Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., September 09, 2008 Elul 9, 5768 | | Israel Time: 06:51 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Top IDF officer: Israel not prepared for next war
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Israel, IDF

Major General (res.) Moshe Ivri-Sukenik, who resigned as commander of the Israel Defense Forces' Northern Corps earlier this year, has sharply criticized the way the army is training. In his first public comments on the matter, Sukenik says the army's training program is flawed and troops are not being prepared for future challenges.

"We are not training enough," Sukenik, who led an IDF in-house probe after the Second Lebanon War, said Thursday.

Sukenik served as commander of the IDF's ground forces several years ago. After the Lebanon war he led the investigation into battles by Division 162. Sukenik was asked to return to the ranks and command the Northern Corps, but he resigned in January, in part to protest what he calls the insufficient allocation of funds for training the land forces.
Advertisement
Sukenik spoke Thursday in Ramat Efal at a conference on the land war in Lebanon.

"After a year at the Corps, I told a forum of the most senior ranks in the army [the General Staff] that it is not taking things seriously. We are not training sufficiently. We are not giving people the minimum means to succeed," Sukenik said.

Although since the war a major effort has been taken to restore the ground forces' readiness, this is not enough, he said.

"I did what I could to restore knowledge. It will take time for the IDF to recover from the wounds of the war .... Now they are once more talking about cuts in the defense budget. The easiest thing to do is to cut training budgets, because that is where there is big money. The result is that next year, after the cut, the readiness level will once more be low," Sukenik said.

Describing the army before the war as having "rusted," he said about one division: "Would you believe they did not have maps of the Golan Heights? They had no operational plans on a critical front. Their plans were for an entirely different front. This is the sort of vertigo the IDF found itself in."

Sukenik blames the war's failures on the conduct of the senior officers, and the confusion in the orders given. "The soldiers in the field heard in the media and in the Knesset that there would not be a ground offensive. 'We can end this with the air force,' they said. In the end it trickles down and has an effect. I say with authority: 70 to 80 percent of responsibility for the results [of the war] lie with the command and the General Staff. The gaps in readiness are not a pleasant thing, but in the end these led to only 10 to 15 percent of the final results."

Sukenik described the results of the war as "embarrassing" and said he accepted the invitation to lead an in-house probe of the performance of a division because he wanted to understand "what had happened to the most skilled group. Why did they behave this way? These are the best people we have."

He also criticized the decline in the ground forces' preparedness in the years before the war, and he himself accepted blame because he was a member of the General Staff.

"People did not understand what a mountainous passage means. An armored battalion goes into a mountainous passage [during the war] without an engineers APC [armored personnel carrier], without bulldozers - and they think that's okay. Things that used to be maxims evaporated. In the air force there is a someone leading a flight of aircraft. If he does not practice twice a month, he is not ready," Sukenik said.

"Everything is written in orders. In the ground forces the company commander is always ready, even if he has not trained all his life. This is not something you learn on the Web .... A battalion goes on a three-week training session in a year - and they trained for deployment in the Gaza Strip or Nablus, not for a major war. Unfortunately this is still not sufficiently understood. A battalion commander needs to know how to defend and attack on the Golan heights."

Sukenik said one of the biggest lessons of the war is that the IDF must deal with short-range rockets. "Since the war we made this part of our orders: The mission of every force is to end the indirect fire from its area of operations. This is a problem the commander must deal with, no one else."


Related articles:
  • Comptroller: IDF reservists didn't train properly for 5 years
  • Banana republic / Monkey business in the IDF
  • Defense sources: Winograd war probe to last at least a year
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Interfaith grandchildren
    A new group is helping U.S. seniors teach their interfaith grandkids Jewish traditions.
    Iranian war games
    Iran army to hold three-day drill amid speculation over Israeli strike.
      1.   Superpower Iran can help train IDF 04:21  |  Aounist 05/09/08
      2.   ISRAEL learned the lesson from the Leb.cross border kidnap murder 05:25  |  PETER SM 05/09/08
      3.   #1 05:43  |  ron 05/09/08
      4.   Recently, America Advised Israel to Prepare for War 05:51  |  Ron 05/09/08
      5.   Training funds for the IDF 06:32  |  Albert Edelson 05/09/08
      6.   Not really, IDF needs more tactical Brains 07:46  |  The Archives 05/09/08
      7.   Read this and BLAME EHUD OLMERT...... 07:58  |  Dagma 05/09/08
      8.   Olmert did say `We are tired of WINNING`.... 08:25  |  Dolly 05/09/08
      9.   Not war preparation, but PEACE, will bring security 08:54  |  Ivar 05/09/08
      10.   Has-been is given voice... 09:00  |  Esther 05/09/08
      11.   The man responsible for unpreparadness,Gen.Ganz slated for top 09:01  |  Absolute Sweden 05/09/08
      12.   There`s always Google 09:08  |  Clickfool 05/09/08
      13.   Something not quite right here 09:10  |  Clickfool 05/09/08
      14.   Starts in the home 09:36  |  Michael 05/09/08
      15.   Lesson learnt ? 09:38  |  Truth 05/09/08
      16.   Israels military is a known quantity 09:53  |  Natallie Durson 05/09/08
      17.   What kind of moron damages his country by announcing this stuff? 10:47  |  Steve Randolph 05/09/08
      18.   For Natallie Durson # 16 10:56  |  Clickfool 05/09/08
      19.   Israel not prepared for next War..... 10:57  |  Pathfinder 05/09/08
      20.   Olmert doing what he can to stay .... 11:11  |  Onlooker 05/09/08
      21.   Top IDF officer 11:35  |  THE TEACHER/INSTRUCT 05/09/08
      22.   #18 Clickfool 12:17  |  H 05/09/08
      23.   #10 Esther - Pls don`t be so sure always. 12:31  |  S 05/09/08
      24.   Thats exactly what Nasrallah says-maybe he`s right? 12:57  |  Alan SA 05/09/08
      25.   The Real Question is Whether Israel is Prepared for Peace 13:01  |  Johan Odin 05/09/08
      26.   CLICKY 18 IS SO RIGHT 13:27  |  Neutered Observer 05/09/08
      27.   General Staff is guilty 13:52  |  fred 05/09/08
      28.   Natallie Durson:Israels military is a known quantity 14:18  |  fk 05/09/08
      29.   ISRAEL WILL SURVIVE, IF.. 14:36  |  indrajaya 05/09/08
      30.   Olmert has NOT been Indicted yet..... 14:48  |  charlie 05/09/08
      31.   Clickfool - why are you not on the other forum 14:51  |  ChanahS 05/09/08
      32.   The Israeli Keystone Kops raid # 28 14:52  |  Clickfool 05/09/08
      33.   Even if that`s true... 15:37  |  Walter 05/09/08
      34.   #13:Clickfool, No you were told not a "divine victory" 15:46  |  Doc Holliday 05/09/08
      35.   Natallie Durson 15:47  |  lady from USA 05/09/08
      36.   # 12/13 Clickfool 16:18  |  THE TEACHER/INSTRUCT 05/09/08
      37.   To Ivar @ 9 - The Saudi Plan? 16:31  |  Dolly 05/09/08
      38.   Clickfool # 13. 16:36  |  David Nigel Braham 05/09/08
      39.   #20 Khalid bin Walid 16:42  |  derone 05/09/08
      40.   talkback is full of b/s soldiers , who have never seen abullet fi 17:10  |  vhardman 05/09/08
      41.   #23 S the answer is BIBI to Lead Israel Netanyahu`ll repair IDF 17:20  |  Big Sur 05/09/08
      42.   PROBABLY YOU NEED SHARON GUYS 17:30  |  indrajaya 05/09/08
      43.   ALL is running upside down exactly on schedule 17:40  |  Helm of Chelm 05/09/08
      44.   collecting arms to rust or arm the enemy 17:45  |  Russ T. 05/09/08
      45.   so mr Barak???? 17:46  |  michel 05/09/08
      46.   Top Army Officer 17:49  |  A. Abrahams 05/09/08
      47.   Top IDF officer, Treason 17:50  |  John 05/09/08
      48.   To fred # 27 - General Staff being those in charge........ 17:56  |  Pathfinder 05/09/08
      49.   What Israel needs is a bunch of 18:23  |  Bitin Dawg 05/09/08
      50.   Re S #23 18:32  |  Esther 05/09/08
      51.   #13 CF 18:41  |  Moshe 05/09/08
      52.   #18 CF 18:56  |  Moshe 05/09/08
      53.   Israel will win 19:54  |  arik 05/09/08
      54.   Old Ways are Gone! 20:01  |  Monitor 05/09/08
      55.   Amongst reasons left and islamists fear kadima departure 20:07  |  Arie 05/09/08
      56.   Natallie-I`m just trying to understand 20:28  |  Arie 05/09/08
      57.   Israelis - What the Hell Is Wrong With You ? 20:54  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/09/08
      58.   LISTEN TO SUKENIK 21:03  |  DENNIS MIV 05/09/08
      59.   Immoral Assignments = Low Moral=Substandard Recruits 21:24  |  Gray 05/09/08
      60.   Re S #23... additional thoughts... 21:29  |  Esther 05/09/08
      61.   # 16 Wrong, Fatmah, the #1 issue is the Israel`s willingness to.. 21:45  |  misha 05/09/08
      62.   Peace is Israel`s only option because... 21:50  |  Gray 05/09/08
      63.   For Gray # 31 21:56  |  Clickfool 05/09/08
      64.   Top IDF Officer should correct his statement: 21:59  |  Persian Hero 05/09/08
      65.   #16 Durson 22:01  |  Angus 05/09/08
      66.   #31, Gray... 22:34  |  Silvienne 05/09/08
      67.   Durson analysis IDF strategy and deployments. 22:36  |  Stephen in New York 05/09/08
      68.   Gray 31- I keep asking you your explain 22:43  |  Stephen in New York 05/09/08
      69.   Ofcourse, who is prepared for a nuke?! 22:57  |  Je! 05/09/08
      70.   Clickfool and limited options 23:18  |  DAVID KAPLAN 05/09/08
      71.   Aounist # 1 23:41  |  Sabra 05/09/08
      72.   Durson 16 23:49  |  Twogunz 05/09/08
      73.   For David Kaplan # 36 00:05  |  Clickfool 06/09/08
      74.   Lust for the End of the Jewish State 00:23  |  Moshe 06/09/08
      75.   Willing to lose 5000 IDF men? 00:35  |  Pablo B 06/09/08
      76.   If the reports are true 00:56  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/09/08
      77.   Good News!! 01:12  |  William 06/09/08
      78.   IDF KIDS SOLDIERS WERE EASY TARGETS 01:12  |  indrajaya 06/09/08
      79.   #39 89th attempt to be posted - the nitwit silvienne again 01:30  |  vhardman 06/09/08
      80.   Naysayers preparing to fight the most recent war 01:30  |  Jay Colbe 06/09/08
      81.   Thanks Stephen NY 02:45  |  Gray 06/09/08
      82.   Clickfool and Silvienne: How about... 03:15  |  Gray 06/09/08
      83.   Stephen in New York re:Gray; your answer about the USS liberty 03:18  |  American in NY 06/09/08
      84.   #2, PETER SM, no match 03:38  |  VIPER 06/09/08
      85.   #13, CLICKFOOL, WHAT! 03:41  |  VIPER 06/09/08
      86.   barak says we are ready his top general says no 04:11  |  josh 06/09/08
      87.   #62:Gray, far from only option but it would be a nice one 04:52  |  Doc Holliday 06/09/08
      88.   oh come on!!! its not like everyone doesn`t know it 04:58  |  comman knowledge 06/09/08
      89.   American in N.Y ; Info 05:34  |  Gray 06/09/08
      90.   Gray 81- Bitterness of vets about Liberty 06:02  |  Stephen in New York 06/09/08
      91.   Stephen in N.Y. NOW do you understand? 06:26  |  Gray 06/09/08
      92.   when is this idiot gray going to talk about us friendly fire 07:09  |  vhardman 06/09/08
      93.   Israel not prepared for next war 07:34  |  Shimon Cleopas 06/09/08
      94.   To Monitor # 54 - What utter rubbish...... 08:00  |  Dagma 06/09/08
      95.   That`s what happens when..... 09:25  |  Palestinian Prince 06/09/08
      96.   Persian Hero #64, let`s be realistic 09:33  |  Palestinian Prince 06/09/08
      97.   To # 92 - Shimon Cleopass - DAVID! 09:49  |  Josephus 06/09/08
      98.   Stephen in New York re Gray`s lies. 10:20  |  Ramius 06/09/08
      99.   Gray there is a reward out for your missing mind 10:29  |  Ramius 06/09/08
      100.   For Moshe # 74 10:52  |  Clickfool 06/09/08
      101.   I notice you`re safely ensconced in lovely Maryland, Moshe # 51 10:54  |  Clickfool 06/09/08
      102.   What Lebanese Arabs preparde to sacrifice 11:06  |  Rick & TC 06/09/08
      103.   For Clickfool Re: Moishe 12:19  |  Ramius 06/09/08
      104.   #60 Esther 12:26  |  S 06/09/08
      105.   The Ultimate Danger of a LIVNI Government.... 13:05  |  Dagma 06/09/08
      106.   For Ramius # 103 14:55  |  Clickfool 06/09/08
      107.   Don`t trust the UN 15:33  |  lady from USA 06/09/08
      108.   What I`m waiting for 16:14  |  BluePearl 06/09/08
      109.   Clickfool laps up his sinking beer and drops his keyboard. 16:17  |  Ramius 06/09/08
      110.   Re S #104 16:26  |  Esther 06/09/08
      111.   #96;Palestinian Prince, I was surprised by your candor 16:33  |  Doc Holliday 06/09/08
      112.   To Gray # 59 - Conscientious Objectors..... 16:40  |  Dolly 06/09/08
      113.   Josephus, Shimon Cleopas 16:44  |  lady from USA 06/09/08
      114.   Addendum re S #104 16:45  |  Esther 06/09/08
      115.   Shimon Cleopas 16:51  |  lady from USA 06/09/08
      116.   Better Army - teach children Zionism & Patriotism 17:03  |  AlexK 06/09/08
      117.   To Gray # 62 - The Islamic Expansionism ..... 17:34  |  Dagma 06/09/08
      118.   #106 not only young israelis clucking fool 17:58  |  vhardman 06/09/08
      119.   Hey Hardman 18:49  |  Ramius 06/09/08
      120.   Michael from Jerusalem 18:51  |  Persian Kitty 06/09/08
      121.   #111 wonderful news ramius , now get rid of the 19:43  |  vhardman 06/09/08
      122.   OTHER READERS Re: Ramius, Jay Cristol & other Liberty liars 20:13  |  Gray 06/09/08
      123.   Israelis in their desperation 20:20  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/09/08
      124.   Gray 91 - Alas, 20:38  |  Stephen in New York 06/09/08
      125.   Ramius - Foxbats over Dimona 20:42  |  Stephen in New York 06/09/08
      126.   American in New York 20:52  |  Stephen in New York 06/09/08
      127.   Gray and Chris are wrong 21:02  |  arik 06/09/08
      128.   Re S #104...(2nd try...) 21:18  |  Esther 06/09/08
      129.   For Aounist # 1 21:56  |  Fortuna Benmayor 06/09/08
      130.   For Tod Zuckerman # 57 21:58  |  Fortuna Benmayor 06/09/08
      131.   #62, Peace is great but how you get there.... 22:39  |  Gary 06/09/08
      132.   The Jews have no loyalty to America. 22:46  |  american 06/09/08
      133.   arik; Not quite & by the way... 23:18  |  Gray 06/09/08
      134.   #132 There are more Jews serving the US, then 100Million Arabs 23:29  |  D Prophet 06/09/08
      135.   Israel Performs Best During Crisis 00:17  |  Baruch Gold 07/09/08
      136.   Doc Holliday #96, with all due respect 00:50  |  Palestinian Prince 07/09/08
      137.   Stephen Thanks 01:26  |  Ramius 07/09/08
      138.   #16 Natalie Durson 02:35  |  Jim 07/09/08
      139.   #125, STEPHEN IN NEW YORK, riiiight, and ... 03:17  |  VIPER 07/09/08
      140.   `67 War; Israel`s Profitable Land Grab 03:17  |  Gray 07/09/08
      141.   #25 Johan Odin 03:26  |  Jim 07/09/08
      142.   More "Gray" Junk 03:53  |  Golani 07/09/08
      143.   #26 Neutered Obserrver 03:56  |  Jim 07/09/08
      144.   Jim re the 5000 men 03:57  |  Golani 07/09/08
      145.   Rip Van Gray is on ot, sweating each little cut and paste 04:19  |  Ramius 07/09/08
      146.   #29 Indrajaya 04:19  |  Jim 07/09/08
      147.   Gray 140- Were you in Israel in May, 1967? 04:23  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      148.   Ramius 04:33  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      149.   Viper- Soviet instigation started 6 day War 04:39  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      150.   #38 David Nigel Braham 05:17  |  Jim 07/09/08
      151.   #136:Palestinian Prince,that is why it`s called the fog of war 05:24  |  Doc Holliday 07/09/08
      152.   American in New York 05:36  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      153.   Good Advice 05:58  |  Reid 07/09/08
      154.   #49 Bitin Dawg Hanging on the fish hook 06:16  |  Jim 07/09/08
      155.   For my angry Ziono-pathic friends....Re: Expansionism 06:20  |  Gray 07/09/08
      156.   Gray quotes all forgeries 06:47  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      157.   74. moshe? what jewish state? 06:58  |  give me a clue 07/09/08
      158.   Gary you dissapoint me 07:11  |  Golani 07/09/08
      159.   Stephen NY; Back to lies again...#154 07:44  |  Gray 07/09/08
      160.   #72 Twoguns Who will take over? 07:47  |  Jim 07/09/08
      161.   Stephen re Robin Wright 09:04  |  Ramius 07/09/08
      162.   Stephen in NY re: Pollard, USS Liberty you dont get it 14:04  |  American in NY 07/09/08
      163.   #155:Gray, #156: Stephen in NY, great pick-up 15:32  |  Doc Holliday 07/09/08
      164.   Stephen in New York re: USS Liberty & incomplete understanding 15:45  |  American in NY 07/09/08
      165.   Gray 159-I repeat: your quotes are forgeries 17:47  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      166.   Amer in NY 162 re Liberty 17:57  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      167.   Stephen #166 Your lies for Israels attack on USS Liberty 18:40  |  American in NY 07/09/08
      168.   American in NY-you have no interest in truth 19:12  |  Stephen in New York 07/09/08
      169.   #167:American in New York, wrong on every point 19:19  |  Doc Holliday 07/09/08
      170.   Stephen #168in New York lacking logic and honesty 22:04  |  American in NY 07/09/08
      171.   Doc Holliday repeats the whitewash and lies 22:09  |  American in NY 07/09/08
      172.   Doc Holliday re now its friendly fire? 22:32  |  American in NY 07/09/08
      173.   Doc H. More Liberty lies & CAMERA...again? 23:54  |  Gray 07/09/08
      174.   American in NY-re Pollard and Liberty motive 01:55  |  Stephen in New York 08/09/08
      175.   #135, Baruch Gold...doubtful... 17:49  |  Silvienne 08/09/08
      176.   Stephen in New York # 174 19:38  |  American in NY 08/09/08
      177.   #176, American in NY... 22:49  |  Silvienne 08/09/08
     Read & React
    Muslim immigrants attack three Jewish teens in Paris
    Responses: 153
    Al Qaida No. 2: Iran waging 'crusader' war against Islam
    Responses: 69
    Police: Indict Olmert's former partner too
    Responses: 58
    Gideon Levy: Shin Bet operatives are no better than other students
    Responses: 40
    Moshe Arens: Likud must say it won't give up Golan
    Responses: 61


    More Headlines
    03:08 Police source: Olmert likely to be convicted of money-laundering
    03:37 Police pressure Olmert cronies to testify against him
    02:12 Panel completes prisoner list for possible Shalit swap
    01:42 Security sources: Israel preparing for Hezbollah terror attack in Israel, overseas
    04:12 Was suspected Netanya mob hit attempt an inside job?
    23:03 Group offers Jews $50,000 to move to U.S. Bible Belt town
    05:29 U.S. coordinator to visit Israel in last-ditch bid for security draft
    03:05 VIDEO / Israelis in D.C. suburb shaken up after swastikas painted on homes
    23:57 Livni: Kadima failed, but we'll rectify our mistakes
    00:59 Neo-Nazi youth asks court to extend jail term so he can serve in IDF
    01:40 Israel's first female ambassador submits credentials to UN
    06:21 Tourists may tread 'Pilgrim's Route,' visit W. Bank Christian sites by next year
    06:37 Massive Limmud event planned for Russian-speakers in Israel
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    JMG your online solution
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    MBA in Israel in English
    APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved