Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., March 15, 2009 Adar 19, 5769 | | Israel Time: 11:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 09:45 10/03/2009
If talk could kill, we would already be at war with Iran
By Yoel Marcus
Tags: Israel news, Nuclear, Mofaz 

We have not yet decided whether to attack Iran, we have not yet decided whether Iran will attack us. We do not know exactly what they have in their nuclear arsenal and whether we are already threatened. Even American intelligence does not know what Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's intentions are and how close he is to making good on his threats. What is clear is that we are prattling on too much about the Iranian threat. If jabbering could kill, no doubt we would have been at war with Iran long ago.

In 1963, we received information that German scientists, experts in developing missiles and unconventional weapons, had been enlisted by the Egyptians to manufacture cobalt bombs and missiles. As usual in such cases in Israel, an argument erupted about whether this was a serious threat and if so, how to respond. Golda Meir and then Mossad chief Isser Harel were in favor of a major operation, while David Ben-Gurion, because of the nascent friendship with Germany and Konrad Adenauer's commitment to Israel's security, was for quiet action.

Indeed, here and there, booby-trapped envelopes were sent, without leaving fingerprints. Quietly, slowly, but surely, the scientists left and the project failed, without declarations and without threats.
Advertisement
For some time now the Iranian threat has been a subject for public discussion, with any public figure who finds a microphone threatening Iran. Shaul Mofaz came out saying that Israel should attack Iran. Ehud Barak, as usual, contradicted himself. One time he directed his barbs at Mofaz, calling the latter's statements "irresponsible." But later Barak himself warned that "time was slipping through our fingers." Barak told Condoleezza Rice on her last visit here that "we will not come to terms with a nuclear Iran and we are not taking any option off the table."

The defense minister's right to say this to the secretary of state is not in dispute, on condition that the statements do not become newspaper headlines; it is highly unlikely that Rice was the one to leak. On another occasion, Barak was quoted as saying: "Without doubt a nuclear weapon in the hands of Iran is a central threat to any world order and, moreover, an existential threat to Israel."

Meir Sheetrit, the voice of reason, warned in an interview in Haaretz that under no circumstances should we attack Iran, talk about attacking Iran or even think about it. "An attack at our initiative is a megalomaniac and irresponsible idea," he said. But Barak was also right when he said it is better to speak less about the Iranian threat. "There is no need for unnecessary talk, what should be done must be done when necessary."

With unnecessary talk we burden ourselves with the Iranian threat and make it easier for countries that do not want to get involved, former Israel Air Force chief Eitan Ben-Eliyahu said. The risk to Europe and to American interests in moderate Islamic countries in our region is no greater than the risk to Israel. It is no coincidence that one of the first acts of President Obama was to propose to Russia's Putin: We will not place missiles in Eastern Europe and you will stop assisting Iran. Our threats to act against Iran, if we feel our existence is at risk, might spur the world to increase sanctions and pressure Iran, on condition that we think a thousand times before we are dragged into irreversible verbiage.

The world accepted with understanding Begin's 1981 decision to blow up the nuclear reactor in Iraq. But in Iran there is no clear focal point to attack, as there was in Iraq. In Iran the infrastructure extends over a large area, much of it underground. Thousands of scientists are involved in the project. Taking it out will not be as simple as destroying the reactor in Iraq. Retired senior Mossad man Eliezer Tzafrir was right when he warned that "if Iran's nuclear facilities are bombed, Israel will be attacked with a shower of missiles." Thanks for the warning, but we already know what that is like, having experienced it in the two failed wars launched by the outgoing government.

Especially now, when it seems we are on our way to a narrow and extreme coalition, it is important for Prime Minister-designate Benjamin Netanyahu to be cautious and more aware of the limitations of Israel's power. Don't prattle on and don't jump in headfirst.



Related articles:
  • Arabs must unite to confront a nuclear Iran, Saudi FM says
  • Iran military chief: Our missiles can hit Israeli nuclear sites
  • Israel's new Iran policy: Sway Obama on Tehran talks
  • Iran proposes building joint nuclear plants with Arab neighbors
  • Q&A with Yossi Melman on Iran, intelligence and espionage
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Talk to Hamas
    Senior U.S. officials are urging Obama to begin dialogue with Islamist group.
    Living large
    Disgraced Wall Street financier Madoff's net worth in 2008 was $823 million.
      1.   Talk softly 03:47  |  David K 10/03/09
      2.   Iran has neithre the will nor the capabilities to... 04:15  |  ManintheMiddle 10/03/09
      3.   Iran is playing chess 04:31  |  An American 10/03/09
      4.   If talk could kill, Israel would have died 61 yrs ago. 04:40  |  Murray of Montreal 10/03/09
      5.   Iran will develop Nuclear weapons because the US 05:26  |  Musilm 10/03/09
      6.   Yadlin declared "Game Over" already. 05:45  |  Fortuna Benmayor 10/03/09
      7.   Iran is playing chess. 05:48  |  Fortuna Benmayor 10/03/09
      8.   Meir Dagan failed. Iran crossed the treshold. 05:51  |  Fortuna Benmayor 10/03/09
      9.   loose talk is dangerous 05:52  |  American 10/03/09
      10.   If Yoel Says We Are Safe We are In Grave Danger 05:54  |  Baruch Gold 10/03/09
      11.   #2 Man in the Middle 05:56  |  Baruch Gold 10/03/09
      12.   Cheap mistaken shot at the end plus Another mistake 06:08  |  Shalom Freedman 10/03/09
      13.   if words could kill... 06:19  |  Rick Byron 10/03/09
      14.   I`m Iranian, and 07:28  |  Ali 10/03/09
      15.   Ali #13. Thank you for participating. 08:16  |  Ben - Africa 10/03/09
      16.   The West should wake up! 08:43  |  Jean Van Daem 10/03/09
      17.   Iran - israel 08:46  |  hormoz 10/03/09
      18.   #13 Ali & political talk 08:58  |  Elina 10/03/09
      19.   At last, enligtenment.. 09:17  |  Faraz 10/03/09
      20.   Where is the Israeli "Kissinger".....????? 09:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 10/03/09
      21.   #13, Ali and "revolutionary speech" 10:03  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/03/09
      22.   do not fret mr.marcus-talk works.to wit you 11:52  |  yossi wortmeister 10/03/09
      23.   #.5. Muslim. 12:18  |  Stephen. 10/03/09
      24.   Freedman: militarily successful? 12:36  |  Davids 10/03/09
      25.   In spring 12:39  |  Mark Lincoln 10/03/09
      26.   Look up hypocrisy in the dictionary--see GOI 12:52  |  Labhras 10/03/09
      27.   YOU CAN TALK AS MUCH AS YOU WANT 12:56  |  ron 10/03/09
      28.   # 12 shalom 13:43  |  Axel 10/03/09
      29.   mr. marcus is right: don`t take a head dive 13:56  |  saul a. readner 10/03/09
      30.   casus belli admission 14:40  |  emad salib 10/03/09
      31.   Buy Melman, it is only Iranian threats they are interested in 14:42  |  emad salib 10/03/09
      32.   Yoel Marcus 15:42  |  Persian Kitty 10/03/09
      33.   Not speech ..... but religion and dogma 15:57  |  allang 10/03/09
      34.   LABHRAS#24, RECENT HISTORY IS PLENTY OF SIGNATURES THAT HAVE... 16:08  |  MOSHEH 10/03/09
      35.   #25 16:31  |  An American 10/03/09
      36.   Obama should encourage continuous diplomatic engagement... 17:45  |  Smadar 10/03/09
      37.   words & reality 17:57  |  Elina 10/03/09
      38.   musilm #5 it`s the muslims that should be worried about iran 17:58  |  face facts 10/03/09
      39.   swiss (dino) 18:06  |  scallywag 10/03/09
      40.   maninthemiddle 18:09  |  scallywag 10/03/09
      41.   what is your point Mosheh 18:42  |  Labhras 10/03/09
      42.   The Iranian Posters on This Article 18:43  |  Persian Kitty 10/03/09
      43.   It`s Purim 19:23  |  Lucy Somera 10/03/09
      44.   #38. You are right. There is a huge deal of enemity 19:31  |  Muslim 10/03/09
      45.   To All Iranians Here and Elsewhere 20:22  |  Baruch Gold 10/03/09
      46.   THAT`S IT LABHRAS#41, THE ANSWER IS IN FRONT OF YOUR EYES AND... 02:37  |  MOSHEH 11/03/09
      47.   Big Spread Out Programs Require Big Spread Out Attacks 03:56  |  UsedToPostHere 11/03/09
      48.   #45 BARUCH GOLD With Israelies like you 04:04  |  jim the mechanic 11/03/09
      49.   When Hamas kills its own people , is not aggression 06:39  |  MMM 11/03/09
      50.   Hormoz....King Cyrus was not the one who freed the Jews 06:47  |  Maria 11/03/09
      51.   #50 who freed jews? 13:04  |  Al 11/03/09
      52.   TO Israelis like Baruch Gold 20:58  |  Mark 11/03/09
      53.   TO # 50 21:06  |  godless 11/03/09
      54.   re: godless 23:09  |  UsedToPostHere 12/03/09
      55.   To Israelis from an Iranian 22:51  |  Ali 13/03/09
      56.   re: Ali 07:06  |  UsedToPostHere 15/03/09
     Read & React
    Israel to Hamas: Deadline for Shalit deal is tonight
    Responses: 26
    Gideon Levy / Don't protest for Shalit, protest for release of terrorists
    Responses: 26
    Arabs view ICC indictment of Sudan president as act of imperialism
    Responses: 16
    Zvi Bar'el: If we give in to Netanyahu from the start, Israel will become a footnote
    Responses: 9


    More Headlines
    10:29 Olmert: We'll decide on Shalit deal on Monday
    09:11 Don't protest for Shalit, protest for release of terrorists
    10:44 IDF to station troops in Hebron's 'House of Contention'
    07:29 Likud leaders: Livni demand for rotation blocking unity coalition
    07:20 ANALYSIS / Why is Livni so quiet on coaltion talks?
    08:41 Arabs view indictment of Sudan president as act of imperialism
    01:21 WATCH: Daily news round-up from Israel
    09:01 ANALYSIS / Olmert using Netanyahu to press Hamas over Shalit
    03:37 Gilad Shalit's brother pleads in letter: 'Please bring him home'
    06:12 'Strategic thought team' to advise Netanyahu's new government
    04:36 Police cite significant achievements against major crime families
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
    Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
    Dead Sea Skin Care
    Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
    Summer in Israel
    Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
    Passover Vacations
    The BEST Passover Vacations around ? Mexico, Arizona and Florida
    Camp Kimama Israel 2009
    The best place for your children this summer
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
    Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved