By Alexander Yakobson : The horror of Amona
Talkback
Title:Under no circumstances should they be allowed to gain
Name:Burned Liberal
City: Of Shattered DreamsState: Of Denial
"Under no circumstances should they be allowed to gain political profit from the result of the confrontation they forced..."

Why should we allow Palestinian national cause political profit gained from identical strategy? -- since THE ENTIRE POINT of evacuating outposts is to give them political profit? Why are you attacking settlers because violence is bad, only to reward your enemies WHO DID violence TO GET TO WHERE YOU WANT TO GIVE THEM CONCESSIONS??


"Those who organized the violence at Amona, then, achieved their goal - belligerent intimidation of the government"

What you`re saying by implication then then is that there IS a military solution to the confrontation with the Palestinians, and those who say "there is no military solution, only negotiations will solve things" wish similar "belligerent intimidation of the government."

So if consistent, Alexander, you will be forced to accept victory over Palestinians as well as Jews! If you say no, lay off the settlers!