Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., August 15, 2008 Av 14, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:16 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 09:01 12/08/2008
The Taiwan of the Middle East
By Aluf Benn
Tags: Israel, Gaza Strip 

Three years after the disengagement, the Taiwan of the Middle East is taking shape in the Gaza Strip - a "rebellious province" of the Palestinian Authority whose government is not internationally recognized, subject to meddling by regional and international superpowers.

Gaza and Taiwan? The comparison seems absurd. One is a fenced-off enclave of 1.5 million poor, unemployed Palestinians, the other is an economic tiger. One is characterized by street battles and violence, the other is a state of law. In one, a terrorist organization is consolidating its rule by force, the other has elections and changes of government.

But it is a mistake to compare Gaza to the peaceful, developed Taiwan of today. Rather, one must remember the circumstances in which Taiwan was established as an independent entity almost 60 years ago: It emerged from a civil war that broke out following the end of a foreign occupation. It, too, experienced severe violence, a repressive government and a shattered economy.
Advertisement
Just like the Fatah government in Ramallah and Hamas in Gaza, the two Chinese governments - in Taipei and Beijing - also both claimed to be the legitimate ruler of all China, and each demanded that the world boycott the other. Taiwan exists today thanks to American patronage, without diplomatic recognition, and subject to constant fear that continental China, which views it as a rebellious province, will once again try to take it over. Taiwan's economic boom preceded that of mainland China by a generation and served as a model for it.

In Gaza, a similar situation is developing. Hamas is consolidating its rule, ignoring the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah and claiming legitimacy as the party that won the last election. Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) enjoys international recognition as the president of all Palestinians, in the West Bank and Gaza alike, and denies the legality of the Hamas government, but has no power or standing in Gaza.

It is frequently claimed that Ariel Sharon did not hand Gaza over to Abbas properly, and therefore, it fell to Hamas. But that is a mistake. It is doubtful that a public embrace by Sharon, whom Palestinians viewed as a cruel and bitter enemy, would have bolstered Abbas' legitimacy. Abbas' error was that instead of waiting for Israel to do him favors, he should have moved his family and his government from Ramallah to Gaza and remained there until he had imposed order and jump-started the economy.

Every week, world leaders and foreign ministers would come visit him, and during their visits, they would press Israel to open the border crossings, approve construction of a Gaza port and allow development of the Strip's natural gas fields. But Abbas, instead of running things himself, left control of Gaza to low-level functionaries and local clans. Hamas swept them aside almost effortlessly.

The second mistake was that of the international community, which insisted on basing Gaza's economy on agriculture - specifically, the greenhouses left behind by Gush Katif. Agriculture requires land and water, both of which are in very short supply in Gaza, as well as rapid access to markets, which depends on a problematic transit through Israel. Instead of making Gaza's existence dependent on the Karni crossing, which was sure to experience closures and security problems, the PA and its donors should have built a high-tech industry in the Strip.

Does that seem delusional? Why? After all, Gaza has no raw materials, but it does have the most valuable resource of the 21st century: a young, energetic population with free time. Just like Taiwan after the Chinese civil war. It is both necessary and possible to teach Gaza residents to test and develop software at competitive prices. High-tech exports require no physical shipping. You hit "send," and the file is on its way - without trucks, checkpoints, X-ray machines or political restrictions.

This idea was presented to the World Bank's representative, but he dismissed it scornfully: "That's good for the long term." That was a mistake. The long term is a collection of short terms. What is not begun now will never materialize in the future. The American administration and the World Bank wasted time finalizing the Agreement on Movement and Access with Israel, which, predictably, was promptly violated. Gaza remained with neither agriculture nor high-tech. Just shortages.

The good news is that it is not too late. If Hamas quells the internal violence, enforces the truce with Israel and internalizes its responsibilities toward Gaza's residents, it can build a new economy in Gaza. But it should not waste time on agriculture; it should train unemployed Palestinians for modern jobs and gradually wean Gaza from its dependence on Israel for transit.

This will not end the conflict or eliminate terror. But if the distress were eased, if Gaza residents were employed and if the storm brewing under the surface were calmed, that would be a huge achievement. And should Gaza flourish, that would also give hope to Palestinians in the West Bank.

Delusional? Absurd? Look at Taiwan.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Robbed in the war zone
Two Haaretz journalists robbed by armed Russian troops in Georgian city of Gori.
The Jewish Brad Pitt
Hollywood star plays American-Jewish hillbilly in the latest Tarantino film.
  1.   If my Grandmother had balls..... 09:18  |  A Jew 12/08/08
  2.   hh 09:19  |  x 12/08/08
  3.   Delusional? Ma Pitom 09:21  |  Dov 12/08/08
  4.   You just don`t get it 09:34  |  Ofer 12/08/08
  5.   israeli leaders have another strategies in their h minds!! 09:49  |  bashaar saleem 12/08/08
  6.   The Taiwan of the Middle East 10:00  |  M. Anthony 12/08/08
  7.   Vision 10:01  |  Brad Farman 12/08/08
  8.   Gaza- The Taiwan of ME: IF, IF IF......... 10:06  |  Rachel 12/08/08
  9.   err..a few basic differences.. like control of borders.. 11:44  |  SD 12/08/08
  10.   Hamas has a root problem: not deep enough 11:54  |  king of Israel 12/08/08
  11.   Gazans beat their swords into ploughshares 11:59  |  x-ray 12/08/08
  12.   The comparison is to Bangladesh 12:24  |  Ilan 12/08/08
  13.   Lunatics like Aluf Benn have been brain-washing Israelis for almo 12:33  |  Absolute Sweden 12/08/08
  14.   Fool For Thought 12:34  |  eva 12/08/08
  15.   Hamas maybe closer to Irgun? 13:39  |  Aaron 12/08/08
  16.   Absurd comparison 14:03  |  Mibble 12/08/08
  17.   TAIWAN Not a bunch of clans killing each other&without a charter 15:10  |  PETER SM 12/08/08
  18.   Not a question of Abbas receiving a "public embrace by Sharon" 16:12  |  newageblues 12/08/08
  19.   Aluf Benn`s fantasy 17:11  |  Brod 12/08/08
  20.   Interesting article, Aluf Benn 17:20  |  Ben Alofs 12/08/08
  21.   Aluf Benn is off his meds again 18:13  |  Gee 12/08/08
  22.   One more difference 18:20  |  KUTW 12/08/08
  23.   What is wrong with the greenhouses? 18:24  |  KUTW 12/08/08
  24.   #20 ben Alofs....no, the Gulf states have NOT 18:27  |  Lynn 12/08/08
  25.   They could, indeed. The point is if they want 18:27  |  KUTW 12/08/08
  26.   Ben Alofs 20 19:32  |  ChanahS 12/08/08
  27.   The only way to turn Gaza into Taiwan... 20:13  |  Terry 12/08/08
  28.   On the other hand if we were to imagine... 20:17  |  Scharker Yid 12/08/08
  29.   Aluf Benn, have you ? 20:19  |  zeev 12/08/08
  30.   Aluf Benn is correct, economics is the key... 20:20  |  Smadar 12/08/08
  31.   Ben Alofs, it`s always nice to read your measured analysis 20:34  |  BBSNews 12/08/08
  32.   Valuing the future more than the past 20:40  |  Gb 12/08/08
  33.   24. Smadar: economics is the key... 20:43  |  KUTW 12/08/08
  34.   TAIWANESE HAD DREAMS OF A NEW LIFE,NOT HATRED AND DEATH 20:45  |  Jorge 12/08/08
  35.   An Israeli marionette show 21:02  |  Natallie Durson 12/08/08
  36.   The ignorancy of Aluf Benn is incredible 22:26  |  Victor 12/08/08
  37.   what a sad joke! 22:31  |  eddie 12/08/08
  38.   Aluf Benn, have you ? 22:39  |  zeev 12/08/08
  39.   to Jorge #32 - poor little neighbour 22:58  |  zeev 12/08/08
  40.   hamas and the pals will put a man on the moon before they 23:08  |  neil armstrong 12/08/08
  41.   are you out of your mind. they know only to turn gold into merd 00:23  |  ralph 13/08/08
  42.   Zeev from Beer Sheva (yeah right) 39 00:34  |  ChanahS 13/08/08
  43.   Shtarke Yid 28 00:38  |  ChanahS 13/08/08
  44.   #24 Nonsense Lynn - educate yourself 01:12  |  Roo 13/08/08
  45.   # 27 Terry ..I have One Thing to Say:What An Insult To Taiwanese 03:10  |  K 13/08/08
  46.   on whos terms 03:27  |  billy jack 13/08/08
  47.   yes Bashar, what a profound suggestion, wait wait 04:48  |  jj 13/08/08
  48.   Missed one simple point: there΄re few Chinese in Gaza.. 06:38  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 13/08/08
  49.   this article did make me laugh 10:01  |  zionist forever 13/08/08
  50.   instead of talking about destroying zionists learn from them 10:28  |  zionist forever 13/08/08
  51.   ChanahS #42 - faulty reasoning 01:25  |  zeev 15/08/08
 Read & React
PMO: Israel won't take in any Palestinian refugees
Responses: 247
Georgia president denies Israel halted military aid
Responses: 40
Editorial: Israel must tone down its warmongering
Responses: 47
Ari Shavit: Russia is as threatening to the West as radical Islam
Responses: 71
Yair Sheleg: Silent settler majority must speak out againt its violent youth
Responses: 25


More Headlines
01:19 Nasrallah: 'Failed' Israeli generals caused Georgia defeat in war
00:27 Georgia Pres.: Russian tanks moving deeper into my country
01:43 ANALYSIS / By failing to aid Georgia, Israel harming efforts against Iran nukes
00:19 Olmert aides: Talansky's evasion of court shows he can't be trusted
22:06 Ahmadinejad, Turkish leaders fail to agree on proposed energy deals
00:30 Olympics / Swimmer returns to Israel after smashing records
16:22 Brad Pitt becomes Jewish hillbilly in new Tarantino film
08:14 Haaretz newsletter: All the news from Israel direct to your inbox
21:31 'If we die, Abbas is to blame,' say Fatah fugitives stranded in Gaza
01:55 Phone company's 'Einstein' ads shelved due to Hebrew U. copyright row
23:05 UN: We've cleared half the cluster bombs Israel dropped on Lebanon
21:24 Two Haaretz journalists robbed by armed Russian troops in Georgia
21:19 B'tselem: IDF only launched 4 probes into 189 Palestinian deaths
21:21 State won't distribute anti-nerve gas drug with gas mask kits
Previous Editions