Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 19, 2009 Shvat 25, 5769 | | Israel Time: 06:57 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 00:00 14/09/2008
The Jewish Agency's smart decision on aliyah
By Alex Sinclair
Tags: Jewish World, Israel 

In a recent Haaretz opinion piece, Anshel Pfeffer wrote that the Jewish Agency, by ceding its aliyah portfolio to Nefesh B'Nefesh, has "signed its own death certificate."

A more thoughtful examination of this recent decision leads to a very different conclusion: that the Jewish Agency has made a profound and admirable strategic decision about the relationship between Israel and the Diaspora in the 21st century.

In the first decades of the Jewish Agency's existence, its primary function was to bring two things from the Diaspora to Israel: money and people. Diaspora Jews, especially Americans, were urged to support Israel financially in every way possible. And, indeed, without Diaspora Jewish money, it is doubtful that the State of Israel would have survived economically in its early years.
Advertisement
But Israel didn't only want Diaspora Jewish money. A core component of Zionist thought, Israeli political strategy, and Jewish Agency organizational vision, was the belief that Diaspora Jews - all of them - should move to Israel. This "shlilat hagolah" (negation of the Diaspora) was central to Israelis and Israeliness. As a teenager on an Israel trip in the 1980s, I remember being asked countless times, by tour guides, taxi drivers, and shopkeepers: "Nu, why do you live in the Golah - you must make aliyah!"

Astute followers of modern Jewish history might notice that this sledgehammer approach to aliyah has had rather limited success. This is the case across the First World Diaspora, and especially in America. American Jews have stayed in America. More to the point, American Jews feel at home in America. For them, America is not "exile" - it is home.

American Jewry disproves each and every classical Zionist thinker: its integration into American society debunks Herzl's belief in the persistence of Diaspora anti-Semitism; its artistic and cultural creativity is a slap in the face to Ahad Ha'am, who believed that only in Israel could Jewish culture flourish; and its religious diversity and creativity offers a humbling rebuke to Rav Kook, or anyone else who still believes that Israel is the only place in the world where the Jewish religion can develop in a creative and holy fashion.

Any Zionist organization, therefore, that continues to operate under the banner of "here is good; there is bad" is totally misreading the map of the Jewish people today. For anyone who cares about the Jewish people, about Israel, and yes, about Zionism in the 21st century, the question is not "how can we get Diaspora Jews to make aliyah?" but "how can we get Diaspora Jews to engage with Israel and with each other?"

The Jewish Agency should be applauded for recognizing this. And now, with this new decision, the Agency has made its strategic direction clear: it is Israel education and engagement, not aliyah-mongering, that will save the connection between Diaspora Jewry and Israel.

Furthermore, we need to reconceptualize completely just what we mean by Israel education and engagement, a process that the Agency has also embarked on.

Israel education in the past too often relied on one-sided, shallow, and sometimes contradictory narratives: Israel as a despised but heroic David surrounded by a series of genocidal Goliaths; Israel as a refuge for Jews ejected from the third world; Israel as a poverty-stricken country desperate for Diaspora help; Israel as a Biblical Eden of kibbutzim and camels. The narratives of Israel that we must present to young people today are very different. We must present Israel as it really is: a society that is diverse, complex, hilarious, confusing, beautiful, ugly, spiritual, messy, frustrating, enriching, old and new.

If we do this kind of Israel engagement and education successfully, then Diaspora Jews will want to talk, think, create and work together with Israelis about where Israel is and where it's going. Complexity and conversation will lead to commitment; but not necessarily to aliyah - and that's ok.

Ultimately, we must acknowledge that American Jews don't need to make aliyah in order to be good Zionists. Israel can learn a lot from American Jewry, and American Jews can learn a lot from Israel; but that will only happen if Israel stops guilt-tripping American Jews and starts treating them like partners whom it wishes to invite into thoughtful, meaningful conversations about how, together, we as the Jewish people can help Israel flourish in every way.

Aliyah is a fine and wonderful thing to encourage. I've even done it myself. Nefesh B'Nefesh should go from strength to strength. But the Jewish Agency's job must be to advocate for and initiate 21st century Israel education and engagement. It is possible to create commitment to Israel through complexity and conversation. Let us stop negating the Diaspora and start talking with it.

Dr Alex Sinclair, who made aliyah in 1998, is a lecturer in Jewish Education at the Schechter Institute of Jewish Studies, as well as an adjunct assistant professor at the Jewish Theological Seminary of America.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Hitler parody
Israeli YouTube Hitler parody infuriates Holocaust survivors.
"Like a virgin"
Will Virgin Mary TV spoof jeopardize Pope visit to Israel?
  1.   Maybe Ahad HaAm was right? 13:02  |  Zev Davis 15/09/08
  2.   I know from experience the jewish agency needs reform 14:44  |  zionist forever 15/09/08
  3.   but here is good!!!! 14:49  |  Interested 15/09/08
  4.   1 15:09  |  zionist forever 15/09/08
  5.   israelis like allyah but don`t like olim hadashim! 15:11  |  Tamy 15/09/08
  6.   So when he says... 15:40  |  Ze`ev 15/09/08
  7.   Jewish Agency acted against aliyah 17:11  |  Jackie 15/09/08
  8.   Place doesn`t decide Jewishness.. 20:16  |  Paul 15/09/08
  9.   Paul, I don`t know if you are, Jewish, but . . . 20:49  |  Zev Davis 15/09/08
  10.   Leave it to Leftist Haaretz to defend Jewish? Agency 22:52  |  Nefesh Lover 15/09/08
  11.   MANY CENTRES 14:59  |  soogy liberal 17/09/08
  12.   thlym 2:6,7 20:28  |  Paul 17/09/08
  13.   Your not describing Ibriy here! 20:32  |  Paul 17/09/08
  14.   Bravo 21:44  |  Steve 17/09/08
  15.   Great article -- How can Israel engage as Diaspora`s focal point? 21:53  |  Serge 17/09/08
  16.   Jewish Agency Questions. 21:55  |  Rena 17/09/08
  17.   Zion 22:04  |  Brian 17/09/08
  18.   #5: Olim hadashim don`t especially like Israelis, either 09:34  |  Yaakov K. 18/09/08
  19.   Israel is a failing country 10:14  |  Ex-Zionist 18/09/08
  20.   jewish agency 11:44  |  soth american 18/09/08
  21.   Disillusioned ex-Zionist, Zionism was always . . . 11:28  |  Zev Davis 19/09/08
  22.   Aliyah from the nations foretold! 10:59  |  J Ricketts 28/10/08
  23.   Israel: love it or lump it! 23:03  |  Sandy 31/10/08
  24.   The jewish agency is no help for american jews 13:02  |  Susan 05/02/09
  25.   The Aliyah "Strainer" 17:49  |  moshe rabeynu 16/02/09
 Haaretz Hot Topics
Israel 2009 election results: Voter breakdown
Israel goes to the polls
Conflict in Gaza
Israel vs. Hamas
Iran: Nuclear and regional ambitions
More Headlines
04:28 Israel drafts new Hamas prisoner list for potential Shalit swap
04:27 ANALYSIS / Israel's strategic games may endanger Shalit deal
05:45 Israel Harel / 'Shalit first' is no more than spin designed to deceive the public
01:32 UN envoy: Gaza will suffer more devastating violence unless truce is achieved
23:39 U.S. State Dept: Syria can play a positive role in Mideast
02:03 IDF: War crime charges over Gaza op are 'legal terror'
06:12 Terror victims sue U.S. oil companies for funding terror
03:52 Arab League chief: A right-wing Israeli gov`t will at least say no to our face
04:21 Not everyone is convinced notorious Nazi 'Dr. Death' is really dead
02:31 Police seek AG Mazuz's approval to question Lieberman under caution
06:12 Olmert reprimands top defense official over critical quotes to Maariv
03:00 London museum to hold Israel science event despite promoters' boycott
05:24 Wardens hang Rabin's picture outside assassin Yigal Amir's prison cell
03:36 Jerusalem fund to invest NIS 5.5 million in Israeli filmmakers
20:05 Israeli YouTube Hitler parody infuriates Holocaust survivors
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Summer in Israel
Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
Passover Vacations
The BEST Passover Vacations around ? Mexico, Arizona and Florida
Camp Kimama Israel 2009
The best place for your children this summer
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved