Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., January 03, 2009 Tevet 7, 5769 | | Israel Time: 04:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Comments:  58
Last update - 00:00 26/08/2008
Missing girl's mother allegedly told husband to 'get rid of her'
By Roni Singer-Heruti, Haaretz Corresponent
Tags: murder, child abuse, Israel 

The mother of 4-year-old Rose Ron, who has been missing for three months, is suspected of having told her husband, the girl's grandfather, to "get rid of her" before he allegedly murdered her.

"I don't want to see the girl any more - get rid of her," Marie-Charlotte Renault allegedly said, according to a police investigation into the affair.

Marie-Charlotte Renault left Rose's father Benjamin Pizem when the child was still an infant, later marrying her father-in-law, Rose's grandfather, Ronny Ron.
Advertisement
It emerged Tuesday that Ronny Ron, a 45-year-old Netanya resident, is suspected of having murdered Rose, stuffing her body into a suitcase which he allegedly dumped in the Yarkon River.

While police believe that Ronny Ron killed the girl alone, they also now suspect that her mother is more involved in the incident than they had initially thought.

On Tuesday morning, following more than two weeks of intensive police searches that did not turn up the suitcase, it was decided to lift a comprehensive gag order that was initially placed on all details of the case. "We couldn't stop the rumor mill surrounding the case anymore," a senior police source said.

Police said that the suspect had confessed to the murder and described it in detail, leading police to where he claimed he had dumped the body. The body has not been found.

Investigators suspect that the couple planned the murder in advance, contradicting the mother's assertion that she did not know anything about her daughter's alleged murder. Police hold evidence that shows Renault tried to cover up Ronny Ron's act.

One example of this is when she learned that Netanya welfare services and police were seeking to find out where her daughter was, she quickly contacted a friend and told him: "Get me a 5-year-old girl."

She did not explain exactly why she needed a child, but said that if she did not get hold of a girl, her husband Ronny was likely "to go to jail." In her testimony, the mother repeatedly said that when her husband said he had sent the girl to a French boarding school, she accepted this and did not ask him questions about it since she did not wish to see her daughter again.

The intricate case has been the Central Police district's top priority over the last two weeks. The investigators have dropped all other cases in favor of the search for Rose. "I have handled many investigations," said the Central District commander, "but I can't recall a single other investigation that turned all of our stomachs, that investigators came out of briefings with tears in their eyes."

Police suspect that the murder occurred last May, but the girl's disappearance was only brought to the police's attention some two weeks ago.

Rose Ron's father: Whoever did this needs to pay

Benjamin Pizem, the girl's father, on Tuesday told various Israeli TV channels that he believes his daughter was murdered.

"I look forward to knowing why all this happened, even if they find Rose in the worst circumstances. Whoever did this needs to pay," he said.

The 25-year-old said since he read about the affair in the French newspaper Le Parisien, he has tried to discover details about what transpired.

Pizem continued: "The last time I saw Rose was a year ago, in November, when our divorce [proceedings] were over and we decided that Rose would travel to Israel to Marie."

Two days ago, the police decided to appeal to the public to help in the search, even though the assumption was that she had been murdered. The reason for the decision was the fact that the suspect had given seven different versions of the events. Though the public flooded the police hotline with information, it appears that nothing substantial was fielded.

The victim's great grandmother Vivian exposed the case when she wrote a letter to the National Council for the Child saying that the girl, who had been in her care until last May, had disappeared since her son had taken her. The letter was transferred to the authorities and then to the police. Investigators quickly realized that the case involved an abduction or murder.

The investigation revealed a complicated family history. Rose Ron was born in France to French-born Marie and Pizem, an Israeli, before either had turned 20. When the she was an infant, her parents came to Israel for a visit with Pizem's family. At the end of the visit, Pizem returned to France with his daughter Rose, and Marie remained in Israel after falling in love with Pizem's father, Ronny.

The young father had difficulty raising his daughter and transferred her to a string of institutions.

Meanwhile, Marie and Ron decided to wed and the couple had two daughters. They lived in Modi'in and recently moved to Netanya. The police investigation revealed that a year ago, Marie found out that her daughter, then three years old, was hospitalized in France, apparently after having suffered abuse at the hand of her father. The mother and her new husband, the girl's grandfather, launched a legal battle to gain custody of the girl. "They had a good feeling that they were heading toward reunification. There was anticipation that this would be good for everyone, and especially for the girl," said attorney Revital Swaid, who represents the couple.

Last December, Marie was awarded custody of the girl and she was brought to Israel to the couple's small apartment in Netanya. Reality turned out to be less optimistic than the couple had originally imagined. Rose, who was apparently a victim of abuse, displayed serious communication problems, slammed her head into the wall, defecated in her pants, could barely speak French and spoke no Hebrew at all. She did not know her mother and found it difficult to form an attachment with her mother and grandfather.

The challenges posed by the child's behavior prompted the couple to neglect her. During questioning, they confessed that they had devoted very little time to her. After failing to find a suitable place for her, the couple decided to place her with the grandfather's mother, Vivian.

Vivian's repeated demands that her son care for the girl sparked a deterioration in their relationship. Vivian asked her son to stop bringing the girl to her home, but he did not comply. One day in May, following a bitter fight between them, Ron arrived at his mother's home and angrily took the girl and a suitcase, in which he put Rose's belongings. The relationship between Ron and Vivian was completely severed after the incident.

Finally, months later, when Vivian called her son to inquire about the girl she received no answer. After several more attempts to gather information, the great grandmother decided to approach the authorities.

The welfare services of the Netanya municipality tried to contact the family several times, and when their efforts failed, they notified the police. Officers arrived at the Rons' house and arrested the grandfather when he failed to provide satisfactory answers to their questions.

During questioning, Ronny initially said he had killed Rose, then recanted and told several other stories. Among other things, he said that he sold her to Arabs in the Palestinian Authority, or he had sent her to a yeshiva or that she had traveled abroad.

After his remand was extended for a second time, Ronny confessed to having murdered his granddaughter and recounted the events. He said that he had picked the girl up from his mother's house, got mad at her during the ride and struck her. He said that after hitting her he didn't hear any sounds and when he turned around he saw that her head was limp and that she wasn't breathing. He went on to say that he then panicked and decided to stuff her into the suitcase, drive to the Yarkon and dump her. He then drove to the Bavli neighborhood in Tel Aviv and dumped the body in the river, he told investigators.

When he returned home, his wife Marie was already asleep. In the morning, when she asked where her daughter was, Ronny told her that he had put her in a boarding school. He later told the police that more than anything, he was afraid that his wife would leave him if she knew what he had done. His wife, for her part, asked no more questions.

When the case broke, police arrested Ron, Marie and Vivian. The great grandmother was released to house arrest but the mother is still in custody on suspicion of failure to report a murder.


Related articles:
  • Police search for missing girl in 'one of the most shocking cases in Israel's history'
  • Girl, 4, forgotten at airport as family moves to Paris
  • Young woman, 19, suspected of trying to kill her infant son 5 times
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Rockets or balloons?
    The importance of many targets hit by the IAF military is unclear at best.
    Hamas in hiding
    Hamas leaders in Gaza know they have good reason to stay in hiding.
      1.   No words are adequate to describe this monster 12:30  |  SJ 26/08/08
      2.   French connection 13:33  |  HS 26/08/08
      3.   And still no death penalty for terrorists? WHY?? 13:38  |  Arie 26/08/08
      4.   Adults, be more observant!!!! 13:44  |  Mimmi 26/08/08
      5.   Especially a little girl nobody wants is worth a warm lap 13:48  |  AliciaYasmeen 26/08/08
      6.   Missing girl`s Grandfather did her in 14:39  |  Millicent 26/08/08
      7.   Poor baby 14:44  |  Hilda 26/08/08
      8.   Horrible story 14:55  |  Daniel Breslauer 26/08/08
      9.   Really sad and and tragic. 15:09  |  sandra chitayat 26/08/08
      10.   If anyone deserves the death penalty 15:11  |  Lynn 26/08/08
      11.   Is it Ok according to Jewish religious law to marry 15:13  |  Kms 26/08/08
      12.   Sounds like Autism or ASD 15:20  |  leven5 26/08/08
      13.   painful and heart breaking 15:20  |  simple guy 26/08/08
      14.   the guy tried to blame the arabs 15:24  |  some guy 26/08/08
      15.   Rose Ron 15:29  |  Lee Lipman 26/08/08
      16.   Little Rose 15:40  |  speechless 26/08/08
      17.   soooo sad 16:04  |  father of four 26/08/08
      18.   Im ain torah, ain derech eretz... 16:13  |  bat yam 26/08/08
      19.   too bad she didnt stay in France with her father 16:16  |  aconstant 26/08/08
      20.   I am Israel most have services to help children. 16:52  |  Jane 26/08/08
      21.   Higher Position /Higher Responsibility 17:38  |  THK 26/08/08
      22.   the littls girl 19:23  |  massimo 26/08/08
      23.   Missing Child Murdered by Grandfather 19:37  |  Jetta Lady 26/08/08
      24.   the little Angel 19:42  |  massimo 26/08/08
      25.   Horror story! 20:33  |  PH 26/08/08
      26.   Bad, but not worst 20:47  |  Dan 26/08/08
      27.   Oubliette 20:47  |  Miche Norman 26/08/08
      28.   Evil doers 22:15  |  Connie 26/08/08
      29.   Haaretz printed this??? 22:30  |  Proad Jew 26/08/08
      30.   to #8 22:35  |  Hilda 26/08/08
      31.   Slow toture for them. Send them to Iran to be finished off! 22:35  |  Mark Crespo 26/08/08
      32.   #11, Khalid 23:00  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/08/08
      33.   poor little child 23:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/08/08
      34.   #28 Say there Connie, what`s wrong? 23:45  |  ballistic 26/08/08
      35.   #11 KMS 23:47  |  ballistic 26/08/08
      36.   Waterboard & kill these monsters 23:52  |  AlexK 26/08/08
      37.   To # 19 - Aconstant 23:57  |  Noami 26/08/08
      38.   If not such a tragedy... 23:59  |  Gimpel the Fool 26/08/08
      39.   understand the problem or see it repeated 00:08  |  Bronxite10 27/08/08
      40.   I`m in love with journalism 00:10  |  S 27/08/08
      41.   "Marie-Charlotte Renault left Rose`s father Benjamin Pizem 00:32  |  totally baffled 27/08/08
      42.   #26-Dan...you`re a piece of work 00:57  |  yezmar 27/08/08
      43.   May Rose Ron Have Sanctuary In Heaven At Last 01:57  |  Jeff Northridge 27/08/08
      44.   Disgusting but, No Surprise 06:19  |  Steven 27/08/08
      45.   in respsonse t0 #42 10:33  |  Bret 27/08/08
      46.   #45, Bret 11:07  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/08/08
      47.   To Khaled and Ballistic 13:01  |  AY 27/08/08
      48.   #39 Bronxite 10 15:57  |  AliciaYasmeen 27/08/08
      49.   The Angel is Dead 16:00  |  Franz 27/08/08
      50.   #11 16:29  |  S 27/08/08
      51.   rose 17:27  |  mohd amin 27/08/08
      52.   So very sad 19:14  |  American 27/08/08
      53.   Lack of Torah 21:18  |  ScotGuy 27/08/08
      54.   Israel`s accomplishments in Godliness need a little work 22:20  |  Jesus Domeguez 27/08/08
      55.   To Jesus D. #52 10:48  |  Israeli Jew 28/08/08
      56.   Errors 10:50  |  Israeli 28/08/08
      57.   DAN YOU HAVE MY SYMPATHY 04:24  |  Mona 12/09/08
      58.   ALYCIAYASMEEN 04:39  |  Mona 12/09/08
     Read & React
    Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff / Now IDF is getting personal with Hamas
    Responses: 57
    Yossi Sarid / If you (or I) were Palestinian
    Responses: 69
    Anshel Pfeffer / Right and Left, Diaspora Jews more critical of Israel than ever
    Responses: 53
    Arthur Neslen / May be time to bring Hamas in from the cold
    Responses: 12
    Bradley Burston: To win in Gaza, Israel only has to survive
    Responses: 32


    More Headlines
    03:35 Bush: Hamas attacks on Israel are an 'act of terror'
    00:30 Hamas: Israel faces more abducted soldiers if it invades Gaza
    21:39 Palestinian official: Egypt in talks with Hamas on restoring Gaza calm
    22:24 IAF strikes more than 30 Hamas targets in Gaza
    23:07 Palestinian police ban pro-Hamas rallies in West Bank
    00:14 Did the IAF bomb a Gazan welding truck or a Hamas Grad transport?
    14:06 Gaza 2009 - To win, all Israel has to do is survive
    00:57 Technion, Yeshiva University, Hadassah lower loss estimates in Madoff scandal
    01:30 Grad rocket fired from Gaza strikes Ashkelon home
    22:10 Rights group Amnesty International says U.S. response to Gaza 'lopsided'
    23:39 IDF phones Gaza residents to warn them of imminent strikes
    16:46 Protests against Gaza assault sweep the Mideast
    20:24 Israel lets Palestinians with foreign passports flee Gaza
    16:30 'Anarchists' block entrance to IAF base in protest of Gaza strikes
    12:00 ANALYSIS / IDF sending Hamas a message: Now it's personal
    13:33 Shin Bet: Number of terror attacks on Israel swelled in 2008
    07:38 Steven Klein / When and how will Israel end Gaza operation?
    06:21 Yossi Sarid / If you (or I) were Palestinian
    23:00 Gideon Levy / Amid exploding rockets, Negev life carries on
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Summer in Israel
    Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
    You can make a direct IMPACT!
    on the life of an Israeli soldier
    State of Israel Bonds
    During this time of market volatility, Israel bonds can help.
    SURF RAMBAM
    Keep current about new-wave medical care, education and research.
    Summer Camp in Israel
    The best place for your children this summer
    Academic Studies in Israel
    All the Q & A at the IDC HERZLIYA Open House, January 9,2009
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved