Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., January 21, 2009 Tevet 25, 5769 | | Israel Time: 04:00 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Comments:  59
Last update - 21:46 15/01/2009
ANALYSIS / Egypt's Gaza truce plan is mostly bad for Hamas
By Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff , Haaretz Correspondents
Tags: Gaza, Hamas, Israel 

After 19 days of fighting and more than 1,000 Palestinian fatalities, the first significant signs that Hamas is breaking could be seen Wednesday night. Hamas representatives to talks with Egypt announced an agreement in principle on Wednesday to the Egyptian cease-fire proposal. They also demanded several clarifications, primarily from Israel.



The war in Gaza isn't over yet. The final days of the Second Lebanon War show that it's best to be wary of agreements that come too early. But the way things looked on Wednesday, Hamas seems to be willing to accept the Egyptian initiative, which is almost a kind of surrender agreement for it.

The Egyptian proposal is mostly bad for Hamas. It doesn't let the organization bring the Palestinian public any political achievement that would justify the blood that has been spilled, and even forces on it the return of the Palestinian Authority to Gaza, in the form of its renewed presence at the Rafah crossing (as a condition for its reopening).

Once the cease-fire is reached, the IDF will withdraw from the positions it captured in Gaza, and only then will the two sides begin to discuss the opening of border crossings and removal of the blockade, which was the reason Hamas gave for waging war. The most that Cairo is offering is a timetable for the opening of the crossing points, and even that depends on negotiations due to begin after the cease-fire is reached, and it's tough to know how or when they will end.

Hamas representatives did say on Wednesday night they had not yet accepted the Egyptian proposal, but in the same breath they said it was the only proposal on the table. In other words, they have to accept it if they want to maintain their rule in Gaza. It was no coincidence that two representatives of the Hamas leadership in Gaza who traveled to the Cairo talks are the ones who held the official press conference, while the Hamas political leadership was already on their way home to Damascus. When concessions are necessary, Hamas prefers to show the public the face of their true representatives rather than the ones living elsewhere, who are not living in Gaza during the Israeli offensive.

The tremendous destruction Israel caused in Gaza significantly increases the level of hatred directed at Israel, but Gazans are also angry at Hamas leaders for dragging the Strip into an unnecessary and poorly considered war. Hamas is already working on its narrative. There's no doubt that when the war does end, it will claim victory. But the destruction in Gaza, which looks like the victim of a massive earthquake, will tell a different story. Perhaps that is why Hamas wanted to make it clear yesterday that it wants to make certain Gaza will be rebuilt and its residents will be compensated for suffering and property damage.

The Hamas statement came as Israeli defense officials were gradually reaching similar conclusions regarding the need for a quick cease-fire. Defense Ministry and top generals have expressed reservations about expanding the ground incursion in Gaza and support bringing the war to a quick end. Some say Israel has already done all it could with all possible goals of the Gaza operation and has proven that it is no longer deterred by a serious conflict with Hamas or by sending in ground forces and reservists.

Several said it would be best to end the operation now, when Israeli deterrence has improved - and before U.S. President George W. Bush makes way for his successor, Barack Obama, on January 20. And some of the participants in Israeli discussions about the issue have expressed support for a quick withdrawal under a cease-fire declaration, even before an agreement is reached on weapons-smuggling.

The Israel Defense Force's Southern Command is in the minority, interested as it is in deepening the operation - but conditioning this on putting a cap of several months on the time limit for soldiers in the field and Shin Bet security service agents.

Some in the IDF think the army succeeded in reaching its military goal, and that now the rest depends on the diplomats. This morning Defense Ministry official Amos Gilad goes to Cairo, and he is eagerly expected back this evening to report on where things stand. Alongside the degree of optimism, one must remember that having thousands of soldiers in hostile territory is a recipe for continued friction, and maybe some mishaps.

The IDF has always had a problem with maintaining operational discipline over a long period, especially when reserve forces are involved. On Wednesday, with the active assistance of bloggers, false rumors were spread saying that Gilad Shalit had been rescued from captivity. That didn't happen, but if nothing goes wrong with the plans in the next few days, Israel has a decent chance of ending this conflict while maintaining the upper hand.


Related articles:
  • Olmert: Gaza war won't end until rockets and smuggling stop
  • IDF begins deploying reservists into Gaza as part of ground op
  • IDF: Hamas rocket fire down 50% since start of Gaza op
  • Immigration officials: Gaza op hasn`t deterred infiltration of migrants from Egypt
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    A new America
    President Obama: U.S. is a friend of all nations, ready to lead again.
    Ignoring white flags
    Gazans claim some Palestinians were waving white flags when shot by IDF.
      1.   hamas 01:01  |  angelo conzachj 15/01/09
      2.   JUST HAREL DOING HIS BIT TO GAIN A HOLY VICTORY FOR HAMAS 01:05  |  Freethinker 15/01/09
      3.   you loose 01:10  |  Hamza 15/01/09
      4.   Bad for Hamas? How? 01:25  |  Mark Lincoln 15/01/09
      5.   Its just another delusion........... 01:37  |  Diego 15/01/09
      6.   Ceasefire plan is even worse for Israel! 01:46  |  MARK KLEIN, M.D. 15/01/09
      7.   Measuring Israeli "victory" by the amount of damage to civilians 01:48  |  Pablo B 15/01/09
      8.   Victory by "the destruction in Gaza" is no victory at all 01:51  |  Pablo B 15/01/09
      9.   "the destruction in Gaza" as a measure of Victory 01:56  |  Pablo B 15/01/09
      10.   Deluded Harel grasping at an image of victory 01:58  |  Chas. 15/01/09
      11.   If Iran is first to spread cash for reconstruction, Israel loses 02:01  |  Pablo B 15/01/09
      12.   Hamas Victorious ?? 02:02  |  Barney 15/01/09
      13.   No Cease-Fire without Shalit 02:03  |  Expert 15/01/09
      14.   Hamza has learned the rhetoric well 02:05  |  Barney 15/01/09
      15.   Mostly BS 02:07  |  Ron 15/01/09
      16.   I`m posting links everywhere I can to this piece 02:07  |  Pablo B 15/01/09
      17.   ?? Gilad Shalit? 02:13  |  Betty 15/01/09
      18.   The Israel bashers don`t get it 02:15  |  Jordan 15/01/09
      19.   Won`t fight face to face? 02:16  |  Miransky 15/01/09
      20.   Has Haaretz 02:22  |  Barney 15/01/09
      21.   to Hamza 02:24  |  Motale 15/01/09
      22.   Hamza`s family is dead!!! 02:24  |  Jame Capaldi 15/01/09
      23.   Israel is the loser AGAIN, this is GREAT 02:24  |  Gabriela 15/01/09
      24.   If Hamas survives isn`t that a victory? 02:25  |  Tupac 15/01/09
      25.   #1 is right: destroy them all. 02:26  |  Hershl 15/01/09
      26.   Intercultural Lesson 02:26  |  Noach 15/01/09
      27.   Mark, everyone is looking for a "narrative" 02:28  |  ManintheMiddle 15/01/09
      28.   Where is Schalit 02:28  |  Scott L. Havsy 15/01/09
      29.   Israeli Detterance? 02:33  |  Mohan 15/01/09
      30.   You`re right, Hamza! 02:39  |  yehudit 15/01/09
      31.   Advantage Israel 02:40  |  Nosama 15/01/09
      32.   # 16 04:23  |  OBSERVER 15/01/09
      33.   Pablo and Hamza 04:27  |  James Considine 15/01/09
      34.   compensation??? for suffering and damage 04:31  |  real vision 15/01/09
      35.   Pay Now or Pay Later 06:10  |  Bretware 15/01/09
      36.   Hamsa, you forgot to mention 06:16  |  Lynn 15/01/09
      37.   Hamas will not keep the agreement. 06:45  |  GloomBoom.com 15/01/09
      38.   Mark Lincoln, the borders will be open, but... 08:06  |  Tzfonit 15/01/09
      39.   Gilad Shalit 08:58  |  michael cohen 15/01/09
      40.   Hamas Deal 09:07  |  Kasa 15/01/09
      41.   I agree with Harel and Issacaroff 09:13  |  Clickfool 15/01/09
      42.   If the Rafah crossing is opened 10:19  |  Chris Linthwaite 15/01/09
      43.   To: Gabriela 10:21  |  Angel 15/01/09
      44.   To: Clickfool 10:37  |  Angel 15/01/09
      45.   #38 Israel has no intention of opening the border, Tsfonit 10:39  |  Johnboy 15/01/09
      46.   #40 Kasa...then, according to your last sentence 14:51  |  Lynn 15/01/09
      47.   LOL THE WORLS knows how and WHO the COWARDS are 15:22  |  Jon Feigenbaum 15/01/09
      48.   The military goal is reached only as soon those having 15:23  |  Jew- and Bookburner 15/01/09
      49.   IDF 17:03  |  Adam 15/01/09
      50.   Snatching defeat from the jaws of victory 17:41  |  Raad 15/01/09
      51.   Adam....they are on the ground. 17:51  |  Lynn 15/01/09
      52.   45 John Boy I disagree 18:48  |  Big Sur 15/01/09
      53.   No. 43 Angel Wow so right on this 19:00  |  Big Sur 15/01/09
      54.   29 Mohan in Georgia 19:05  |  Big Sur 15/01/09
      55.   The hatred is always the same! 19:34  |  Paul 15/01/09
      56.   Johnboy and Mark Lincoln 19:51  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 15/01/09
      57.   #56 Margie we have borders as well 20:13  |  Lynn 15/01/09
      58.   Peace B4 Hamas pulls white flag=Israel`s DEFEAT 22:36  |  Joubin Rabbani 15/01/09
      59.   Everybody loses except Tehran 03:28  |  JP 16/01/09
     Read & React
    Bradley Burston: Mr. Obama, grant Hamas the freedom to fail
    Responses: 58
    David Grossman: Gaza success proves Israel is strong, not right
    Responses: 338
    A. Eldar: As Obama is sworn in, Israelis and Palestinians will be thinking 'no we can't'
    Responses: 66
    Report: Hamas leader says he never expected scale of IDF op in Gaza
    Responses: 84
    Editorial: Bush will be remembered as a friend of Israel, despite his mistakes
    Responses: 63


    More Headlines
    23:24 President Obama: U.S. is a friend of all nations, ready to lead once more
    23:52 Olmert: U.S.-Israeli relations will grow even stronger under Obama
    21:51 Anti-apartheid hero Mandela calls Obama 'new voice of hope'
    23:45 Americans cheer on Obama in inauguration parties in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv
    23:25 IAF bombs Gaza target after 8 mortar shells fired at Israel
    18:34 UN Chief: Hamas rocket attacks are 'appalling and unacceptable'
    23:24 France may talk to Hamas even if group doesn't recognize Israel
    12:19 Lieberman to Tibi: We must treat some Arab MKs like we treated Hamas
    23:25 IAEA to probe Arab claim Israel used uranium ammo on Gaza
    14:56 WATCH / Inside Israel medical center for Gaza residents
    02:00 Obama considering George Mitchell as Mideast envoy
    02:06 Israeli Lebanon war film 'Waltz with Bashir' shown in Beirut
    00:32 Voldemort's sidekick turns Jewish psychiatrist in film on Nazi era
    21:00 Gaza reporter caught on tape confirming Hamas fired rockets near TV offices
    15:22 Israel pinning hopes for Hamas deal in Gaza on Egypt intel chief
    14:09 Report: Hamas leader says he never expected scale of IDF op in Gaza
    12:44 Olmert: Hamas responsible for damage IDF op caused in Gaza
    13:44 Livni: We need progress on Shalit before we address Hamas demands
    17:41 Aid agencies supply essentials to Palestinians following Gaza conflict
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Summer in Israel
    Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
    Blue And White Forever Israel Army T-shirts
    Wear with Proud Donate the Soldiers Kit
    You can make a direct IMPACT!
    on the life of an Israeli soldier
    State of Israel Bonds
    During this time of market volatility, Israel bonds can help.
    SURF RAMBAM
    Keep current about new-wave medical care, education and research.
    Summer Camp in Israel
    The best place for your children this summer
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved