Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., October 03, 2008 Tishrei 4, 5769 | | Israel Time: 16:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 02:39 29/09/2008
The Etzion illusion
By Gershom Gorenberg
Tags: Israel News, Kfar Etzion

History - the history everyone thinks they know - misleads us. Take the story of Kfar Etzion, the first Israeli settlement in the West Bank, established 41 years ago this week.

In the Israeli consciousness, Kfar Etzion has played a double role. On one hand, it has been the ultimate "consensus settlement." After all, the settlers returned to the site of a kibbutz that was overrun, along with the rest of the Etzion Bloc, on the eve of Israel's independence. Even veteran opponents of settling in occupied territory shrug, smile and say "that's different" when the Etzion Bloc is mentioned.

On the other hand, Kfar Etzion is seen as the starting point of the religious, messianic settler movement. In the narrative accepted by both supporters and opponents of that movement, a group of young religious Jews imposed its will on Levi Eshkol's hesitant government. And that was an omen of what was to come.
Advertisement
But the accepted understanding of the return to Kfar Etzion is built on mistakes and deceptions. The Kfar Etzion settlers did not defeat Eshkol. Rather, they broke through an open doorway.

As archival documents testify, Eshkol conducted a typical argument with himself in the summer of 1967, then firmly decided to push settlement at Kfar Etzion. That July, when he received a top-secret memorandum on options for the West Bank's future, Eshkol wrote only one comment in the margins - concerning the Etzion Bloc and Beit Ha'arava, a kibbutz abandoned in 1948.

Eshkol, a veteran of Labor Zionist settlement, was interested in reestablishing lost kibbutzim. In September he received a report, apparently at his request, from the Jewish Agency on the economic basis for settlement in the Etzion Bloc. Meanwhile, he requested and received a secret opinion on the legal aspects of settlement in the territories, particularly in the Etzion area. A few days later, he informed the cabinet that he had approved letting children of the original Etzion Bloc residents settle there.

The survivors of the Etzion Bloc and their children knew nothing of this. They saw his decision as a response to their pressure. But the memory of secular politicians being dragged along by settlers conceals the partnership that was actually created between them.

As for that legal opinion: It was written by Foreign Ministry legal counsel Theodor Meron, a Holocaust survivor with a doctorate in international law from Harvard. Meron was the government's top expert in the field. A decade later, he accepted an academic appointment in the United States and became a world-renowned authority on international law. Today he is a judge on the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.

His status gives particular weight to the words he wrote 41 years ago: "My conclusion is that civilian settlement in the administered territories contravenes the explicit provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention."

Put simply, Meron warned in advance that settlement in the territories was illegal. The claim that the West Bank was not "normal" occupied territory would not stand up internationally, he wrote. On the other hand, he said that "settlement by military bodies" having "a temporary, not permanent, character" was permissible.

Eshkol exploited that opening. The public, and Israel's representatives at the United Nations, were told that Kfar Etzion would be an outpost of Nahal, the army branch combining active duty with settlement training.

A secret military order dated September 27, 1967, the day the settlement was established, says the tie between Kfar Etzion and Nahal is "a 'cover' for purposes of the diplomatic battle," but "there is no intention of practical steps by the Israel Defense Forces to implement this 'cover.'" This was deception, carried out under orders, intended to hide a violation of international law.

But the most basic self-deception involves the emotion that drove the decision to resettle the Etzion Bloc and created a consensus supporting it. The feeling was that those who lost their homes must return. Settlements that fell and were etched in national memory must be reestablished. If the refugees themselves or their descendants were not interested in going back, other Jews would "return" in their place.

In other words, the right of return for 1948 refugees was taken as self-evident - if the refugees were Jews. That became a diplomatic position. In negotiations, no Israeli representative would dream of giving up the Etzion Bloc. Rather, the Arab side will have to accept our emotional tie to the place. This is sloppy and dangerous strategic thinking. Can there be a greater folly than Israel insisting on reopening the file of 1948 and returning all the refugees to their homes?

The real history of Kfar Etzion is a story of collaboration between settlers and a political leadership that saw settlement as a sacred value. It is a story of deception, illegality with knowledge aforethought, and failed political thinking. And in that way, it was indeed an omen of what was to come.

Gershom Gorenberg is the author of The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967-1977.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Rise in anti-Semitism
ADL warns financial crisis is causing upsurge in anti-Jewish activity on the internet.
Bubbes for Obama
Comedian posts video calling on Jews to lobby Florida grandparents to vote Obama.
  1.   THE Settlement movement began with the 3 Arab No`s of Khartoum. 09:20  |  PETER SM 29/09/08
  2.   Goremberg`s Illusion 09:53  |  Ben Israel 29/09/08
  3.   Jews Lived Here 10:02  |  Yishai Kohen 29/09/08
  4.   Settlements can`t exist ... 10:51  |  Observer 29/09/08
  5.   The settlers days are ending 12:44  |  Natallie Durson 29/09/08
  6.   gershom gorenberg settlements or not 13:05  |  judah 29/09/08
  7.   The Settler Enterprise is the rock upon which Zionism foundered 13:30  |  Ivar 29/09/08
  8.   WHAT GENEVA CONVENTIONS? 13:54  |  Neutered Observer 29/09/08
  9.   Settlements must include mass deportations 14:04  |  American Patriot 29/09/08
  10.   There`s Nothing "Accidental" Here 15:02  |  Hank N Tennessee 29/09/08
  11.   Natallie Durson 15:16  |  lady from USA 29/09/08
  12.   Why do Jews want to live in apartments? 15:19  |  lady from USA 29/09/08
  13.   Ivar 15:28  |  lady from USA 29/09/08
  14.   American Patriot 15:56  |  lady from USA 29/09/08
  15.   The Jewish population of Judea and Samaria rose by 20% 16:00  |  Dani 29/09/08
  16.   The unpalatable contradiction..... 16:02  |  Johnboy 29/09/08
  17.   Mrs. USA 17:07  |  Murray 29/09/08
  18.   # 10 lady 18:34  |  Axel 29/09/08
  19.   This is clearly a mistake-ask Jeff Northridge 18:39  |  Roo 29/09/08
  20.   Rationalization, Lies, Deception 101 18:47  |  Lou Medel 29/09/08
  21.   #1 PETER SM- settlement of territories pursued before that 18:55  |  Roo 29/09/08
  22.   roo you are confused.this is not your subject 19:35  |  yaheskel 29/09/08
  23.   Gorenberg - He Should Talk About Self-Deception ? 19:37  |  Tod Zuckerman 29/09/08
  24.   roo whence this sudden interest in eshkols doodling 19:38  |  yaheskel 29/09/08
  25.   #10 Lady from US: The Arabs do not ask 20:04  |  Diane Mason 29/09/08
  26.   The Ultra Left Are The Only Obstacles to Peace with the Arabs 23:23  |  Baruch Gold 29/09/08
  27.   # 26 baruch 01:01  |  Axel 30/09/08
  28.   #5 Natalie. Settler`s days are just beginning. 01:08  |  Chaim 30/09/08
  29.   Haaretz Censors - Set Out Your Guidelines Re What Is Unaccepable 08:12  |  chet 30/09/08
  30.   what a bunch of legal bung! 08:27  |  Mark 30/09/08
  31.   to "lady from USA" 10:49  |  Steve the Pals. 30/09/08
  32.   axel to baruch 11:49  |  erwin honigstein 30/09/08
  33.   GORENBERG to quote you a little out of context..... 13:58  |  Miriam 30/09/08
  34.   Diane Mason 14:59  |  lady from USA 30/09/08
  35.   Axel!!! 15:01  |  lady from USA 30/09/08
  36.   Steve the Pals. 15:02  |  lady from USA 30/09/08
  37.   smooth talking,with or without Muslims don`t want Jews 15:50  |  Jacob,Toronto 30/09/08
  38.   Bad Idea Then Bad Idea Now 16:03  |  Jane 30/09/08
  39.   Israeli Justice 18:43  |  Jim 30/09/08
  40.   #5 Natalie Durson 19:20  |  Jim 30/09/08
  41.   Gorenberg`s Article Published In The Washington Post 19:50  |  chet 30/09/08
  42.   #14 lady from USA 20:55  |  Jim 30/09/08
  43.   theodor meron and the law 21:29  |  meshack 30/09/08
  44.   there is no palestinian arab 03:56  |  JfromC 01/10/08
  45.   what is important 04:38  |  JfromC 01/10/08
  46.   meshack #42 04:40  |  Veritas 01/10/08
  47.   Lady from USA, please, please, check yourself... 06:06  |  BBSNews 01/10/08
  48.   Whose illusion? 09:32  |  Moshe 01/10/08
  49.   # 34 lady from USA you missed something in the bible 11:46  |  Traude 01/10/08
  50.   chet 14:47  |  lady from USA 01/10/08
  51.   Gershom,you reasoned yourself out of existence,pack 10 kg at most 15:10  |  Absolute Sweden 01/10/08
  52.   to lady from USA #14 15:31  |  zeev 01/10/08
  53.   BBSNews 15:42  |  lady from USA 01/10/08
  54.   to lady from USA #34 - 2nd try 15:59  |  zeev 01/10/08
  55.   The Empire is receding 16:11  |  Bitin Dawg 01/10/08
  56.   Zeev # 54 very well said--too bad you are not 16:45  |  Labhras 01/10/08
  57.   all the irish banks are bust 19:40  |  papalbull 01/10/08
  58.   zeev logic 19:44  |  abendego 01/10/08
  59.   There are no "pearly gates" Lady from USA... 20:14  |  BBSNews 01/10/08
  60.   So strange 21:49  |  Ephraim 01/10/08
  61.   # 60 ephraim 00:36  |  Axel 02/10/08
  62.   I don`t get this 01:04  |  Adam 02/10/08
  63.   axel "what belongs to you" 01:13  |  erwin honigstein 02/10/08
  64.   This is true 01:50