"The Israel Factor: Ranking the presidential candidates" is a new project on Rosner's Domain that rates potential presidential contenders in the 2008 race for the White House based on their attitudes toward Israel.
Each month, a group of distinguished Israeli panelists, all of them experts on American policy and politics (go to the panel page to see who they are), will try to assess the candidates' positions on various Israel-related issues, and deliver their verdict on whom they consider to be the best candidate for Israel.
Why are we doing this? The reason is quite obvious: As the U.S. is the sole world superpower, the influence wielded by the American president impacts way beyond the borders of the U.S. As a major recipient of U.S. aid and political support, Israel is one country for whom the positions and policies of the American president are crucial.
Advertisement
Like the rest of the world, Israelis closely follow the race for the presidency, acutely aware that the person who inhabits the White House will influence their future more that any other world leader - perhaps, even more than their own leaders.
From now, until the elections in November 2008, our panelists will answer a set of five questions each month regarding the candidates. Four of the questions will deal with topics of relevance in the period leading up to the survey, while the last question will ask them to give a more general assessment of the candidate's attitude toward Israel.
Each panelist will award each candidate marks out of 10 (10 being "best" for Israel and 1 being "worst") for each question. The results of the four questions on the topics of relevance will be processed by Haaretz pollster Camil Fuchs, who will provide an average score for each candidate for each question. The fifth and final question, which will be asked each time, is "How good is the candidate for Israel?" It is the score for this question that appears along with the picture of each candidate on the front page of our special project.
We are starting with a large group of potential candidates, and will eliminate those who drop out of the race as we go along. As the race progresses, we will be asking you, the readers, to also express your opinions - both on the candidates and on our ranking of the candidates.
By now, you are clearly asking yourselves the crucial question: how does one define "friendly toward Israel." For some, Bill Clinton's intense involvement in efforts to secure an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement was evidence of his "friendliness" towards Israel. For others, it was evidence of an over-meddling president trying to ram a dangerous agreement down the throats of Israelis.
What about Jewish settlements? Is a president who opposes settlement in the West Bank a friend or foe of Israel? Is a president who opposes dialogue between Jerusalem and Damascus serving Israel's best interests? What about a president who promotes democratization in the Middle East? Or a president who supports military action against Iran? Or, for that matter, one who opposes military action against Iran, preferring the diplomatic option? And what of a president who supports a future unilateral withdrawal from the West Bank?
To get as balanced a picture as possible, our panel includes experts from the left and the right in Israel, for whom the question "What constitutes an Israel-friendly president?" produces often strikingly different answers. The panel includes both academics and former high-ranking government officials. We have collected background information on each panelist concerning their beliefs and political positions.
By building the panel in this way, we will be able to give you a more nuanced and sophisticated assessment of the candidates' attitudes toward Israel. Once in a while, we will ask one of the panelists to answer specific questions - posed by us and by you - by inviting them to appear on "Rosner's Guest" for a week.
The one thing that will remain confidential is how each panelist voted on each specific question. Apart from the monthly ranking, I will write a weekly analysis in which I will try to assess the possible factors and events that could influence the next panel vote.
I will be facilitating this project - a new part of Rosner's Domain - but a large group of people at Haaretz.com is working on it. Professor Camil Fuchs of Tel Aviv University (who is also the Haaretz pollster) has also generously agreed to help me crunch the numbers.
I thank them for their participation, their help and their support.
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
