Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., November 18, 2009 Kislev 1, 5770 | | Israel Time: 10:16 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 13:17 26/01/2009
IDF rabbinate publication during Gaza war: We will show no mercy on the cruel
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Israel News, rabbinate, IDF 

During the fighting in the Gaza Strip, the religious media - and on two occasions, the Israel Defense Forces weekly journal Bamahane - were full of praise for the army rabbinate. The substantial role of religious officers and soldiers in the front-line units of the IDF was, for the first time, supported also by the significant presence of rabbis there.

The chief army rabbi, Brigadier General Avichai Rontzki, joined the troops in the field on a number of occasions, as did rabbis under his command.

Officers and soldiers reported that they felt "spiritually elevated" and "morally empowered" by conversations with rabbis who gave them encouragement before the confrontation with the Palestinians.
Advertisement
But what exactly was the content of these conversations and of the plethora of written material disseminated by the IDF rabbinate during the war? A reservist battalion rabbi told the religious newspaper B'Sheva last week that Rontzki explained to his staff that their role was not "to distribute wine and challah for Shabbat to the troops," but "to fill them with yiddishkeit and a fighting spirit."

An overview of some of the army rabbinate's publications made available during the fighting reflects the tone of nationalist propaganda that steps blatantly into politics, sounds racist and can be interpreted as a call to challenge international law when it comes to dealing with enemy civilians.

Haaretz has received some of the publications through Breaking the Silence, a group of former soldiers who collect evidence of unacceptable behavior in the army vis-a-vis Palestinians. Other material was provided by officers and men who received it during Operation Cast Lead. Following are quotations from this material:

"[There is] a biblical ban on surrendering a single millimeter of it [the Land of Israel] to gentiles, though all sorts of impure distortions and foolishness of autonomy, enclaves and other national weaknesses. We will not abandon it to the hands of another nation, not a finger, not a nail of it." This is an excerpt from a publication entitled "Daily Torah studies for the soldier and the commander in Operation Cast Lead," issued by the IDF rabbinate. The text is from "Books of Rabbi Shlomo Aviner," who heads the Ateret Cohanim yeshiva in the Muslim quarter of the Old City in Jerusalem.

The following questions are posed in one publication: "Is it possible to compare today's Palestinians to the Philistines of the past? And if so, is it possible to apply lessons today from the military tactics of Samson and David?" Rabbi Aviner is again quoted as saying: "A comparison is possible because the Philistines of the past were not natives and had invaded from a foreign land ... They invaded the Land of Israel, a land that did not belong to them and claimed political ownership over our country ... Today the problem is the same. The Palestinians claim they deserve a state here, when in reality there was never a Palestinian or Arab state within the borders of our country. Moreover, most of them are new and came here close to the time of the War of Independence."

The IDF rabbinate, also quoting Rabbi Aviner, describes the appropriate code of conduct in the field: "When you show mercy to a cruel enemy, you are being cruel to pure and honest soldiers. This is terribly immoral. These are not games at the amusement park where sportsmanship teaches one to make concessions. This is a war on murderers. 'A la guerre comme a la guerre.'"

This view is also echoed in publications signed by Rabbis Chen Halamish and Yuval Freund on Jewish consciousness. Freund argues that "our enemies took advantage of the broad and merciful Israeli heart" and warns that "we will show no mercy on the cruel."

In addition to the official publications, extreme right-wing groups managed to bring pamphlets with racist messages into IDF bases. One such flyer is attributed to "the pupils of Rabbi Yitzhak Ginsburg" - the former rabbi at Joseph's Tomb and author of the article "Baruch the Man," which praises Baruch Goldstein, who massacred unarmed Palestinians in Hebron. It calls on "soldiers of Israel to spare your lives and the lives of your friends and not to show concern for a population that surrounds us and harms us. We call on you ... to function according to the law 'kill the one who comes to kill you.' As for the population, it is not innocent ... We call on you to ignore any strange doctrines and orders that confuse the logical way of fighting the enemy."

The Israeli human rights organization Yesh Din has called on Defense Minister Ehud Barak to immediately remove Rabbi Rontzki from his post as chief rabbi.

In response, an IDF spokesman said that: "Overall, letters that are sent to the chief of staff [such as the request for Rontzki's dismissal] are reviewed and an answer is sent to those who make the request, not to the media."

Related articles:
  • 'You'll be proud of me, yet' slain IDF soldier told family before entering Gaza
  • Chief IDF rabbi: Army rabbinate needs to inculcate Jewish values
  • Chief IDF rabbi taught Torah to jailed Jewish extremists
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Kosher vampires
    Popular books and movies Twilight and New Moon are making vampirism more Jewish
    Most popular names
    If you were born in 2008, you're likely to be named one of these...
      1.   Leave the Rabbis alone. 04:28  |  Damon 26/01/09
      2.   Which God and whose interpretation? 04:30  |  Maureen Ann 26/01/09
      3.   Not propaganda 04:33  |  Maurice 26/01/09
      4.   IDF rabbinate disseminated extremist propaganda during Gaza war 04:57  |  John Q. Public 26/01/09
      5.   Avi Ronski is a true hero 05:09  |  mandy 26/01/09
      6.   "extremist propaganda" - By Haaretz 05:12  |  Sam 26/01/09
      7.   Avi Ronski is a hero 05:12  |  mandy 26/01/09
      8.   Explains some things 05:39  |  motti 26/01/09
      9.   Can`t have it both ways. 06:32  |  Daniel 26/01/09
      10.   shame 06:40  |  menuchasarah 26/01/09
      11.   re extremists opinions 06:51  |  Richard Barnes 26/01/09
      12.   These guys are as bad as Hamas 06:57  |  Brad 26/01/09
      13.   Jewish Prophets Are Mentioned in Independence Declaration 07:10  |  Joseph.E 26/01/09
      14.   I don`t get it -- Boosha! 07:39  |  Retired soldier 26/01/09
      15.   Nice to know 08:07  |  Mike 26/01/09
      16.   Breaking the Silence - A hopeful light. 08:26  |  Tony Price 26/01/09
      17.   Your "Secular" society is getting smaller and smaller. 08:52  |  Eliyahu Galli 26/01/09
      18.   Where is the power 09:13  |  Aba 26/01/09
      19.   Finally ! 09:21  |  Steven Ruddell 26/01/09
      20.   Restraint 09:27  |  Joseph 26/01/09
      21.   Changed the framework 09:40  |  Motic 26/01/09
      22.   Laws of War 09:43  |  Sherlock Holmes 26/01/09
      23.   Difference between soldiers and Peace Now 09:44  |  Smadar 26/01/09
      24.   Good! This Is Their Role 09:53  |  Yishai Kohen 26/01/09
      25.   zionist existentialism 09:58  |  Jim 26/01/09
      26.   Obviuos Deception Gives Jews a Bad Image 09:59  |  Alen 26/01/09
      27.   To all the readers and commentators 10:19  |  Canadian 26/01/09
      28.   To all the readers and commentators 10:19  |  Canadian 26/01/09
      29.   #10 Eliyahu Galli 10:23  |  Jim 26/01/09
      30.   Judaism is behind most religious intolerance today. 10:48  |  Michael 26/01/09
      31.   Beware of Distortion In this Article 10:55  |  Yehoshua 26/01/09
      32.   Well, the IDF surely "paid attention" to the Rabbis advice..... 11:03  |  Swiss (Dino) 26/01/09
      33.   The religion should not have anything... 11:03  |  Anne 26/01/09
      34.   Israel`s Holly Warriors.... 11:34  |  JustMe 26/01/09
      35.   Hamas literature? 12:07  |  Motic 26/01/09
      36.   wake up you Jews 12:10  |  Sydney 26/01/09
      37.   Difficult balance 12:13  |  Joe 26/01/09
      38.   Let`s share this prayer with those rabbis 13:27  |  Clickfool 26/01/09
      39.   Rather call it Israeli Army rabiate publication 14:15  |  John 26/01/09
      40.   Taliban in Israel 14:20  |  Armin 26/01/09
      41.   Neither will God have mercy on the unrepentant unjust 14:20  |  Ivar 26/01/09
      42.   #10 Eliyahu Galli 14:34  |  Jim 26/01/09
      43.   Very disturbing 14:42  |  Michal 26/01/09
      44.   Israel`s `Hamas Charter` 15:28  |  Sylvie 26/01/09
      45.   Teaching hate and murder 16:06  |  American 26/01/09
      46.   Great Objective. What is your point Haaretz? That jews go to war. 16:14  |  robin 26/01/09
      47.   Yiddishkeit - That`s what is missing at Haaretz 16:44  |  Boris 26/01/09
      48.   the IDF better clean up their mess - 17:21  |  ivo 26/01/09
      49.   REMEMBER POPE PIUS, PEOPLE? 17:27  |  indrajaya 26/01/09
      50.   What Israel Should Do With These Rabble Rousers 18:00  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/01/09
      51.   # 48 ivo, don`t fool yourself into believing that those rabbis... 19:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 26/01/09
      52.   King Saul showed mercy on the cruel! 19:12  |  Maria 26/01/09
      53.   #25 Jim hey when you equate Zionism... 19:39  |  BIG SUR 26/01/09
      54.   #2 Maureen Ann 19:42  |  Moshe 26/01/09
      55.   No difference between Al-Qaeda and Israel 20:42  |  Ali 26/01/09
      56.   Religion and war 20:57  |  Alex 26/01/09
      57.   #6 Sam. Most humans have a conscience... 20:59  |  Maureen Ann 26/01/09
      58.   War mongering Rabbi`s 22:17  |  David 26/01/09
      59.   Swiss (Dino) again baseless numbers 22:24  |  David Israel 26/01/09
      60.   Mazeltov: As evidence for war crimes... 22:30  |  Seawife 26/01/09
      61.   This the law written in the Talmood 23:12  |  Johnny from NY 26/01/09
      62.   Rabbi is right 100%: Hamas are cruel, even to thier own 23:28  |  Orkochav 26/01/09
      63.   Jon Stewart 23:28  |  Fromm 26/01/09
      64.   #57i agree 23:28  |  Rab Burns 26/01/09
      65.   Finally, the Country is United 23:43  |  Daniel 26/01/09
      66.   zot torah? 23:50  |  joelemm 26/01/09
      67.   Maureen Ann...Most humans have a conscience? 23:58  |  Maria 26/01/09
      68.   Dino #51: no, this is the twisted image you hold dear, Dino - 23:59  |  ivo 26/01/09
      69.   Religious interference in military doctrine 00:06  |  Physicist 27/01/09
      70.   Ali wrote that no difference between Al-Qaeda and Israel? 00:09  |  Maria 27/01/09
      71.   General MacArthur comments on War crimes of soldiers 00:34  |  n_erber 27/01/09
      72.   JOHNY FROM NY Since when is the "Talmood" the Jewish law?? 00:48  |  PETER SM 27/01/09
      73.   to maureen #2 00:57  |  mazal 27/01/09
      74.   Maureene, you fail to understand Jewish religion, but 01:25  |  AK 27/01/09
      75.   But David fought FOR the Philistines 01:52  |  Roo 27/01/09
      76.   A PRICE"breaking the slence"In Israel this is often criticised 01:59  |  PETER SM 27/01/09
      77.   Canadian: Way off the mark 02:10  |  Jasper 27/01/09
      78.   No mercy 02:15  |  Sean 27/01/09
      79.   IVAR Where are the borders as per UNSCR 242?? 02:43  |  PETER SM 27/01/09
      80.   If it wasn`t for the rabbis, we`d lose 02:57  |  Avital 27/01/09
      81.   Learn to read yourself Jasper, sheesh... 03:15  |  BBSNews 27/01/09
      82.   NO INNOCENT PALESTINIANS 03:24  |  Lowell 27/01/09
      83.   This is why you are hated 03:41  |  Ben 27/01/09
      84.   Sadly, this is just more proof....... 03:43  |  John 27/01/09
      85.   To Maureen Ann (# 57). What would you know about "most humans"? 03:48  |  flyingdoc57 27/01/09
      86.   Corrupting Israeli culture 05:31  |  zeev 27/01/09
      87.   turnabout is fair play 05:56  |  Te`oma 27/01/09
      88.   BEN You really should look at the opinion surveys in the USA 06:00  |  PETER SM 27/01/09
      89.   on Sam #6 and his like 06:13  |  zeev 27/01/09
      90.   # 83 to ben in new york re: stereotypes (2nd try) 08:50  |  eric 27/01/09
      91.   Tom Clancy on the Vietnam War 10:14  |  DJStahl 27/01/09
      92.   "Controversial" indeed ! 11:10  |  Avrohom Bilgrei 27/01/09
      93.   # 68 Dear ivo, April 1999 is not (yet) a decade...:) 22:39  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/01/09
      94.   "Finally, the country united" 21:48  |  Salah-id-Din 28/01/09
      95.   Understanding Extremism 04:40  |  karkov 29/01/09
      96.   Anne, whose Bible? 13:32  |  Zev Davis 29/01/09
      97.   slimy evangelicals 21:28  |  Rick Nelson 12/02/09
      98.   Morally Bankruptcy 19:56  |  Miles Stuart 06/03/09
      99.   No mercy on the cruel 07:34  |  +Khary Sudan 10/03/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    10:06 Police probing MK over fraudulent West Bank outpost deal
    09:29 Netanyahu: Israel is world's 'most threatened country'
    09:45 Comment / Why Netanyahu really does want to advance peace
    10:00 Meet the rabbi who inspires IDF troops' insubordination
    09:34 ANALYSIS / Netanyahu senses Obama's weakness on Jerusalem
    09:38 Intel to employ only non-Jews at Jerusalem plant on Shabbat
    09:41 Who are Israel's ultra-Orthodox Jews?
    22:55 TV ROUND-UP: Israel disregards U.S. objections, Netanyahu criticizes refusniks
    23:37 Peres in Argentina: Ahmadinejad, Chavez will fall
    10:13 City delays evacuation of rightists from East Jerusalem building
    04:33 Panel suggests scrapping bereaved parents' consent for combat service
    04:46 'Egyptians should read in Hebrew, to know what the enemy is plotting'
    07:29 Study: Arabic textbooks are riddled with spelling, grammar errors
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved