Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., February 28, 2009 Adar 4, 5769 | | Israel Time: 06:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Comments:  173
Last update - 00:00 06/08/2008
IDF colonel and soldier charged in shooting of bound Palestinian
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: IDF, Israel, Na'alin 

Israeli human rights organizations on Wednesday blasted the Israel Defense Force's decision to remove an officer from his current post and reassign him, over an incident in which a soldier under his command fired a rubber bullet at a bound Palestinian prisoner.

B'Tselem and Yesh Din both released statements Wednesday condemning the deal reached between the attorneys of Lt. Colonel Omri Burberg, the officer, and the military advocate general, Brigadier General Avihai Mandelblit.

The deal saw Burberg indicted in a military court on Thursday morning on a minor charge of "inappropriate behavior for a commander" The soldierú Staff Sergeant L., who carried out the shooting was also indicted on Thursday.
Advertisement
"The Military Advocate General determined that the said incident reflects a severe moral failure of command, and requires that both the officer and soldier involved will be tried in a military court," the spokesman said in a statement.

The Military Advocate General said it was charging the soldiers with the offence of "unworthy conduct."

Branding the deal as "disgraceful," B'Tselem stated: "The army treats the shooting at point-blank range of a bound man [only] as inappropriate behavior. It disgraces the values which it pretends to uphold."

Last week, Burberg was suspended for 10 days pending an investigation into the incident, which occurred three weeks ago near the West Bank village of Na'alin.

The incident was caught on camera by a local Palestinian. The footage shows Burberg, the commander of the 71st Armored Battalion, holding on to a bound and blindfolded civilian as the soldier took aim and shot him in the foot with a rubber-coated bullet.

B'Tselem is also demanding that the military police launch an investigation into the IDF Ramallah Brigade commander, Col. Aviv Reshef, for not immediately reporting the incident.

The soldier in the incident claimed in a hearing earlier this week that he opened fire upon orders from his superior, but Burberg said he simply wanted to intimidate the victim.

His future in the IDF is presently uncertain, but Burberg said in a statement he released Wednesday evening that he takes responsibility for the incident and expects to continue to serve in the IDF.

Last week's decision to suspend Burberg came following a hearing by GOC Northern Command, Major General Gadi Eisenkot, who is the overall commander of Battalion 71.

Eisenkot said at the conclusion of the hearing that the incident "was serious and reflected a failure of command and values, even though the battalion commander did not intend for real shots to be fired, only that it be used as a scare tactic."

Related articles:
  • IDF officer in shooting probe linked to other Palestinian abuse case
  • Soldier filmed shooting bound Palestinian released from detention
  • VIDEO: Settlers tie Palestinian man to phone pole and beat him
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    War crimes probe
    A Spanish court says it will go on investigating Israeli officials over a Gaza bombing
    Peres' Abe
    Did Abraham Lincoln promise to support the establishment of a Jewish state?
      1.   Any comments from Zionists who claimed this was staged? 21:13  |  Clickfool 06/08/08
      2.   dismissed 21:15  |  anja 06/08/08
      3.   Still serving in the IDF? 21:24  |  Dave 06/08/08
      4.   Still plans to serve? 21:30  |  GS 06/08/08
      5.   Cleaning the stables 21:45  |  MarkC 06/08/08
      6.   Lt. Col. not a "senior officer" 21:52  |  John 06/08/08
      7.   Click the fool #1 22:13  |  Philippe 06/08/08
      8.   Israel`s Dichotomy 22:16  |  Milo 06/08/08
      9.   John (6) 22:21  |  Magnus Kragset 06/08/08
      10.   Just Following Orders 22:25  |  Binyamin 06/08/08
      11.   This is the norm for IDF 22:26  |  Navy Vet 06/08/08
      12.   Harsh punishment 22:43  |  Brod 06/08/08
      13.   He was dismissed 23:03  |  EDBTZ 06/08/08
      14.   #1 the fool 23:11  |  Dr Noam 06/08/08
      15.   Cowardly Pathetic Brutal Thugs 23:14  |  Lee Kaplan 06/08/08
      16.   justice 23:27  |  yuval 06/08/08
      17.   One Swollen Toe - Big Deal 23:29  |  X Ajerate 06/08/08
      18.   To: Magnus Kragset 23:38  |  Howard 06/08/08
      19.   Disgrace B`Sheker doesn`t demand demolishing terrorist houses 23:39  |  Genuine Tosefta 06/08/08
      20.   Cowardly Pathetic Brutal Thugs 23:39  |  Jay 06/08/08
      21.   Thanks GOD for the world communities to witness this. 23:41  |  Bernadette 06/08/08
      22.   The REAL B`tselem shame 23:42  |  Arie 06/08/08
      23.   shooting a blindfolded man 23:43  |  Dik 06/08/08
      24.   Disgrace...! 23:45  |  Esther 06/08/08
      25.   #7.Philippe, bet you he will B rewarded with a Medal? 23:46  |  philipa 06/08/08
      26.   shot him in the foot with a rubber coated bullet 23:47  |  Akiva P 06/08/08
      27.   # 7 philippe 23:53  |  Axel 06/08/08
      28.   Genuine Tosefta @#19 23:55  |  Akiva P 06/08/08
      29.   #14 - Dr. Nonothing 23:59  |  yezmar 06/08/08
      30.   A wrongful act, sure, but puh-leez. 00:01  |  Jack 07/08/08
      31.   IDF should let Palestinian shoot IDF officer with a rubber bullet 00:03  |  Uzi Hirschberg 07/08/08
      32.   To Magnus Kragset (9) 00:07  |  John 07/08/08
      33.   Dr Noam 00:16  |  Chet 07/08/08
      34.   To Lee Kaplan 00:17  |  John 07/08/08
      35.   General questions 00:20  |  John 07/08/08
      36.   Apologies.. the Pal was a wanted terrorist. 00:33  |  Homer Sexeul 07/08/08
      37.   slap on the wrist 00:39  |  hanna 07/08/08
      38.   Hirschberg will B`Sheker object to your inhumane suggestion? 00:41  |  Genuine Tosefta 07/08/08
      39.   Akiva more 00:44  |  Genuine Tosefta 07/08/08
      40.   B`tselem another bias accusation 00:46  |  Fred 07/08/08
      41.   #30 Jack 00:50  |  Boycott 07/08/08
      42.   BIG DEAL!! 00:50  |  WYSIWYG 07/08/08
      43.   # 26 akiva 00:52  |  Axel 07/08/08
      44.   Barbarian Israelis.Nothing new. 00:58  |  jaffar 07/08/08
      45.   # 30 jack 01:01  |  Axel 07/08/08
      46.   Brit soldiers who drowned Iraqi youths got acquited 01:26  |  Absolute Sweden 07/08/08
      47.   When a suicde bomber destroys a full bus, b`tselem keeps quiet 01:32  |  dave 07/08/08
      48.   B`Tselem should relocate to Gaza 01:52  |  Great White North 07/08/08
      49.   Free Shalit 01:55  |  Great White North 07/08/08
      50.   Axel # 27 02:02  |  Philippe 07/08/08
      51.   this IS punishment 02:06  |  Miransky 07/08/08
      52.   Milo # 8 02:06  |  Philippe 07/08/08
      53.   There`s always politics... 02:10  |  Victor 07/08/08
      54.   #1 Clickfool - Unlike your side 02:12  |  * BEN JABO 07/08/08
      55.   Rotting within.. 02:16  |  E40 07/08/08
      56.   For real? 02:30  |  roger 07/08/08
      57.   Bernadette #21 02:56  |  Philippe 07/08/08
      58.   perspective 03:16  |  Dr Noam 07/08/08
      59.   oh yea as if Israeli`s aren`t punished enough living w/savages 03:49  |  david 07/08/08
      60.   yep an israeli did something bad 03:55  |  fuck every 07/08/08
      61.   PHIL THE LIP # 04:04  |  Mona 07/08/08
      62.   JOHN / Washington, DC 04:10  |  Mona 07/08/08
      63.   B`Tselem Sure Wants Its Pound Of Flesh On This One 04:23  |  Jeff Northridge 07/08/08
      64.   Isreal should treat him as Lebanon treated 04:49  |  Adrian de Klerk 07/08/08
      65.   He should be awarded a small medal 05:03  |  Jewboy 07/08/08
      66.   Only a toe 07:18  |  rm 07/08/08
      67.   Really shameful and unacceptable. 07:19  |  sandra chitayat 07/08/08
      68.   Cowardly Army of Occupation 07:24  |  Patrick 07/08/08
      69.   With this, there`s no chance Mohammed Omer will receive justice.. 07:56  |  BBSNews 07/08/08
      70.   Chet, # 33 08:04  |  Michael 07/08/08
      71.   These folks never apologize when proven wrong Clickfool... 08:16  |  BBSNews 07/08/08
      72.   Lt. Col. not a "senior officer #6 08:18  |  Gerald Zang 07/08/08
      73.   Mere dismissal of officer is a disgrace 08:37  |  Gerald Zang 07/08/08
      74.   #31 medicine to feel better Uzi 09:19  |  ka 07/08/08
      75.   For Philippe, on IDF thuggery # 7 09:36  |  Clickfool 07/08/08
      76.   Lt. Colonel Burberg is an Israeli hero 09:37  |  Steve the Pals 07/08/08
      77.   Ya-di-da, Michael # 36 09:38  |  Clickfool 07/08/08
      78.   DOUBLE STANDARDS, DOUBLE STANDARDS!!! 10:05  |  Robert 07/08/08
      79.   Lebanon 10:27  |  Elazar 07/08/08
      80.   Israel`s Ambassadors 10:31  |  alan alan 07/08/08
      81.   Michael #36.... you`re naive... 10:43  |  Esther 07/08/08
      82.   Leftist groups will never be happy 11:00  |  Gili 07/08/08
      83.   violent protests 11:06  |  peter 07/08/08
      84.   Cold-blooded, monstrous, unforgivable 11:19  |  Clickfool 07/08/08
      85.   #37 Clickfool, he hasn`t been dismissed. 11:29  |  Johnboy 07/08/08
      86.   #81, fool, cut the hyperbole 12:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/08/08
      87.   clickfool #83 12:39  |  ka 07/08/08
      88.   Gili #81 I agree 12:41  |  ka 07/08/08
      89.   #82, peter, you are right 12:43  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/08/08
      90.   yes; we believe the good colonel... 13:39  |  eric 07/08/08
      91.   For Cluckwit, again 13:51  |  Star of David 07/08/08
      92.   Cipora#86...your own sanctimonious hyperbole... 13:52  |  Esther 07/08/08
      93.   but Israel releases their murderers every now and then 13:53  |  bob 07/08/08
      94.   To Gerald Zang 14:22  |  John 07/08/08
      95.   mutual fire 15:19  |  kj 07/08/08
      96.   Inappropriate Behavior 15:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      97.   The Apologetics of Peters and the Ciporas 15:48  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      98.   Johnboy # 85 I Don`t Think That That`s The Idea 15:48  |  Jeff Northridge 07/08/08
      99.   Cipora Julianna Kohn `excuses` #86 15:54  |  Georgio Samaras 07/08/08
      100.   To Milo 16:05  |  Mrs. Fatso from USA 07/08/08
      101.   Mental problems in the IDF? 16:29  |  Senior Psychiatrist 07/08/08
      102.   A reasonable plea bargain for the officer 16:36  |  Tosefta 07/08/08
      103.   Mr. Northridge and his pound of flesh #98 16:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      104.   Clickfool the Hypocrite 16:55  |  Think Again 07/08/08
      105.   #69 I saw Mohammed`s Nation article, BBS 17:43  |  Aphemia 07/08/08
      106.   Yakoub Suleiman forget Peters, flesh, where is your promised repo 17:59  |  Genuine Tosefta 07/08/08
      107.   Yaakov Sullivan # 103 A More Serious Charge? 18:05  |  Jeff Northridge 07/08/08
      108.   More Muslim deadly craziness if you want to a worthy uproar 18:21  |  Genuine Tosefta 07/08/08
      109.   Mr. Northridge`s Response #107 18:43  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      110.   #14 - pathetic and cheap 18:48  |  Adil 07/08/08
      111.   @Clickfool 19:22  |  Ralph 07/08/08
      112.   #1, Clickfool, and when they were unable to continue with that... 19:54  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      113.   #11, Navy Vet... 19:56  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      114.   #26, Akiva... 19:59  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      115.   sullivan`s smug slank 20:01  |  peter 07/08/08
      116.   #91, For S of D, again... 20:05  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      117.   For Genuine Tosefta 20:25  |  Fenno-Ugrian 07/08/08
      118.   #1 Clicky , who never apologizes, and really needs to 20:42  |  Big Sur 07/08/08
      119.   In 1905 clicky the Zionist congress stood upfor Palistinian right 20:45  |  Big Sur 07/08/08
      120.   peter lauds racism and apartheid 20:48  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      121.   #112 Silvienne I thought you were smarter then that 20:59  |  Big Sur 07/08/08
      122.   #120 Yaakov Sullivan, are you Jewish? I think not what occupiers? 21:06  |  Big Sur 07/08/08
      123.   Yaakov Sullivan # 109 You Didn`t Answer My Question 21:32  |  Jeff Northridge 07/08/08
      124.   "INAPPROPRIATE"? 21:38  |  tad chase 07/08/08
      125.   Actually, BBS, i have read numerous posts on here from 21:46  |  jj 07/08/08
      126.   Hypocrisy of the media and the left 22:21  |  JS 07/08/08
      127.   Silvienne # 112 Put It In Context 22:34  |  Jeff Northridge 07/08/08
      128.   Clickfool (#1) Here is My Comment 22:46  |  Gil 07/08/08
      129.   Mr. Northridge and my response 22:52  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      130.   #99, Georgio Samaras of London 23:21  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/08/08
      131.   Yakoub Suleiman do not run away from topic of adoption report 23:30  |  Genuine Tosefta 07/08/08
      132.   Cipora on Iraq 23:33  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/08/08
      133.   Nothing has changed 23:52  |  Maki 07/08/08
      134.   #127, Jeff Northridge... 23:57  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      135.   #132, SullivAn, off the mark as usual 23:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/08/08
      136.   #133, Maki... 00:41  |  Silvienne 08/08/08
      137.   #135, Cipora Kohn off the mark... 00:44  |  Silvienne 08/08/08
      138.   #98 That post of yours is now pinned to the fridge, Jeff 01:04  |  Johnboy 08/08/08
      139.   Yaakov Sullivan # 129 Oh, Boy! Let`s Get Something Straight 01:15  |  Jeff Northridge 08/08/08
      140.   Didn`t Like What They Did To The Bound Guy! 01:25  |  Yosemite 08/08/08
      141.   This is bad for all.Let those who have not sinned 01:50  |  PETER SM 08/08/08
      142.   TOSEFTA 02:03  |  Mona 08/08/08
      143.   Silvienne # 134 Humiliation Is Not A War Crime 02:15  |  Jeff Northridge 08/08/08
      144.   CFOOL Any comments about Israel kidnapping Johnstone 02:21  |  PETER SM 08/08/08
      145.   STEVE the Pals He is a hero? Based On?Where did you read that? 02:25  |  PETER SM 08/08/08
      146.   JOHNBOY If you are still working at the University 02:39  |  PETER SM 08/08/08
      147.   Yaakov Sullivan Lauds Racism and Apartheid 02:45  |  JP 08/08/08
      148.   Still Defending Atrocities 02:49  |  Gray 08/08/08
      149.   When will all the whining stop? 02:59  |  Fuad 08/08/08
      150.   IDF colonel and soldier charged in shooting of bound Palestinian 03:47  |  RAMBO 08/08/08
      151.   Fuad; The "whining Palestinian " culture??? 04:08  |  Gray 08/08/08
      152.   139 Jeff Northridge - Try Homesh 06:53  |  Mark of Lewiston 08/08/08
      153.   132 Yaakov Sullivan - Abu Ghraib Not Permanent 07:27  |  Mark of Lewiston 08/08/08
      154.   GRAY Whinning Opting for terrorism instead peace & partition 08:26  |  PETER SM 08/08/08
      155.   40+ years of occupation 08:42  |  rm 08/08/08
      156.   #152 Mark, on trying to reason with Jeff 09:11  |  Johnboy 08/08/08
      157.   #139 Jeff, as Julie Andrews once sang.... 09:20  |  Johnboy 08/08/08
      158.   # 154 to peters m re: massacre 12:38  |  eric 08/08/08
      159.   Mark of Lewiston #153 13:02  |  R. Mears 08/08/08
      160.   #71 BSnews - How about an apology from you? 17:20  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/08
      161.   # 160 to ben jabo re: "apologies" (2nd try) 03:21  |  eric 10/08/08
      162.   #161 eric 20:03  |  Look Again 10/08/08
      163.   # 162 well then `look again`; you need to look again 07:46  |  eric 11/08/08
      164.   eric 10:50  |  Look Again 11/08/08
      165.   #163 eric continued 10:57  |  Look Again 11/08/08
      166.   pssssst, look again? 14:35  |  eric 11/08/08
      167.   #166 eric 15:25  |  Look Again 11/08/08
      168.   look again! and maybe you`ll see (3nd try) 12:51  |  eric 12/08/08
      169.   eric 19:07  |  Look Again 12/08/08
      170.   `look again` doesn`t look so good 12:38  |  eric 13/08/08
      171.   eric 17:40  |  Look Again 13/08/08
      172.   no matter how many times you `look again` (2nd try) 10:54  |  eric 15/08/08
      173.   Eric and the New Orleans Floods 14:57  |  Gabriel 27/02/09
     Haaretz Hot Topics
    Israel 2009 election results: Voter breakdown
    Israel goes to the polls
    Conflict in Gaza
    Israel vs. Hamas
    Iran: Nuclear and regional ambitions
    More Headlines
    05:47 U.S. to boycott Durban 2 summit on racism
    02:14 Israel, Jewish groups hail U.S. boycott of Durban 2 summit
    03:17 U.S.: No normal Syria ties until it stops backing Hamas, Hezbollah
    21:34 Spanish war crimes probe against Israeli officials to go on
    02:52 Israeli film 'Waltz with Bashir' captures French Oscar
    22:38 Obama sets deadline for Iraq pullout, unveils new strategy
    16:27 U.K. diplomat suspended for alleged anti-Semitic rant
    15:27 Did Abraham Lincoln support the creation of a Jewish state?
    10:29 Can Israel make peace with Syria without leaving Golan?
    14:45 Netanyahu: Livni refused my offer for unity
    18:11 Germany may arrest Holocaust-denying bishop for hate crime
    13:02 40 days after war, Hamas rule of Gaza gaining legitimacy
    09:39 Israel planning mass expansion of West Bank settlement bloc
    15:18 Alabama city recruiting Jews gets its first new family
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
    Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
    Dead Sea Skin Care
    Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
    Summer in Israel
    Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
    Passover Vacations
    The BEST Passover Vacations around ? Mexico, Arizona and Florida
    Camp Kimama Israel 2009
    The best place for your children this summer
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
    Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved