Fania Oz-Salzberger: The democratization of evil
Talkback
Title:The wonder of Talkbacks
Name:Clickfool
City: SussexState: England
Discussion boards are a fascinating mix of things.
They certainly invite opinions - some are extreme (Israelis probably view mine in this light), some balanced, some borderline psychotic - but a good moderator without an agenda can easily filter out the out-and-out nutters, the racists and other genuine bad boys and girls.
Discussion boards are,however, also a wonderful source of valuable information. I can remember one contributor, possibly on this Talkback, providing a link to the Sunburn cruise missile, whose existence I was unaware of, and of which Iran now has a large stock.
Do they change minds?
Who knows?
My own feeling is that they probably do not. In arguing a case we probably all become more entrenched in our opinions.
The one danger with Talkbacks is excessive censorship. Once they become vanilla, they tend to die.
Haaretz`s Talkbacks have the feel of the Wild West about them, with a hefty dose of the surreal too. This makes them very enjoyable.