| Talkback | |
|
Title: | lakshmi - you are as much of a joke as Indrayahoo | |||
| |||||
| Name: | Polybios | | |||
| |||||
| City: | All over | State: | the US these days | | |
| You criticizing someone else for generalizing! Wow. Wonders never cease. And in the same post you revise history to suit your whim. You (correctly) say there were people `there` when the Israelites returned - about 1300 BCE. Then you say `those people` were converted to Islam (2000 years later) as if it was the same people with the same identity and culture, which is just wrong. And - how did they convert? Voluntarily seeing the light? Or under the weight of the sword and institutional discrimination? And- there were Jews in the Holy Land at every time between 200 and now. It`s you who are generalizing. And badly, at that. The kicker is that rights don`t derive from ancient history. And "rights to the land" is a meaningless phrase. Human Rights, the kind your Hamas heroes vigorously deny, are the real issue. |
| |  |
|
 |
|
 |
