Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 07, 2008 Tishrei 8, 5769 | | Israel Time: 18:57 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 09:16 06/10/2008
Nuclear deterrence, with a grain of salt
By Amir Oren
Tags: Nuclear deterrence, Iran 

The director of the Israel Atomic Energy Commission, Dr. Shaul Horev, rushed on Rosh Hashanah eve to give a speech at the annual International Atomic Energy Agency conference in Vienna and issue a thinly veiled warning against a nuclear Iran and Syria. He was still speaking when Ali Asghar Soltanieh, the Iranian representative, took his turn, complaining about how forgiving the world is of Israeli nuclear power. There was no contact between the two, who spoke from different corners of the same hall.

Horev is an officer in the naval reserves, a commander of the submarines to which international journalists never fail to attribute the ability to launch strategic munitions. The conference ended, and just like 35 years ago, it's almost Yom Kippur. And still, the Iranian challenge appears resistant to Israeli deterrence.

October 6 is not just the date of Yom Kippur in 1973. It is also an important date in the lives of the two Arab leaders who attacked Israel at the time. It is Hafez Assad's birthday and the day of Anwar Sadat's death. They were momentary partners and conditional allies - Assad relied on the Soviet Union, Sadat neglected it in favor of American pleasantries - but their different activities indicate that in the eyes of foreigners, the image of Israeli nuclear capability is of very limited value. Rather than reining in plans to destroy Israel with a single blow, it leads them down other, more gradual paths. The nuclear deterrence attributed to Israel does not affect the capability of hostile elements or even their intentions - just the time frame in which they can carry out their plans.
Advertisement
In crossing the Suez Canal, Sadat was striving for a narrow military achievement that would lead to a wide-scale political one: the return by Israel of the entire Sinai as a preface to the return of the other territory captured in June 1967. He thought defeating Israel inside the Green Line was not practical, for various reasons - including the nuclear capability attributed to it, which would be activated during an existential crisis.

Sadat got rid of most of the Soviet presence in Egypt (aside from Scud missiles launched at Israel Defense Forces troops at Suez at the end of the war) and defected to the American bloc. Assad, by contrast, received Soviet help in the 1982 war as well, and Syria hosted SAM-5 long-range surface-to-air missiles that threatened the entire region between Turkey and Haifa, along with thousands of instructors in every brigade and battalion. In the face of Israel's nuclear deterrence, Assad built a force of surface-to-surface missiles as well as chemical and biological warheads.

Now his son, Bashar, is signaling that the choice is in the hands of Washington and Jerusalem: If they want, he'll move toward the West and accept Israel; otherwise, he'll remain under the Iranian umbrella, which will soon go nuclear. A year ago, it became clear that Israeli strength and even the proximity of Damascus to the Golan border, a few short hours for the IDF's armored vehicles, had not deterred Syria from choosing the North Korean shortcut to nuclear armament. The Israel Air Force operation on September 6 last year revealed Israel's determination to prevent a neighboring country from going nuclear, but also exposed Israel's helplessness in the face of Syria's determination to become stronger while continuing to use terrorism and to arm itself with rockets and missiles, more numerous and accurate than in the past.

Rowan Scarborough's 2004 book "Rumsfeld's War" revealed a secret intelligence report from the U.S. Defense Department's Defense Intelligence Agency in 1999 that described what it called "the future threat," from 1999 to 2020. The report indicated that U.S. President George W. Bush did not invent the double threat of Iraq and Iran; it was identified during Bill Clinton's time. In the report, the DIA's director, Lt. Gen. Patrick M. Hughes, took inventory of the world's nuclear weapons. Nine years ago, he wrote that Israel had 60 to 80 nuclear weapons and that by the end of the century's second decade, it would have between 65 and 85. Iran and Iraq were expected to go from having no nuclear weapons to between 10 and 20 each by 2020. That was before Saddam Hussein's Iraq was crossed off the chart, but that still leaves Iran.

Every known nuclear site in the world can be pinpointed with precision and targeted for demolition. The international literature is full of guesses about Israeli nuclear sites. The Iranians, Syrians and fundamentalist Islamic organizations are liable to believe that barrages of missiles and rockets on these sites will damage Israel's strategic alignment, or will at least disrupt or paralyze it, without giving Israel a reason to use other, well-hidden means against them from that same alignment. The sad conclusion, on the 35th anniversary of the Yom Kippur War, is not that the nuclear deterrence attributed to Israel is completely superfluous - it dissuaded Saddam from using chemical and biological weapons in 1991 - but that if embraced without earnestly and continuously striving for peace, that deterrence will be a costly illusion.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Forgotten peace
French FM: I fear distracted world may forget Mideast peace process.
Settlers vs. Shin Bet
Daniela Weiss: Shin Bet behind attack on left-wing advocate prof. Sternhell.
  1.   Couldn`t the Arabs overrun Israel one day....??? 09:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  2.   Swiss Dino 35 years ago was a matter of hours 10:35  |  Tzfonit 06/10/08
  3.   So only you have the right to deter and no one else ? 10:59  |  mehmet 06/10/08
  4.   # 2 Tzfonit (1) 11:20  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  5.   # 2 Tzfonit (2) 11:49  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  6.   THANK OLMERT, BROTHER 11:53  |  indrajaya 06/10/08
  7.   dopey dino and the difficulty of him using his brain 11:54  |  victor hardman 06/10/08
  8.   3 12:17  |  zionist forever 06/10/08
  9.   Just a few N. Bombs on neighbors on vicinity and some H bombs for 12:20  |  JP 06/10/08
  10.   Just a few N. Bombs on neighbors on vicinity and some H bombs for 12:21  |  JP 06/10/08
  11.   Amir Oren is completely wrong 12:21  |  Clickfool 06/10/08
  12.   Just a few N. Bombs on neighbors on vicinity and some H bombs for 12:22  |  JP 06/10/08
  13.   1 12:32  |  zionist forever 06/10/08
  14.   Swiss (Dino) Where`s that hand extended in peace? 12:47  |  Tzfonit 06/10/08
  15.   Israels enemies have got weapons of mass destruction.Sadaam used 13:19  |  PETER SM 06/10/08
  16.   # 13 zionist forever 13:23  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  17.   # 14 Tzfonit (1) 13:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  18.   # 14 Tzfonit (2) 13:46  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  19.   MEHMET Israel is outgunned 5:1 plus Arabs have WMD`s 13:53  |  PETER SM 06/10/08
  20.   Dino the Swiss dont you remember that they tried it, not once 13:54  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/10/08
  21.   INDRAJAYA how many Hezb. supermen were able to cross into Israel? 14:06  |  PETER SM 06/10/08
  22.   #16/17 dino still has difficulty in sorting possibility from 14:09  |  victor hardman 06/10/08
  23.   #20 Margie in Tel -Aviv 14:20  |  oetis 06/10/08
  24.   #20 Margie in Tel -Aviv 14:25  |  oetis 06/10/08
  25.   Well if Israel`s nuclear deterrence doesn`t work 14:47  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/10/08
  26.   # 20 Margie, I understand that it`s a wonderful thing..... 14:50  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  27.   # 22 victor hardman 14:55  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  28.   oetis 15:00  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/10/08
  29.   Our Enemies Want To Die 15:10  |  UsedToPostHere 06/10/08
  30.   Dino, you write as if Israel`s proportions are new 15:17  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/10/08
  31.   #27 dopey dino forgets what nasty nasrallah said 15:41  |  victor hardman 06/10/08
  32.   Dino S it depends on what you call impressive 15:43  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/10/08
  33.   # 30 / # 32 Margie in Tel Aviv 16:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/10/08
  34.   Pakistan is not in the ME 17:09  |  mehmet 06/10/08
  35.   #2 Tzfonit 17:31  |  Lou Medel 06/10/08
  36.   16 18:06  |  zionist forever 06/10/08
  37.   Our alleged deterrence hasn`t failed. 18:35  |  Mike 06/10/08
  38.   Lou Medel 18:49  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/10/08
  39.   Deterrence 20:06  |  rigma 06/10/08
  40.   MEHMET Pakistan trains terrorists that go back to Britain etc 20:40  |  PETER SM 06/10/08
  41.   If Israel has nukes the Arabs should have them too! 03:39  |  Sandos 07/10/08
  42.   Peter SM the wise and righteous 03:42  |  Bob Berry 07/10/08
  43.   There is a "Muslim Bomb" already! 04:30  |  jgarbuz 07/10/08
  44.   nuculear Iran 04:38  |  elliot57 07/10/08
  45.   Pakistani pilots shot down Israeli planes... 06:08  |  jgarbuz 07/10/08
  46.   Israel Does Not Need Nukes To Defeat Arab Enemy 06:29  |  Baruch Gold 07/10/08
  47.   Nuclear weapons - M.A.D. 08:01  |  michael cohen 07/10/08
  48.   B.BERRY I would not gloat at their dead for starters 08:16  |  PETER SM 07/10/08
  49.   No.43 - Nuclear States 13:02  |  Ant 07/10/08
  50.   No.43 - Nuclear States 13:02  |  Ant 07/10/08
  51.   Israel should not let her nukes rest i.e. rust in vain 18:39  |  WAKEUP ISRAEL LEADER 07/10/08
 Read & React
Security officials: Time running out on deal for Shalit release
Responses: 69
Lebanese union to sue Israel for 'claiming ownership' of falafel
Responses: 106
Avi Primor: It's time for the IDF to leave the West Bank
Responses: 39
The Holocaust, Tarantino-style: Jews scalping Nazis
Responses: 28
Hamas: Jewish Lobby in U.S. to blame for global financial crisis
Responses: 71


More Headlines
18:57 Olmert: Medvedev says Russia won't allow threats to Israel's security
16:28 Hamas: 'Jewish Lobby' in U.S. to blame for global financial crisis
17:14 In surprise move, Bank of Israel cuts interest rate by 0.5 percent
13:25 Israeli security officials: Time running out on Shalit deal
18:42 VIDEO / YouTube pranksters have Hitler raving about Obama, Xbox
18:06 Ariel Sharon told 1973 probe: IDF top brass was clueless in Yom Kippur War
16:24 Dutch lawyers seek arrest of Minister Ayalon for 'war crimes'
16:45 Televised Hamas course teaches militants how to fight the IDF
17:34 Stock markets across Arab world suffer steep losses
10:28 Burial artifact inscribed 'Son of High Priest' found near West Bank fence route
13:50 Arab MK to Dichter: Protect Arab drivers from stone hurling on Yom Kippur
17:38 VIDEO / Foreign Min. compiles report on likelihood of West holding talks with Iran
15:50 Hamas leaders head to Cairo for talks on Palestinian reconciliation
09:33 The Holocaust, Tarantino-style: Jews scalping Nazis
Previous Editions