Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 22, 2009 Kislev 5, 5770 | | Israel Time: 03:55 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted: August 31, 2006

Get ready for the Democrats

WASHINGTON - Congressman Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat, ran into a problem - he unintentionally found himself in the camp of Israel's enemies. All he wanted was an immediate cease-fire in Lebanon. A few weeks ago, as the war raged, he sent a letter to Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, and asked her to do something. He was trying to take aim at the Bush administration - which is what a Democrat is expected to do on the eve of elections - but it turned out that this is not how Israel's friends saw things. Van Hollen was called in for a little chat with officials from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.

Some accepted his explanations - he did not apologize, just clarified his statements - but others thought that was not enough and that Van Hollen had crossed the red line.

At the root of the American administration's support for Israel lies the assumption that this is not a subject of controversy. One can attack George W. Bush, but not at Israel's expense. Van Hollen's district in Maryland is very pro-Democrat, and is also populated by many Jews. Some of them may reconsider their congressional choice.

The midterm election campaign committee is scheduled to meet next week and throw the Democrats in high gear, which will probably lead them to victory. They can expect to take over the House of Representatives for the first time after a decade of Republican control, and they may even succeed in gaining control of the Senate. Until the 2008 presidential elections, political life will look different. The president will lack a congressional majority, and some of the most senior senators will be busy trying to win reelection campaigns.

The pro-Democrat voters are eager for a victory. Their support for Israel is stable, but their views differ from those of the Republicans. A Pew survey taken three weeks ago showed an interesting response to how much the U.S. should be involved in Lebanon. Most Republicans felt that the administration is intervening appropriately; however, many of the Democrats felt their country should be both "much more involved" and "much less involved." In this they reflected two common approaches of voters on the left: that calling for diplomatic intervention to settle conflicts, and that demanding the U.S. avoid interfering in such areas.

The main issues on the Middle East agenda will surely be influenced by a Democratic victory in the elections. Most of the Democratic voters no longer support an immediate withdrawal from Iraq, but they may change their minds. They will want to dispose of the problem, and not retain it for the next president to deal with, one who may be from their ranks. On the issue of Iran they face a dilemma: should they bypass President Bush on the right and present themselves as hawks, or should they take a moderate stance and present the administration as threatening to draw America into another military adventure?

The basic attitude of Congress toward Israel is not likely to change, according to some pro-Israel officials busy trying to insure just that. Given history they are likely to be correct, and the general support can be expected to continue. But there are times when the details also matter.

When a congressional majority comes from the ranks of the opposition, it may choose to fall in line with the president or to attack his administration. If it chooses to attack - it has the option of doing so from the right or the left. Traditionally, supporters of Israel have managed to keep its interests bipartisan. However, this task may now become more complicated: So long as Israel's affairs were at the sidelines of the American political agenda, an opposition party could easily forgo using it as a tool to confront the administration - since it was not a controversial issue. However, as the issues pertaining to Israel become increasingly central to U.S. foreign policy, it becomes more enticing to make use of them for political purposes.

The crisis with Iran, Lebanon, terrorism, the confrontation with Islam, democratization in the Middle East and the price of oil - these are all issues directly linked to Israel. Can a Democratic Congress avoid using these against the president, sometimes even at Israel's expense? This is an intriguing question. A partial answer has already been offered by Chris Van Hollen, and this does not necessarily herald easy days to come.




  1.   Shmuel as the expert 05:13  |  Ann 31/08/06
  2.   I was a Democrat 30 years... 07:08  |  Chezi 31/08/06
  3.   THE COMING SECOND AMERICAN CIVIL WAR 07:25  |  PhiloEvraios 31/08/06
  4.   Democrat Cut and run tendancies concern me 07:45  |  RLG 31/08/06
  5.   I must have missed someyhing 10:51  |  wally 31/08/06
  6.   DON`T WORRY ISRAEL 11:08  |  indrajaya 31/08/06
  7.   Chezi -- I`m not sure you deserve your freedom 11:18  |  bbl 31/08/06
  8.   My President is an idiot 11:24  |  bbl 31/08/06
  9.   There`s no opposition to Israel officially anywhere in Congress 11:26  |  RW 31/08/06
  10.   RLG -- taken from the Republican playbook 11:31  |  bbl 31/08/06
  11.   The Democrats are BOOBS 12:52  |  Dror 31/08/06
  12.   # 3 PhiloEvraios 12:59  |  Critic 31/08/06
  13.   Only Democrats really care about Israel`s real interests! 13:05  |  Louis T. Sigel 31/08/06
  14.   I wish I could be as confident of a Democratc victory!~ 13:18  |  Louis T. Sigel 31/08/06
  15.   To Dror; who supplied nuclear reactors to North Korea? 13:26  |  Louis T. Sigel 31/08/06
  16.   BRAIN WORKS MUCH BETTER THAN GUNS AND BOMBS 13:27  |  MARCO 31/08/06
  17.   Louis T. Sigel 13:44  |  Dror 31/08/06
  18.   # 8, BBL 13:45  |  indrajaya 31/08/06
  19.   This young man.... 13:58  |  Edith 31/08/06
  20.   #13 apparently... 14:02  |  Edith 31/08/06
  21.   To Dror--put up and don`t ignore the evidence 14:39  |  Louis T. Sigel 31/08/06
  22.   Lous T. Sigel 15:41  |  Dror 31/08/06
  23.   Indrajaya from Jakarta: Have compassion for YOUR people 15:41  |  Vittorio 31/08/06
  24.   Congressman Van Hollen gets called in by AIPAC 15:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/08/06
  25.   Israel and US 15:44  |  John 31/08/06
  26.   More Rosner Twaddle 15:52  |  Mark Lincoln 31/08/06
  27.   Typical Dror--schmopping points citing NO evidence! 15:53  |  Louis T. Sigel 31/08/06
  28.   MD Representation (also response to #24) 16:02  |  MD voter 31/08/06
  29.   To Louis T. Sigel 17:17  |  Sage 31/08/06
  30.   Mark Lincoln agreed 17:24  |  Danite 31/08/06
  31.   Rosner, are you saying that the protocols of the elders 17:39  |  Mark B. 31/08/06
  32.   @29 Sage and the anti-Semitism of pro-Israel American Christians 17:43  |  Mark B. 31/08/06
  33.   DUMP THE DEMOCRAZIES 19:29  |  Philly Jew 31/08/06
  34.   DEMS WEAK ON NATIONAL SECURITY 19:34  |  Philly Jew 31/08/06
  35.   DEMOCRAT ELITES HOLDING OUT FOR ISRAEL... 19:37  |  Philly Jew 31/08/06
  36.   INDRAJAY THank You for COMPLEMENT 20:05  |  TOBIA 31/08/06
  37.   AIPAC = Warmongers 20:09  |  Chris 31/08/06
  38.   Chris=Antisemite, perhaps? 20:38  |  Philly Jew 31/08/06
  39.   Louis T. Sigel 20:41  |  Dror 31/08/06
  40.   Chris - The wrong equation 20:49  |  Mark Lincoln 31/08/06
  41.   The silent majority 21:08  |  Dr David Grosss 31/08/06
  42.   the Israel Lobby 21:12  |  norman ravitch 31/08/06
  43.   Don`t Worry Indrajaya! 21:15  |  Sam The Sham 31/08/06
  44.   Thank you, Dror 21:15  |  L 31/08/06
  45.   Thank you, Gideon Levy 21:18  |  Louis T. Sigel 31/08/06
  46.   re:#32 21:29  |  jeff 31/08/06
  47.   Wonders How Lieberman`s Defeat Fits Into The Picture 21:33  |  Gracie 31/08/06
  48.   Mr.Phiily Jew and Lobbies #35 21:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/08/06
  49.   Gracie in Paris on Lieberman #42 21:47  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/08/06
  50.   dual loyalties 22:00  |  levi 31/08/06
  51.   #21-Louis T. Siegel--thanks, you are correct! 22:11  |  Mike Levi 31/08/06
  52.   Georg Soros purchased the Democratic party 22:17  |  Melvin Schnell 31/08/06
  53.   KUDOS FOR AIPAC 22:20  |  Philly Jew 31/08/06
  54.   bbl 22:35  |  Connie 31/08/06
  55.   Philly Jew 22:40  |  Connie 31/08/06
  56.   Shmuel Rosner 22:42  |  bob 31/08/06
  57.   RE:I wish I could be as confident of a Democratc victory!~ 22:55  |  RLG 31/08/06
  58.   Indrajaya #18 23:07  |  bbl 31/08/06
  59.   Connie, you are mistaken 23:14  |  bbl 31/08/06
  60.   to #51 Connie 23:21  |  Mike Levi 31/08/06
  61.   to #51 Connie 23:25  |  Mike Levi 31/08/06
  62.   Philly Jew:a lobby is in a way a conspiracy.any lobby 23:56  |  Mario 31/08/06
  63.   Connie:God gave you the "brain" to vote Bush?seriously 00:00  |  Mario 01/09/06
  64.   Mike 00:02  |  Connie 01/09/06
  65.   Melvin #49-- that`s idiotic 00:15  |  bbl 01/09/06
  66.   #55, to Connie my friend 00:46  |  Mike Levi 01/09/06
  67.   #55, to Connie my friend 00:47  |  Mike Levi 01/09/06
  68.   to my friend Connie #55 01:02  |  Mike Levi 01/09/06
  69.   Mike Levi 01:33  |  Connie 01/09/06
  70.   Yaakov -- the number one lobby in the US is.. 02:03  |  bbl 01/09/06
  71.   Mario 02:10  |  Connie 01/09/06
  72.   What does pro-Israel even mean? 02:48  |  Amir Flesher 01/09/06
  73.   What does pro-Israel even mean? 02:52  |  Amir Flesher 01/09/06
  74.   Called in by AIPAC??? 03:57  |  watcher 01/09/06
  75.   A bit more about AIPAC 04:03  |  bbl 01/09/06
  76.   Amir -- I agree with alot of that. However.... 04:18  |  bbl 01/09/06
  77.   Melvin Schnell (Post No. 49) 04:21  |  Johnny Weintraub 01/09/06
  78.   Mike Levi 04:42  |  Connie 01/09/06
  79.   Haaretz - Monitor Please Quit skiping post 06:18  |  RLG 01/09/06
  80.   Mike Levi 09:33  |  Connie 01/09/06
  81.   to #80 Connie 13:15  |  Mike Levi 01/09/06
  82.   The importance of "saychel" 16:19  |  D.R. Zukerman 01/09/06
  83.   The Atonement Tour 16:51  |  Anne 01/09/06
  84.   Rosner doesn`t get it 17:29  |  Zach 01/09/06
  85.   Re: Dems weak on Natl Sec. 18:15  |  Sky-Ho 01/09/06
  86.   Louis T.Sigel and Sage 18:27  |  Chaval 01/09/06
  87.   AIPAC Enforcers 19:30  |  Brighid McBride 01/09/06
  88.   Get Ready for the Independents 21:55  |  Watcher on the Hill 01/09/06
  89.   Do Not Vote For Democrats If You Want Terrorism Stopped 23:02  |  The Warrior 01/09/06
  90.   war on terror... 23:14  |  lebanese 01/09/06
  91.   Anything but AIPAC 23:18  |  LF 01/09/06
  92.   Zach 00:18  |  Connie 02/09/06
  93.   Israel, simply amazing! 01:15  |  Nasser Abdu 02/09/06
  94.   Is this the same Rosner who sneered at "Israel lobby" influence? 01:52  |  Joe 02/09/06
  95.   Is this the same Rosner who sneered at "Israel lobby" influence? 03:12  |  Joe 02/09/06
  96.   haaertz monitors suck on this one 08:49  |  diana 02/09/06
  97.   to philly 10:53  |  asad 02/09/06
  98.   Philly Jew 11:38  |  Dror 02/09/06
  99.   #4 Stay the Course 15:06  |  fisa 02/09/06
  100.   And this guys is... 15:58  |  Ignacio 02/09/06
  101.   Sky Ho in Philly 18:04  |  Dror 02/09/06
  102.   cut and run 19:48  |  tadchase 02/09/06
  103.   Republican ineptitiude 21:24  |  syllepsis 02/09/06
  104.   Israel big loser 21:32  |  Dav 02/09/06
  105.   Re:cut and run 23:07  |  RLG 02/09/06
  106.   Re #88 Get Ready for the Independents 23:30  |  RLG 02/09/06
  107.   21 & 51 Republican Talking Pts, Democrats Israel 01:56  |  John Isenhower 03/09/06
  108.   Sky Ho 02:22  |  Dror 03/09/06
  109.   to #32 Christians anti-semites? 07:23  |  tbonetx 03/09/06
  110.   Re:RLG -- taken from the Republican playbook 08:21  |  Bud 03/09/06
  111.   NSA, Carter, etc. 16:07  |  syllepsis 03/09/06
  112.   Rosner`s Blog 17:22  |  marge 03/09/06
  113.   Democrats 20:42  |  Marc 03/09/06
  114.   # 32 Meaning of antiSemitism Mark B 22:07  |  John Isenhower 03/09/06
  115.   Re:NSA, Carter, etc. 22:35  |  Bud 03/09/06
  116.   Re: NSA, Carter, etc. 00:53  |  syllepsis 04/09/06
  117.   Woah "called in for a little chat with officials from the AIPAC" 01:17  |  David 04/09/06
  118.   End of Democrats 01:44  |  Aaron 04/09/06
  119.   answer to #14 -conspiracy 01:53  |  Bob 04/09/06
  120.   Democrats are anti-Israel 04:05  |  TexasJew 04/09/06
  121.   BRAIN WORKS MUCH BETTER THAN GUNS AND BOMBS 06:34  |  John 04/09/06
  122.   Mike Levi 08:56  |  Connie 04/09/06
  123.   Indeed, the Dems are not sweethearts 10:13  |  D.R. Zukerman 04/09/06
  124.   AIPAC of cutey pies 10:26  |  D.R. Zukerman 04/09/06
  125.   Hear this #8 16:08  |  D.R. Zukerman 04/09/06
  126.   Dems and Israel 16:22  |  PJT 04/09/06
  127.   Both parties moribund 19:00  |  John Isenhower 04/09/06
  128.   I have a hard time taking seriously 20:01  |  syllepsis 04/09/06
  129.   Bush`s main talent 20:32  |  syllepsis 04/09/06
  130.   The Democrats are coming! 01:58  |  sandra chitayat 05/09/06
  131.   Re: RLG@#s 105 & 106 Please: Less Beer-More Brain 08:59  |  Watcher on the Hill 05/09/06
  132.   Re: Sillepsis 129 16:49  |  007 05/09/06
  133.   RE:PJT 126 16:59  |  007 05/09/06
  134.   To Philly Jew & Texas Jew 19:03  |  Lee 05/09/06
  135.   To Connie 19:22  |  Lee 05/09/06
  136.   To TexasJew 21:58  |  Sterling 05/09/06
  137.   Democrats vs. Republicans and Israel`s interests 23:37  |  Carla 05/09/06
  138.   Re:Do Not Vote For Democrats If You Want Terrorism Stopped 23:43  |  Carla 05/09/06
  139.   to bbl 23:43  |  Charles 05/09/06
  140.   to bbl again 23:47  |  Charles 05/09/06
  141.   to Louis T. Sigel 23:51  |  Charles 05/09/06
  142.   Gee Charles --you don`t seem to understand your own posting 00:13  |  bbl 06/09/06
  143.   to 007 02:29  |  syllepsis 06/09/06
  144.   So what is the Democrat Plan for Israel? 03:05  |  Spook 06/09/06
  145.   AIPAC 03:41  |  tom 06/09/06
  146.   Dillema for American Jewery 08:33  |  omolll 06/09/06
  147.   the Democrats and Israel 11:23  |  Veronica Vita 06/09/06
  148.   Re 147 Veronica 16:20  |  007 06/09/06
  149.   US Learned Hard Lesson 17:46  |  Sonja 06/09/06
  150.   Jeff # 46 21:25  |  Sophie 06/09/06
  151.   Re: Congressman Van Hollen Called by AIPAC 04:53  |  Wiseplato 07/09/06
  152.   RE:Gee Charles --you don`t seem to understand your own posting 21:04  |  Bud 07/09/06
  153.   Clinton-like capability? 02:21  |  Nita 09/09/06
  154.   RE:Clinton-like capability? 20:21  |  Bud 10/09/06


Domain's Guest
David Rivkin
Top Washington lawyer and former official David Rivkin will discuss Israel-related strategic and legal issues. Readers can send questions.
Previous guests
* Click here for a list of previous guests


Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved