Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., December 20, 2008 Kislev 23, 5769 | | Israel Time: 04:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate GA 2008 Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 13:58 28/11/2008
For the sake of peace, Israel and Palestinians should apologize to each other
By Judea Pearl
Tags: Israel News, Daniel Pearl 



It now seems clear that no peace agreement, not even on principles, will be signed by the Israeli-Palestinian negotiating team before some time in 2009.

The two sides are locked in a fundamentally immobile stalemate.
Advertisement
Israel cannot accommodate a sovereign neighbor rocket-range away from its vital airports while militant elements can and vow to use the shelter of sovereignty to accomplish their aims. And Palestinian society, having taught its youngsters for decades that Israel's existence is temporary, is unable to restrain its militants from pursuing their aims, especially under conditions of occupation, when Iran promises to render those teachings a reality.

Yet if movement on the ground is infeasible, movement above it - in the metaphysical sphere of words, metaphors and paradigms - may hold the key to making peace agreements feasible.

The current stalemate hangs on two ideological contentions, Israelis demand for "legitimacy" and Palestinians' demand for "justice."

The legitimacy demanded by Israelis is primarily a litmus test for gauging Arabs' intention to treat peace agreements as permanent. Thus, if the Palestinian Authority agrees to recognize Israel's "historical right to exist," instead of just "right to exist," and if this recognition percolates down to textbook level, Israel's demand for a proof of intention will be largely satisfied.

However, Palestinians have a profound impediment to recognizing Israel's "right to exist," be it historical or de facto, fearing that it would depict their century-old struggle against the Zionist program as a misguided, unjust aggression, thus weakening their own demand for "justice," as embodied in the claimed "right of return."

A possible remedy: A dramatic symbolic action that satisfies the Palestinians' claim to justice, while neutralizing, or substituting for the literal right of return.

Palestinian columnist Daoud Kuttab wrote in the Washington Post, (May 12, 2008): "The basic demand is not the physical return of all refugees but for Israel to take responsibility for causing this decades-long tragedy"

Israeli peace activist Uri Avnery believes that this demand can be satisfied through an open and frank Israeli apology. "... peace between us and the Palestinian people -a real peace, based on real conciliation - starts with an apology" he wrote in Arabic Media Internet Network (June 14, 2008).

"In my mind's eye" he writes "I see the President of the State or the Prime Minister addressing an extraordinary session of the Knesset and making an historic speech of apology:

"MADAM SPEAKER, Honorable Knesset,

"On behalf of the State of Israel and all its citizens, I address today the sons and daughters of the Palestinian people, wherever they are.

"We recognise the fact that we have committed against you a historic injustice, and we humbly ask your forgiveness.

"The burning desire of the founding fathers of the Zionist movement was to save the Jews of Europe, where the dark clouds of hatred for the Jews were gathering ... that would eventually lead to the terrible Holocaust, in which six million Jews perished.

"All this does not justify what happened afterwards. The creation of the Jewish national home in this country has involved a profound injustice to you...

"We cannot ignore anymore the fact that in the war of 1948 - which is the War of Independence for us, and the Naqba for you - some 750 thousand Palestinians were compelled to leave their homes and lands".

Israeli society is not prepared of course to make such an apology. For an Israeli, the formation of the state was the culmination of an organic historical process that admits no apology. Still, many Israelis would be prepared to assume responsibility for some of the consequences of the war, provided the Palestinians assume their share.

To reciprocate, I now take poetic liberty and, following Avnery, appeal to my mind's eye at the same Knesset session.

I see President Abbas waiting for the applause to subside, stepping to the podium and saying:

"MADAM SPEAKER, Honorable Knesset,

"On behalf of the Palestinian people and the future State of Palestine, I address today the sons and daughters of the Jewish nation, wherever they are.

"We recognise the fact that we have committed against you a historic injustice, and we humbly ask your forgiveness.

"The burning desire of the founding fathers of the Palestinian national movement was to liberate Palestine from colonial powers; first, the Ottoman empire and then the British Mandate Authorities. In their zeal to achieve independence they have treated the creation of Jewish national home in this country as a form of colonial occupation, rather than a homecoming endeavor of a potentially friendly neighbor, whose historical attachment to this landscape was not weaker than ours.

"We cannot ignore anymore the fact that the Great Arab Revolt of 1936-1939 has resulted in the British White Paper, which prevented thousands, if not millions of European Jews from escaping the Nazi extermination plan.

Nor can we ignore the fact that, when survivors of Nazi concentration camps sought refuge in Palestine, we were instrumental in denying them safety and, when they finally established their historical homeland, we called the armies of our Arab brethren to wipe out their newly created state. Subsequently, in our zeal to rectify the injustice done to us we have taught our children that only your demise can bring about the justice and liberty they so badly deserve. Thousands of your innocent citizens were killed, maimed or injured by violence that erupted from this teaching."

Utopian? Of course! Feasible? Most Utopias are. Necessary? Only if we aim at a genuine and lasting peace and, having seen the consequences of interim solutions, neither side can afford to aim for less.

Judea Pearl is a professor at UCLA and president of the Daniel Pearl Foundation (www.danielpearl.org), named after his son. He and his wife, Ruth, are editors of "I am Jewish: Personal Reflections Inspired by the Last Words of Daniel Pearl (Jewish Light, 2004).
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Bride and prejudice
Head of Palestinian clan offers Iraqi shoe-throwing journalist his daughter and a dowry.
Unconventional war
U.S. report: Hezbollah guerillas fought Israel better than any Arab army.
  1.   Yes, but 14:29  |  Samantha 26/11/08
  2.   ITS not an apology Pals want.Its Israel 14:45  |  PETER SM 26/11/08
  3.   Imagine hugging a terrorist, better you than me. 14:47  |  Harvey 26/11/08
  4.   Israels obsession with "legitimacy" 15:00  |  Natallie Durson 26/11/08
  5.   Dear Judea 15:02  |  Dr Eric 26/11/08
  6.   Dear Hamas - I apologize for anything I may have done! 15:03  |  Dr Eric 26/11/08
  7.   Dear Ahmadinajad - I`m sorry for living in Eretz Yisrael!!! 15:04  |  Dr Eric 26/11/08
  8.   Dear 9/11 Bombers - I`m sorry I`m not muslim!! 15:05  |  Dr Eric 26/11/08
  9.   Israel can and will apologize - Will the arabs! 15:09  |  Dr Eric 26/11/08
  10.   Peace will come after evil is crushed! 15:11  |  Dr Eric 26/11/08
  11.   only Jews/Israelis grovel and as for 16:10  |  Lebanese Expat 26/11/08
  12.   HOW TO SAY THAT YOU ARE SORRY ZIONISTS? 16:21  |  indrajaya 26/11/08
  13.   Speaking of apologies 16:22  |  Ben 26/11/08
  14.   Dr Eric, you can be our GP anytime 16:29  |  Harvey 26/11/08
  15.   The writer is not familiar with Palestinians 16:50  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  16.   Ramzi. let me respond to your 5 points 17:39  |  Harvey 26/11/08
  17.   Apologies 17:51  |  Ben Kokas Okiror 26/11/08
  18.   Ramzi 18:25  |  Daniela 26/11/08
  19.   Brillant proposal 18:41  |  arik 26/11/08
  20.   The writer is not familiar with Palestinians 2 18:42  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  21.   Ramzi from Bethesda MD 18:49  |  David Israel 26/11/08
  22.   The writer is not familiar with Palestinians 3 18:51  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  23.   Ramzi, you and the Pilgrims! 18:54  |  Zev Davis 26/11/08
  24.   Thank you Mr. Pearl!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 18:55  |  Lee 26/11/08
  25.   The writer is not familiar with Palestinians 4 19:00  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  26.   Turks, Greece, peace 19:03  |  Lexo 26/11/08
  27.   David Israel in New York 19:12  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  28.   No Palestinian-Israeli peace because the conflict is an Arab... 19:16  |  Jehudah Ben-Israel 26/11/08
  29.   Zev Davis 19:18  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  30.   Barak apologised already - no reciprocation from our Arab friends 19:21  |  x-ray 26/11/08
  31.   Jehudah Ben-Israel 19:27  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  32.   Judea: Why Are They In Ghettos? 19:28  |  Tex 26/11/08
  33.   Ramzi 19:31  |  Tex 26/11/08
  34.   The origin of the idea of a "Palestinian state" 19:34  |  Amir 26/11/08
  35.   Tex 19:35  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  36.   an apology like this from Israel could destroy negotiation abilit 19:49  |  zionist forever 26/11/08
  37.   Tex 19:51  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  38.   Ramzi: I`d Rather You Be In Amman Than Gaza 19:54  |  Tex 26/11/08
  39.   Ramzi - Let me disagree with you 19:56  |  David Israel 26/11/08
  40.   Ramzi the Pal. 20:05  |  Palestinian 26/11/08
  41.   Ramzi and Israeli/Palestinian Accountability 21:10  |  Gil 26/11/08
  42.   Apologize? After Arab attempts at genocide against us... 21:41  |  bat yam 26/11/08
  43.   Natallie...your WRONG analogy 22:27  |  Dan 26/11/08
  44.   to Razi, a Palestinian - from CH 22:28  |  Daniel 26/11/08
  45.   Judea, have you apologized to your son`s decapitators? 22:30  |  Genuine Tosefta 26/11/08
  46.   What happens after? 22:32  |  Hamzeh N. 26/11/08
  47.   This is a mild reaction to murderous terrorist attacks in Jerusal 22:37  |  Genuine Tosefta 26/11/08
  48.   Gil in Philadelphia 22:55  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 26/11/08
  49.   25 Ramzi, you are right Judea Pearl has it all wrong 22:56  |  Dutch 26/11/08
  50.   Apologies.. 23:37  |  Michael Greenberg 26/11/08
  51.   Not an apology but right of return of Arbs is needed 23:47  |  Genuine Tosefta 26/11/08
  52.   No equivalence 00:29  |  Hamzeh N. 27/11/08
  53.   The Irish example 00:48  |  Pat 27/11/08
  54.   Ben Koklas Okiror 01:00  |  David Lipman 27/11/08
  55.   Hamzeh- just a point 01:10  |  Jake 27/11/08
  56.   INDRAJAYA HOW? TREAT ARABS THEY WAY THEY DO EACH OTHER 02:23  |  PETER SM 27/11/08
  57.   HAMZEH A miion Jews were forced out of Arab countries 03:03  |  PETER SM 27/11/08
  58.   At last-- deep call for apologies 03:16  |  Eryn 27/11/08
  59.   How about a one state solution... 04:08  |  Nemesis 27/11/08
  60.   I`m so far removed from this struggle... 04:10  |  athiest zionist 27/11/08
  61.   more deluded relativism 04:37  |  athiest zionist 27/11/08
  62.   How can they apoligize when 05:11  |  Mark Lincoln 27/11/08
  63.   Good idea, but 05:14  |  Elad Lending 27/11/08
  64.   Hamzeh, no equivalence indeed 05:27  |  I 27/11/08
  65.   Apologies have their time and place.. 06:27  |  US CITIZEN 27/11/08
  66.   Palestinians? Apologize? HAH!! 06:53  |  Awake 27/11/08
  67.   Hamzeh N is my Evidence 07:09  |  Awake 27/11/08
  68.   46 Hamzeh, indeed no equivalence {2nd try} 07:13  |  I 27/11/08
  69.   Don`t mind us. Just "Resisting" 07:23  |  Awake 27/11/08
  70.   `Apology` is a white wash & not what is needed! 07:46  |  Akram Zekaria 27/11/08
  71.   Israel`s part is to name land piracy by it`s right name 08:16  |  Ivar 27/11/08
  72.   x-ray #30 I always liked short sentences to the point. Yours! 08:45  |  S 27/11/08
  73.   #45 that comment to Perle was in the worst possible taste 09:00  |  x-ray 27/11/08
  74.   To Ramzi - From a brother 09:23  |  Zeidan 27/11/08
  75.   To Ramzi - continued 09:31  |  Zeidan 27/11/08
  76.   Jewish exodus from Arab/Muslim lands not the same 11:37  |  Hamzeh N. 27/11/08
  77.   Zeidan, you represent the voice of fair-minded Palestinians 11:58  |  Daniel 27/11/08
  78.   dr eric 4 16:24  |  potobac 27/11/08
  79.   Hamzeh N 21:14  |  David Israel 27/11/08
  80.   Zeidan 21:24  |  David Israel 27/11/08
  81.   Hamzi it is in your power to make it the same 00:38  |  Genuine Tosefta 28/11/08
  82.   x-ray you are right my comment is tastless but 00:46  |  Genuine Tosefta 28/11/08
  83.   David Israel 08:59  |  Hamzeh N. 28/11/08
  84.   Genuine Tosefta 09:07  |  Hamzeh N. 28/11/08
  85.   Hamzeh N 17:42  |  David Israel 28/11/08
  86.   David Israel 18:34  |  Hamzeh N. 29/11/08
  87.   good idea, but not an even-handed proposal 03:00  |  Dan 20/12/08
 Read & React
Ben-Eliezer: IDF will use all its power to end Gaza Qassam fire
Responses: 175
Daniel Levy: Gaza likely to turn into Somalia if Israel continues siege
Responses: 19
U.S. report: Hezbollah fought Israel better than any Arab army
Responses: 88
Shady land deal unfolds from West Bank to California strip mall
Responses: 34
Immigrant IAF pilot fights to be recognized as a Jew
Responses: 17


More Headlines
00:08 Rice: Renewed Gaza violence will not help Palestinian cause
07:08 ANALYSIS / Barak's restraint in Gaza is a huge elections gamble
19:12 Thousands of Hezbollah supporters protest Gaza siege
14:58 'Russian arms sales could help Iran obliterate Israel'
22:49 Will Obama press Israel to allow nuclear inspection of Dimona reactor?
20:51 Head of Palestinian clan offers Iraqi shoe-throwing journalist a bride
02:09 Bush: Mideast peace talks have yielded progress
20:29 Want to help improve the Haaretz.com homepage?
20:48 15 activists sail from Cyprus to Gaza in effort to break siege
14:33 Rare first century half shekel coin found in Temple Mount dirt
23:47 Is Russian-Israeli tycoon Arcadi Gaydamak leaving Israel for good?
09:36 U.S. report: Hezbollah fought Israel better than any Arab army
15:07 Three injured as light plane crashes off Haifa coast
15:48 Katsav complainant confronts former president over rape accusation
09:14 Israeli UN envoy decries Hamas play mocking Gilad Shalit
04:52 ANALYSIS / Lessons of Madoff scam: invest with more wisdom
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Summer in Israel
Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
Summer Camp in Israel
The best place for your children this summer
Living in Israel Studying in English
Click & Meet our students from all around the world
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
Car rental in Israel
Shlomo Sixt Receive $15.00 from our low rates.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Hebrew Summer courses
From $39.95
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved