Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., December 26, 2008 Kislev 29, 5769 | | Israel Time: 04:48 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 00:00 26/10/2008
The amusing term 'coexistence'
By Hisham Nafa'
Tags: Israeli Arabs, Acre 

Many people have expressed surprise at the recent violence in Acre. Particularly amusing was the mantra that rolled off the tongues of government officials, their eyes wide open: "How could such a thing happen in a city of coexistence?"

There are two possible explanations for the bizarre logic behind this sentence: stupidity, or a cynicism that insults the public's intelligence. It is of course difficult to attribute stupidity to the seasoned public servants with wit enough to climb to positions of power, close to the goodies. They also know how to numb the minds of the sheep while arousing their base instincts. Since the fear instinct in these parts is overly combustible, its manifestations appear immediately: arrogance and hatred toward all Arabs. And when all of these combine to form a near-chemical compound, it will be difficult to put out the fires they ignite simply by spraying them with slogans.

In Acre, as in the rest of the Greater Land of Israel, there is no coexistence. In Acre, there is pain and bitterness, built up over decades. It began not on Yom Kippur of this year, but rather since the ships filled with refugees left the city's shores; since the residents were placed in the handcuffs of military rule; since tens of thousands of their countrymen became victims of a violent, colonialist occupation; since a conscious, intentional policy of national suppression and racial hostility was instituted against them; and since they, living in their homes facing the city's beaches and on their land, began to be described as a demographic threat.
Advertisement
There are more details to this ugly picture: Acre has poor Jewish neighborhoods, where the ruling establishment sees to it that the building rage of the inhabitants is not turned against it. It is not a conspiracy in the classic sense, the kind found in fiction, but rather the product of all of the governmental interests. Because a thinking public is a public that is dangerous to its rulers. So where does this rage get channeled? To the usual suspect, the Arabs. Here is where racism takes on a very popular expression. The Jewish victims of the regime become a weapon against the ultimate victims of the same regime. There you have it: an explosive vicious circle.

For years, Acre's local government officials have been babbling, in the spirit of the times, about the need to Judaize the city. Groups of settlers and of young religious people, who have undergone right-wing nationalization, were brought to the city. And Acre's Arabs ask themselves what this Judaization means, if not their actual and symbolic removal; have we been disinherited once again?

In recent years, religious tendencies have grown among significant "non-white" segments of Israeli society. It turns out that the "opiate of the masses" effect has not skipped over the People of Israel. And in a state where hostility regarding matters of identity has spread to every part - social rifts, in sociological lingo - even Yom Kippur has become an opportunity to exercise hatred, in utter contradiction to its religious meaning. Instead of requests for divine forgiveness, there is an increase in violent rituals against anything that moves. Maybe some people need a Yom Kippur II, to ask forgiveness for their actions during Yom Kippur I.

Acre, of course, is not alone. There is the "coexistence" model of Jaffa. In that city, greedy real-estate developers and pseudo-artists have infiltrated the Old City and live in walled fortresses, because it's so much fun to live in such an exotic area. With regard to the adjacent areas of poverty, suffering and oppression, however, their eyes - and especially their conscience - have remained sealed. And there are those who are enchanted by the idea of implementing this model in the Old City of Acre, too. The Arab residents and their representatives speak of an accelerated assault in recent years of real estate acquisitions. They are convinced, justifiably, that it is a creeping takeover that will end with in their exclusion and even expulsion from their living space. It is not for nothing that the concept of Nakba appears in their reactions.

So there is nothing surprising in what happened in Acre. I suggest to all the potentially surprised individuals to get ready for more "surprises" in other locales. Unless, of course, a a practical, sincere, strategic decision is taken to change Israeli policy concerning the "Arab question" - both at home and beyond.

In the meantime, the Arabs of Acre, like all Arab citizens of Israel, have no magic formula for coping. What is available to them is the lesson learned in the shadow of the Israeli regime: It's called sumud ["steadfastness" in Arabic], holding on to the homeland and waging a stubborn struggle for full civil and national equality.

Hisham Nafa' is an author and a journalist.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Not so funny
Jewish groups condemn a Belgian public broadcaster for airing Holocaust jokes.
An endless nightmare
An Indian paper reports the Mumbai terrorists tortured their Chabad House victims.
  1.   Hisham, you`re ridiculous 08:17  |  SDHD 26/10/08
  2.   nafa needs lessons in rationality!!! 08:29  |  victor hardman 26/10/08
  3.   I`m a Mizrachi Jew and not a victim 08:47  |  Avi 26/10/08
  4.   For SDHD #1 09:01  |  Esther 26/10/08
  5.   Israel is a passing phenomenon. 09:57  |  B.Saleem 26/10/08
  6.   #4 Esther 10:01  |  Sarah 26/10/08
  7.   Esther/SDHD 10:03  |  sh 26/10/08
  8.   Who is Mr. Nafa? 10:11  |  Sarah 26/10/08
  9.   Real Estate 10:14  |  Peter Williams 26/10/08
  10.   hisham you`ll never be a businessman 10:20  |  rich 26/10/08
  11.   #5 saleem explains the symptoms but not the answer 10:21  |  victor hardman 26/10/08
  12.   don`t worry, aquisitions by Jewish billionares 10:46  |  fadi 26/10/08
  13.   So where do we go from here, Hisham Nafa? 11:01  |  Tzfonit 26/10/08
  14.   To SDHD- The inborn errors!! 11:06  |  B.Saleem 26/10/08
  15.   B. Saleem in Gaza on being unwanted 11:30  |  Tzfonit 26/10/08
  16.   Tzfonit 11:34  |  fadi 26/10/08
  17.   #14 has saleem forgotten when 250,000 arabs came to work from 11:45  |  victor hardman 26/10/08
  18.   To Fadi 13:19  |  Ofer 26/10/08
  19.   Fadi in Australia 13:27  |  Tzfonit 26/10/08
  20.   Sarah #6... there is no "conspiration... 14:23  |  Esther 26/10/08
  21.   sh #7... your observations are astute... 14:26  |  Esther 26/10/08
  22.   Re Sarah #8 14:35  |  Esther 26/10/08
  23.   Peter #9 14:47  |  Esther 26/10/08
  24.   Attacking living space 14:58  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 26/10/08
  25.   Esther- don`t patronize us 15:24  |  Mizrachi Jew 26/10/08
  26.   #14 B Saleem....actually, the Arabs are more racist 16:34  |  Lynn 26/10/08
  27.   #5 Saleem 16:50  |  John Allen 26/10/08
  28.   Multiculturalism cannot work. 16:59  |  John Allen 26/10/08
  29.   Weighing intolerance 17:05  |  SDHD 26/10/08
  30.   Look what is happening in England. 17:09  |  John Allen 26/10/08
  31.   You won`t get the land of Israel 17:13  |  lady from USA 26/10/08
  32.   B.Saleem 17:20  |  lady from USA 26/10/08
  33.   #15 Better future for all concerned? 17:20  |  John Allen 26/10/08
  34.   fadi 17:25  |  lady from USA 26/10/08
  35.   Muslim anger 17:31  |  lady from USA 26/10/08
  36.   Tzfonit 17:47  |  lady from USA 26/10/08
  37.   Mr Hisham Nafa` 17:49  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 26/10/08
  38.   Nafa`s mindset IS the reason or strife 17:50  |  Nathaniel 26/10/08
  39.   The ultimate spectator sport 18:10  |  Bitin Dawg 26/10/08
  40.   Anecdote About Coexistance In Akko 18:22  |  Gil Franco 26/10/08
  41.   saleem, your national poet darwish is a 19:01  |  vladimir 26/10/08
  42.   better option 20:43  |  Hatem Bazian 26/10/08
  43.   in particular as a journalist, stop 21:36  |  kay 26/10/08
  44.   Gil Franco - not a rimon (pomegranate) perchance? 21:40  |  sh 26/10/08
  45.   Gil #40... my Akko annecdote differs from yours... 22:12  |  Esther 26/10/08
  46.   Reverse Discrimination!! 22:55  |  Robert 26/10/08
  47.   Tzfonit 23:07  |  christa 26/10/08
  48.   For Mizrachi #25 23:10  |  Esther 26/10/08
  49.   Lady from USA 23:12  |  christa 26/10/08
  50.   Lynn 23:17  |  christa 26/10/08
  51.   #20 Esther 23:39  |  Sarah 26/10/08
  52.   #47 christa 00:03  |  Sarah 27/10/08
  53.   Interesting commentary - the area is headed for more disaster if 00:04  |  Rashon 27/10/08
  54.   Correct No. 50 (and excellent article) 00:10  |  Marlene N. 27/10/08
  55.   Marlene and international law 00:38  |  SDHD 27/10/08
  56.   B.Saleem in Gaza #5 03:29  |  Jasper 27/10/08
  57.   Christa #47 03:49  |  Jasper 27/10/08
  58.   Gentrification of Acre 05:50  |  Shareen 27/10/08
  59.   Hisham Nafa appears to be 06:52  |  Robert Haymond 27/10/08
  60.   Oye, Rob #59... 07:58  |  Esther 27/10/08
  61.   #5 Saleem 07:58  |  sharon 27/10/08
  62.   Esther #60. Thanks 08:23  |  Robert Haymond 27/10/08
  63.   Sharon #61..."dangerous" case of paranoia... 08:37  |  Esther 27/10/08
  64.   christa 11:21  |  lady from USA 27/10/08
  65.   #63 Esther - 15:20  |  sharon 27/10/08
  66.   Lady from USA 16:46  |  Tareq 27/10/08
  67.   Yom Kippur and Acre 14:24  |  Daniel Garcia 28/10/08
  68.   Let him show us what coexistance truly is... 16:22  |  LdA 28/10/08
  69.   SDHD - Weighing Intolerance 21:33  |  The Gentile 28/10/08
  70.   Nathaniel from Minneapolis 21:44  |  The Gentile 28/10/08
  71.   This article is an accurate analysis - take heed! 02:21  |  Abe Hayeem 26/12/08
 Read & React
Jewish parents deny Arab girl place in Jezreel Valley daycare
Responses: 185
IDF assault on Hamas approved after massive Gaza rocket barrage
Responses: 119
ANALYSIS / Hamas seems to believe Jews 'understand only force'
Responses: 116
Israel Harel: IDF should deliver Hamas mortal blow for every rocket fired
Responses: 39


More Headlines
03:36 Olmert to hold series of consultations ahead of possible Gaza action
03:56 Gaza operation may lead to harming of Shalit, Egypt warns
04:03 ANALYSIS / A hard look at Hamas' capabilities
02:59 ANALYSIS / How did Assad manage to gain international respect?
20:20 Lebanon army: 7 missiles ready to be fired at Israel found in south Lebanon
01:13 Report: Mumbai terrorists badly tortured Chabad House victims
03:48 14 hurt in New York as car crashes into Hanukkah party
02:49 New anti-Livni slogan slammed for being sexist
04:45 Hit-and-run victim's widow calls on public to help find assailant
20:47 Ahmadinejad Christmas address to U.K. viewers sparks angry row
19:48 Israel sentences PFLP leader to 30 years in prison
19:36 Nobel-laureate playwright Harold Pinter dies aged 78
15:31 Jewish groups blast Belgian TV for comic's Holocaust jokes
13:15 Tourists flock to Bethlehem as city basks in Christmas spotlight
18:52 Ministry slams government decision to cut back on school security
10:53 Leftist Meretz issues rare call for military action against Hamas
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Summer in Israel
Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
SURF RAMBAM
Keep current about new-wave medical care, education and research.
Summer Camp in Israel
The best place for your children this summer
Academic Studies in Israel
All the Q & A at the IDC HERZLIYA Open House, January 9,2009
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
Car rental in Israel
Shlomo Sixt Receive $15.00 from our low rates.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Hebrew Summer courses
From $39.95
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved