Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., November 27, 2009 Kislev 10, 5770 | | Israel Time: 14:51 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted:

The dictionary of war clichés - part 2

To the many readers who sent suggestions, thank you. To those of you who missed part 1 - read it here.

And now to the second part:

We have hit a large part of their weapons arsenal (IDF): And in two weeks they'll get more by way of Iran or Syria. The same goes for "we hit the top commanders of...", "we hit 80 percent of the terrorists infrastructure" etc.

We condemn both sides...: Conan O'Brien had a good one perfectly suitable for this. "This morning the Vatican weighed in on the crisis. The Vatican came out and condemned Israel's attacks on Lebanon... which is great, because all day yesterday, the Jews and Muslims were asking, 'What do the Catholics think?'"

United Nations delegation: Are you Americans? You're not Americans? Then why would you even think Israel is going to listen to you? (The same goes to EU envoys, Russian messengers, and all other goodwill ambassadors).

Special envoy Vijay Nambiar: The operation will continue for as long as it takes us to learn how to pronounce your name right.

At some point in the future, the secretary intends to travel to the region (U.S State department): At some point in the future Secretary Rice also intends to have a hair cut, to ride a horse and to retire after a long, fulfilling career. But seriously, the date they're talking about is not far off, and maybe as soon as next Sunday.

The situation is very serious, very grave (EU's Solana): The EU was impotent so far, and intends to stay so - but will always be ready to give a grave assessment of "the situation." How about sending an international force?

We have exercised pressure on the Syrian government (Italian foreign minister): The truth is, the world hasn't yet put real pressure on Syria. Just consider this: The UN started a process of investigating the parties responsible for the assassination of former Lebanese prime minister Rafik Hariri. This should have led to more Security Council resolutions and more sanctions on Syria - but it never happened. At such a pace, the resolution might be ready by the time Assad's grandson comes to power.

International force: A military unit capable of escaping as fast as everyone else.

The Lebanese army is strong enough (Israel): To do nothing. The chances it will fight Hezbollah, so I'm told by Lebanese in the know, is zero. The military is mostly Shi'ite and is taking orders from the president, a Syrian puppet. On the other hand, Israel doesn't trust an international force, and for good reasons.

No more. Israel will not be held hostage - not by terror gangs or by a terrorist authority or by any sovereign state (Ehud Olmert): Well, not until next week.

Everyone wants it to stop now (Tony Blair): It's like saying "everyone wants peace," or "everyone wants to be rich". Of course everyone wants it to stop - on their terms!

Disproportionate / Disproportionate response: This expression is the clear winner of the day, with many readers suggesting it should be included in our dictionary.

Michael Weingarten wrote: "How about adding 'disproportionate'? What does it mean? If they kill 10 of our guys, we should only kill 10 of theirs, or it's not proportional?"

Bruce Feldman of West Lafayette, Indiana, suggested: "A dangerous condition threatening an actual solution to a problem. Targets of disproportionate response are entitled to the status of "victims."

Steven Poole directed me to his blog where you can find this: "Few will suggest that a pedantic notion of the exactly proportionate response, i.e. to kidnap two members of Hezbollah in return, was the correct deed."

Anyway, an interesting, more serious, article entitled "Israel and the Doctrine of Proportionality" can be read ).

I want to thank the readers Paul Denhup, Nicole Miznik, David Mark, Jacob Penn, Muhammad Bashir.

Previous blogs on the situation in Lebanon

Call it 'Arab democracy'

The war-clichés dictionary, part 1

If there is a millitary...

The don't-mess-with-us-moment

  1.   THE BUSHMERT DICTIONARY: BROWN IS THE NEW BLACK 15:33  |  Prof. V. de la Vega 20/07/06
  2.   Suggestion: Israel--the only democracy in the Middle East 20:00  |  Frank 20/07/06
  3.   disproportionate and wrong response 21:00  |  Ezzat Yomtob 20/07/06
  4.   Disproportionate the wrong response 21:14  |  Ezzat Yomtob 20/07/06
  5.   The IDF is the most "moral" army in the world 22:19  |  America`s Succubus 20/07/06
  6.   Taint the horse, not the rider, twerent you 23:43  |  Ali Babba 20/07/06
  7.   How to conquer Hezbollah from the safety of Pocatella, USA 00:14  |  LB 21/07/06
  8.   Great Job! 00:19  |  Thomas Dzieran 21/07/06
  9.   Disproporsionate 02:43  |  raphael G 21/07/06
  10.   3 Ezzat Yomtob 07:53  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/07/06
  11.   LB in Philadelpia 08:02  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/07/06
  12.   Damascus 11:43  |  BB 21/07/06
  13.   Fucking Child Killers 12:30  |  Elisabeth 21/07/06
  14.   Vega another unbalanced intellectual 13:14  |  Tulip 21/07/06
  15.   we`re bombing specific targets 13:18  |  yana 21/07/06
  16.   not having the balls to do it 13:20  |  m 21/07/06
  17.   1. Prof. V de La Vega 14:24  |  Amos Magram 21/07/06
  18.   #13 Elisabeth 14:29  |  Amos Magram 21/07/06
  19.   A few from Israel 14:36  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/07/06
  20.   Hizbullah is morally responsible for ALL civilian casualties 14:50  |  Michael Smith 21/07/06
  21.   This war will bring true democracy into Lebanon 14:51  |  Seawife 21/07/06
  22.   IDF moral valor 15:23  |  do kh 21/07/06
  23.   Che Guevara is NOT Al zarquaui 15:38  |  noemí 21/07/06
  24.   Just heard another one 16:29  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/07/06
  25.   Amos Magram 16:44  |  Elisabeth 21/07/06
  26.   "Knight in Shining Armor": Che Guevara 16:56  |  Vicky 21/07/06
  27.   War cliche #7: "The IDF is the most moral army in the world" 17:40  |  Stephen Murray 21/07/06
  28.   more...more 17:50  |  Mori Dar 21/07/06
  29.   Cliche` 1: the moral IDF 18:00  |  Rose Garden 21/07/06
  30.   Cliche` 2: A just war 18:03  |  Rose Garden 21/07/06
  31.   israel don t stop !! 18:16  |  lebanese christian 21/07/06
  32.   already there 18:22  |  Noam 21/07/06
  33.   To Mark 18:32  |  Terry M. 21/07/06
  34.   Does Elisabeth gets a free pass? 18:36  |  Yoram Koch 21/07/06
  35.   New name for this war...Re-Engagement War 19:03  |  bat yam 21/07/06
  36.   pick up one of Tulip`s compasses `m` 21:38  |  Jacob Blues 21/07/06
  37.   Ground Operations will be limited in scope 23:20  |  Seawife 21/07/06
  38.   31 Terry M 23:27  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/07/06
  39.   Elisabeth #25 Which type of killing do you prefer? 01:13  |  Zardos 22/07/06
  40.   This war will bring nothing good to both sides 18:02  |  Rana 22/07/06
  41.   SAUDI - ISRAELI IDEOLOGY 18:56  |  Prof. V. de la Vega 22/07/06
  42.   Dictionary 00:44  |  dov epstein 23/07/06
  43.   Rana 03:49  |  non-aligned 23/07/06
  44.   elisabeth 17:00  |  z 23/07/06
  45.   War Cliches 17:51  |  Howell 24/07/06
  46.   Peace and Propaganda 08:09  |  Saif wa Saif 25/07/06
  47.   Targetting civilians 00:13  |  Fed Up 31/07/06
  48.   Lebanon 09:35  |  Chris 03/08/06


Domain's Guest
David Rivkin
Top Washington lawyer and former official David Rivkin will discuss Israel-related strategic and legal issues. Readers can send questions.
Previous guests
* Click here for a list of previous guests


Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved