Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 22, 2009 Kislev 5, 5770 | | Israel Time: 13:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted:

Democratic leaders: Carter wrong on Israel

Carter

Does Jimmy Carter represent the Democratic Party's view on Israel? Carter - who's about to publish a book on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Palestine Peace, Not Apartheid - is quoted as saying that he represents "the vast majority of the Democrats." But House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi begs to differ (I wrote about the new book a couple of days ago).

She issued a statement regarding Jimmy Carter's new book saying: "With all due respect to former President Carter, he does not speak for the Democratic Party on Israel. Democrats have been steadfast in their support of Israel from its birth, in part because we recognize that to do so is in the national security interests of the United States. We stand with Israel now and we stand with Israel forever? It is wrong to suggest that the Jewish people would support a government in Israel or anywhere else that institutionalizes ethnically based oppression, and Democrats reject that allegation vigorously."


Democrats

54% of the Jewish population defining themselves as Democrats, according to the new AJC poll, but the same percentage, 54%, see themselves as slightly liberal, moderate or slightly conservative. This means that the Jewish community is more centrist than one might think, and will not tolerate a Party in which the extremists rule. Pelosi knows it and so does Howard Dean, who issued a similar statement regarding Carter's book: "While I have tremendous respect for former President Carter, I fundamentally disagree and do not support his analysis of Israel and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. On this issue President Carter speaks for himself, the opinions in his book are his own, they are not the views or position of the Democratic Party."

Israel

That's one of the reasons for which Israeli analysts and policy makers do not perceive the expected victory of the Democratic Party in the Midterms to be a problem for Israel. They think that Congress will stay as supportive as it is now. Since it seems as though Joe Lieberman is on his way to winning in Connecticut, some of them feel that the trend toward a more leftist party - the trend that propelled Ned Lamont to the candidacy - is toning down.

  1.   "Supporting Israel is in the US` national interest" 23:26  |  Polybios 24/10/06
  2.   U.S. Congress: Educate yourselves 00:04  |  Jill 25/10/06
  3.   Jimmy! Under The Peanut Shell For Now 00:36  |  Tony Anthony 25/10/06
  4.   Pelosi vs Carter 00:41  |  Grif 25/10/06
  5.   The left and Israel 01:33  |  Yakov 25/10/06
  6.   re: Pelosi v. Carter 02:07  |  sanfran 25/10/06
  7.   Unclear Writing - And Carter`s bias 02:29  |  David 25/10/06
  8.   Billy Carters Brother 04:11  |  MF 25/10/06
  9.   #4 is correct 05:30  |  bbl 25/10/06
  10.   I Think Jimmy Carter Is An Alien From Planet X! 05:40  |  Yosemite Sam 25/10/06
  11.   Need a follow-up question on party ID 05:42  |  sk 25/10/06
  12.   To MF 05:47  |  Dee Dubb 25/10/06
  13.   Nancy Reassures "The Lobby" 06:20  |  Harris 25/10/06
  14.   #2 06:32  |  Jordan 25/10/06
  15.   Nancy Pelosi Has it all Wrong 06:41  |  Dutch 25/10/06
  16.   Hey, the editors changed the numbers -- I now mean #6 is correct 08:04  |  bbl 25/10/06
  17.   Carter may not speak for pelosi 09:42  |  Guy From NYC 25/10/06
  18.   Of course he does not 13:52  |  Noura 25/10/06
  19.   Political necessity 14:58  |  George 25/10/06
  20.   yes not the first time !! 15:22  |  george 25/10/06
  21.   What`s The Best Thing You Can Say About Jimmy Carter? 15:25  |  Yosemite Sam 25/10/06
  22.   Condi Rice For President In 2008! 15:28  |  Yosemite Sam 25/10/06
  23.   Jimmy Carter outlived his usefulness long before he was president 16:07  |  Claudia 25/10/06
  24.   Pelosi is a drip 16:14  |  hollingsworth 25/10/06
  25.   Carter 16:52  |  Brod 25/10/06
  26.   15: Dutch is a funny girl 16:53  |  David Teich 25/10/06
  27.   23: No, Gloria, just during it 16:55  |  David Teich 25/10/06
  28.   21&22: Yosemite`s confused 16:58  |  David Teich 25/10/06
  29.   That`s a poll that probably will not be taken 17:04  |  hollingsworth 25/10/06
  30.   Democratic party 17:11  |  Mndem 25/10/06
  31.   alway discredit the Messenger when u don`t like the message 17:18  |  xman 25/10/06
  32.   And yet David Teich 17:25  |  Jacob Blues 25/10/06
  33.   Jimmy Carter who facilitates Islamofascism 17:29  |  Howard 25/10/06
  34.   Public Political Opinion 17:38  |  Ernie 25/10/06
  35.   is that sorry old fool still alive ? sigh.. 17:40  |  Mike 25/10/06
  36.   Mndem (Post No. 30) 17:52  |  Johnny Weintraub 25/10/06
  37.   Jimmy Carter for president 18:09  |  Amin Nusseibeh 25/10/06
  38.   Speak for yourself Doris 18:15  |  US Supports Israel 25/10/06
  39.   Who has read Jimmy Carter`s book? 18:56  |  Peter Wallace 25/10/06
  40.   Madame Speaker sets her priorities 18:57  |  Voice of Reason 25/10/06
  41.   Carter 18:58  |  MNdem 25/10/06
  42.   Carter Wrong On Israel 19:14  |  Malleck Amode 25/10/06
  43.   That`s for DEM sure ! 19:14  |  Akiva Patysh 25/10/06
  44.   MS Pelosi Knows All Too Well What Side Her Bread Is Buttered ON 19:20  |  Yaakov Sullivan 25/10/06
  45.   re#7 Carter not liberal? What banana truck you fall off? (end) 19:26  |  Charles 25/10/06
  46.   Grif @# 4 19:27  |  Akiva Patysh 25/10/06
  47.   what does Lamont & Carter have to do with each other? 19:33  |  steve 25/10/06
  48.   # 37 solving the Jewish Problem? 19:45  |  Daniel 25/10/06
  49.   Washington Carver went penniless.. 20:02  |  Akiva Patysh, Tzioni 25/10/06
  50.   Carter is just a shmock 20:08  |  Jeff 25/10/06
  51.   #37 Amin: Indescribable stupidity 20:10  |  Polybios 25/10/06
  52.   Sanfran you forgot. 20:10  |  Billy jack 25/10/06
  53.   yosemite sam 20:13  |  Billy jack 25/10/06
  54.   The United States of Israel 20:22  |  Abraham 25/10/06
  55.   The United States of Israel 20:22  |  Abraham 25/10/06
  56.   To Jordan 20:25  |  Nathan 25/10/06
  57.   Congress: bought and paid for by AIPAC 20:29  |  NG 25/10/06
  58.   32: Jacob, I never said he was all bad... 20:37  |  David Teich 25/10/06
  59.   The hypocrisy and criminality of the Carter radical left 20:41  |  Shalom Freedman 25/10/06
  60.   CARTER SHOULD MOVE TO AFRICA 20:42  |  TIM 25/10/06
  61.   Nathan the spokesperson 20:54  |  Polybios 25/10/06
  62.   cARTER 21:48  |  James Eells 25/10/06
  63.   Don`t Bother Me Billy Jack! 22:12  |  Yosemite Sam 25/10/06
  64.   No. 37 "The Jewish Problem"????????? 22:28  |  Andy from Virginia 25/10/06
  65.   Carter brought us a maniacal Iran 22:32  |  William 25/10/06
  66.   yes not the first time !! 22:37  |  gershon 25/10/06
  67.   Public Political Opinion 22:47  |  gershon 25/10/06
  68.   to Amin Nusseibeh 23:07  |  gershon 25/10/06
  69.   Israel Has A Jewish Majority Because Of The Holocaust! 23:12  |  Yosemite Sam 25/10/06
  70.   carter 23:14  |  tom 25/10/06
  71.   Carter speaks for Dems not the Party 23:30  |  GC Fraser 25/10/06
  72.   Carter speaks for nobody! 00:39  |  jeff atkinson 26/10/06
  73.   Carter is an enemy of Israel. 00:39  |  Haldrik 26/10/06
  74.   A vote for Carter = a win for Republicans! 00:46  |  AV 26/10/06
  75.   Carter is the Democrat Party 00:58  |  rick geiger 26/10/06
  76.   Carter right on Israel 01:04  |  prairdog 26/10/06
  77.   Carter equal Decency 01:13  |  BP Dipl 26/10/06
  78.   Carter equal Decency 01:18  |  BP Dipl 26/10/06
  79.   re#63yosamite sam 01:33  |  Billy jack 26/10/06
  80.   its simple 02:19  |  Omar 26/10/06
  81.   Jimmy Carter 03:12  |  Richard 26/10/06
  82.   Carter`s shortcomings not anti-semiticism 03:26  |  Nathaniel 26/10/06
  83.   BUSH the best president ofr Israel 04:00  |  Marco 26/10/06
  84.   The majority of Palestinians arent decent: they voted for Hamas! 04:08  |  AV 26/10/06
  85.   Carter brought us a maniacal Iran 05:01  |  AV 26/10/06
  86.   Carter misses the basic difference 06:10  |  DavidAK 26/10/06
  87.   david ak 06:36  |  joe 26/10/06
  88.   Politically Correct Carter 06:52  |  Bracha 26/10/06
  89.   RE: Nathan..Israel brought Terrorism to ME.. 06:57  |  Charles T. Brown 26/10/06
  90.   FORMER PRES. CARTER SPEAKS THE TRUTH 07:31  |  Joe 26/10/06
  91.   In Nathan`s Opinion, Israel is Terrorism 07:41  |  Steven 26/10/06
  92.   FORMER PRES. CARTER SPEAKS THE TRUTH 07:42  |  Joe 26/10/06
  93.   Carter`s book....so what`s your point Shmuel? 07:46  |  RW 26/10/06
  94.   DavidAK is exactly right 12:01  |  AV 26/10/06
  95.   69: No Yosemite. Quit foaming and deal with facts 12:42  |  David Teich 26/10/06
  96.   Dutch 20:38  |  Jane 26/10/06
  97.   Carter wrong on Israel 02:40  |  Andrea 27/10/06
  98.   Carter-Israel 07:06  |  Sophia 27/10/06
  99.   98: Sophia, thanx for the amusement, now try facts 14:54  |  David Teich 27/10/06
  100.   # 99 David Teich. re:Jimmy Carter..... 16:16  |  Kathy 27/10/06
  101.   Rant from a bitter old man 23:24  |  NS 27/10/06
  102.   Carter 12:59  |  Jamie 28/10/06
  103.   Das apelle falt nisht vait funem boim 14:56  |  Max Zinger 28/10/06
  104.   #92 Joe, I find Pelosi support sickening too ! 00:18  |  Dutch 29/10/06
  105.   Do the homework 17:32  |  Neahle 29/10/06
  106.   Carter`s view! 09:28  |  Willy 30/10/06


Domain's Guest
David Rivkin
Top Washington lawyer and former official David Rivkin will discuss Israel-related strategic and legal issues. Readers can send questions.
Previous guests
* Click here for a list of previous guests


Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved