Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 04, 2008 Kislev 7, 5769 | | Israel Time: 10:33 (EST+7)   Back to Homepage web haaretz.com Haaretz Toolbar Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Car Rental Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate GA 2008 Travel Week's End Anglo File

Dayan as tragedy, Bibi as farce By Gershom Gorenberg Tags: Israel News  When Benjamin Netanyahu speaks about "economic peace," his new, brilliant diplomatic platform, which will postpone any diplomatic moves far into the unforeseeable future, I see his face shrink, his chin sharpen, a patch cover his eye. Moshe Dayan is speaking, just as he spoke in a cabinet meeting 40 years ago, in early December 1968. The Eshkol government met then to discuss Dayan's proposal for a policy on the occupied territories. Dayan's plan had three pillars: large-scale settlement on the West Bank mountain ridge, permanent Israeli rule of the territories without Israeli citizenship for the Arab residents, and economic integration of the territories with Israel. Arabs would work in Israel, Hebron would get its electricity from the Israeli grid, and Israel would raise the standard of living of the residents of the territories. As a result, Dayan argued, they would become dependent on Israel, maybe even grateful to it. The official cabinet minutes are still classified, but a partial record from a reliable source exists. Dayan's words reveal his worldview with shocking clarity. "We want to keep this population calm. Let them work, let them study," he said - and then added that when he visited the one-time German colony of Togo in Africa, "I was impressed by the memories they still have of German rule before World War I. [The Germans] left orchards and culture." Advertisement Straightforwardly, Dayan sought to establish a colonial regime, supposedly benevolent. Israel would rule; the natives would work, study and be happy with their lot. For Dayan, the independence of his own people was a necessity of life, like food or air. But his proposal treated the Palestinians practically as different species: They would be satisfied with economic improvements and wouldn't seek political expression as individuals or a collective. In that debate and in others, the cabinet rejected Dayan's proposals. His dedicated opponent, finance minister Pinchas Sapir, warned during a later discussion in the Labor Party that the arrangement proposed by Dayan would put Israel in a class with "countries whose names I don't even want to say in the same breath." Yet Dayan and others who came after him managed to carry out his intent to a large degree. The Palestinians became laborers in Israel. Their material standard of living rose. Settlements were established on the mountain ridge, breaking the territorial contiguity of the Arab population, as Dayan wanted. And like the fatal conceit that Egypt would never attack Israel, the conceit that the Palestinians would remain calm eventually collapsed. The difference between the two was that Dayan was no longer among the living when the first intifada erupted, proving that an increase in jobs and a decrease in infant mortality do not erase the affront of living without rights, ruled by another nation. Though the occupation continued, Israel was forced to recognize the Palestinians as a nation and enter a diplomatic process with them. This isn't the place to analyze the impasse that this process has reached. Each side deserves a piece of the blame. Meanwhile, Israel has dug in deeper in the territories. Settlements have blossomed, and with them bypass roads, the security fence and the roadblocks - out there, in places that long ago became far away from the lives of most Israelis. Now comes Netanyahu, gleefully proclaiming that there's no chance of a political agreement with the Palestinians any time soon, just as Dayan declared with satisfaction in the fall of 1968 that "no peace with the king of Jordan is in sight." So, Netanyahu says, he'll seek "economic peace." The free market will flourish in the territories and the Palestinians will be able "to put food on their table." Netanyahu is careful not to say that we will stay forever in the territories. Economic peace, he says, will be "a corridor leading to the possibility of political peace" sometime in the future. That is, when the Palestinians enjoy the fruits of the free market, when they buy more flat-screen TVs and shares on the stock market, they'll moderate their political demands so much that they'll be able to accept what Netanyahu offers. Netanyahu doesn't say a word about what he'll offer. We may safely assume that while he pursues economic peace, the settlements will expand, houses will replace mobile homes in the outposts, and the probability of withdrawal will approach zero. Netanyahu is really offering the Palestinians a free-market economy within shrinking enclaves dependent on Israel's good will. Netanyahu's platform is a con game twice over. Palestinians will not abandon their demand for independence because of economic growth. And given the absolute lack of free movement in the territories, even a colonial economy can't grow there. The question is what will happen first: a new violent confrontation, or an international economic boycott of the sort that already defeated one of the countries that Pinchas Sapir didn't want to mention in the same breath as Israel. Still, there's a difference between Dayan and Netanyahu: Dayan didn't learn from the experience of other nations. Netanyahu wants to recycle the failure of his own nation. Perhaps that's the difference between tragedy and farce. Gershom Gorenberg is the author of "The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967-1977." He blogs at southjerusalem.com. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Light unto the nations Obama must help Israel break its territorial addiction. Blockade busters Israeli Arab leaders vow to sail to Gaza to break blockade.   1.   Retrospective 09:38  |  David Hoffman 03/12/08   2.   Three lousy leaders 09:41  |  zeev 03/12/08   3.   to David Hoffman #1 11:27  |  zeev 03/12/08   4.   Selective history 13:45  |  Zvi 03/12/08   5.   Gorenberg: Hallucinations, Not Politics 14:09  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 03/12/08   6.   Gerson Gorenberg as farce 14:10  |  AR 03/12/08   7.   Gershon Gornenberg, do your homework 14:48  |  ARA 03/12/08   8.   To Zeev 15:17  |  Ralph Levy 03/12/08   9.   Who are the negotiators 16:12  |  M Rosenzweig 03/12/08   10.   Bibi as farce 16:33  |  Dr. Abraham Z. Simho 03/12/08   11.   Deceptive proposals 16:43  |  arik 03/12/08   12.   Who Are The Negotiators 16:46  |  Dr. Abraham Z. Simho 03/12/08   13.   #10: Saudi Peace Plan. Public Beheading. Film at Eleven. 17:39  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 03/12/08   14.   to Ralph Levy #8 17:43  |  zeev 03/12/08   15.   Pipe dreams 17:59  |  Colin 03/12/08   16.   to AR #6 19:15  |  zeev 03/12/08   17.   #14 Zeev 20:58  |  Ralph Levy 03/12/08   18.   to Ralph Levy #17 22:38  |  zeev 03/12/08   19.   Dayan knew..."maintaining the status quo in the territories .... 23:38  |  Smadar 03/12/08   20.   to Smadar #19 01:27  |  zeev 04/12/08   21.   Bibi the republican Obama in Israel 02:35  |  Honi 04/12/08   22.   Bibi as farce 10:31  |  Dennis 04/12/08

Read & React Israeli Arab leaders vow to sail to Gaza to break blockade Responses: 68 Defense Ministry: Hebron house eviction may spark rampant settler violence Responses: 20 Editorial: Jewish terrorists are holding hostage Israel's future Responses: 8 Ari Shavit: Beware of Pakistan Responses: 1 Shlomo Avineri: The State of Israel as the kingdom of evil Responses: 1 More Headlines 10:06 Internal report: IDF must take strong stance on settler violence 09:43 Barak and settler leaders meet in bid for deal on Hebron house evacuation 03:32 ANALYSIS / Settlers can't stop evacuation of Hebron house 07:36 NATO: Diplomacy, not defense, will determine deployment of peacekeepers in Mideast 07:43 Footage released of Palestinian militant reenacting murder of Israeli lawmaker 07:50 At synagogue overlooking Obama's house, blacks and Jews live side by side 06:08 New initiative threatens male domination over Bedouin sheep farming 10:23 Israel opens Gaza border to foreign journalists, aid workers 10:11 Is Bar Refaeli the new James Bond girl? 07:46 Libya accuses Israel of piracy for blocking Gaza aid ship 06:55 Report: Israeli mineral water company closes site due to Scottish boycott 06:43 Parents of Mumbai attack victim decide to raise their orphaned grandson 03:20 Blair urges Obama to press hard for progress in Mideast talks 06:15 Shin Bet blocks Sun D'Or charter flights to Africa due to terror alerts 03:56 Forget about renewable energy in Israel, Infrastructure Ministry says 06:45 Likud to target Livni with negative ads 02:31 Report: Argentina to halt trade with Iran over Jewish center bombings Previous Editions Select Day 03 dec 02 dec 01 dec 30 nov 28 nov 27 nov 26 nov 25 nov 24 nov 23 nov 21 nov 20 nov

Special Offers Advertisement Israeli Style Summer in Israel Living in Israel Studying in English Click & Meet our students from all around the world Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. Car rental in Israel Shlomo Sixt Receive $15.00 from our low rates. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Jewish Singles Personal Ads Find the love of your life on JDate.com Israel's Premier Real Estate Website www. israel-property.com Hebrew Summer courses From $39.95 Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel

birthright Israel | Search engine marketing

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved