Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 22, 2009 Kislev 5, 5770 | | Israel Time: 00:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted: December 21, 2006

Explaining Obama to Israelis

In the summer of 1961, several months after John F. Kennedy entered the White House, a beautiful boy was born in Hawaii to a father "black as pitch" and a mother "white as milk." Forty-five years hence, Barack Hussein Obama, the son of a student from Kenya and a woman from Kansas, whose parents are thus colorfully described in his first book, the best-seller "Dreams from My Father," is the most exciting politician in America.

Just as Kennedy was. Very soon, it appears, his candidacy for office of president will be announced. He will then be asked, over and over, the obvious question: How can a young, inexperienced man compete for the job desired by seasoned political lions like the Democrat Hillary Clinton and the Republican John McCain?

Obama's second book is also at the top of the best-seller lists. Its title is "The Audacity of Hope." Obama surely wants to be audacious like JFK, who also wrote two best-sellers before he was elected president, and to radiate hope and appear erudite and charismatic as another young Democrat named Bill Clinton did (Clinton was "The man from Hope" - the name of his hometown).
But for that annoying question about his lack of experience, Obama has an answer to fend off detractors. He can point to political figure who casts a bigger shadow than either JFK or Clinton. Like Obama, he was a legislator from the state of Illinois and had only two years of experience before being elected president. His name was Abraham Lincoln, and he was a success.

Here are some of the reasons why the Israeli public should be interested in Obama: he manifests the genuine longing for change in American society; he is the most charismatic candidate and represents a new generation of politicians; he is the proof that the less you do, the more difficult it is for your opponents to slander your candidacy; he offers a key to understanding the strength, but also the weakness of the political dynamics in the United States; and he may be the next president, or his deputy, in two years.

Obama is probably a brilliant man, but his record to date is somewhat thin. Elected to the Senate only two years ago, he has not led any important piece of legislation nor did he make a moving speech. And not because he is especially careful - all the candidates are careful at this point. And not because he lacks views. He has simply never had to account for anything. Obama never managed an organization, never led soldiers into combat, was not a governor, was not a mayor, minister or a Congressional leader. In any event, no dirt seems to have stuck to him. Whoever does nothing, makes no mistake. Therefore, beyond the slogans for unity and change, love and hope, it is hard to know what kind of president he wants to be.

Those closely following the American political scene are fixated on Obama. Magazines put him on their covers like a movie or pop star. Among those who care for Israel's interests, there is reason for concern: For example, the panel of experts that Haaretz convenes monthly to rank the potential candidates for the presidency boycotts him. They note that the supporters of the front-runner are left-wing Democrats and voters whose views on Israel are less positive than those of the average American voter.

The fact that Obama has a fighting chance to be a presidential candidate reflects the obvious weakness of the American system, which is capable of tossing the leadership of a superpower, the most important job on the planet, to a person whose leadership has never been tested. But this also reflects the system's strength: The old is replaced by the new, the tired with the fresh, the insider by the outsider.

Obama's sudden rise in politics reflects the tremendous thirst for new faces. He comes from a generation that is willing to admit to having smoked marijuana as a rite of coming of age. And the color of his skin does not fit the stereotype. He, like the most popular black statesman to date, Colin Powell, is not "a real African-American." His family history does not carry the weight of humiliation and guilt from the age of slavery.

There are Israelis who see possibilities in Obama: The two presidents who invested the greatest effort to bringing peace to Israel and its neighbors were nearly as foreign to the mainstream as he is - Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter, who were both anonymous governors of less important states, and no one could have guessed the Israeli conundrum would fascinate them. Whoever prefers this sort of president may have hope for the next generation. Sometimes, it actually works out.

More American politics on Rosner's Domain:

The Israel Factor: Ranking the American Presidential candidates.

Political notes: Obama, Kerry, McCain, Soros.

  1.   the US and probably Obama are Israel`s sugar daddy 16:45  |  tuairimiocht 21/12/06
  2.   Moving 21:02  |  Bill 21/12/06
  3.   B. OBAMA 21:52  |  A.BAKER 21/12/06
  4.   Obama can be the next president ? 22:13  |  paulo2005 21/12/06
  5.   Obama from one Israel supporter viewpoint 23:00  |  Dave from Chicago 21/12/06
  6.   #1 23:03  |  Bill Pearlman 21/12/06
  7.   Obama following Carter/Clinton? 00:37  |  Rich 22/12/06
  8.   Bill`s disingenuity, from the land of Helen Clarke 01:15  |  Jake 22/12/06
  9.   tuiairiamiocht`s fuzzy math 01:25  |  Jake 22/12/06
  10.   Hold It Guys! We Gotta Be Careful! 02:00  |  Yosemite Sam 22/12/06
  11.   Obama has no chance of being elected President 03:46  |  * BEN JABO 22/12/06
  12.   #2 Bill NZ 04:02  |  * BEN JABO 22/12/06
  13.   Obama would be a Puppet on Clinton`s strings 05:54  |  Tomas 22/12/06
  14.   "black as pitch" 06:09  |  Randy 22/12/06
  15.   to #1 06:29  |  Jake 22/12/06
  16.   Rosner is quickly taking on the role of hate monger 06:59  |  Pablo B 22/12/06
  17.   To Bill re 1 10:06  |  Dan 22/12/06
  18.   Barack Hussien Obama 11:43  |  Carlos Murphy 22/12/06
  19.   the US and probably Obama are Israel`s sugar daddy 12:22  |  tuairimiocht 22/12/06
  20.   #16 Pablo`s jealous 14:55  |  * BEN JABO 22/12/06
  21.   #19 What are you guys still doing 15:01  |  * BEN JABO 22/12/06
  22.   abortionist obama 15:48  |  albert paul ortiz 22/12/06
  23.   #21 "you guys" 15:59  |  tuairimiocht 22/12/06
  24.   Really doesnt matter the family history. 16:32  |  Simon 22/12/06
  25.   Short Of A Revolution In Iran... 17:57  |  Yosemite Sam 22/12/06
  26.   Dave from Chicago 22:12  |  Stephen Connor 22/12/06
  27.   Obama 05:51  |  Connie 23/12/06
  28.   to Stephan from Ann Arbor 06:28  |  Dave from Chicago 23/12/06
  29.   Jesus Israel is full of herself 06:30  |  Marilyn 23/12/06
  30.   Iranian History Didn`t Start in 1979 08:39  |  Mark of Lewiston 23/12/06
  31.   Response to Marilyn #29 14:42  |  Eli 23/12/06
  32.   Obama`s broad spectrum support 18:51  |  Pam 23/12/06
  33.   Giuliani will be the next president 19:12  |  Joseph 23/12/06
  34.   Obama 22:16  |  Catherine 23/12/06
  35.   To Dave in Chicago 22:16  |  amazed american 23/12/06
  36.   marilyn #29, East Timor slaughter 23:41  |  Seymour 23/12/06
  37.   #27 Connie...I`m confused 01:29  |  tadchase 24/12/06
  38.   it`s not all about Israel 04:44  |  margaret 24/12/06
  39.   Marilyn #29 05:30  |  Bill Pearlman 24/12/06
  40.   To #14 07:32  |  yh 24/12/06
  41.   Bill 39, I have Palestinian friends 17:30  |  Marilyn 24/12/06
  42.   Too soon for the top job. 21:00  |  Joe 24/12/06
  43.   Marilyn #29 22:35  |  Bill Pearlman 24/12/06
  44.   Anything but re-born Christians and neocons please 23:47  |  Mark B. 24/12/06
  45.   Explaining to Israelis 01:38  |  Shmuelshachor 25/12/06
  46.   to Amazed American 03:25  |  Dave from Chicago 25/12/06
  47.   to Margret from NYC 03:34  |  Dave from Chicago 25/12/06
  48.   Give him a chance! 03:36  |  lawyer II 25/12/06
  49.   to Margeret cont / Obama for Israel 03:48  |  Dave from Chicago 25/12/06
  50.   How dare Isarelis try to influence american Presidential election 04:03  |  omolll 25/12/06
  51.   to lawyer II 05:16  |  Dave from Chicago 25/12/06
  52.   to Omoll. Impacting elections 05:23  |  Dave from Chicago 25/12/06
  53.   obama 06:43  |  Gordon 25/12/06
  54.   To Bill #39 06:52  |  Gordon 25/12/06
  55.   To Dave in Chicago 07:26  |  amazed american 25/12/06
  56.   to Gordon #54, Islam and the West 07:31  |  Dave from Chicago 25/12/06
  57.   Dear Omolll from Dallas 07:37  |  amazed american 25/12/06
  58.   Obama 08:09  |  Bel 25/12/06
  59.   obama 08:18  |  k mASRY 25/12/06
  60.   HE`LL NEVER BE PRESIDENT 18:44  |  MOSHE 25/12/06
  61.   To Dave From Chicago 20:42  |  Lawyer II 25/12/06
  62.   To Moshe 05:50  |  Nathan 26/12/06
  63.   a 11:15  |  a 26/12/06
  64.   Way too early 16:29  |  Calhoun 26/12/06
  65.   #27 a response inspired by connie`s post 02:41  |  milica 27/12/06
  66.   Letter To The LA Times Today Asked Again! 09:26  |  Yosemite Sam 27/12/06
  67.   Obama did make a moving speech! 08:13  |  Jose 28/12/06
  68.   Where`s the Carter article??? 11:54  |  PBR 28/12/06
  69.   Obama 12:13  |  dominique 28/12/06
  70.   next Prez no way 17:44  |  BO 28/12/06


Domain's Guest
David Rivkin
Top Washington lawyer and former official David Rivkin will discuss Israel-related strategic and legal issues. Readers can send questions.
Previous guests
* Click here for a list of previous guests


Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved