Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., January 24, 2009 Tevet 28, 5769 | | Israel Time: 03:17 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 23:40 02/01/2009
Like in Lebanon, in Gaza Israel blinked first
By Israel Harel
Tags: israel news, hamas, gaza 


Many people have been receiving over the Internet a link where Yitzhak Rabin is heard sarcastically attacking those who "fear peace" and who threaten that letting Yasser Arafat's forces into Gaza would lead to Katyushas on Ashkelon. About six months ago, when Hamas was on the ropes and begging for a cease-fire, many people warned that if Israel responded and picked Hamas up off the ropes, the rockets it would fire after it recovered would reach Ashdod and Be'er Sheva.


Advertisement
But Defense Minister Ehud Barak, in a very strange decision, decided to allow Hamas to regroup, increase its capabilities, manufacture and smuggle in more advanced arms, and upgrade from a gang of terrorists to a Hezbollah-like military organization. Now the people of the Negev - and especially the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip - are paying the price of the defense minister's weakness and failed leadership, and the whole government bears collective responsibility.

The declared goal of Operation Cast Lead ("the creation of a new security reality") is minimalist and reveals Israel's unwillingness to fight for a long-term resolution that will create a comprehensive new reality, not only a new security reality.

What is worse, the way the battle is being waged after the impressive air strikes raises concerns that the operation's leaders do not intend to achieve even its modest aims, among other reasons because Israel once again blinked first.

The blinking did not begin on Tuesday with Barak's announcement that Israel was considering a "humanitarian" 48-hour cease-fire. It began when the first air strikes were not immediately accompanied by a ground operation. Israel showed, as in Lebanon, that it does not want to reach a strategic resolution and does not have the will, determination or self-confidence to lead a military operation beyond reprisal and punitive action.

This is a major and painful operation, but despite its ambitious intentions it is not a military action that will end the eight-year nightmare of the people of the Negev.

The more days go by with the main component aerial bombardment, which, like in Lebanon, cannot stop the rockets, the public begins to feel (our leaders' arguments show this) that the operation is losing momentum. A sense is growing that something has been missed, especially in the Negev communities.

The national mood, which rallied last Saturday, is beginning to sag, and disappointment is beginning to seep in. The pubic does not want to make do with a situation in which a sovereign country with significant military capabilities - certainly vis-a-vis Hamas - once again signals that it is willing to stop a battle at its height, before a real response to the problem that led the Israel Defense Forces into the fight in the first place.

Had it not been for the 80 rockets fired at the Negev a week ago Wednesday - which aroused public anger that the government and defense minister cannot ignore, especially before elections - it is doubtful the operation would have begun. That's the way it was after the suicide bomber at the Passover seder in Netanya in 2002. After that major attack and more than 130 casualties in the suicide bombings of the previous month, prime minister Ariel Sharon could no longer claim that "restraint is strength." However, then, when Operation Defensive Shield was finally launched, the goal was to root out terror.

Then, too, a loud media campaign opposed entering cities; then, too, military reporters and commentators, among them retired generals, frightened us that there would be masses of casualties; then, too, they said terror could not be beaten by military means. But the result even after eight years speaks for itself.

At the end of the operation Israel withdrew from big cities like Nablus, Ramallah and Jenin. But the destruction of terror infrastructure and the psychological shock the terror groups experienced made it possible for the IDF to sharply reduce its number of attacks to this day. This is mainly because the army can, if need be, enter the cities almost unhindered to stop anyone planning a suicide attack or making rockets intended for the Tel Aviv region's population centers.

If there will still be a ground operation in Gaza, it must not be hesitant like in Lebanon. It must be conducted as Defensive Shield was, minus the command misstep in Jenin. And if the political and military leadership does not have the courage to risk soldiers to decide the campaign and attain its goals, then it is better not to risk them.

If the concealed goal is not resolution but another cease-fire, then it is a pity to use ground forces because the enemy will revive once again and smuggle in rockets, which this time will be able to hit Dimona, and perhaps even Tel Aviv. And once again the air force will be sent in. And again, after every red line is crossed, there will be an amazing air strike. And what then? And until when?

Related articles:
  • IDF recommends major, but brief Gaza ground incursion
  • IAF bombs Gaza mosque being used as weapons storehouse
  • Haniyeh: Palestinian victory in Gaza is near
  • 4 rockets hit south as 'special situation' status extended to 40 kilometers from Gaza border
  • Disinformation, secrecy and lies: How the Gaza offensive came about
  • Amira Hass / 'Gaza strike is not against Hamas, it's against all Palestinians'
  • GIDEON LEVY / The IAF, bullies of the clear blue skies
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Geert accused
    Dutch MP behind film on radical Islam says move to prosecute him is political.
    Immunity for soldiers
    Israel to approve aid for IDF officers accused of Gaza war crimes.
      1.   Air raids first, then ground invasion 06:25  |  Peter Williams 01/01/09
      2.   Forget a Ground Op 10:41  |  Awake 01/01/09
      3.   Great article 10:45  |  Terry 01/01/09
      4.   impressive air strikes...!!!!! 11:07  |  ravi 01/01/09
      5.   it took same 8 years to act and only because of the public 14:12  |  nuchem 01/01/09
      6.   There will be no ground operation 14:16  |  Vladimir 01/01/09
      7.   15 seconds 14:40  |  AA 01/01/09
      8.   Israel blinked first 14:45  |  Dr David Schiby 01/01/09
      9.   Moral support 14:50  |  Joseph 01/01/09
      10.   Reoccupy Rafa area only 15:11  |  andrew 01/01/09
      11.   And what then? And until when? 15:18  |  AB 01/01/09
      12.   Stop avoiding the comprehensive reality yourself 15:29  |  Dutch 01/01/09
      13.   Its The Leadership no doubt, Sderot should lead the army 15:41  |  Simon 01/01/09
      14.   Delusional man 15:47  |  Mark Lincoln 01/01/09
      15.   # 4 ravi....Mumbai was just as ugly 16:04  |  Lynn 01/01/09
      16.   Good analysis, but 16:06  |  ANUAR AL SADAT 01/01/09
      17.   # 9 joseph....I read Asharq Alawsat, Tariq Alhomayyed 16:09  |  Lynn 01/01/09
      18.   Truth 16:11  |  daat y 01/01/09
      19.   Bring back Moshe Bogie Ya`alon! 16:12  |  ARA 01/01/09
      20.   Bring back Likudnik Moshe Bogie Ya`alon! 16:17  |  ARA 01/01/09
      21.   Like in Lebanon 16:34  |  Ole A. Brønmo 01/01/09
      22.   The comphehensive reality the Israeli public ought to get clear 16:35  |  Dutch 01/01/09
      23.   it is obvious 17:09  |  ali 01/01/09
      24.   Andrew (#10) 17:10  |  Benjamin 01/01/09
      25.   Operation in Gaza 17:26  |  Pini 01/01/09
      26.   is IDF bunch of COWARDOS??? 17:32  |  r.d. cohen 01/01/09
      27.   Barak+Ulmert+Livni=Peretz+Ulmert+Livni 17:47  |  Yaakov Hillel 01/01/09
      28.   ground offensive would be foolish 18:23  |  ankhfnkhonsu 01/01/09
      29.   gaza must become israel sovereign territory 19:16  |  chalom 01/01/09
      30.   No ground forces required because..... 19:18  |  Avrum 01/01/09
      31.   Leadership Reflects the People 19:34  |  Rick Abrams 01/01/09
      32.   15... lyn... ignorance,,, 19:59  |  ravi 01/01/09
      33.   Israeli government has lost its nerve 20:03  |  Scott L. Havsy 01/01/09
      34.   Israeli government has lost its nerve 20:03  |  Scott L. Havsy 01/01/09
      35.   humanity anyone? 20:08  |  I am Lebanese 01/01/09
      36.   To #1 air raids,etc. 20:17  |  Jerri i 01/01/09
      37.   Dutch....to save the Pals, Hamas has to stop 20:19  |  Lynn 01/01/09
      38.   #32 ravi... About that "we in India" 21:52  |  Lynn 01/01/09
      39.   Is it beacuse his name is Israel that he is only one who knows? 22:05  |  r 01/01/09
      40.   #15 Palestine & Kashmir 23:53  |  An Indian 01/01/09
      41.   More hogwash 00:15  |  Free Gilad Shalit 02/01/09
      42.   26 R Cohen, you are failing to look atthe root cause & fault line 02:43  |  Dutch 02/01/09
      43.   Go for it 02:47  |  Blinko 02/01/09
      44.   no faith 03:01  |  ali 02/01/09
      45.   why not Egypt 03:17  |  Davidcor 02/01/09
      46.   Responce to #10 04:03  |  wetstt 02/01/09
      47.   Israel Harel is blinking instead of watching reality. 04:29  |  Fortuna Benmayor 02/01/09
      48.   Gotta` love the Harel-speak. 04:34  |  Johnboy 02/01/09
      49.   An Indian #40 04:58  |  Persian Kitty 02/01/09
      50.   Ditto #3 05:29  |  David R. Zukerman 02/01/09
      51.   Israel is Right! 05:52  |  Baruch Gold 02/01/09
      52.   Lebanese #35, tell it to your cousins in Gaza 10:47  |  Terry 02/01/09
      53.   Clever analysis and comments, but not wise 19:29  |  Ziad from Lebanon 03/01/09
      54.   gaza 07:41  |  ram 04/01/09
      55.   G-d Bless Sharon, Israel needs stronger Leaders. 03:08  |  JR 24/01/09
     Read & React
    UN rights official: Gaza evokes memories of Warsaw Ghetto
    Responses: 174
    Obama: We will aggressively seek lasting Mideast peace
    Responses: 141
    Dutch MP behind film on radical Islam: Decision to prosecute me is political
    Responses: 65
    Israel to approve aid for IDF officers accused of Gaza war crimes
    Responses: 52
    Shashi Tharoor: India watched in envy as Israel attacked Gaza
    Responses: 37


    More Headlines
    22:36 Paratrooper commander: IDF reached its goals in Gaza operation
    21:52 Israel to approve aid for IDF officers accused of Gaza war crimes
    02:07 Saudi envoy to U.S.: Obama mustn't repeat Bush's 'sickening legacy' in Mideast
    20:19 Doctors: Many Palestinians in Gaza hospitals in danger of dying from their wounds
    15:00 Israel's multi-faceted Gaza cease-fire
    18:20 Israel to allow Egypt to boost force on Gaza border to fight smuggling
    16:31 UN: Israel cooperating in efforts to improve Gaza humanitarian situation
    17:29 UNRWA chief: Israeli offensive in Gaza boosted extremists
    11:49 Dutch MP behind film on radical Islam: Decision to prosecute me is political
    18:01 IDF soldier suspected of seriously wounding Palestinian at West Bank checkpoint
    19:55 U.S. Jews blast plan for anti-Israel UN official to attend Holocaust prayer service
    19:01 Study: 20 years of conflict has cost Middle East $12 trillion
    19:57 Dutch minister: Arabs need to learn more about Holocaust, Jews need to study Palestinian 'Nakba'
    00:11 Hamas: Obama does not represent change
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Summer in Israel
    Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
    Blue And White Forever Israel Army T-shirts
    Wear with Proud Donate the Soldiers Kit
    You can make a direct IMPACT!
    on the life of an Israeli soldier
    State of Israel Bonds
    During this time of market volatility, Israel bonds can help.
    SURF RAMBAM
    Keep current about new-wave medical care, education and research.
    Summer Camp in Israel
    The best place for your children this summer
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved