Rabbi tells Sarah Silverman: Your potty-mouth politics are un-Jewish. Go have babies

What the hell is the good rabbi doing listening to Sarah Silverman anyway?

pair that would make !

It would be interesting to know why the Rabbi thinks he knows anything about "the most basic desire of the feminine soul." Does he have one of those?

this article was funny and amusing. sarah is awesome and so is donald.

This isn't funny. She and he sick dad need counselling for mental illness.

I think this Rabbi being Haredi and all has forgotten that he's not supposed to be watching or listening to any woman other than his wife! So sick of the Orthodox thinking they have the right to decide how all Jews are supposed to live their lives. I think he should worry more about the orthodox men who throw stones at women who aren't dressed modest enough to suit them and vandalize signs that have pictures of women who aren't dressed tznius. I also find it fascinating that the Rabbi publicly supports Rick Perry.

I am a Jew careful with Jewish values, and I can say this rabbi Rosenblatt is a shame for the Jewish spirit. Jewish values must be full of fairness and fairness today is not fairness 400 years ago. Mister Rosenblatt hates what is fair. He belittles women and feels free to enter their private lives. Of course he KNOWS what sex and fertility must be for EVERYONE. This man is disgusting. He knows the Bible only litterally and have no other knowledge. He himself should stay home and not bother people. Disgusting.

I am a Jew careful with Jewish values, and I can say this rabbi Rosenblatt is a shame for the Jewish spirit. Jewish values must be full of fairness and fairness today is not fairness 400 years ago. Mister Rosenblatt hates what is fair. He belittles women and feels free to enter their private lives. Of course he KNOWS what sex and fertility must be for EVERYONE. This man is disgusting. He knows the Bible only litterally and have no other knowledge. He himself should stay home and not bother people. Disgusting.

Sarah - You don't speak for me. Speak for yourself and leave the jewish cultural bit out.

She's a comedian. Being funny is her mission in life. Don't like what she has to say? Don't listen.

Well, I am breathless. As for Mr. Silvermans' comments, If he at all believes there is the thinnest chance that G-d does exist, he has given up his share in Resurrection and the World to come.

Yaakov, commenter #6: There are news articles and there are blog entries. This is a blog entry.

Good comedians do not have to resort to lewd behavior. Shows she does not have the brain to be funny without smut. I also find Rabbi Rosenblatt's comments insulting too. He obviously thinks women cannot have careers other than having children. What a narrow minded view of women.

Wonderful letter, wonderful Rabbi! He does not see for one moment he is only speaking as a male, a Jew is a man and a Jew has a spouse...clearly she is not "a Jew"... So our Rabbi can only admonest, back to where you belong, "woman". This man is deadly afraid of women and has not even begun to understand what sexuality and relationships are about...

and her daddy is a pretty one too! :D

Spare us- Please don't try to pass off such a vindictive and biases piece of writing as a newspaper article Next time please file this under blog as it amounts to a terrible offense to the disinterested ideal of journalistic integrity . I mean please: "I can’t even begin to imagine what Sarah Silverman prays for the rabbi in return. If anyone - rabbi or not - wrote something like that about me, I’d definitely have some choice prayers for his future. And they’d be pretty unholy." Very professional ...

And there's also that Sarah SIlverman poll on the JewishPress.com too! http://www.jewishpress.com/the-poll/

Sarah I am totally with you

Sarah Silverman is not only a disgrace to the Jewish people, but to all of humanity.

The Rabbi had some valid points. Sarah is very confused. Her mind is caught in American secularism/liberalism/individualism. I am a secular American Jew. The video she made with the scissor offer to Sheldon Adelson was sad. I felt bad for Sarah. I saw her interviews on Israel TV and I liked her. She is just really lost with her ideology on life. I think it comes down to a lack of morals. I am not religious, but the morals that come from religion would definitely help her. But at 42, if she doesnt have kids immediately, she'll just be stuck making obscene videos for another 10 years for attention. If she does have kids, imagine them watching the video she made. I feel bad for her desperate soul.