Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., February 10, 2010 Shvat 26, 5770 | | Israel Time: 18:30 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books Haaretz Store
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted:

Americans have a favorable view of Israel, especially Republicans

1.

You might want to check out this Gallup poll.

Israel might not be one of the top four most favorable countries in America, but it is among the top five. Following Canada, Britain, Germany and Japan - and more favorable than countries like India, France and Mexico (India is in a better position when it comes to unfavorable views).

I can tell you as much: Israel's ambassador to Washington, Salai Meridor, is quite satisfied. American support, he says, is essential today as it ever was.

2.

Two of the countries with which Israel has some issues to solve are among the three less favorable countries: Iran at the bottom, the Palestinian authority third from the bottom (they are separated by North Korea). The most surprising Arab country in this poll is Egypt, with 61% favorability, and only 26% of Americans mentioning it in the unfavorable column - just one percent more than Israel.

3.

I wrote quite a lot in the past about polls measuring Israel's favorability ranking in America. This post, for example, was dealing with a similar poll by Quinnipiac University:

In a survey asking Americans to identify countries in which support of America is the most visible, the public identified England, Canada and Israel as the most favorable and Iran, North Korea and Cuba as the least favorable.

So the trend is similar: when the name of Israel is presented, very few (mostly English speaking) countries get a more favorable rating. In this post I wrote about previous Gallup poll (from Feb. 2006):

In its surveys, Gallup usually asks whether the sympathies of the interviewees lie more with the Israelis or with Palestinians. Sympathy for Israel is now at one of its highest points ever. Only twice in the past 15 years has it been higher: During the first Iraq war in 1991 (Iraq was then launching Scud missiles into Israel) and shortly before the second war with Iraq, in 2003.

4.

So what's new about this new survey? Not much. And some of the more troubling political trends are in play more than ever.

For one: "Israel, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Iraq are all viewed more favorably by Republicans than by Democrats".

Are they trying to tell us something?

Apparently they do, because the Democrats seem to be far less supportive of Israel than Republicans. The margin is significant - 20% (84% GOP, 64% Dem. Note that they dislike Iran and the Palestinian Authority in similar numbers). And one can argue that 64% is still very nice, a clear and unshakable majority. But imagine this: If Democrats would have been as favorable of Israel as Republicans, Israel would have been at the top of the list, second only to Canada and Britain.

5.

And here is another such nugget: "Younger adults are also more likely than those 55 and older to have favorable views of" Egypt, the Palestinian Authority, Iran. They are less likely to have favorable view of Israel.

6.

Israel has some 25% of staunch supporters (very favorable). This something India and Egypt, who fare quite well in this poll, do not have. And take a look at the second half of this poll (come to think of it, it is possibly the first half):

The 71% of Americans viewing Israel favorably today is eight points higher than the 63% recorded last year, and is the highest favorable score for Israel since the 79% recorded during the 1991 Gulf War.

Three countries, France, Israel, and Iraq, are now held in higher esteem by Americans than they were a year ago. With France the reason is clear: President Sarkozy. With Iraq it is also clear: General Petraeus.

And for Israel?

2006 was probably a fluke.

  1.   Demographics are changing 06:51  |  amazed American 05/03/08
  2.   LIES 11:13  |  Me 05/03/08
  3.   probably not the catholics 11:20  |  chester a. 05/03/08
  4.   The difference between U.S. and European public opinion....... 11:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/03/08
  5.   IGNORANT AMERICANS 11:26  |  indrajaya 05/03/08
  6.   New generation will see the truth 11:42  |  justicenik 05/03/08
  7.   Very soft numbers ... 12:09  |  spyguy 05/03/08
  8.   big deal... 12:29  |  ravi 05/03/08
  9.   # 1 Amazed American 12:55  |  Nick Ferriman 05/03/08
  10.   Thanks 2 APIC lobby and evanglicals! Not this American!! 12:58  |  Tupac 05/03/08
  11.   especially republicans 13:00  |  JJ burke 05/03/08
  12.   English speaking becuase Isrealis are European Colonists. 13:01  |  Tupac 05/03/08
  13.   Depends on what ... 13:01  |  Edith 05/03/08
  14.   Younger adults less likely to have favorable view of Israel. 13:05  |  Tupac 05/03/08
  15.   Thats because India is stealing our jobs and Isreal is buying our 13:11  |  Tupac 05/03/08
  16.   #9 nick and more of the syndrome ! 13:40  |  v hardman 05/03/08
  17.   The Internet generation is coming at age 13:51  |  Mark B. 05/03/08
  18.   No. 7, spyguy 14:18  |  W 05/03/08
  19.   #1 Here we go again! 14:21  |  Moshe 05/03/08
  20.   #5 15:01  |  Ignorant American 05/03/08
  21.   # 17 W...yes, it is amazing 15:02  |  Lynn 05/03/08
  22.   No background 15:06  |  Reality Check 05/03/08
  23.   I lived in America. Americans SO NAIVE when it comes to politics 15:16  |  James 05/03/08
  24.   Some Choices!! 15:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/08
  25.   no. 19 you`ve been reported to authorities 16:05  |  Ami Five 05/03/08
  26.   You are biased commenters 16:12  |  Amazed American 05/03/08
  27.   Pedro F 16:21  |  Iraq Veteran 05/03/08
  28.   Indrajaya - you`re right, Americans are ignorant 16:27  |  Steve 05/03/08
  29.   No fox news here 16:31  |  Amazed American 05/03/08
  30.   nonsense 18:13  |  al 05/03/08
  31.   Indy #5 18:29  |  Neal 05/03/08
  32.   what else ??? David Israel 18:38  |  mehmet 05/03/08
  33.   nonsense 18:48  |  God fearing 05/03/08
  34.   The average American is entirely ignorant... 20:19  |  Deborah 05/03/08
  35.   Humus is quite delicious 20:20  |  Bill 05/03/08
  36.   What about sponsoring a friendly meeting between... 20:42  |  Luis 05/03/08
  37.   Why so many Muslims opt to live in this called "land of stupids"? 20:46  |  luis 05/03/08
  38.   mehmet - you asked so Ianswer 20:48  |  David Israel 05/03/08
  39.   Mehmet Now let me ask you 21:09  |  David Israel 05/03/08
  40.   support 21:12  |  bel 05/03/08
  41.   Deborah - You dont know Americans 21:18  |  David Israel 05/03/08
  42.   Rosner blows hot air again... 21:21  |  betz55 05/03/08
  43.   And one more thing... 21:26  |  betz55 05/03/08
  44.   favorable view of Israel 21:48  |  Ralph 05/03/08
  45.   @Swiss Dino 14 21:52  |  Ralph 05/03/08
  46.   American viewpoints and #30 22:05  |  BET 05/03/08
  47.   Why so many Muslims opt to live in this called "land of stupids"? 22:07  |  Luis 05/03/08
  48.   mehmet - you asked so I answer 22:08  |  David Israel 05/03/08
  49.   American viewpoints and #30 22:13  |  BET 05/03/08
  50.   Swiss (dino) don`t be so snobbish 22:17  |  David Israel 05/03/08
  51.   Why is there freedom of speech/faith in the "land of stupids"? 22:25  |  Luis 05/03/08
  52.   Bill I don`t know why but 22:42  |  David Israel 05/03/08
  53.   # 34 Deborah...where did you get your limited 22:54  |  Lynn 05/03/08
  54.   betz55...US gives aid to Pals 22:58  |  Lynn 05/03/08
  55.   mehmet of Istanbul....why trust? 23:06  |  Lynn 05/03/08
  56.   #4 Swiss- more drivel presented as "fact" 23:22  |  Ronaldinho 05/03/08
  57.   Swiss ....Please!!! 23:22  |  Lynn 05/03/08
  58.   #38 David Israel 23:33  |  Deborah 05/03/08
  59.   Israelis love America 23:43  |  Iz Ray Leigh 05/03/08
  60.   Reply to Yaakov #24 23:44  |  Zoran 05/03/08
  61.   Deborah has a theme tune 23:44  |  x-ray 05/03/08
  62.   lies 23:59  |  mike191 05/03/08
  63.   David Israel # 38 re Deborah # 34 You are full of it 00:12  |  American in NY 06/03/08
  64.   Google: Gaza Shoah comment: 1 million hits 00:21  |  Angel 06/03/08
  65.   Deborah - You can be fixed to your idea but 00:24  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  66.   # 42 Ralph 00:27  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/08
  67.   David Israel also... 00:35  |  American in NY 06/03/08
  68.   Iz Ray Leigh # 53 00:38  |  American in NY 06/03/08
  69.   # 50 Ronaldinho (1) 00:42  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/08
  70.   #45 David Israel; why did America help Moslem Albanians 00:58  |  AliciaYasmeen 06/03/08
  71.   # 50 Ronaldinho (2) 00:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/08
  72.   # 51 Lynn 01:08  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/08
  73.   Swiss -- Americans will always support its friend and ally Israel 01:16  |  Gina 06/03/08
  74.   Deborah -- as ignorant as those who believe 01:20  |  Gina 06/03/08
  75.   Iz Ray Leigh -- I believe you 01:39  |  Gina 06/03/08
  76.   Swiss (Dino) # 4 re: Lynn # 51 02:06  |  American in NY 06/03/08
  77.   Swiss - the mask is slipping... 02:49  |  Ronaldinho 06/03/08
  78.   AliciaYasmeen - USA has enough bases 02:58  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  79.   # 59 Gina, still living in her (own) fantasy-world.... 03:13  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/08
  80.   Israel, Americas reliant ally. 03:20  |  Stephen. 06/03/08
  81.   Am,erican in NY - 03:57  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  82.   Another bogus article from GOP lover, Rosner. 08:56  |  devin 06/03/08
  83.   Republicans 08:58  |  Psaturn 06/03/08
  84.   THis article is BS 09:09  |  Mark 06/03/08
  85.   # 77 Ronaldinho 09:48  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/08
  86.   Wow..Look at all the talkbacks 10:44  |  James 06/03/08
  87.   #35 10:45  |  Jimmy 06/03/08
  88.   #78 David Israel 13:47  |  AliciaYasmeen 06/03/08
  89.   Davis Israel # 81 Invalid Poll many countries left out 15:45  |  American in NY 06/03/08
  90.   American in NY (I doubt it) 16:12  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  91.   AliciaYasmeen #88 16:28  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  92.   Growing up American 17:34  |  Lisa 06/03/08
  93.   who did you poll? 17:54  |  sam i am 06/03/08
  94.   Growing up American-2 18:05  |  Lisa 06/03/08
  95.   Fuzzy math, I see. 19:42  |  Mijan 06/03/08
  96.   American in NY (I doubt it) 19:43  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  97.   AliciaYasmeen #88 19:44  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  98.   American in NY about BBC 19:50  |  David Israel 06/03/08
  99.   david Israel the wannabe 21:26  |  American in NY 06/03/08
  100.   #1 00:11  |  sam 07/03/08
  101.   #14 00:16  |  SAM 07/03/08
  102.   American media bias 19:50  |  Yankeegoy 08/03/08
  103.   Hey American Jews. Why do you still support Democrats? 23:51  |  Chaim 08/03/08
  104.   American Media Bias 05:53  |  amazed american 10/03/08
  105.   Israel and US 10:29  |  John 23/06/08
  106.   American Support for Israel 03:29  |  Bob 25/06/08


Domain's Guest
David Rivkin
Top Washington lawyer and former official David Rivkin will discuss Israel-related strategic and legal issues. Readers can send questions.
Previous guests
* Click here for a list of previous guests


Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved