Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., March 13, 2009 Adar 17, 5769 | | Israel Time: 11:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 00:00 29/07/2008
Provocateurs vs. defeatists
By Haaretz Editorial
Tags: outposts, West Bank settlers 

The outgoing commander of the northern West Bank, Colonel Amir Baram, says he is "not surprised" by the settlers' recent rioting. Nor were his predecessors. There is really nothing new under the West Bank sun - things repeat themselves.

Officials in the Israel Defense Forces, police and prosecution know mainly how to summarize events, warn of similar ones in the future, write reports and hold meetings summing up their failure to deal with the West Bank lawbreakers.

Colonel Baram named Kedumim council head Daniela Weiss and the rabbi at the Ma'aleh Levona religious girls' high school, Gadi Ben Zimra, as the "main provocateurs."
Advertisement
The girls who refused to talk in police detention because they did not recognize the state's authority did indeed come from the Levona high school. The Kedumim council gives the outlaws shelter because Weiss believes they are persecuted.

The generations come and go - settlers, lawbreakers, yeshiva students, soldiers who guard them and get treated contemptuously, teachers drawing salaries from taxpayers, settlers' sons and grandchildren who do whatever they like. And some of them constitute an infrastructure for Jewish terrorism in the territories. Palestinian generations, meanwhile, also come and go as the settlers, their children and grandchildren rampage and plunder unhindered in a state that has seemingly given up.

A short while ago it turned out that senior settler Zeev (Zambish) Hever, a veteran member of the Jewish terror cells of the 1980s, is being persecuted by the right wing, which is more extreme than he is. The man who invented the diversionary tactics that enabled the construction of the supposedly legal state-funded settlements is now regarded as too moderate and is being harassed for his willingness to give up two outposts in order to hang on to a hundred others.

The excuse for Thursday's rampage was an attempt to evacuate a mobile home, a sort of fake outpost that had only been erected so its removal could be portrayed as a semblance of an evacuation.

Evacuating a mobile home gives the right-wing activists a chance to exercise their forces. The extremist yeshiva students gather by means of a communications network, they block roads, beat up passing Palestinians, snatch soldiers' weapons, burn orchards and plantations and throw stones - faced by defeatist, helpless defense forces.

This absurd spectacle is everyday routine in the West Bank - one in which illegal yeshivas, operating in illegal settlements, whose teachers' wages are paid by the state, halt studies to enable their students to engage in illegal activity. No Israeli government has even tried to deal with the settlers' violence.

Radical yeshiva students - the yeshiva formerly at Joseph's Tomb that moved to Yitzhar and the one on Havat Gilad in Ma'aleh Levona - are marching class after class on the high road of illegal activity.

The attempt to remove a mobile home in the Adei Ad outpost led to Thursday's confrontation, but this is but one incident in a succession of confrontations. The outgoing commander is joining dozens who have said that the settlers' leadership, not the youth, must be dealt with. This statement will probably remain hanging in the air.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
J'accuse
Facing rape charges, Katsav says 'I haven't surrendered'.
Capital punishment
Madoff pleads guilty to huge financial swindle.
  1.   Because there are root causes 15:28  |  judith 29/07/08
  2.   Squatters 15:33  |  John Allen 29/07/08
  3.   Judith, you`re wrong 15:43  |  Lisa in Chicago 29/07/08
  4.   LISA, learn the hard facts before you speak. 16:02  |  judith 29/07/08
  5.   Judith #1 Yes to root causes! 16:16  |  Roo 29/07/08
  6.   #4 judith some other hard facts for you to learn 16:18  |  Labhras 29/07/08
  7.   On their way out and grasping for straws 16:27  |  Guy From NYC 29/07/08
  8.   Settlers 16:39  |  Natallie Durson 29/07/08
  9.   IDF = Israel Defeatist Forces 16:44  |  Danny 29/07/08
  10.   Israelis support their Terrorist Squatters. It`s how they steal 17:11  |  POP 29/07/08
  11.   The police say that the leftists are causing these problems 17:14  |  Dani 29/07/08
  12.   They are simply Jewish Terrorists posing as settlers 17:14  |  Yossi Cronenberg 29/07/08
  13.   SETTLERS AND HAMAS ARE EXTREMIST 17:14  |  BENGURION 29/07/08
  14.   IDF 17:34  |  Peter 29/07/08
  15.   The way we live... 17:35  |  Esther 29/07/08
  16.   If these people are marginalize they will turn to terror 18:00  |  Always Happens 29/07/08
  17.   Lahbras, yes, I will 18:12  |  Judith 29/07/08
  18.   Learn - Settlers are NOT root of conflict! = Convienent Scapegoat 18:22  |  Dan 29/07/08
  19.   mine vs. yours 18:24  |  Refer N. Dem 29/07/08
  20.   simple 18:37  |  potobac 29/07/08
  21.   Provocateurs vs. defeatists 19:04  |  martin list, m.d. 29/07/08
  22.   #17 judith sfely tucked away in NY dreams the impossible dream 19:08  |  Labhras 29/07/08
  23.   yes... why not..? 19:14  |  ravi 29/07/08
  24.   "an infrastructure for Jewish terrorism in the territories" 19:36  |  BBSNews 29/07/08
  25.   judith #1: where have I heard that expression before? 19:37  |  ivo 29/07/08
  26.   #1, Judith... 19:50  |  Silvienne 29/07/08
  27.   Solution: The Saudi Plan NOW! 19:55  |  Ivar 29/07/08
  28.   #7 GuyfromNYC. Wanna bet our settlers are "on their way out"? 19:59  |  Chaim 29/07/08
  29.   I find it funny and ironic that the people who claim... 20:15  |  Czarkazem13 29/07/08
  30.   #23 ravi...do you think 20:32  |  Lynn 29/07/08
  31.   Czarkasem13: Welcome To Selective Outrage Headquarters 20:33  |  Gray 29/07/08
  32.   Lords of the Land 20:40  |  David 29/07/08
  33.   Re BBC #24 20:55  |  Esther 29/07/08
  34.   Peter #14: it`s you who are spinning - 20:58  |  ivo 29/07/08
  35.   Only a Palestinian State with final borders will resolve this. 21:20  |  Pablo B 29/07/08
  36.   Ivo no 34 response 22:19  |  Peter 29/07/08
  37.   Lynn shows her true colors. 22:57  |  Ibrahim 29/07/08
  38.   Police Allow Muslims to Attack Jews-ARREST VICTIMS 23:02  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/08
  39.   Jew-HATERS DECEIVE for Expansionist Islam. Already ARAB Pal State 23:12  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/08
  40.   Arab Leaders ORDERED Arabs to LEAVE Palestine/Israel (One 23:17  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/08
  41.   Arab Leaders ORDERED Arabs to LEAVE Palestine/Israel (One 23:17  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/08
  42.   KKK`s Kosher Cousins 23:20  |  Gray 29/07/08
  43.   Arab Leaders ORDERED Arabs to LEAVE Palestine/Israel (Two) 23:20  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/08
  44.   Peter #36: I believe you, but let`s just try to be fair - 23:22  |  ivo 29/07/08
  45.   H.H.=Haaretz Hypocrisy 23:29  |  H.H.=Hate Haaretz 29/07/08
  46.   Judith #4 23:31  |  Fish 29/07/08
  47.   Gray #31: that`s a great name for this Talkback - 23:33  |  ivo 29/07/08
  48.   This is the other ugly and evil face of Israel today 00:14  |  Dutch 30/07/08
  49.   The settlers are VICTIMS! 00:14  |  Rabid Rabbi 30/07/08
  50.   Well, Esther .... 00:31  |  Dutch 30/07/08
  51.   Chaim...I`ll take that bet... 00:32  |  kiwi girl 30/07/08
  52.   Creating new enemies - that s the goal 00:37  |  ruiz 30/07/08
  53.   poisonous fruit blossoming in Zion 00:38  |  newageblues 30/07/08
  54.   Haaretz 00:52  |  michael pielet 30/07/08
  55.   ivo; Sounds like a good idea 01:42  |  Gray 30/07/08
  56.   funny, they missd this part 01:46  |  complete 30/07/08
  57.   Taking on the setlers...Israel`s PAWNS.. 01:58  |  ali 30/07/08
  58.   I submitted at least 5 separate comments. None published 01:58  |  Linda Rivera 30/07/08
  59.   The settlers represent the other unlawful face of Israel 02:17  |  Dutch 30/07/08
  60.   The settlers...USED..Image Probelm........ 03:25  |  ali 30/07/08
  61.   Hello "complete", About your "wonderful pioneering" thing 03:42  |  Gray 30/07/08
  62.   Police Allow VIOLENT Muslims to Attack Jews-ARREST VICTIMS 04:18  |  Linda Rivera 30/07/08
  63.   Who Does World Prefer? Terrorist KILLERS or Jew Homebuilders (1) 04:22  |  Linda Rivera 30/07/08
  64.   Who Does World Prefer? Terrorist KILLERS or Jew Homebuilders (2) 04:24  |  Linda Rivera 30/07/08
  65.   The Solution is to remove the settlers beyond the Green Line 04:41  |  Mr. Know-It-All 30/07/08
  66.   #9 Danny, you might like to actually READ some articles. 04:53  |  Johnboy 30/07/08
  67.   #40 Kiwi. I look forward to Israel`s day of reckoning. 04:55  |  Chaim 30/07/08
  68.   Kadima:Hands back the counry to its people. 05:19  |  Akram Zekaria 30/07/08
  69.   The settlers ARE Zionism. That`s why you 05:43  |  Che Vive 30/07/08
  70.   48# Dutch : More blood ? normal.Palestine no ! 05:50  |  Akram Zekaria 30/07/08
  71.   Czar # 29 06:22  |  judith 30/07/08
  72.   400,000 need to go home 07:39  |  Shelly 30/07/08
  73.   Last sentence "remain hanging in the air"... 07:41  |  Miriam Ashkelon 30/07/08
  74.   IDF -- defeated from the get-go 09:37  |  Yaakov K. 30/07/08
  75.   Shelly #72: check your numbers - 13:53  |  ivo 30/07/08
  76.   The Vangaurds of Zionism 14:07  |  Heroic Bob 30/07/08
  77.   linda rivera 63,64 17:31  |  potobac 30/07/08
  78.   Judith, you`re wrong 03:05  |  Aaron Berg 07/08/08
  79.   Not an absurd spectacle, a criminal one 08:16  |  Zak Lamont 13/03/09
 Read & React
Sources: Israel agrees to free all 450 Hamas prisoners for Shalit
Responses: 16
Was Katsav's speech a monologue or stand-up comedy?
Responses: 1
Henry Siegman: Is a right-wing government the answer?
Send response
Ron Breiman: No room for two states
Send response
Who is Marwan Barghouti, the man Palestinians love to love?
Send response


More Headlines
06:19 Sources: Israel agrees to free all 450 Hamas prisoners for Shalit
06:51 ANALYSIS / Even God may find it hard to help Olmert close Shalit deal
04:32 Katsav: 'My noose is Mazuz's lifeline'
09:51 Katsav's lawyer: Press conference won't affect trial
06:25 ANALYSIS / Was Katsav's speech a monologue or stand-up comedy?
06:28 Obama extends U.S. sanctions against Iran by one year
10:24 Arms dealer promotional film dubbed 'most atrocious of all time'
04:38 Scholar: The Essenes, Dead Sea Scroll 'authors,' never existed
04:54 Prof. Neeman to take Justice Min. as Lieberman given absorption portfolio
02:47 Anshel Pfeffer / Israel minorities see IDF service as key to social mobility
03:00 Plan to introduce biometric IDs stirs privacy debate
06:29 IDF chief heads to Washington to stress Iran dangers to U.S.
02:12 Court rules Jewish immigrant who confessed to killing Arab taxi driver unfit to face charges
16:02 Hamas condemns Gaza rocket strikes on Israel
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Summer in Israel
Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
Passover Vacations
The BEST Passover Vacations around ? Mexico, Arizona and Florida
Camp Kimama Israel 2009
The best place for your children this summer
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved