Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., September 06, 2008 Elul 6, 5768 | | Israel Time: 21:26 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Haaretz Toolbar Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Car Rental Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 09:40 12/07/2008 Twilight Zone / 'Worse than apartheid' By Gideon Levy Tags: Apartheid, Nablus, Israel I thought they would feel right at home in the alleys of Balata refugee camp, the Casbah and the Hawara checkpoint. But they said there is no comparison: for them the Israeli occupation regime is worse than anything they knew under apartheid. This week, 21 human rights activists from South Africa visited Israel. Among them were members of Nelson Mandela's African National Congress; at least one of them took part in the armed struggle and at least two were jailed. There were two South African Supreme Court judges, a former deputy minister, members of Parliament, attorneys, writers and journalists. Blacks and whites, about half of them Jews who today are in conflict with attitudes of the conservative Jewish community in their country. Some of them have been here before; for others it was their first visit. For five days they paid an unconventional visit to Israel - without Sderot, the IDF and the Foreign Ministry (but with Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Memorial and a meeting with Supreme Court President Justice Dorit Beinisch. They spent most of their time in the occupied areas, where hardly any official guests go - places that are also shunned by most Israelis. On Monday they visited Nablus, the most imprisoned city in the West Bank. From Hawara to the Casbah, from the Casbah to Balata, from Joseph's Tomb to the monastery of Jacob's Well. They traveled from Jerusalem to Nablus via Highway 60, observing the imprisoned villages that have no access to the main road, and seeing the "roads for the natives," which pass under the main road. They saw and said nothing. There were no separate roads under apartheid. They went through the Hawara checkpoint mutely: they never had such barriers. Advertisement Jody Kollapen, who was head of Lawyers for Human Rights in the apartheid regime, watches silently. He sees the "carousel" into which masses of people are jammed on their way to work, visit family or go to the hospital. Israeli peace activist Neta Golan, who lived for several years in the besieged city, explains that only 1 percent of the inhabitants are allowed to leave the city by car, and they are suspected of being collaborators with Israel. Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge, a former deputy minister of defense and of health and a current member of Parliament, a revered figure in her country, notices a sick person being taken through on a stretcher and is shocked. "To deprive people of humane medical care? You know, people die because of that," she says in a muted voice. The tour guides - Palestinian activists - explain that Nablus is closed off by six checkpoints. Until 2005, one of them was open. "The checkpoints are supposedly for security purposes, but anyone who wants to perpetrate an attack can pay NIS 10 for a taxi and travel by bypass roads, or walk through the hills. The real purpose is to make life hard for the inhabitants. The civilian population suffers," says Said Abu Hijla, a lecturer at Al-Najah University in the city. In the bus I get acquainted with my two neighbors: Andrew Feinstein, a son of Holocaust survivors who is married to a Muslim woman from Bangladesh and served six years as an MP for the ANC; and Nathan Gefen, who has a male Muslim partner and was a member of the right-wing Betar movement in his youth. Gefen is active on the Committee against AIDS in his AIDS-ravaged country. "Look left and right," the guide says through a loudspeaker, "on the top of every hill, on Gerizim and Ebal, is an Israeli army outpost that is watching us." Here are bullet holes in the wall of a school, there is Joseph's Tomb, guarded by a group of armed Palestinian policemen. Here there was a checkpoint, and this is where a woman passerby was shot to death two years ago. The government building that used to be here was bombed and destroyed by F-16 warplanes. A thousand residents of Nablus were killed in the second intifada, 90 of them in Operation Defensive Shield - more than in Jenin. Two weeks ago, on the day the Gaza Strip truce came into effect, Israel carried out its last two assassinations here for the time being. Last night the soldiers entered again and arrested people. It has been a long time since tourists visited here. There is something new: the numberless memorial posters that were pasted to the walls to commemorate the fallen have been replaced by marble monuments and metal plaques in every corner of the Casbah. "Don't throw paper into the toilet bowl, because we have a water shortage," the guests are told in the offices of the Casbah Popular Committee, located high in a spectacular old stone building. The former deputy minister takes a seat at the head of the table. Behind her are portraits of Yasser Arafat, Abu Jihad and Marwan Barghouti - the jailed Tanzim leader. Representatives of the Casbah residents describe the ordeals they face. Ninety percent of the children in the ancient neighborhood suffer from anemia and malnutrition, the economic situation is dire, the nightly incursions are continuing, and some of the inhabitants are not allowed to leave the city at all. We go out for a tour on the trail of devastation wrought by the IDF over the years. Edwin Cameron, a judge on the Supreme Court of Appeal, tells his hosts: "We came here lacking in knowledge and are thirsty to know. We are shocked by what we have seen until now. It is very clear to us that the situation here is intolerable." A poster pasted on an outside wall has a photograph of a man who spent 34 years in an Israeli prison. Mandela was incarcerated seven years less than that. One of the Jewish members of the delegation is prepared to say, though not for attribution, that the comparison with apartheid is very relevant and that the Israelis are even more efficient in implementing the separation-of-races regime than the South Africans were. If he were to say this publicly, he would be attacked by the members of the Jewish community, he says. Under a fig tree in the center of the Casbah one of the Palestinian activists explains: "The Israeli soldiers are cowards. That is why they created routes of movement with bulldozers. In doing so they killed three generations of one family, the Shubi family, with the bulldozers." Here is the stone monument to the family - grandfather, two aunts, mother and two children. The words "We will never forget, we will never forgive" are engraved on the stone. No less beautiful than the famed Paris cemetery of Pere-Lachaise, the central cemetery of Nablus rests in the shadow of a large grove of pine trees. Among the hundreds of headstones, those of the intifada victims stand out. Here is the fresh grave of a boy who was killed a few weeks ago at the Hawara checkpoint. The South Africans walk quietly between the graves, pausing at the grave of the mother of our guide, Abu Hijla. She was shot 15 times. "We promise you we will not surrender," her children wrote on the headstone of the woman who was known as "mother of the poor." Lunch is in a hotel in the city, and Madlala-Routledge speaks. "It is hard for me to describe what I am feeling. What I see here is worse than what we experienced. But I am encouraged to find that there are courageous people here. We want to support you in your struggle, by every possible means. There are quite a few Jews in our delegation, and we are very proud that they are the ones who brought us here. They are demonstrating their commitment to support you. In our country we were able to unite all the forces behind one struggle, and there were courageous whites, including Jews, who joined the struggle. I hope we will see more Israeli Jews joining your struggle." She was deputy defense minister from 1999 to 2004; in 1987 she served time in prison. Later, I asked her in what ways the situation here is worse than apartheid. "The absolute control of people's lives, the lack of freedom of movement, the army presence everywhere, the total separation and the extensive destruction we saw." Madlala-Routledge thinks that the struggle against the occupation is not succeeding here because of U.S. support for Israel - not the case with apartheid, which international sanctions helped destroy. Here, the racist ideology is also reinforced by religion, which was not the case in South Africa. "Talk about the 'promised land' and the 'chosen people' adds a religious dimension to racism which we did not have." Equally harsh are the remarks of the editor-in-chief of the Sunday Times of South Africa, Mondli Makhanya, 38. "When you observe from afar you know that things are bad, but you do not know how bad. Nothing can prepare you for the evil we have seen here. In a certain sense, it is worse, worse, worse than everything we endured. The level of the apartheid, the racism and the brutality are worse than the worst period of apartheid. "The apartheid regime viewed the blacks as inferior; I do not think the Israelis see the Palestinians as human beings at all. How can a human brain engineer this total separation, the separate roads, the checkpoints? What we went through was terrible, terrible, terrible - and yet there is no comparison. Here it is more terrible. We also knew that it would end one day; here there is no end in sight. The end of the tunnel is blacker than black. "Under apartheid, whites and blacks met in certain places. The Israelis and the Palestinians do not meet any longer at all. The separation is total. It seems to me that the Israelis would like the Palestinians to disappear. There was never anything like that in our case. The whites did not want the blacks to disappear. I saw the settlers in Silwan [in East Jerusalem] - people who want to expel other people from their place." Afterward we walk silently through the alleys of Balata, the largest refugee camp in the West Bank, a place that was designated 60 years ago to be a temporary haven for 5,000 refugees and is now inhabited by 26,000. In the dark alleys, which are about the width of a thin person, an oppressive silence prevailed. Everyone was immersed in his thoughts, and only the voice of the muezzin broke the stillness. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Playing with fire Sarkozy warns Iran it risks Israeli strike on nuke program. Our own desert island Israel tries to lure 'Big Brother' type U.S. reality TV series.   1.   Nothing Like Apartheid 12:30  |  Slibovitz 12/07/08   2.   worse than apartheid 16:23  |  Ben 12/07/08   3.   Levy gives the word bias a whole new meaning 17:13  |  Freethinker 12/07/08   4.   Worse than apartheid 17:42  |  Boycott 12/07/08   5.   Worse then apartheid 18:05  |  Julian 12/07/08   6.   Ben #1 - Sanctimony `R` Us 18:26  |  dana 12/07/08   7.   Apartheid 18:34  |  scott 12/07/08   8.   What the Palestinians don`t tell their guests 18:49  |  Rachel 12/07/08   9.   Should one even bother? 18:52  |  Mr Ipp 12/07/08   10.   Chosen People 19:10  |  Sasi 12/07/08   11.   Twisted picture 19:14  |  Koby 12/07/08   12.   worse than anything 19:15  |  Boris 12/07/08   13.   twilight zone 19:20  |  JL 12/07/08   14.   Worse than apartheid 19:42  |  Sam 12/07/08   15.   Wow, I commend the courage of these South Aficans to speak out 20:19  |  Paul 12/07/08   16.   Apartheid 20:34  |  Poppy 12/07/08   17.   that`s sensational journalism on the base of the yellow press 20:58  |  saul a. readner 12/07/08   18.   Apartheid / Israel 21:15  |  Gimpel the Fool 12/07/08   19.   #9 Paul, Apartheid & the Bible 21:27  |  Boycott 12/07/08   20.   APARTHEID 21:27  |  poppy 12/07/08   21.   hypocrates 21:58  |  crazyed 12/07/08   22.   Worse than apratheid 22:17  |  Saul 12/07/08   23.   boycott 22:23  |  saul a. readner 12/07/08   24.   #21 saul a. readner 23:30  |  Boycott 12/07/08   25.   Thank you for sharing the thoughts of the HR activists 15:51  |  Dutch 13/07/08   26.   The Zionist Mind 22:21  |  Salviati 13/07/08   27.   Gideon Levy is an appalling "journalist" 08:58  |  David Hersch 14/07/08   28.   And by the way... 08:59  |  David Hersch 14/07/08   29.   And by the way... 09:02  |  David Hersch 14/07/08   30.   Worse Than Apartheid 19:41  |  Hershl Hartman 14/07/08   31.   To the editor of Ha`aretz 20:20  |  David Hersch 14/07/08   32.   Salviati #26 20:26  |  Zvi David 14/07/08   33.   Nothing Like Apartheid? 22:43  |  Todd Turner 14/07/08   34.   Haaretz Editors No need whatsoever for an apology 02:03  |  Dutch 15/07/08   35.   I find it amazing 03:15  |  Janice 15/07/08   36.   Israel and South Africa 03:18  |  Janice 15/07/08   37.   Yes, worse than Apartheid it is. 04:40  |  Eldad 15/07/08   38.   Worse than aparthied 14:08  |  hug 15/07/08   39.   Thank you for stating the reality 20:00  |  Laura 15/07/08   40.   they would know 06:30  |  deborah 16/07/08   41.   I support Aaptheid 04:38  |  Sam 23/07/08   42.   hell on Earth 22:27  |  Bill 25/07/08   43.   #4 OK 00:11  |  outsider 27/08/08   44.   Nationalzeitung 19:16  |  Daniel 06/09/08

Read & React Rosenblum: Israeli leaders want to be Obama Responses: 51 Pfeffer: Jewish Agency has signed its own death certificate Responses: 73 Greenberg: The hero on flight 11 Responses: 30 Nasrallah: We still seek fallen guerillas' bodies Responses: 127 Top IDF officer: Israel not prepared for next war Responses: 120 Chabad envoy to Alaska: Palin staunch friend of Jews Responses: 125 More Headlines 20:15 Abbas: Jerusalem, right of return are inalienable Palestinian rights 15:45 Israeli official denies U.S. supervisors will take part in Israel-Syria peace talks 20:06 Report: UN to demand Israel pay Lebanon $1 billion in reparations 13:19 Iran rejects French warning over possible Israeli strike 10:42 Gaddafi meets Rice during secretary of state's historic Libya trip 13:09 Israeli hacker arrested in Canada for $2 million online fraud 08:56 Court rules Michigan resident helped liquidate Polish Jews during Holocaust 19:18 Why was airing of 1st Palestinian soap opera cancelled? 18:48 65 kilos of drugs seized in 'record raid' in north 03:06 Jewish World / The language of anti-Semitism 11:26 Egypt uncovers three smuggling tunnels on border with Gaza 16:56 VIDEO / Hamas' Meshal agrees to pass Noam Shalit's letter to Gilad 23:17 Palestinians clash with IDF as Israel limits entry for Ramadan 01:25 Chabad envoy to Alaska: Palin staunch friend of Jews Previous Editions Select Day 05 sep 04 sep 03 sep 02 sep 01 sep 31 aug 29 aug 28 aug 27 aug 26 aug 25 aug 24 aug

Special Offers Advertisement Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. JMG your online solution Jewish Singles Personal Ads Find the love of your life on JDate.com MBA in Israel in English APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available Israel's Premier Real Estate Website www. israel-property.com Hebrew Summer courses From $39.95 ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt