| Talkback | |
|
Title: | For those who wish to compare apples with apples | |||
| |||||
| Name: | Johnboy | | |||
| |||||
| City: | Sydney | State: | Australia | | |
| This is my best estimate of the relative values, noting where necessary when the figures are via subtraction... Note that for the purposes of comparison I teased apart "police" (fixed at 255) from "combatants"; you can lump them back together again if you want, but if you do you should do it for all the lists. PCHR Total: 1,417 Civvies: 926 Children: 313 Women: 116 Males (sub): 497 Police: 255 Combatants (sub): 236 Combat Status Unknown: 0 ICAG Total: 1,370 Civvies: 309 Children: 189 Women: 91 Elderly: 21 Aid Workers: 8 Males (sub): 0 Police: 255 Combatants (sub): 345 Combat Status Unknown: 320 IDF Total: 1,166 Civvies: 295 Children: 89 Women: 49 Males (sub): 157 Police: 255 Combatants (sub): 454 Combat Status Unknown: 162 Two comments: 1) The ICAG list is unbelievable, because there is no room at all for "male civilians". 2) Both Israeli lists are "rubbery", while the Pal list is "dogmatic" |
| |  |
|
 |
|
 |
