Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., August 09, 2008 Av 8, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:28 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 22:29 04/08/2008
Rights group: Shin Bet coercing ill Palestinians to become informants
By The Associated Press
Tags: informants, Shin Bet, Israel 

The Shin Bet security service has been trying to coerce ill Palestinians to become informants in exchange for medical treatment, according to an 80-page report released recently by the Israel branch of Physicians for Human Rights.

The Shin Bet denied the charge but said it does conduct security checks on Palestinians leaving Gaza to ensure they do not pose a security threat.

"I would say it's self-explanatory and clear that you shouldn't extort patients," said Miri Weingarten of the group.
Advertisement
The Palestinians quoted in the report said the pressure began after the Islamic militant Hamas seized power of the Gaza Strip in June 2007. That prompted Israel and Egypt to seal its borders with Gaza. Only residents needing urgent treatment can now leave the territory with Israeli permission.

Gaza resident Bassam Waheidi is slowly going blind, but he won't pay what he says is the price of regaining his sight - spying for Israel in order to receive medical treatment.

Waheidi is one of 32 Palestinian patients who said the Shin Bet tried to bully them into giving information about militants.

The Associated Press interviewed two of the 32 independently - Waheidi and Shaban Abu Obeid.

Waheidi, a 28-year-old radio reporter, said he developed a visual problem last August, and Palestinian doctors in Gaza referred him for urgent treatment in Israel.

Waheidi says at the Erez border crossing, where Gaza residents pass into Israel, he was led by armed men in civilian clothes to a man sitting behind a desk in an underground room.

Waheidi said in an hours-long interrogation session, he was asked about militants who fire rockets at Israel. He said he refused to provide information, and said he did not know much anyway.

"I work on women's issues, social affairs and worker's rights," the radio reporter said.

Waheidi says Israel has not granted him a permit since. He said he has since gone blind in his right eye and is losing sight in the other.

Abu Obeid, a 38-year-old public worker, said he frequently went to Israel for years for heart treatment. He had a pacemaker installed at an Israeli hospital. He is loyal to Fatah-the bitter rival of Hamas.

But when Abu Obeid applied last August for a permit to enter Israel to check on his pacemaker, he said an intelligence official offered him a tough choice.

"He said, 'Let's make a deal. You give me information, and I'll make it easy for you to go Israel,'" Abu Obeid said.

Abu Obeid refused, and he said Israel has not given him a permit since. Instead, he is waiting for an Israeli medical team to come into Gaza to examine his heart and pacemaker.

This is not the first time such allegations have been raised, and Israel has always denied them.

A Shin Bet official directed reporters' queries to a letter by Shoshi Golan of the Israeli Prime Minister's Office, which speaks on the agency's behalf. Golan said the agency did not make entry into Israel for humanitarian reasons contingent on an applicant's willingness to submit any information, except for reliable information on his medical condition.

Golan said the security checks were conducted partly to evaluate the degree of danger posed by the applicant and noted several cases where Gaza residents tried to obtain permits to carry out attacks in Israel.

Related articles:
  • The Shin Bet - guardian of democracy?
  • Shin Bet head Diskin: Gaza lull is lifeline to Hamas
  • Bullies in the intelligence community
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Iranian row
    Rice on possible IDF Iran strike: U.S. has no veto over Israeli military operations.
    Hamas movie set
    Hamas transforms former Gaza settlement into movie production house.
      1.   We save their lives. They could save ours 09:05  |  x-ray 04/08/08
      2.   Israel: unbeatable World Limbo Dancing Champions 09:45  |  Clickfool 04/08/08
      3.   ISRAEL OCCUPATION IS AT ITS LOWEST POINT 09:49  |  indrajaya 04/08/08
      4.   Human rights should not be sectarian 09:57  |  Ulf 04/08/08
      5.   saving Israelis lives are the priority 10:03  |  zionist forever 04/08/08
      6.   #2 Israeli stupidity matches UK lack of humanity 10:06  |  Ulf 04/08/08
      7.   Do what you must - Remember Wafa Samir Ibrahim al-Biss 10:16  |  Sima 04/08/08
      8.   Only if you`re giving out the prize, Clickfool 10:19  |  David 04/08/08
      9.   A lesson well learned, and with enthusiasm 10:30  |  Natallie Durson 04/08/08
      10.   Israel: Dr. Death is right here at home 10:35  |  Palestinian in UK 04/08/08
      11.   Insane palestinians want Israeli medical help, but hate Israel? 11:11  |  Steve Randolph 04/08/08
      12.   These Israeli `human rights` groups only seem to harm Israel 11:12  |  Steve Randolph 04/08/08
      13.   Good: Their Lives For Ours 11:17  |  Yishai Kohen 04/08/08
      14.   Terrorists should be treated as war criminals. 12:00  |  Jean Van Daem 04/08/08
      15.   Gaza palestinians can go to Egypt for medical treatment, then 12:33  |  Steve Randolph 04/08/08
      16.   Israeli policies are short sighted 14:15  |  paulo2005 04/08/08
      17.   Informants 15:06  |  Dani 04/08/08
      18.   Rights Group doesn`t blame HAMAS, FATAH. They blame Istrael. 15:21  |  Vittorio 04/08/08
      19.   Can you imagine if this was done to a jew. 15:33  |  Labhras 04/08/08
      20.   morality won`t get us anywhere 15:41  |  judith 04/08/08
      21.   #17 Rights Grouup 16:32  |  John Allen 04/08/08
      22.   #3 Indonesia`s social elitetest! 16:39  |  John Allen 04/08/08
      23.   #6 People and their demands. 16:45  |  j 04/08/08
      24.   #16 Spain has a very bad history about Jews. 16:55  |  John Allen 04/08/08
      25.   A SHIN BET INFORMANT AT 2002 17:15  |  indrajaya 04/08/08
      26.   #19 labarse of arabia and knowing sfa about anything 17:32  |  victor hardman 04/08/08
      27.   Clickfools Mullah logic again 17:37  |  Nathan Rai 04/08/08
      28.   What a way to bribe helpless palestinians 17:45  |  noor 04/08/08
      29.   israel should not even need ask. 18:06  |  frenz 04/08/08
      30.   Another anti-Israel salvo from AP`s Diaa Hadid 18:17  |  Francis 04/08/08
      31.   What Goes Around, Comes Around 18:21  |  Raymond 04/08/08
      32.   Who is surprised about this?? 18:21  |  Silvienne 04/08/08
      33.   If Israel denies the allegations... 18:21  |  Colin Wright 04/08/08
      34.   Blackmailing Ill Palestinians with American funded facilities... 18:38  |  Edithann, USA 04/08/08
      35.   Noor, they are not helpless, quite the opposite 18:40  |  jj 04/08/08
      36.   #23 indrajaya 18:44  |  Daniela 04/08/08
      37.   JJ, you dont know what "helpless" is 18:51  |  noor 04/08/08
      38.   Very Sad and Wrong 19:00  |  David 04/08/08
      39.   Israel gives plenty of medical care to those who want it destroy- 19:00  |  jj 04/08/08
      40.   Where does money come from 19:01  |  Jackie 04/08/08
      41.   Exelent strategy . 19:21  |  TOMY 04/08/08
      42.   yes thats right Noor, all these years and now 19:21  |  jj 04/08/08
      43.   Edithann American taxes don`t fund everything in Israel 19:25  |  x-ray 04/08/08
      44.   #43 x-ray and free ponds of flesh 19:53  |  Labhras 04/08/08
      45.   Children as well? 19:58  |  Magnolia 04/08/08
      46.   #44, Labhras... 20:31  |  Silvienne 04/08/08
      47.   rights and obligations 20:39  |  R`fael Moshe 04/08/08
      48.   #46 Silvienne re social welfare given to Israel 20:45  |  Labhras 04/08/08
      49.   Press briefing 20:53  |  Palestinian Brit 04/08/08
      50.   Where are the Palestinian Hospitals? 21:07  |  utagawa 04/08/08
      51.   28 21:10  |  zionist forever 04/08/08
      52.   Clickfool in Limbo 21:12  |  utagawa 04/08/08
      53.   Rights and Obligations... 21:12  |  Palestinian Brit 04/08/08
      54.   indrajaya you are cute! 21:13  |  jehuda arieh 04/08/08
      55.   Isn`t this just shocking...where is their shame? 21:16  |  Dutch 04/08/08
      56.   Labhras and flesh ponds 21:35  |  x-ray 04/08/08
      57.   Dutch is right 21:53  |  jehuda arieh 04/08/08
      58.   #56 x-ray you have no facts 22:01  |  Labhras 04/08/08
      59.   indrajaja on the dutch dole 22:02  |  frenz 04/08/08
      60.   The Middle East is becoming more primitive by the second 22:08  |  cry thief 04/08/08
      61.   So what? Pathetic 22:11  |  Liliane 04/08/08
      62.   #16 Portuguese Inquisition / Genocide. Clean your laundry 22:14  |  Albert 04/08/08
      63.   #48, Labhras...I agree with you... 22:21  |  Silvienne 04/08/08
      64.   #52, utagawa to Clickfool... 22:23  |  Silvienne 04/08/08
      65.   Human rights group 22:46  |  JG 04/08/08
      66.   Labhras (#48) 23:10  |  Gil 04/08/08
      67.   Labhras (#19) ``Thank God I live. . .`` 23:26  |  Gil 04/08/08
      68.   @34, edithann 23:31  |  vladimir 04/08/08
      69.   #53 Palestinian Brit - Israel didn`t chose 23:31  |  * BEN JABO 04/08/08
      70.   #55 Dutch - far be it for you 23:33  |  * BEN JABO 04/08/08
      71.   eye for an eye 23:35  |  fred 04/08/08
      72.   #61 Silvienne re Palestinian State 23:46  |  Labhras 04/08/08
      73.   Silvienne 23:50  |  utagawa 04/08/08
      74.   more aid per capita 23:53  |  Scharker Yid 04/08/08
      75.   Send them to Gaza hospitals 23:59  |  KUTW 04/08/08
      76.   #64 Silvienne re utagawa on German POW 00:11  |  Labhras 05/08/08
      77.   coercion 00:13  |  tom 05/08/08
      78.   #66, Gil, stop complaining! 00:17  |  Silvienne 05/08/08
      79.   Remarkable, really. 00:18  |  Elihu 05/08/08
      80.   How many people does it take for an occupation 01:12  |  Gee 05/08/08
      81.   The wheel turns... 01:38  |  Maureen ann 05/08/08
      82.   70 Ben Jabo, Given a choice, I would take primitive Qassams 02:05  |  Dutch 05/08/08
      83.   Gil #66 02:09  |  Gee 05/08/08
      84.   Many Palestinians travel to Israel for medical treatment. 02:12  |  Stephen. 05/08/08
      85.   # 57 Jehuda arieh , How easily you forget ... 02:28  |  Dutch 05/08/08
      86.   the amount of hate 02:30  |  Tarzan 05/08/08
      87.   Rights Group? 02:39  |  Ron 05/08/08
      88.   To Whom It May Concerned Just Read And Think About Economy.. 03:30  |  . 05/08/08
      89.   zionist forever 04:04  |  noor 05/08/08
      90.   But if it was the other way around... 04:06  |  noor 05/08/08
      91.   Stephen, that isnt the argument 04:09  |  noor 05/08/08
      92.   WHAT DOES NAOMI WOLFE SAY IN HER LATEST COLUMN IN KHALEEJ TIMES? 04:52  |  HAFIZ 05/08/08
      93.   Israel transfers 88 Fatah men who fled Gaza to West Bank 05:18  |  AVRUM 05/08/08
      94.   #32...Silvienne 05:23  |  Nemesis 05/08/08
      95.   The Entitlement Of These people. They Terrorize Israel and Then 06:26  |  Eli 05/08/08
      96.   Dutch and Choices # 82 _ How About No Primitive Qassms and No 06:30  |  Eli 05/08/08
      97.   send theem to egypt not israel 07:08  |  david 05/08/08
      98.   To # 24 Do you know who protected the Jews from the Spanyard? 08:10  |  EDBTZ 05/08/08
      99.   Good if they did it 08:44  |  Paris 05/08/08
      100.   Healthcare 09:19  |  Michael 05/08/08
      101.   Thanks Labhras for the info 17:37  |  utagawa 05/08/08
      102.   #101, utagawa.... 17:59  |  Silvienne 05/08/08
      103.   #95, Well now, Eli...you may just be wrong... 18:02  |  Silvienne 05/08/08
      104.   Silvienne, try to understand 18:26  |  utagawa 05/08/08
      105.   And you wonder why everyone hates Israel? 20:42  |  frankie malvino 05/08/08
      106.   Dutch, you are right 21:37  |  jehuda arieh 05/08/08
      107.   #105, frankie, you`re right... 23:32  |  Silvienne 05/08/08
      108.   #104, utagawa... 23:34  |  Silvienne 05/08/08
      109.   Honest Reporting`s Response: 01:52  |  Free Gilad Shalit 06/08/08
      110.   #82 Dutch - Don`t you remember 04:13  |  * BEN JABO 06/08/08
      111.   Oh Sivienne #103 _ And I Thought You Are A Brit 08:26  |  Eli 06/08/08
      112.   Yes but, Mr. Shalit 13:18  |  Murray 06/08/08
      113.   Murray 112 16:50  |  Free Gilad Shalit 06/08/08
      114.   #112 Murray - Milan - They`re not Israeli patients 17:04  |  * BEN JABO 06/08/08
      115.   #111, Eli...well, actually... 2ND TRY 20:56  |  Silvienne 06/08/08
      116.   #115 Silvienne - You`re just jealous 22:39  |  * BEN JABO 06/08/08
      117.   For Silvienne part 1 23:56  |  THE TEACHER/INSTRUCT 06/08/08
      118.   #116, Ben Jabo...now you know very well... 00:00  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      119.   Silvienne #115 _ There Was No attempt To Slagg 00:04  |  Eli 07/08/08
      120.   *BEN JABO # 116 _ Let Me Confirm Your Post And Ad The 00:12  |  Eli 07/08/08
      121.   #119, Eli.... 00:50  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      122.   #117, KATHY aka TEACHER/INSTRUCT... 00:53  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      123.   #120, Eli and the Menorah... 00:54  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      124.   #118 Silvienne - You`ve said a lot 07:24  |  * BEN JABO 07/08/08
      125.   Eli - Berkley 07:29  |  * BEN JABO 07/08/08
      126.   #120 Eli - Berkley 07:32  |  * BEN JABO 07/08/08
      127.   #124, Ben Jabo... 17:53  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      128.   Eli & the Menorah... 18:18  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      129.   Ben Jabo... 20:59  |  Silvienne 07/08/08
      130.   Ben Jabo #124 01:22  |  Free Gilad Shalit 08/08/08
      131.   #127 Silvienne - You still are evading 16:31  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/08
      132.   #129 Silvienne - Eli is correct 16:34  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/08
      133.   #129 Silvienne - I tell it like I see it!!! 16:35  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/08
      134.   #130 Free Gilad Shalit 16:38  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/08
     Read & React
    Israel slams Turkey over Ahmadinejad plan to visit
    Responses: 79
    Israel: We'll hold Lebanon responsible for Hezbollah's actions
    Responses: 136
    PRC: Open crossings within 3 weeks or we'll end Gaza truce
    Responses: 44
    Ze'ev Sternhall: Burying the Jewish state between Hebron and Yitzhar
    Responses: 51
    Ultra-Orthodox 'Modesty Guard' suspected in beating of J'lem woman
    Responses: 69
    Rosner's Domain
    The reassuring candidacy of Eric Cantor (WTR)
    Congress likely to see record number of Jewish legislators
    Israel looking for leader and agenda, but finds neither
    On Peter Rodman, Lebanon and Syria


    More Headlines
    01:07 EU tightens sanctions against Iran over nuke program
    00:12 Peres joins 80 world leaders at Olympics opening ceremony
    17:00 Beijing can help stop Iran threat, Peres tells Jintao
    01:13 Police question Olmert for 5th time in graft probe
    01:28 Russia sends tanks into South Ossetia in bid to wrest control from Georgia
    21:58 'Israeli Miracle' is developing strong ties with Communist China
    15:04 Ultra-Orthodox 'Modesty Guard' suspected in beating of J'lem woman
    15:17 Israel at the Beijing Olympic Games
    13:39 Israeli security expert takes pride in his role at the Olympics
    22:59 Bernie Brillstein, producer of 'The Muppets' and 'Ghostbusters,' dies at 77
    18:20 What Gaza's zookeeper really wants is to smuggle in an elephant
    13:22 Haredi philanthropist took cocaine before fatal crash, U.K. inquest finds
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Isaac Maimon at Dreamshoppe
    Special summer sale. Make an offer now. You will be surprised.
    MBA in Israel in English
    APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Yossi Avrahami Presents:
    New Luxurious Projects in North Tel Aviv & Eilat
    Your vacation starts here
    Israel Travel Center Guaranteed Lowest Rates
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved