Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., January 14, 2008 Shvat 7, 5768 | | Israel Time: 08:22 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. (Archives) Last update - 09:56 13/01/2008 Ministry disputes PM's claim of divided UN stance during war By Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff, Haaretz Correspondents Tags: Lebanon war, foreign ministry  A Foreign Ministry document prepared shortly after the Second Lebanon War challenges Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's claim of major differences between the various versions of United Nations Security Council Resolution 1701 which brought an end to the fighting. On the basis of this claim, Olmert and then Defense Minister Amir Peretz justified the final ground offensive in the war which claimed the lives of 33 soldiers in the Israel Defense Forces. According to documents and testimony received by Haaretz, the final version of the resolution, before the offensive, was not "unacceptable for Israel," as Olmert and Peretz claimed, and the differences from the version of the resolution that was passed were slight. Advertisement Moreover, the ground offensive began while the final version had been finalized, and had no impact on its content. The different drafts of the resolution is one of the main questions the Winograd Committee report due on January 30 is expected to address. The IDF began its final ground offensive after a green light from Olmert, during the night of August 11, 2006. The forces were ordered to proceed and take up positions along the Litani River in anticipation of a cease-fire that was due to go into effect 60 hours later. In practice, the forces failed in their mission and their progress was stopped, by orders of the political leadership, even before a cease-fire began. On Thursday, August 10, at 4 P.M., deliberations in the Prime Minister's Bureau began with the U.S. envoy, David Welch, and the legal adviser at the State Department, Jonathan Schwartz. At the end of the meeting, three hours later, a draft of 1701 that was acceptable both to the U.S. and Israel was reached. The Foreign Ministry's document evaluating the various drafts of the resolution dubbed this version the "Welch Draft." It was clear that changes might take place when the Americans negotiated the draft at the United Nations with the French, who represented the position of the Lebanese government. A new draft was received by Israel's ambassador to the UN, Danny Gillerman, following talks between the U.S. and French ambassadors to the international body. This draft served as the main reason for the final ground offensive. Israel applied intense diplomatic pressure on the U.S. and France for changes to this draft, which were included. The final version was sent to Jerusalem on Friday, August 11, a little after 8 P.M. At that time the IDF had only begun flying forces deep into southern Lebanon, which was the first part of the ground offensive. On Saturday, August 12, at 2:52 A.M., Resolution 1701 was passed at the Security Council. This was the version that Israel received seven hours earlier. Sources close to the prime minister said on Saturday there were a number of reasons the final ground offensive went ahead. But it mainly stemmed from the feeling that there might be a last-minute softening in the American position, accepting the French/Lebanese demands, the sources said. PM aide says opposed final ground offensive in Lebanon Meawnhile, one of the four individuals advising Olmert on August 11, 2006 - the day he decided to initiate the major ground offensive toward the end of the Second Lebanon War - says he advised against the operation and suggested a series of feints instead. Major General (res.) Amiram Levine, told Haaretz on Saturday that he suggested the prime minister make do with creating the impression among Hezbollah and the international community that the Israel Defense Forces were about to advance in Lebanon. In the first public statement by a participant in the August 11, 2006 meeting, Levine told Haaretz that he opposed a large-scale operation. "I wanted the world to believe we were going in without actually endangering soldiers. I gave the prime minister a detailed proposal," he said. On Thursday Haaretz published a report of events at the end of the war, with details of the meetings Olmert held with Levine, Major General (res.) Yedidia Ya'ari, military systems analyst Dr. Haim Assa and opinion survey consultant Kalman Geier. Related articles: Kadima sources: Mofaz critique of war conduct gives him 'alibi' U.S. academic Finkelstein meets top Hezbollah official in Lebanon Two UN peacekeepers lightly wounded by roadside blast in Lebanon UN human rights inquiry: Israel should compensate Lebanon Lebanon to UN: Israel breached truce deal hundreds of times Bookmark to del.icio.us   Iranian rhetoric Iranian boats threaten, so the U.S. candidates step up rhetoric. A new citizen Israeli pianist Daniel Barenboim takes Palestinian citizenship   1.   It should also be noted .. 10:48  |  Natallie Durson 13/01/08   2.   New Elections! New Government! 11:09  |  Natan 13/01/08   3.   There was much more going on behind the scenes.. 11:41  |  Judith, Haifa 13/01/08   4.   Political Exit Strategy vs Counter-Force Results 11:44  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 13/01/08   5.   Natan The Dreamer No. 2 12:05  |  Michael 13/01/08   6.   Early discussion of Winograd?s Report 16 days before its publica 12:27  |  H.H.M 13/01/08   7.   The inconvenient truth 14:09  |  Chris Linthwaite 13/01/08   8.   new and different 17:00  |  edgar 13/01/08   9.   #7 Linthwaite: Intel Corp. in Iraq? Not Yet... 17:04  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 13/01/08   10.   to Natallie 17:04  |  edgar 13/01/08   11.   #9 Ovadiah - Intel does not run US foreign policy 01:48  |  Johnboy 14/01/08   12.   Natalie Durson - where is your proof? 04:29  |  chris w 14/01/08

Today Online Israeli pianist Daniel Barenboim takes Palestinian citizenship Responses: 241 Palestinians sue for NIS 40 million for land taken by settlers Responses: 164 Yossi Sarid: Nice things in U.S., which would do Israel well Responses: 118 Gideon Levy: Time for PM to oust refusers of peace in government Responses: 87 Haaretz.com TV: Gaza parents can't join their sick children in Israel Responses: 182 Rosner's Domain Iranian boats threaten, so the candidates up the rhetoric The way to war with Iran (WTR) From 'The year of change' to 'The year of the comeback'? Rosner's Guest: The Jews are best prepared for a "flat world" Poll: Who is the candidate that will have better policies for Israel? More Headlines 03:07 Barak reaches deal for evacuation of outposts 08:20 IAF strike kills three Palestinian militants near Gaza City 01:26 Shin Bet head: More than 800 killed in Gaza in last two years 07:07 Court to hear petition against segregation of sexes on buses 06:35 Court not to issue back-to-work orders for striking lecturers 05:44 PM 'unworried' by Lieberman's threat to leave gov't over peace talks 03:45 Families lament ignorance of Lamed Heh's heroic sacrifice 03:50 PM aide: We'll fire rabbis who refuse to recognize legitimate converts 02:17 Diskin to MKs: Hamas managed to smuggle $100 million into Gaza 04:30 Cops: Mistaken identity behind attacks on elderly millionaire Previous Editions Select Day 13 jan 11 jan 10 jan 09 jan 08 jan 07 jan 06 jan 04 jan 03 jan 02 jan 01 jan 31 dec

Special Offers Advertisement Teach & Study Program make a difference in Israel FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer Inbal Jerusalem Hotel Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations AMERICANS CHOOSE DEMOCRATIC NOMINEE U.S. citizen in Israel vote in Democrats-Abroad official global primary.

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved