Maya Sela, Haaretz Correspondent: Israeli wins French prize for book questioning origins of Jewish people
Talkback
Title:#8, Miriam. I`m sorry if it hurts,
Name:zmogus
City: Paris/VilniusState:
but "The book, which was published by the Resling imprint, spent 19 weeks on the bestseller list in Israel."

Your blanket judgement could still work in the context where there are no evidences to contradict your statement. But it will work alright for many readers here, for whom the evidence goes after the judgement.