Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., December 22, 2008 Kislev 25, 5769 | | Israel Time: 18:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate GA 2008 Travel Week's End Anglo File
Israel bites back at UN watchdog over alleged strike on Syria reactor
By Yossi Melman
Tags: Israel News, Syria 

Israel is assisting the International Atomic Energy Agency in its efforts to determine what Syria planned to manufacture in the nuclear reactor it was building that was destroyed in an Israeli Air Force strike in September 2007.

An Israeli source said that although the state neither confirmed nor denied that it carried out the attack on the reactor, "We are finding our own ways to relay the information that needs to be relayed."

Israel apparently "laundered" the intelligence at its disposal about the Syrian reactor via the United States. In April the Central Intelligence Agency released a multimedia presentation featuring satellite images as well as photographs taken inside the reactor The agency declared that the bombed site was a nuclear reactor in the final stages of construction.
Advertisement
This is the background to the serious accusations traded between the Israel Atomic Energy Commission and the International Atomic Energy Agency. Recently Israel's representative to the IAEA, Israel Michaeli, sent a sharply worded letter of protest to Director General Mohammed ElBaradei.

The crisis began in May, when the IAEA began claiming that Israel was not providing satellite images of the reactor that was hit, hurting the investigation. The agency's spokeswoman, Melissa Fleming, later sent a letter to The Wall Street Journal reiterating claims made by ElBaradei.

On a number of occasions the agency head argued that by bombing the reactor instead of first reporting its suspicions to the IAEA Israel harmed the organization's ability to thoroughly investigate what was in the reactor.

The letter to the Wall Street Journal stated that "information was withheld from the IAEA for more than six months" - the satellite images and perhaps also important intelligence information - "by which time Syria had cleaned away the rubble and built a new facility." On the same occasion Fleming strayed from the ostensible topic, the Syrian reactor, to charge that Israel, together with Iraq, Iran and North Korea, was "in violation of [IAEA] rules and [to have] restricted [its] IAEA technical cooperation projects." This was a reference to Israel's refusal to permit the agency's inspectors to visit the Dimona nuclear reactor.

Israel's Atomic Energy Commission, which is one of the most secretive and silent organizations in the country, generally prefers to stay out of the headlines. But this time it decided not to hold back. It is still unclear whether this was a one-time response to a specific situation or a change in approach related to the change in leadership. A year ago Dr. Shaul Horev replaced Gideon Frank as the commission's director general after 12 years.

In any event, a decision was made early this month, with the approval of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, to launch a frontal assault against the IAEA. In addition to the letter of protest to the agency, commission spokeswoman Nili Lifshitz sent her own letter to the Wall Street Journal.

"The claim that Israel is withholding critical information on the site is nothing but a smoke screen," Lifshitz wrote, adding, "Nothing should stand in the way of the agency's search for evidence" regarding the purpose of the destroyed Syrian installation. Lifshitz argued that the IAEA should obtain commercial satellite images to back up its findings if it needs them. She noted a recent IAEA report on Syria that stated that the agency is examining uranium particles found at the Syrian site where some features are similar to what may be found in connection with a reactor site, and has asked Syria to allow visits to locations containing the debris and any equipment removed from the site for the purpose of taking samples.

"Each time the agency comes under political criticism for handling of a Middle Eastern country's flagrant breaches of its obligations under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty or its safeguards agreement, the agency immediately resorts to publicly invoking Israel's name," Lifshitz wrote. According to the Israeli source: "We are fed up with the IAEA's attacks on us. This time they went too far."

Non-scientist gets a top spot

For the first time in the history of the Israel Institute for Biological Research in Nes Tziona, the position of deputy director has been filled by a candidate with no background in science through what employees have called a "fixed tender."

The institute recently issued an internal tender for the position of deputy and acting director. The head of human resources, Natan Rosenbaum, was the sole applicant for the position and was awarded the tender.

Rosenbaum retired from the Israel Defense Forces 12 years ago at the rank of colonel after serving as head of the draft administration, among other positions. Rosenbaum, who is considered to be close to the institute's director, Dr. Avigdor Shafferman, was brought in to head the institution's department of human resources.

The institute conducts medical, environmental and military research and development for Israel's military establishment and for foreign clients, including the U.S. Army. Most of the institute's work is classified but according to foreign publications it develops chemical and biological weapons and means for defending against such weapons. It is under the administrative purview of the Prime Minister's Office, but in effect it answers to the Defense Ministry. Most of its 300 employees have a background in the natural sciences.

The institute's deputy director, Dr. Amram Golumbeck, recently announced his intention to take a three-year sabbatical after which he would be leaving his post. Shafferman decided to appoint Rosenbaum to replace him, despite his lack of background or experience in the sciences.

The internal tenders committee convened to draft the conditions for the tender decided that that one of them would be "eight years' experience in human resources administration." Many institute employees, including some who spoke with Haaretz, said they thought it was tailored specifically for Rosenbaum, but none of them dared oppose Shafferman, who is said to rule the institute with an iron hand.

The Defense Ministry said in a response that any questions should be directed to Shafferman. The ministry said it does not have the authority to force the institute's director to respond to questions on administrative matters, although in the past the Defense Ministry has responded to queries in the institute's stead.

Related articles:
  • Report: IAEA chief says efforts to curb Iran nuke program 'a failure'
  • European powers: Iran showing 'utter disrespect' for UN nuclear watchdog
  • Experts argue: How close is Iran to its first nuclear weapon?
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Madoff not welcome
    Members of exclusive N.Y. synagogue lose collective $2 billion in Madoff scam.
    Under threat
    Shin Bet chief says Hamas rockets can hit outskirts of Be'er Sheva.
      1.   The fox guarding the chicken coop 05:54  |  Shmuelshachor 18/12/08
      2.   Jordan the next Iran? 07:00  |  Capt Ahab 18/12/08
      3.   Israel has no right to ask anything of the 08:04  |  Che Vive 18/12/08
      4.   Syria should be ashamed 09:11  |  Palestinian 18/12/08
      5.   IAEA Is Crazy -- Post Strike Photos Were Published Worldwide 13:48  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 18/12/08
      6.   #4 Gullible `Palestinian` 13:52  |  Boycott 18/12/08
      7.   It will take a miracle to reform UN agencies 13:55  |  Simon 18/12/08
      8.   Israel does the dirty-work for the IAEA.... 13:59  |  Esther 18/12/08
      9.   It`s an ALLEGED reactor 15:30  |  Clickfool 18/12/08
      10.   To: Clickfool 16:25  |  Angel 18/12/08
      11.   Why look at Syria and Iran? Look at Dimona 17:17  |  Lou Medel 18/12/08
      12.   To: Lou Medel 18:02  |  Angel 18/12/08
      13.   Ovadiah ben Avraham is crazy - they were not 18:22  |  Mark Lincoln 18/12/08
      14.   #12 Angel. I didn`t miss the point. 18:37  |  Lou Medel 18/12/08
      15.   To: Mark Lincoln 18:46  |  Angel 18/12/08
      16.   Click #9... deliberate disinformation... 19:05  |  Esther 18/12/08
      17.   Syrian site penetration or doubts 19:10  |  allang 18/12/08
      18.   Lincoln, not supporting his allegations again 19:28  |  SDHD 18/12/08
      19.   #13 Lincoln: UNSCOM & UNMOVIC VX & Anthrax Were the WMDs 19:39  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 18/12/08
      20.   Addendum to "disinformation"... 19:40  |  Esther 18/12/08
      21.   For "Angel" # 10 19:52  |  Clickfool 18/12/08
      22.   For Esther # 16 19:54  |  Clickfool 18/12/08
      23.   To: Clickfool 20:18  |  Angel 18/12/08
      24.   Clickfool and blatant lies 20:46  |  SDHD 18/12/08
      25.   For Angel, again # 23 21:10  |  Clickfool 18/12/08
      26.   Angel - you jest 22:17  |  Mark Lincoln 18/12/08
      27.   Thick as a brick - Angel 22:23  |  Mark Lincoln 18/12/08
      28.   square building 22:27  |  Baz Mann 18/12/08
      29.   It`s [SECRET] 22:57  |  Mark Lincoln 18/12/08
      30.   "Snarling "at the IAEA...!! 23:25  |  Stephen. 18/12/08
      31.   Lincoln`s mouth opens, spews nonsense and no evidence 23:42  |  SDHD 18/12/08
      32.   Click #21 23:49  |  Esther 18/12/08
      33.   Angle your posts are a hoot, thanks for the good laugh. 00:04  |  EstEuroSpaniard 19/12/08
      34.   Angle your posts are a hoot, thanks for the good laugh. Cont. 00:06  |  EstEuroSpaniard 19/12/08
      35.   UN and IAEA distrust able Israel will do the job before the hatch 00:09  |  e.m.Jordan is Palest 19/12/08
      36.   Oh dear, so the IAEA isn`t swallowing the intel? 00:41  |  Johnboy 19/12/08
      37.   #23, ANGEL, and her "reliable" sources 00:48  |  VIPER 19/12/08
      38.   Why Baz Mann? The report makes no sense 02:01  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      39.   If you read carefully Clickfool 02:20  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      40.   Viper you are recieving garbled com. 02:22  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      41.   The IAEA has essentiall rejected the reactor theory 02:26  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      42.   Stepping through the article 02:35  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      43.   Somehow there are those who can`t get it 02:48  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      44.   Angel your posts are a hoot Cont. 03:09  |  EstEuroSpaniard 19/12/08
      45.   Next time Dimona will be destroyed 03:41  |  USA 19/12/08
      46.   How to approach the problem? 04:56  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      47.   #39, MARK LINCOLN, it`s a sarcastic reply 04:56  |  VIPER 19/12/08
      48.   Surreal 05:19  |  Colin Wright 19/12/08
      49.   So where does General Platt lead us? 05:20  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      50.   For those who wish to know 05:28  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      51.   Viper - of course it was sarcastic 05:35  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/08
      52.   Johnboy`s "load of crap" 05:35  |  SDHD 19/12/08
      53.   Lincoln, the IAEA has NOT essentially rejected the reactor theory 05:38  |  SDHD 19/12/08
      54.   #51, MARK LINCOLN, you do know 03:54  |  VIPER 20/12/08
      55.   so many lies on one thread 11:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 20/12/08
      56.   #25, the fool and his great friend 11:26  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 20/12/08
      57.   #30, Stephen, absolutely correct 11:29  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 20/12/08
     Read & React
    Bradley Burston: Can the First Gaza War be stopped before it starts?
    Responses: 105
    Strikes on Negev drop as Hamas holds 24-hour truce
    Responses: 105
    Damascus: Talks with Israel only after U.S., Israeli elections
    Responses: 27
    B'Tselem: 58% of Ofra settlement built on Palestinian land
    Responses: 52


    More Headlines
    18:06 Strikes on Negev drop as Hamas holds 24-hour truce
    17:31 ANALYSIS / Israel must choose between bad and worse Gaza options
    18:00 Assad: Direct peace talks with Israel possible and will happen
    16:11 Can the First Gaza War be stopped before it starts?
    18:05 Russia: Reports on deliveries of advanced anti-aircraft systems to Iran are untrue
    17:40 Livni, on her home life: We're a completely normal family
    15:23 Man eats 46 latkes in 8 minutes to win N.Y. Hanukkah contest
    20:29 Want to help improve the Haaretz.com homepage?
    14:39 World Bank: New crossings for Palestinian goods may hurt exports
    01:46 PM opts for hearing in bid to stave off indictment on Rishon Tours case
    07:43 2008 marks record-breaking year for returning Israeli citizens
    15:36 B'Tselem: 58% of Ofra settlement built on Palestinian land
    05:29 Sderot may be a cautious city, but it's no 'ghost town'
    12:26 Falafel with bratkartoffeln / My love affair with Tel Aviv
    12:28 Be'er Sheva mayor: We are installing Qassam warning system
    20:27 Members of exclusive N.Y. synagogue lose collective $2 billion in Madoff scam
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Summer in Israel
    Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
    SURF RAMBAM
    Keep current about new-wave medical care, education and research.
    Summer Camp in Israel
    The best place for your children this summer
    Academic Studies in Israel
    All the Q & A at the IDC HERZLIYA Open House, January 9,2009
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Car rental in Israel
    Shlomo Sixt Receive $15.00 from our low rates.
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved