Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., June 22, 2009 Sivan 30, 5769 | | Israel Time: 09:13 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Focus U.S.A. Travel Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 02:49 02/06/2009
Border Control /Nothing natural about it
By Akiva Eldar
Tags: Israel News, Settlements

The myth of "natural population growth" doesn't impress Col. (res.) Shaul Arieli, nor do the stories about little children from good Jewish homes who are left without a kindergarten. Arieli, who in the late 1990s served as deputy military secretary to former prime minister and incumbent Defense Minister Ehud Barak, did the calculations and found that one third of Israelis living in the territories (not including East Jerusalem) settled there during the Oslo years and another third after the peace process was suspended.

Expressed in numbers: From 1992-2001, the number of Jewish settlers increased by approximately 93,000 and four settlements were added; in the period from 2001-2009, another 95,000 settlers were added to the population and 100 additional outposts established.

As for East Jerusalem, 45 percent of Israelis living in East Jerusalem moved there after the Oslo agreement.
Advertisement
And now for the total: While 32 settlements (not including East Jerusalem) were established in the territories between 1967 and 1977, housing some 6,000 settlers, today 127 Jewish settlements can be found in the territories, alongside another 100 outposts, housing a total of 295,000 settlers.

It doesn't take a demographer to deduce from Arieli's figures that "natural population growth" - even at a record 3.4 percent per annum (which is twice the national average among Jews) - cannot explain a 100 percent growth to the settlers' population in 2001-2009.

Sansana says it all

When the heads of the Barack Obama administration ask Defense Minister Ehud Barak about the latest news about the Jewish settlements in the territories, Barak had better not swear that on his watch, no new settlements were constructed. U.S. satellites are photographing every new house in the territories and the American consulate in Jerusalem is reporting on every new building plan that is submitted to the planning commissions. It is therefore highly likely that they also conveyed the story about the settlement of Sansana.

More than two months ago it was reported here that with Barak's special authorization, the Civil Administration deposited a detailed master plan for building this small settlement in the southern Hebron Hills. The first stage involves the retrospective koshering of the illegal construction of more than 50 housing units, which the settlement's inhabitants put up near the Green Line (the pre-Six-Day War border). The plan's second stage foresees the approval of some 400 additional units.

The plan depicts Sansana as an expansion of the Eshkolot settlement - even though a distance of three kilometers separates the two sites, there is no road connecting them and the separation fence runs between them.

At the time, the Defense Minister's Bureau asserted that Sansana had been established in accordance with Cabinet Decision 3951, dating back to 1998, to establish six new settlements along the seam line, and that the planning had been approved in 2003.

But a more recent investigation has shown that there is no connection between Master Plan 3951 and the new plan for Sansana. According to the coordinates mentioned in 3951, Sansana was supposed to be built within the jurisdiction of the Bnei Shimon regional council, located within the Green Line, and not in the jurisdiction of the Hebron Hills regional council, located in the West Bank. This fact also emerges from the aerial photograph appended to the government's decision. Meanwhile, the detailed master Plan for Sansana (505/1) was deposited and prepared in accordance with the Jordanian planning law, as required in the procedure to approve settlements.

Ergo, Sansana was built in the occupied territories, contrary to the government's decision.

Nir Shalev, from the Bimkom - Planners for Planning Rights non-profit organization, which has submitted an objection to the plan, says Sansana fits some of the criteria of an illegal outpost: There is no government decision for its establishment in the territories and it does not have an approved master plan.

The Defense Minister's Bureau has not denied the facts. It was explained that the settlement was allotted state lands, which are "adjacent" to the Green Line, in order to avoid uprooting planted woods. Moreover, the bureau claims that Sansana is located west of the security barrier. It is worth recalling that in the context of the road map, Israel undertook not to construct any new settlements anymore. The world has never recognized the "route of the barrier" as the route of the settlements.

A police state - then and now

Under a plea bargain reached with the prosecution, Gregory Lerner is expected to spend many more years in prison. Within the next few days the oligarch will be found guilty, by virtue of his confession, of stealing NIS 62 million from 2,500 investors, most of them immigrants from the Confederation of Independent States. In the previous round, Lerner was sentenced to six years in prison and a steep fine, after confessing to embezzling about $48 million from three Russian banks and attempting to bribe politicians.

At the height of the first investigation into Lerner's activities, at the end of July 1997, Avigdor Lieberman (the incumbent foreign minister) - who served at the time as director general of the Prime Minister's Bureau under Benjamin Netanyahu (who was prime minister then, as now) - called an urgent press conference. "Investigations against Russians," Lieberman declared, "are part of a witch hunt the likes of which were seen only during the McCarthy era in the United States. What is wrong with a person donating money to institutions or to individuals? Why aren't they examining the donations made by Mr. [Nahum] Manbar, who is accused of spying for an enemy country? In the social climate we have created, anyone who has succeeded has to be screwed, and any nuisance and informer becomes a police stool-pigeon."

On that same occasion, this very loyal citizen suggested a flattering definition of the State of Israel: "We are much more of a police state than a law state." It would be interesting to find out whether Lieberman still holds the same beliefs today, now that his party has gained control over the police.

Related articles:
  • Yes, freeze settlements
  • Crisis nears as U.S. slams Israeli settlement policy
  • New residents account for one-third of West Bank settlement growth
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Bombing Iran
    How do recent protests change Israel's military option against Iran's nukes?
    Deadly Tehran protests
    Mousavi urges Iranians to continue rallies after 17 protestors die
      1.   They are looking for a buyout. That is settle now 03:42  |  American in NY 02/06/09
      2.   Very simple answer to the increase.. 03:58  |  M Lazak 02/06/09
      3.   Excellent article with some new information 04:09  |  American 02/06/09
      4.   Why do leftists hate Settlers 04:40  |  Rabbi Yakov Lazaros 02/06/09
      5.   The Myth of Greater Israel! 04:41  |  Le Corbeau 02/06/09
      6.   cal hacavod to the settlers!!! 05:06  |  Akiva P 02/06/09
      7.   don`t bother me with facts 05:18  |  Billy 02/06/09
      8.   If this is "disputed land" WHY NOT FREEZE THE ARAB SETTLEMENTS ? 05:24  |  Howard 02/06/09
      9.   WHAT ABOUT THE ILLEGAL ARAB SETTLEMENTS? 05:26  |  Howard 02/06/09
      10.   #4 Say that again, Rabbi? 06:13  |  Johnboy 02/06/09
      11.   Fake Rabbi Yakov Lazaros, peace is a buffer zone... 06:17  |  BBSNews 02/06/09
      12.   End colonialism 06:23  |  david 02/06/09
      13.   To Rabbi Lazarus 06:24  |  DAvid 02/06/09
      14.   liberals can`t add 06:53  |  david 02/06/09
      15.   If it were the Palestinians who were ... 07:12  |  Jasper 02/06/09
      16.   Natural Growth Revisited 07:20  |  Shimon Cleopas 02/06/09
      17.   About correctness: hatred is difficult to measure. 07:56  |  Mario Sala 02/06/09
      18.   Rapid Population Growth 08:04  |  Joe 02/06/09
      19.   Prime reason for vast population growth on settlements... 08:33  |  Esther 02/06/09
      20.   #4 greater israel dreams stretching from egypt to iraq 09:06  |  muslim-- 02/06/09
      21.   #Rabbi Yakov 10:02  |  Kilminster 02/06/09
      22.   Settlements: No obstacle to "peace" 10:11  |  Hebrew Hammer 02/06/09
      23.   "Rabbi" #3... "buffer zone" complete nonsense.. 10:32  |  Esther 02/06/09
      24.   The Jewish right to live anywhere in Israel stems from God. 11:07  |  Yakov 02/06/09
      25.   Rabbi Lazaros and the myth of protection 11:24  |  Tzfonit 02/06/09
      26.   Plenty of room for natural growth 11:28  |  Tzfonit 02/06/09
      27.   Arab population in the wast bank has grown much more 12:01  |  Peter Snodgrass 02/06/09
      28.   see youtube.com/muslim demographics 12:03  |  me 02/06/09
      29.   #4 Rabbi Yakov Lazaros. Two theological question: 12:12  |  zmogus 02/06/09
      30.   #13, Hebrew Hammer. An exercise #1 in military geography. 12:41  |  zmogus 02/06/09
      31.   To 7 Hear Hear!! 13:06  |  richelle 02/06/09
      32.   in 1920 there were no Pals here. How about *their* natural growh 13:54  |  l.s.b. 02/06/09
      33.   What is a settlement 14:30  |  Jackie 02/06/09
      34.   Nothing wrong with that--Jews have a right to live anywhere 15:30  |  IW 02/06/09
      35.   Yakov: The Jewish right 15:48  |  DavidSanders 02/06/09
      36.   This is great news !!! Baruch Hashem ! 15:56  |  Akiva P 02/06/09
      37.   #13, Hebrew Hammer. An exercise #2 in military geography. 16:36  |  zmogus 02/06/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    hotel Jerusalem
    David Citadel Hotel, come stay at the finest of Jerusalem hotels.
    ISRAEL ARMY SURPLUS STORE
    IDF insignia,Uniforms, Paladium Boots Watches, Israel Army T-shirts & Collectibles
    Dead Sea Skin Care
    Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    02:40 Can Iran ever be freed from its religious regime?
    08:25 'Iran authorities free daughter of Ahmadinejad rival'
    03:45 ANALYSIS / Expect things to get worse in Iran - at least for now
    04:34 Israel taps new negotiators for Shalit deal
    05:30 Entire Iran school year may be lost amid rising protests
    07:21 U.S. road cleaned by neo-Nazis could be renamed after rabbi
    06:42 Woman denied benefits after visiting husband in West Bank
    14:12 Iran interactive - images, videos and Tweets from the streets
    20:58 WATCH: Daily news round-up from Israel
    07:51 Father killed in road crash hours after son's wedding
    04:40 New Yorkers head to Tel Aviv beach - in Central Park
    05:12 Jewish groups blast 'anti-Zionist' conference at Toronto university
    06:03 Wagner's great-granddaughter agrees to open family archives
    02:13 Health Ministry: HMOs, not hospitals, will treat swine flu patients
    23:24 West demands Iran recount; Ahmadinejad: Don't meddle
    22:11 Israelis and Palestinians 'hug' Jerusalem for peace
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Israel 2009 election results | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved