Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., April 07, 2009 Nisan 13, 5769 | | Israel Time: 16:44 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 21:37 31/03/2009
JEWISH WORLD / No citizenship without loyalty? Then why let Israelis vote from abroad?
By Roi Ben-Yehuda
Tags: israel elections 

Before writing an op-ed, my brain holds a vociferous debate with itself. One side argues passionately against the other and in the end, a vote is taken. Whichever position takes the majority vote becomes the topic of my column. But sometimes there is a stalemate. When this happens, the article will (usually) be left unwritten.

This is what happened when I sat down to write an op-ed about a law recently proposed by Benjamin Netanyahu and Avigdor Lieberman which would allow Israelis living abroad to cast their ballot in future elections.

As an Israeli living in New York, I thought, "Great for me, finally I'll be able to participate in Israeli elections."
Advertisement
But then a nagging thought entered my mind: "Do I, or any other Israeli expatriate, deserve to vote from afar?"

That question inspired the following row in my brain:

Left Brain: Yes, you do deserve it. Suffrage is an inalienable right inherited by virtue citizenship, not residence, and guaranteed under Israel's Basic Laws. To condition civil rights on residence is to violate the principle of democratic rights and open the door for further compromises. It is for this reason that many democratic countries allow absentee ballots. If it is good enough for venerable democracies like the United States and France, then it is good enough for Israel.

Right Brain: No, you don't deserve it. So what if many democratic countries allow ex-pats to cast absentee ballots? Israel is different. It is different in that so many of its citizens live abroad; it is different in that many more could be granted citizenship via the Law of Return; and it is different in that Israeli politics actually matter. All combined, the law could create a gallut (Diaspora) swing-vote whereby Israelis abroad play a crucial role in constructing domestic policy. In a country like Israel, it is unfair to let people who don't partake in the challenge of living here to decide the fate of those who do.

Left Brain: Look, this law is not so radical. At the moment, Israelis living abroad can vote if they are able to return to Israel during election times - this privileges those who can afford to return. The proposed law would simply enable those who can't afford the plane ticket, to have the opportunity to exercise a right that is given to them under Israel's Basic Law. I think we can all agree that voting should not privilege the rich.

Right Brain: Yes, we can agree. It is unfair. As such, it should be changed so that all non-residence Israelis, irrespective of bank accounts, should be disenfranchised.

Left Brain: I can't believe our neurons are related. How can you just speak of depriving voting rights? In a real democracy, such an idea would never be entertained. I think you need some Prozac.

Right Brain: I don't think it is my side that should be medicated. You speak of rights in platonic, pie-in-the-sky way. But rights are evolving legal/cultural constructs that have to respond to the demands of reality. Israel's basic law (which you mention) also recognizes this plasticity when it states, "Every Israel national of or over the age of eighteen years shall have the right to vote in elections to the Knesset unless a court has deprived him of that right by virtue of any Law."

I hate to offend your democratic sensibilities, but a civil right like voting is not really inalienable. For example, when people break the law and go to prison, they lose their right to vote - it becomes alienable. Therefore a civil right like voting is granted by virtue of citizenship but maintained under certain conditions, so long you don't violate your responsibility to uphold the law.

Left Brain: Hold on there. It is true that many prisoners don?t have voting rights. But that punishment makes no sense - revocation of voting rights does not deter crimes, nor does prisoner enfranchisement pose a risk to society. Many countries have overturned this practice: including Ireland, Spain, France and the Netherlands. Besides, are you saying Israelis who chose to live abroad are equivalent to thieves, rapist and murderers?

Right Brain: Not at all. I am saying that many societies recognize that a civil right like voting is not absolutely inalienable. Rights come attached with basic responsibilities (like following the law), and those who fail to fulfill those responsibilities may have their basic rights revoked. When Israelis live abroad, they stop fulfilling their civic obligation - paying taxes, serving in the IDF and reserve duty - so why should they also get the right to vote and have a meaningful hand in shaping the society to which they no longer - or never did - contribute.

Let me ask you a question. Even if you believe that Israelis should never lose the right to vote, don't you think that this is not the time to support a law that would further strengthen the power of right-wing (anti-democratic) politicians? I mean even Haaretz, as a newspaper, stood up against this proposition.

Left Brain: Well, that is the risk of democracy - you can't restrict the votes of those who are going to vote for people you don't like. But somewhere in your question, there is a good point. There seems to be a contradiction when a politician who ran on the platform 'No loyalty. No Citizenship' advocates a bill that would grant voting right to people who have willingly chosen (usually for economic and social reasons) to remove themselves for the sphere of civic responsibility.

Lieberman's 'Citizenship law' disenfranchises Israelis who don't serve their country through the army or civil service, or who fail to pledge loyalty to the [Jewish] state of Israel. Well, isn't that exactly what Israeli ex-pats do - they don't pay taxes or fulfill their service obligations [remember reserve duty?], and I would say that they vote with their feet on their ultimate loyalty to the state of Israel.

Right Brain: So now you support the citizenship law?

Left Brain: Not at all - it is because I believe that civil rights are inalienable that I reject this anti-democratic law to the core. It is cerebral hemispheres like you who believe that rights are contingent upon responsibilities that pave the way for politician like Lieberman to put up citizenship as a topic of legitimate debate.

Right Brain: Ok, enough, are you ready to vote on this one?

Left Brain: You sure you want to give me the right?

Right Brain: I am glad you still have your sense of humor.

Left Brain: Yes, I am ready.

All in favor of writing a pro-position article?

(Every neuron on the left side of the brain raises hand. None on the right.)

All in favor of a con-position article?

(Every neuron on the right raises hand. None on the left.)

It is settled. Without a clear majority, there will be no article.

Roi Ben-Yehuda is an Israeli writer based in New York. He is a regular contributor to Haaretz and France 24. His blog, RoiWord, can be read here
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Fighter for peace
Gaza doctor whose three daughters were killed during Gaza op gets Nobel nomination.
Determined diplomacy
Obama: U.S. 'strongly supports' two-state solution, vows to continue peace process.
  1.   I am loyal from 9,000 miles and I don`t need soil under my feet 18:59  |  Think 29/03/09
  2.   oi wei Haaretz(!) 18:26  |  Tatyana 29/03/09
  3.   Hmmm, maybe US needs "Loyalty Law" 18:42  |  Ruth 29/03/09
  4.   Israelis abroad right to vote! 18:50  |  Ros 29/03/09
  5.   Ex-pat voters 19:01  |  Ussishkin 29/03/09
  6.   more haaretz lies! 19:01  |  David 29/03/09
  7.   Jews always complain about something 19:17  |  Saul 29/03/09
  8.   saul,the arab,yes you are always complaining about something 19:57  |  ur day will come 29/03/09
  9.   # 8 20:19  |  Murad 29/03/09
  10.   Those who live abroad on a temporary basis are probably loyal 20:45  |  Realist 29/03/09
  11.   #3, Ruth - bad example 20:47  |  Bruce 29/03/09
  12.   Bruce # 11 re: Ruth it is a good example. 21:33  |  American in NY 29/03/09
  13.   Edited by moderator 21:41  |  Joe 29/03/09
  14.   Israeli abroad do not have voting rights? Oh weh, oh weh..! 21:47  |  Kris Lazar 29/03/09
  15.   Prisoners vote in Israel... 22:07  |  Yael 29/03/09
  16.   What about "Israeli Arab" Palestinians abroad? 22:58  |  Isadora 29/03/09
  17.   to #6 David 23:01  |  Gershon Reed 29/03/09
  18.   Absenty Votes 23:11  |  Gil J. Yashar 29/03/09
  19.   This is a stupid editorial. You can be loyal without being there 23:52  |  John Doe 29/03/09
  20.   # 6 david 00:48  |  Axel 30/03/09
  21.   #12, This is US 00:59  |  Bruce 30/03/09
  22.   Excellent article: Right Brain Wins The Debate 01:03  |  Sam 30/03/09
  23.   Isadora, both Arab and Jewish Israely citizens 01:04  |  Bruce 30/03/09
  24.   I agree and america should stop 01:07  |  Bob 30/03/09
  25.   leibermans assets in moldova 01:27  |  michael 30/03/09
  26.   #1 Think - why don`t you? Too busy straddled between the two? 01:39  |  Maureen Ann 30/03/09
  27.   Absolutely no 01:56  |  Northern 30/03/09
  28.   And what about your third brain? 02:05  |  Jason 30/03/09
  29.   Totally Stupid 02:16  |  Angela 30/03/09
  30.   Joe # 13 Did you ever hear of Pollard? kadish, Rosen? 03:28  |  American in NY 30/03/09
  31.   voting from abroad 04:23  |  ester 30/03/09
  32.   #3 loyalty oath 13:45  |  Hilda 30/03/09
  33.   totally understand the duality 13:48  |  dinah 30/03/09
  34.   Keep the Vote 23:54  |  Terry 30/03/09
  35.   truce 17:31  |  Lisa 31/03/09
  36.   Right to vote from abroad 19:05  |  Gadi Peller 31/03/09
  37.   Loyalty 22:46  |  Oleg 31/03/09
  38.   israelis abroad 00:39  |  Tuli 01/04/09
  39.   Rights 10:56  |  JBT 01/04/09
  40.   Voting 14:44  |  Yaakov 01/04/09
  41.   voting from abroad 15:04  |  david 01/04/09
  42.   To gershon in Be`er Sheva:YOU ARE WRONG 17:01  |  David 01/04/09
  43.   Axel Germany is an exception for obvious reasons 17:03  |  David 01/04/09
  44.   American in NY (#12) has not taken the oath of allegiance 20:54  |  Gil 01/04/09
  45.   people DO pledge in the USA EVERY DAY 02:30  |  ks 02/04/09
  46.   Jew....ish 03:14  |  The Red Baron 02/04/09
  47.   Right to vote 09:31  |  Danielle 02/04/09
  48.   Voting right 04:18  |  M.S 05/04/09
  49.   Paying the consequences of ones choice. 09:46  |  Ethan 05/04/09
  50.   Not influenced by leftist media... 16:08  |  Michael 06/04/09
  51.   Domingo: Not Clear that Israelis abroad will vote right of center 17:12  |  Will B Free 06/04/09
  52.   Er, Terry, 23:50  |  nina 06/04/09
 Haaretz Hot Topics
Air strike in Sudan
Israel 2009 election results: Voter breakdown
Conflict in Gaza
Israel vs. Hamas
Iran: Nuclear and regional ambitions
More Headlines
16:11 Palestinian killed after attacking officers at home of Jerusalem terrorist
16:32 Israel successfully test fires Arrow missile defense system
13:28 Haaretz exclusive: Obama to visit Israel, West Bank in June
12:10 ANALYSIS / Obama speech heralds end of 'axis of evil' era
14:58 Olmert to court: Defer hearings in graft cases against me
15:33 'It's not easy being an Ethiopian Jew in America'
16:24 Lieberman questioned for third time since becoming foreign minister
11:13 WATCH: Daily news round-up from Israel
14:07 Obama's Turkey address draws praise across Middle East
08:24 ANALYSIS / Obama saying Israel still bound to two-state solution
08:31 Pesach gift-giving has robbed us of our freedom
08:59 Galilee family holds out hope for son missing in Italy quake
08:25 IDF keeps Bedouin trackers in dark about Egypt border ops
08:42 Security officials may be barrier to Netanyahu's 'economic peace'
09:17 Knesset approves two-year state budget
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Camp Kimama Israel 2009
The best place for your children this summer
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved