johnboy 24/06/09
  65.   question asker 03:51  |  Jennifer 24/06/09
  66.   Bibi will not budge on the settlements 03:55  |  Marc Leb 24/06/09
  67.   Outpost are for peace and security 07:35  |  Baruch Gold 24/06/09
  68.   Judenrein Areas not indicative of peace 07:38  |  Baruch Gold 24/06/09
  69.   Indispensable 09:32  |  Iain 24/06/09
  70.   If The Settlements Are The Sole Obstacle For Peace .. 11:28  |  Tim R 24/06/09
  71.   Burston is right 17:12  |  Tuvea 26/06/09
  72.   Settlements R religious issues=keep out! 01:21  |  sam 28/06/09
  73.   Ultimately 09:08  |  Choni Davidowitz 28/06/09
  74.   to Mark Lincoln #17 23:15  |  zeev 28/06/09
  75.   to Baruch Gold #67 23:38  |  zeev 28/06/09
  76.   to Baruch Gold #68 23:57  |  zeev 28/06/09
  77.   i hope the settlers put up LOTS more!!! 02:26  |  wow! i LOVE the sett 05/07/09
  78.   ~21 AVI 22:33  |  Courcey 08/07/09
  79.   Gaza/Settelments 22:05  |  Marty 13/07/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
hotel Jerusalem
David Citadel Hotel, come stay at the finest of Jerusalem hotels.
ISRAEL ARMY SURPLUS STORE
IDF insignia,Uniforms, Paladium Boots Watches, Israel Army T-shirts & Collectibles
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
More Headlines
22:15 France to retry suspects of anti-Semitic murder
21:47 Opening ceremony launches 18th Maccabiah - the biggest one yet
22:09 Netanyahu: Palestinians could achieve more if they cooperated
21:32 One of FBI's 100 most wanted apprehended in Tel Aviv
19:40 Obama to host American Jewish leaders at White House
22:11 Will Israel grant asylum to fascism?
22:01 Tensions soar between Israeli UN delegation, Al-Jazeera bureau
00:15 WATCH: Daily news round-up from Israel
17:36 Arab MK urges ban on ad showing IDF troops playing soccer at West Bank fence
18:24 First indictment issued in Olmert travel expenses probe
16:40 U.K.: We revoked Israel arms licenses, but it's no embargo
17:28 Suspected Nazi Demjanjuk indicted by German court
19:36 Jordan launches medical tourism advertising campaign in U.S.
18:56 Supreme court blasts acquittal of Haredi motorist who ran over woman
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Israel 2009 election results | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved