Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., August 26, 2008 Av 25, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 08:51 24/08/2008
Ma`aleh Adumim mayor to appeal new West Bank fence route
By Tomer Zarchin, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: separation fence 

The mayor of the biggest settlement in the West Bank, Ma'aleh Adumim, said Friday that he intends to appeal the state's decision to relocate part of the West Bank separation fence.

The state attorney's office has said that in response to court petitions by Palestinian landowners it would reroute a section of the barrier running east of Maaleh Adumim, restoring Palestinian access to about 1,000 acres of farming and grazing land which the original plan would have placed on the Israeli side.

"We shall fight this by all means at our disposal," Maaleh Adumim mayor Benny Kashriel told Army Radio Friday.
Advertisement
"In the court and through public opinion."

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Defense Minister Ehud Barak had decided to reroute the West Bank separation fence, to enure that the barrier does not encroach on Palestinian land.

A government statement said the new route represented a significant change in plans for the barrier to the east.

Also on Thursday, nine protesters were lightly wounded when Israel Defense Forces troops fired rubber bullets during a demonstration against the separation fence in the West Bank village of Na'alin.

Related articles:
  • Israel agrees to raze part of West Bank separation fence
  • Court orders state to alter West Bank separation fence route at Bil'in
  • UN: West Bank fence severs Palestinans farmers from fields
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Bad company
    Madonna draws ire for picturing John McCain near Hitler during a recent show.
    Raw energy
    An unemployed Israeli ecologist has a solution to the fuel crisis and global warming.
      1.   Capitulation flows in the veins of Israelis 16:54  |  Absolute Sweden 21/08/08
      2.   AND IN RETURN ISRAEL GETS NOTHING in return AS USUAL 16:56  |  jewish doctor 21/08/08
      3.   Open Desert Belongs to Palestinians ? 17:08  |  Tom 21/08/08
      4.   Amazing. 17:28  |  Ibrahim 21/08/08
      5.   All Part of Olmert`s Going Out of Business Sale 17:31  |  Erich 21/08/08
      6.   Supreme Court of Palestinian Justice 17:44  |  AlexK 21/08/08
      7.   Let`s hope they implement this 17:51  |  Sylvie 21/08/08
      8.   Maaleh Adumim 17:53  |  Mike Friedman 21/08/08
      9.   #2`s falacy 17:57  |  james 21/08/08
      10.   no palestine 18:00  |  james 21/08/08
      11.   good ruling 18:10  |  rm 21/08/08
      12.   Finally, Pals use laws instead of bombs 18:22  |  Lynn 21/08/08
      13.   Olmert and Barak 19:31  |  Edifice 21/08/08
      14.   Law, Not Politics 19:57  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/08/08
      15.   #2 Jewish Doctor in GA 20:29  |  johnj 21/08/08
      16.   Lynn - dumb posting of the day 21:13  |  Sylvie 21/08/08
      17.   Why is Olmert & his government still here? New elections now. 21:34  |  bat yam 21/08/08
      18.   Tom thats great 22:01  |  Dave Duncan 21/08/08
      19.   James 23:53  |  pamela 21/08/08
      20.   Wish at least that sort of independant justice in arab states 00:26  |  Arthur 22/08/08
      21.   Ibrahim #4: I agree, the Wall WILL need more adjustments - 00:52  |  ivo 22/08/08
      22.   Doctor (#2) 01:44  |  jjvanka 22/08/08
      23.   But, of course, they won`t actually *move* it. 01:49  |  Johnboy 22/08/08
      24.   Maale Adumim 03:54  |  Joseph 22/08/08
      25.   To James 04:53  |  Motale 22/08/08
      26.   To James 04:58  |  Motale 22/08/08
      27.   #15 johnj 05:51  |  John Allen 22/08/08
      28.   #2 Jewish Doctor: In return for what? they aren`t giving anything 06:26  |  David Appletree 22/08/08
      29.   #18 Dave Duncan: They don`t really have a Plan 06:34  |  David Appletree 22/08/08
      30.   #14 No Mark, this is politics 06:39  |  Johnboy 22/08/08
      31.   #11 rm is another who doesn`t understand what this is. 06:51  |  Johnboy 22/08/08
      32.   21/22 Johnboy - Coulda Sworn 07:47  |  Mark of Lewiston 22/08/08
      33.   sylvie..please enlighten us with some figures 07:59  |  meir gush etzion 22/08/08
      34.   favour my foot... 09:34  |  ravi 22/08/08
      35.   To mark of Lewiston and Johnboy 10:16  |  rm 22/08/08
      36.   The Mayor should focus on relocating M. A. West of the Green Line 11:02  |  Ivar 22/08/08
      37.   The +plusses+ of derouting the fence to the Israeli side 12:04  |  AliciaYasmeen 22/08/08
      38.   Nice gesture, more Arab terror in return, now try something else 12:06  |  Harvey 22/08/08
      39.   Meir Gush Etzion 12:08  |  Mike Friedman 22/08/08
      40.   Neverending Theft 12:21  |  Walid 22/08/08
      41.   Sylvie 12:33  |  Walid 22/08/08
      42.   i wonder where he plans on getting the public opinion? 12:50  |  eric 22/08/08
      43.   RM & Johnboy - Evolving Story 13:11  |  Mark of Lewiston 22/08/08
      44.   #8 Mike Friedman - "that hideous city" 13:35  |  Yonatan 22/08/08
      45.   #10 james - Tell me something about Palestine 13:42  |  Yonatan 22/08/08
      46.   Johnboy # 30 There Are Precedents Though 13:45  |  Jeff Northridge 22/08/08
      47.   # 36 alicia 13:46  |  Axel 22/08/08
      48.   Have you been to Maale Adumin 13:54  |  jackie 22/08/08
      49.   Alicia Yasmeen # 36 Where Is The "Israeli Side"? 14:22  |  Jeff Northridge 22/08/08
      50.   #33 Walid: get your record straight! 14:26  |  AliciaYasmeen 22/08/08
      51.   The mayor is a land thief! 15:05  |  American Patriot 22/08/08
      52.   Mike Freedman # 38 The Security Barrier 15:24  |  Jeff Northridge 22/08/08
      53.   # 36 Alicia Yasmeen.....exactly, 15:38  |  Lynn 22/08/08
      54.   #16 sylvie.......too bad your pessimism 15:46  |  Lynn 22/08/08
      55.   Your answer, Jeff Northridge 16:14  |  Murray 22/08/08
      56.   #47 alice forgets the negev and kinneret 16:50  |  v.hardman 22/08/08
      57.   #46 Jeff: true! But this measure shuts them up. 17:02  |  AliciaYasmeen 22/08/08
      58.   Yes, Yonatan, I have been there 17:03  |  Mike Friedman 22/08/08
      59.   #19 Pam 17:07  |  james 22/08/08
      60.   Not pessimism Lynn 17:07  |  Sylvie 22/08/08
      61.   #48 "American Patriot" 17:09  |  Yonatan 22/08/08
      62.   #49 Jeff Northridge on "Mike Freedman" 17:11  |  Yonatan 22/08/08
      63.   Re- Sylvie 17:13  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      64.   Re- Mike Friedman 17:16  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      65.   Re-James 17:19  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      66.   To Dave Duncan 17:31  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      67.   To ravi 17:46  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      68.   Re- Mike Friedman 17:55  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      69.   # 47 alicia 17:56  |  Axel 22/08/08
      70.   Walid 17:59  |  lady from USA 22/08/08
      71.   Here`s a better Idea 18:03  |  ID 22/08/08
      72.   # 45 jackie 18:05  |  Axel 22/08/08
      73.   How Israel can get rid of Maale Adumim 18:52  |  Tosefta 22/08/08
      74.   Think About It 18:56  |  Reason 22/08/08
      75.   49# howdy Jeff Land Gabbing in whatever angle one look at it. 19:13  |  Randy 22/08/08
      76.   Assertions re property rights verus lives 19:28  |  R`fael Moshe 22/08/08
      77.   #37 Harvey you are right. Unfortunately Bloody right 19:30  |  Big Sur 22/08/08
      78.   The problem is Ma`Aleh Adumim. It is an illegal settlement. 19:37  |  Jozef 22/08/08
      79.   Lynn, Jeff Northridge 20:08  |  Mark of Lewiston 22/08/08
      80.   Not Content With 80% Of Palestine.... 20:17  |  Gray 22/08/08
      81.   A Wall Is A Wall Is A Wall and... 20:30  |  Gray 22/08/08
      82.   Ibrahim really amazing 21:36  |  David Israel 22/08/08
      83.   Peace against fence 21:58  |  V 22/08/08
      84.   CARNAGE IN YOUR HICHWAYS 22:19  |  SALAM CANTOR 22/08/08
      85.   yonatan- trying to spin the truth with bs 22:28  |  yezmar 22/08/08
      86.   .#2 to yonatan..some questions for you 22:40  |  yezmar 22/08/08
      87.   #42 Yonaton 00:56  |  mike 23/08/08
      88.   Sylvie 01:00  |  mike 23/08/08
      89.   Pamela, another lost soul. 01:02  |  mike 23/08/08
      90.   Jackie -beauty is in the eye of the beholder.. 01:19  |  Palestinian Brit 23/08/08
      91.   # 47 alicia 01:21  |  Axel 23/08/08
      92.   Yezmar, quite wrong 01:31  |  Science 23/08/08
      93.   #57 CAN`TOR........ Won`t; 01:34  |  Gray 23/08/08
      94.   David Israel, regarding Ibrahim #55 01:38  |  Palestinian Prince 23/08/08
      95.   To mike 01:58  |  avi 23/08/08
      96.   #35 rm, you are MEANT to be confused 02:28  |  Johnboy 23/08/08
      97.   #43 Jeff, this is pretty simple 02:43  |  Johnboy 23/08/08
      98.   #57 Salam Cantor - Don`t be so concerned 02:53  |  * BEN JABO 23/08/08
      99.   #60 Mike - I`ll prove it, then it`s your turn 03:05  |  * BEN JABO 23/08/08
      100.   Johnboy # 70 It`s Not That Simple (part 1) 04:08  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      101.   Johnboy # 80 It`s Not That Simple (part 2) 04:54  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      102.   #100 Jeff shows his simple-mindedness 06:33  |  Johnboy 23/08/08
      103.   #101 Ahem, Jeff....... 06:41  |  Johnboy 23/08/08
      104.   #100 I`ll try and explain this one more time Jeff. 06:51  |  Johnboy 23/08/08
      105.   Johnboy 07:55  |  Daniela 23/08/08
      106.   Johnboy; Kudos but good luck 08:26  |  Gray 23/08/08
      107.   Lady from USA - grab that land? 08:27  |  Palestinian Brit 23/08/08
      108.   Ben Jabo - waste of space 08:32  |  Palestinian Brit 23/08/08
      109.   YONATON, you want Palestine? 09:46  |  ELIAS KHOURY 23/08/08
      110.   tosefta #73, that`s asking israel 09:50  |  Michael McKenna 23/08/08
      111.   A little help for Jeff ... 11:31  |  Axel 23/08/08
      112.   David Israel 11:36  |  Walid 23/08/08
      113.   #91 AXEL, the ref.s you asked for 11:39  |  AliciaYasmeen 23/08/08
      114.   Jackie 11:53  |  Walid 23/08/08
      115.   #73 Tosefta, Ma´ale Adumim is not a problem to Israel 12:12  |  AliciaYasmeen 23/08/08
      116.   # 48 jackie 12:12  |  Axel 23/08/08
      117.   Where there is a will there is a Wall. 13:10  |  Labhras 23/08/08
      118.   #85 jezmar - You contradict yourself 13:10  |  Yonatan 23/08/08
      119.   Where there is a will there is a Wall. 13:11  |  Harry 23/08/08
      120.   #57AliciaYasmeen, utter rubbish 13:16  |  Ben Alofs 23/08/08
      121.   Maaleh Adumim is an illegal settlement 13:16  |  John 23/08/08
      122.   #112 labarse of arabia and tikk as 2 short planks 13:28  |  v.hardman 23/08/08
      123.   Tosefta, since when is Maale Adumim a thorn in the eye of Pals? 13:29  |  ivo 23/08/08
      124.   Alicia 13:35  |  ballistic 23/08/08
      125.   #86 - Anwers to your questions - PART 1 14:46  |  Yonatan 23/08/08
      126.   #86 yezmar - Answers to your questions - Part 2 14:54  |  Yonatan 23/08/08
      127.   Motale 15:19  |  noor 23/08/08
      128.   Axel # 106 The CIA Figures Are Tentative 15:47  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      129.   #114 Ben Alofs, you`re right: we see what we choose to see 15:59  |  AliciaYasmeen 23/08/08
      130.   dr ben and problems with the armistice line 1949 16:19  |  v.hardman 23/08/08
      131.   Johnboy # 102 The Secondary Purpose 16:53  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      132.   Re- David Israel 16:54  |  lady from USA 23/08/08
      133.   This wall......... 16:55  |  T A Sheppard 23/08/08
      134.   To yezmar 17:02  |  lady from USA 23/08/08
      135.   Walid 17:05  |  David Israel 23/08/08
      136.   # 108 alicia 17:13  |  Axel 23/08/08
      137.   121 lady 17:16  |  Axel 23/08/08
      138.   Some facts of life (A Yasmeen #73) 17:19  |  Tosefta 23/08/08
      139.   AXEL STILL GRINDING THE HALF SHAFTS 17:19  |  v.hardman 23/08/08
      140.   #116 Paul Harris in TA aka Victor Hardman 17:29  |  Labhras 23/08/08
      141.   Johnboy # 103 You Can`t Have One Without The Other 17:35  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      142.   the nerve of settlers 17:35  |  ayboday 23/08/08
      143.   re David Israel 17:42  |  T A Sheppard 23/08/08
      144.   #119 jeff 17:47  |  Axel 23/08/08
      145.   Urgent offer for exchanging Slowman 18:09  |  Beijing Zoo 23/08/08
      146.   114 Ben Olofs The Israelis are going to get what`s coming to them 18:09  |  Dutch 23/08/08
      147.   absolutely right! 18:16  |  Space 23/08/08
      148.   TA sheppard 18:19  |  David Israel 23/08/08
      149.   Johnboy # 104 The IVth Geneva Convention 18:28  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      150.   Terrorist mayor wants to expand the ethnic cleansing settlements 18:28  |  anti-racist 23/08/08
      151.   Re Alicia #110 18:28  |  Esther 23/08/08
      152.   #108 AliciaYasmeen 18:54  |  Boycott 23/08/08
      153.   Some facts of life (A Yasmeen #73) 18:57  |  Tosefta 23/08/08
      154.   Jeff fails in Law--now trys Maths 19:47  |  Labhras 23/08/08
      155.   David Israel 19:55  |  Walid 23/08/08
      156.   Johnboy; Good job 20:03  |  Gray 23/08/08
      157.   Johnboy # 104 Article 4, IVth GC 20:18  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      158.   #127 AXEL 20:45  |  AliciaYasmeen 23/08/08
      159.   Mike & Aesthetics#8 20:56  |  Meir 23/08/08
      160.   "139 Jeff Northridge who cant stand dates or borders 20:59  |  Labhras 23/08/08
      161.   #134 Esther, why should Israel feel false guilt? 21:00  |  AliciaYasmeen 23/08/08
      162.   Labhras # 136 Of Course Not 21:21  |  Jeff Northridge 23/08/08
      163.   # 141 alicia 21:23  |  Axel 23/08/08
      164.   # 142 meir 21:27  |  Axel 23/08/08
      165.   Gray 139 21:30  |  jackie 23/08/08
      166.   # 132 jeff 21:31  |  Axel 23/08/08
      167.   Thank you walid 21:43  |  jackie 23/08/08
      168.   #135 Boycott, Transjordan and British betrayal 21:54  |  AliciaYasmeen 23/08/08
      169.   There were no farms 21:58  |  Jackie 23/08/08
      170.   140 Jeff Northridge - Right of Reestablishment 21:58  |  Mark of Lewiston 23/08/08
      171.   PA shepperd 2nd try 22:09  |  David Israel 23/08/08
      172.   Walid 22:10  |  David Israel 23/08/08
      173.   114 Ben Olofs, Re : Buildup in the Ma`aleh Adumim 22:11  |  Dutch 23/08/08
      174.   #100 Jeff of the cranial security Barrier 22:19  |  Labhras 23/08/08
      175.   self-destruction 22:36  |  lebaneese 23/08/08
      176.   Walid - Baruch Goldstein - Samir Kuntar 22:37  |  David Israel 23/08/08
      177.   labarse of arabia and law! murphys bar on a saturday night 22:49  |  vhardman 23/08/08
      178.   to Yasmeen 22:49  |  Lebaneese 23/08/08
      179.   # 141 alicia 23:02  |  Axel 23/08/08
      180.   # 132 jeff the deaf 23:07  |  Axel 23/08/08
      181.   # 143 jackie 23:10  |  Axel 23/08/08
      182.   To Jackie in Florida 23:46  |  Lebaneese 23/08/08
      183.   143 Jackie - Skimming vs Reading 23:57  |  Mark of Lewiston 23/08/08
      184.   Labhras # 148 Produce It Or Back Off 00:01  |  Jeff Northridge 24/08/08
      185.   Mark of Lewiston # 144 That Depends 01:42  |  Jeff Northridge 24/08/08
      186.   to #18 Dave 01:45  |  B`Galil 24/08/08
      187.   Some facts of life (A Yasmeen #73) 01:52  |  Tosefta 24/08/08
      188.   VII.1 Judge Jeff, the Legal Eagle: Legalizing Settlements #132 01:54  |  Tosefta 24/08/08
      189.   VII.2 Judge Jeff, the Legal Eagle: Legalizing Settlements #132 01:55  |  Tosefta 24/08/08
      190.   We accept no limitations our our right to settle our land! 02:11  |  Chaim 24/08/08
      191.   My forefathers 02:33  |  Jackie 24/08/08
      192.   Sorry Mark 02:38  |  Jackie 24/08/08
      193.   Mike , actually, most palestinians have not 02:54  |  jj 24/08/08
      194.   to mike 2 03:01  |  jj 24/08/08
      195.   #164 Jeff having a bad day at the office. 03:10  |  Labhras 24/08/08
      196.   Jeff fails in Law--now trys Maths 2nd try JEFF 03:15  |  Labhras 24/08/08
      197.   to mike 1 actually the majority of the pals were not there for 03:17  |  jj 24/08/08
      198.   Jackie - NYT Convinced 03:38  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/08/08
      199.   185 Chaim , That tiny land will never be Israelis 04:48  |  Dutch 24/08/08
      200.   Tosefta # 190 & 191 Old Canned Posts 05:08  |  Jeff Northridge 24/08/08
      201.   #157 Jeff wants us all to feel the vibe! feel the vibe! 05:10  |  Johnboy 24/08/08
      202.   Labhras # 202 The Law Produced Does Not Apply 05:50  |  Jeff Northridge 24/08/08
      203.   Chaim; If it`s your land, then... 06:37  |  Gray 24/08/08
      204.   #199 kiwi fruitcake. Calling this post gutter level is flattery. 08:35  |  Chaim 24/08/08
      205.   #206 Dutch. Israel is ours now and forever. 08:39  |  Chaim 24/08/08
      206.   #208 Gray. How do the Americans pay for Israel? 08:45  |  Chaim 24/08/08
      207.   Appeal to Jeff the Judge from Germany 13:09  |  Axel 24/08/08
      208.   #108 Palestinian Brit 15:38  |  * BEN JABO 24/08/08
      209.   #141 2nd try to correct Jeff. 18:11  |  Johnboy 24/08/08
      210.   # 205 chaim 18:59  |  Axel 24/08/08
      211.   Chaim, Re 14 justices and one unanimous ruling... 20:49  |  Dutch 24/08/08
      212.   #171 David Israel What Was All that About?( Fifth Try) 21:51  |  KATHY 24/08/08
      213.   # 209 johnboy 00:11  |  Axel 25/08/08
      214.   #157 Point of order, Jeff...... 01:01  |  Johnboy 25/08/08
      215.   #149 That isn`t an argument you can win, Jeff. 02:14  |  Johnboy 25/08/08
      216.   #155 Walid Youare wrong.You forget the attacks in Hebron. 03:10  |  Benny 25/08/08
      217.   #172 David Israel spot On.And without a preamble You`ve said it. 03:16  |  Benny 25/08/08
      218.   #202 Jeff preens in front of the mirror.... 05:24  |  Johnboy 25/08/08
      219.   #190 Then Israel needs to claim it, Chaim. 05:38  |  Johnboy 25/08/08
      220.   #208-2 Palestinian Brit - Cat got your tongue? 15:02  |  * BEN JABO 25/08/08
      221.   #146 Dutch - And we thought you were going 15:04  |  * BEN JABO 25/08/08
     Read & React
    Gilad Shalit becomes punchline for jokes in the Gaza Strip
    Responses: 111
    ANALYSIS / On verge of Rice visit, Israel and PA far from peace accord
    Responses: 28
    Akiva Eldar: Let settlers who refuse evacuation in peace deal stay in Palestine
    Responses: 57
    Israel not planning to detain activists' boats leaving Gaza
    Responses: 32
    Rosner's Domain
    One State solution? Let the debate begin
    What killed the campaign for Darfur?
    Better chances for a Lieberman VP?
    Poll: Who will be better as leader of the Kadima Party?


    More Headlines
    00:09 Obama: World must press Iran before Israel strikes
    02:26 Abbas: No peace until all Palestinian prisoners released
    18:21 Rice arrives in Israel in bid to push forward Israel-PA talks
    23:03 Israel foiled the Gaza blockade-busting boat 'provocation' - but who gets the credit?
    02:34 Barak puts Tel Aviv apartment up for sale for NIS 40 million
    02:39 Hitler and McCain: Madonna's photo montage angers GOP presidential nominee
    23:19 Can an unknown Israeli save the world from ecological disaster?
    23:48 Israel to shut Gaza border crossings following Qassam strike
    23:45 Gilad Shalit becomes punchline for jokes in the Gaza Strip
    22:47 Mofaz slams Livni for supporting release of Palestinian prisoners
    02:31 As convention kicks off, Democrats say U.S. Jews will overcome fears of Obama
    20:47 Syrian FM: No headway made in negotiations with Israel
    22:34 Israel Bank raises interest rate for second time in a month
    22:25 Democratic Convention Notes: Meet Chinese Jewish candidate Hank Eng
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    MBA in Israel in English
    APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved